ŷ

megs_bookrack's Reviews > Mexican Gothic

Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
48328025
's review

liked it

**3.5-stars**

When Neomi Taboada's father enlists her help to check on her cousin, Catalina, she really doesn't want to. Neomi's got so much going on in the city. She doesn't have time for this!

Catalina, recently married, lives in a remote manor home, known as High Place, with her husband, Virgil and his family, far from the bustle of Mexico City.



According to Catalina's recent letters, the home is a desolate place, where she is currently either very unwell, purportedly with tuberculosis, or she's in incredible danger.

Mr. Taboada is insistent that Neomi should go check on her. When his persistent urging doesn't work, he does what any good parent would do. He bribes her instead.



Neomi wants nothing more than to attend University, so that's exactly the carrot he dangles in front of her. Her father knows her well.

Before she even realizes what's happening, Neomi is packing her bags and heading off to High Place.



Once there, Neomi immediately feels at odds with Virgil's stuffy, overly-proper family. She is a modern, society-girl, who is used to having her own way, or at least being able to have a conversation over dinner.

In addition to the regimented, claustrophobic feel of the house itself, Neomi begins feeling spooked by Virgil's family and starts experiencing vivid nightmares. Something is going on in this house.



Her interactions with Virgil and his family get more disturbing as the days go by, until Neomi doesn't fear just for Catalina's well-being, but also her own.

Y'all, I was highly anticipating this novel. I have really enjoyed previous works from Moreno-Garcia and the gothic vibes of this are totally my jam.



While there is no denying that Moreno-Garcia's writing is lush and captivating, something about the pace of this one was off for me.

The premise is super intriguing, the atmosphere was top notch, but the characters were not as well developed as I would have liked. I feel like I should have been attached to Neomi, but I wasn't.



The horror elements were interesting; definitely unique. I found the ideas behind that aspect alluring, for sure.

There were also scenes that legit grossed me out. I may even have gagged once or twice. Uncle Howard is horrifying. The descriptions. I had to take a shower after.



Overall, for me, this is a good book, bordering on really good. I think if the pace wasn't so variant from quiet lulls to extreme intensity, I would have enjoyed it more.

I hope that Moreno-Garcia continues in this lane though. This gothic horror is fantastic for her writing style. I'm on board for anything else she writes, believe that.

541 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Mexican Gothic.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
April 5, 2020 – Shelved
April 5, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
July 21, 2020 –
page 18
5.63%
July 29, 2020 –
page 27
8.44%
July 31, 2020 –
page 53
16.56%

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Rachel Fantastic review! I agree, the middle was S L O W!!


megs_bookrack Rachel wrote: "Fantastic review! I agree, the middle was S L O W!!" Thanks, Rachel! I felt like I was going in and out of consciousness, like, ohhhh, this is interesting to what's happening, where am I, was I asleep?


message 3: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Great review, Megs!


megs_bookrack Deanna wrote: "Great review, Megs!" Thank you, Deanna! Honestly, I was surprised I didn't enjoy this more, but it was still a good story. xx


MK ( MaKayla) Uncle Howard and Catalina's husband were so nasty . A lot of scenes there definitely left me feeling the same way .


megs_bookrack MK ( Makayla) wrote: "Uncle Howard and Catalina's husband were so nasty . A lot of scenes there definitely left me feeling the same way ." Yes! They were both so vile, from the very start!


message 7: by Kelli (new)

Kelli Wilson Great review Meg!


megs_bookrack Kelli wrote: "Great review Meg!"
Thank you so much, Kelli! I appreciate it! xx


message 9: by Aisling Zena (new)

Aisling Zena Fantastic review Megs! I love goth vibes but the gross scenes are not my jam at all lol xx


megs_bookrack Aisling Zena wrote: "Fantastic review Megs! I love goth vibes but the gross scenes are not my jam at all lol xx" There are gross scenes aplenty in this one! Did you read it and were shocked by that, or are you avoiding it? And, thank you!


message 11: by Aisling Zena (new)

Aisling Zena megs_bookrack wrote: "Aisling Zena wrote: "Fantastic review Megs! I love goth vibes but the gross scenes are not my jam at all lol xx" There are gross scenes aplenty in this one! Did you read it and were shocked by that..."

I saw many mixed reviews and was considering it. Your review was the first mentioning gross scenes and now I'm avoiding it. I couldn't handle it when my girl was a baby and throwing up all over the place. Somehow I doubt I'll be able to read it lol


megs_bookrack Aisling Zena wrote: "megs_bookrack wrote: "Aisling Zena wrote: "Fantastic review Megs! I love goth vibes but the gross scenes are not my jam at all lol xx" There are gross scenes aplenty in this one! Did you read it an..."Yeahhhhh, I'll be honest, you probably wouldn't like it. For gothic vibes though, have you ever read Hester Fox? Her novels are swimming in gothic atmosphere! ((and no gross stuff...))


message 13: by Aisling Zena (new)

Aisling Zena megs_bookrack wrote: "Aisling Zena wrote: "megs_bookrack wrote: "Aisling Zena wrote: "Fantastic review Megs! I love goth vibes but the gross scenes are not my jam at all lol xx" There are gross scenes aplenty in this on..."

I haven't but definitely checking her out! Thank you for the recommendation. :D xx


megs_bookrack Aisling Zena wrote: "megs_bookrack wrote: "Aisling Zena wrote: "megs_bookrack wrote: "Aisling Zena wrote: "Fantastic review Megs! I love goth vibes but the gross scenes are not my jam at all lol xx" There are gross sce..."
Good luck! xx


Kat valentine ( Katsbookcornerreads) Another excellent review meg!!💕💯😉💋👊


megs_bookrack Kat wrote: "Another excellent review meg!!💕💯😉💋👊"
Awwww, my heart. Thank you, Kat!!!


Melissa ♥ Dog/Wolf Lover ♥ Martin I have it 3 Stars. I loved the cover and the end 🤷🏻‍♀�


megs_bookrack Melissa � Dog/Wolf Lover � wrote: "I have it 3 Stars. I loved the cover and the end 🤷🏻‍♀�"
The cover is so gorgeous. I really enjoyed the atmosphere and sense of place. Neomi was a good character for me, too. I'll pick up anything she writes. It was definitely a slow build-up initially.


Trisha I can't wait to read this one even if I'm a chicken. Great review!


megs_bookrack Trisha wrote: "I can't wait to read this one even if I'm a chicken. Great review!" Thank you, Trisha!!! I am ao sorry I didn't see your comment until now. Have you read it yet?


message 21: by Marlow (new)

Marlow Placed a hold


megs_bookrack Jae wrote: "Placed a hold" I hope you enjoy it!


Shelbi I was really grossed out as well while reading the book. I quickly read the rest to be done with it.


megs_bookrack Shelbi wrote: "I was really grossed out as well while reading the book. I quickly read the rest to be done with it." Hahaha, awww, Shelbi! Yes, it was yucky, yucky, yucky! Luckily for me, I enjoy being grossed out. ;)


message 25: by Marlow (new)

Marlow what about it was yucky? part of the horror aspect?


megs_bookrack Jae wrote: "what about it was yucky? part of the horror aspect?" Yeah, some of the Horror, some of the character work and family dynamics. I wanted more Horror though, so don't take me saying it's yucky as a bad thing. I live for that.


message 27: by Marlow (new)

Marlow megs_bookrack wrote: "Jae wrote: "what about it was yucky? part of the horror aspect?" Yeah, some of the Horror, some of the character work and family dynamics. I wanted more Horror though, so don't take me saying it's ..."

thanks!


Paulette You were so spot on about not feeling attached to Naomi!! And Uncle Howard was the absolute ick. 🫣


megs_bookrack Paulette wrote: "You were so spot on about not feeling attached to Naomi!! And Uncle Howard was the absolute ick. 🫣"Sooooo ick. Hahahaha


_no_bad_people This book just felt so so so sloooow to me. I really wanted to like it but at some point I really had to fight to keep reading and that does not happen often to me. I can totally see that the writer has potential though

I can just say my first thoughts when reading "Funghi" will never be the same ... yuck lol


megs_bookrack _no_bad_people wrote: "This book just felt so so so sloooow to me. I really wanted to like it but at some point I really had to fight to keep reading and that does not happen often to me. I can totally see that the write..."
Yeah, I hear you. The pace was definitely slow. I am currently reading The Hacienda and loving it. It's actually sort of what I wanted this book to be... you should check it out if you haven't already!


message 32: by Jenny (new)

Jenny Great review Meg!


megs_bookrack Jenny wrote: "Great review Meg!"Awww, Jenny! Thank you. I always appreciate your kindness! xx


Mel (Epic Reading) Very honest review Meg! I gave this one a pretty darn good review because I loved the premise and the ‘twist� in it. But in reality everything you’ve identified as an issue was also off for me too.
I have Certain Things on hold right now by her. I’m hoping it’s a bit better or at least as good.


megs_bookrack Mel (Epic Reading) wrote: "Very honest review Meg! I gave this one a pretty darn good review because I loved the premise and the ‘twist� in it. But in reality everything you’ve identified as an issue was also off for me too...."I enjoyed Certain Dark Things. It was fun and not really like anything I had read before. I've read almost all of this author's books actually and always enjoy them. I think for me, part of the problem was how much I hyped this one up in mind. Picturing it as the perfect book, obviously before reading it and then it just sort of was underwhelming. It's most likely more my own fault than anything else. LOL On another note though, did you read The Hacienda yet? Without being offensive, it's sort of what I wanted this one to be.


message 36: by Marie (new) - rated it 1 star

Marie Ronronne I couldn’t even finish it, I really hated Neomi, so annoying, girl we get it! you like flirting and dressing up, now can you get out of this creepy house with your cousin, hurry!!!


megs_bookrack Marie wrote: "I couldn’t even finish it, I really hated Neomi, so annoying, girl we get it! you like flirting and dressing up, now can you get out of this creepy house with your cousin, hurry!!!"
Hahaha, I absolutely get what you are saying, Marie!! Her sense of urgency was like non-existent. LOL Sorry you didn't have a better experience with it!!


message 38: by Kim (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kim Glad we are in agreement on this one! (We usually are :) )


back to top