ŷ

Joe's Reviews > And Then There Were None

And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26876584
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: mystery-suspense

The Year of Women--in which I'm devoting 2021 to reading female authors only--continues with my introduction to the fiction of Dame Agatha Christie! I chose And Then There Were None, published in the U.K. in late 1939 and the U.S. in early 1940. The Christie estate claims that this is the bestselling crime novel of all time. I was curious about it because the suspense framework was echoed by my favorite movie of all time: Alien. While nothing is as terrifying as that, Christie tossed and turned me all the way through with this ghoulishly conjured and immaculately penned thriller.



The story begins with eight strangers arriving at a spot on the Devon coast, each having received invitations for business or pleasure on the private "Soldier Island" as guests of Ulick Norman Owen and Una Nancy Owen, a couple they’ve never met. Mr. Justice Wargrave is a retired criminal judge. Vera Claythorne is a young woman on leave from her job as a mistress at a girls� school. Phillip Lombard is a mercenary concealing a revolver. Miss Emily Brent is a Bible thumping spinster. General John Macarthur is a widowed World War I veteran. Dr. Edward Armstrong is a renowned physician. Anthony Marston is a young hot rodder. Will Blore is a private investigator. Blore offers the others a fake name, "Natal Davis," and claims to be from South Africa.

Deposited on the island by a ferryman, the group are greeted by Mr. and Mrs. Rogers, the butler and housekeeper, who inform the party that not only have the Owens not arrived, but they’ve never seen them, having been employed only a week prior and given instructions on how to proceed. All ten received offers of luxuriating rest or gainful employment on the island from individuals they are at least marginally acquainted with. None thought to refuse, but without hosts or means to leave, they grow uneasy.

Dinner was drawing to a close.

The food had been good, the wine perfect. Rogers waited well.

Every one was in better spirits. They had begun to talk to each other with more freedom and intimacy.

Mr. Justice Wargrave, mellowed by the excellent port, was being amusing in a caustic fashion, Dr. Armstrong and Tony Marston were listening to him. Miss Brent chatted to General Macarthur, they had discovered some mutual friends. Vera Claythorne was asking Mr. Davis intelligent questions about South Africa. Mr. Davis was quite fluent on the subject. Lombard listened to the conversation. Once or twice he looked up quickly, and his eyes narrowed. Now and then his eyes played around the table, studying the others.

Anthony Marson said suddenly:

"Quaint, these things, aren't they?"

In the centre of the round table, on a circular glass stand, were some little china figures.

"Soldiers," said Tony. "Soldier Island. I suppose that's the idea."

Vera leaned forward.

"I wonder. How many are there. Ten?"

"Yes--ten there are."

Vera cried:

"What fun! They're the ten little soldier boys of the nursery rhyme, I suppose. In my bedroom the rhyme is framed and hung up over the mantelplace."

Lombard said:

"Mine too."

"And mine."

"And mine."

Everybody joined in the chorus. Vera said:

"It's an amusing idea, isn't it?"

Mr. Justice Wargrave grunted:

"Remarkably childish," and helped himself to the port.


After dinner, a phonograph record is played. Rather than music, accusations of murder are leveled specifically at each person in the house. Almost immediately, guests begin dropping or turning up dead. After a second fatality is discovered in the morning, the remaining eight surmise that a murderer is in their midst. Individually, their consciences weigh on them regarding the deaths responsible for summoning each of them to the island. Worse, their ferry back to the mainland is nowhere to be found and a storm is approaching. Three of the men conduct a search of the island but discover no one hiding. The guests realize that"Ulick Norman Owen" and "Una Nancy Owen" are anagrams for "Unknown."It is agreed that the murderer must be among them.

From the start, And Then There Were None proceeds with a crystal clear and delightful command of English I've grown to enjoy from British writers born in the 19th century, H.G. Wells and George Orwell specifically. There is nary a wasted word on the page. The murder plot is devilish and Christie keeps upping the stakes, from the possibility of a killer being on the prowl to the much more compelling prospect that one of our characters isn't who they appear to be. She balances the paranoia with internal monologues from several of the characters over the deaths they've been accused of. The pacing is mathematically precise, neither ending too quickly without sufficient explanation or going on too long with too much information.

The title has a sordid history. It was published in the U.K. as Ten Little N-----s in newspaper serial and book form, reflecting the 19th century rhyme Christie’s murderer uses as a framework. Considered racially offensive even in 1940, the novel was published as And Then There Were None in the U.S. It’s also been published as Ten Little Indians or Ten Little Soldiers, with the location becoming "Indian Island" or "Solider Island" depending on the name of the rhyme. The china dolls are referred to as either Indians or soldiers. The edition I read uses “soldier� throughout.

Agatha Christie was born in 1890 in Tourqay, Devon. Homeschooled, Agatha fancied making up stories with her older sister Madge and their mother. While her first husband was deployed in World War I, Christie worked as an assistant in a pharmacy, beginning a lifelong study of drugs and poisons. Motivated by Madge, Agatha wrote a mystery novel, The Mysterious Affair at Styles, published to modest success in 1920. She kept writing and earned monumental success with more mysteries, many featuring Belgian detective Hercule Poirot or English village spinster Miss Marple. The author died in 1976, one year after killing off Poirotin print.



In the event you missed them. Previous reviews in the Year of Women:

-- Come Closer, Sara Gran
-- Veronica, Mary Gaitskill
-- Clothes, Clothes, Clothes, Music, Music, Music, Boys, Boys, Boys, Viv Albertine
-- Pizza Girl, Jean Kyoung Frazier
-- My Year of Rest and Relaxation, Ottessa Moshfegh
-- Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe, Fannie Flagg
-- The Memoirs of Cleopatra, Margaret George
-- Miss Pinkerton, Mary Roberts Rinehart
-- Beast in View, Margaret Millar
-- Lying In Wait, Liz Nugent
115 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read And Then There Were None.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 23, 2020 – Shelved
June 23, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
March 31, 2021 –
2.0% "In the corner of a first-class smoking carriage, Mr. Justice Wargrave, lately retired from the bench, puffed at a cigar and ran an interested eye through the political news in The Times.

He laid the paper down and glanced out the window. They were running now through Somerset. He glanced at his watch--another two hours to go."
April 1, 2021 –
8.0% " Fred Narracott sat by the engine thinking to himself that this was a queer lot. Not at all his idea of what Mr. Owen’s guests were likely to be. He’d expected something altogether more classy. Togged up women and gentlemen in yachting costume and all very rich and important looking."
April 1, 2021 –
25.0% "this had been an old house, with creaking wood, and dark shadows, and heavily panelled walls, there might have been an eerie feeling. But this house was the essence of modernity. There were no dark corners—no possible sliding panels—it was flooded with electric light—everything was new and bright and shining. There was nothing hidden in this house, nothing concealed. It had no atmosphere about it."
April 4, 2021 –
41.0% "The storm broke just as the old man’s body was borne in through the door."
April 5, 2021 – Started Reading
April 5, 2021 –
82.0% "Why? Yes, why? It was my ambition to invent a murder mystery that no one could solve. But no artist, I now realize, can be satisfied with art alone. There is a natural craving for recognition which cannot be gainsaid. I have, let me confess it in all humility, a pitiful human wish that someone should know just how clever I have been�."
April 6, 2021 – Shelved as: mystery-suspense
April 6, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-35 of 35 (35 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Anne Joe, fabulous review. Thanks for extra info about the title and Christie. Love the book and the movie.


Gina Great review. In my top 10 all time favorite books.


Julie G What a fantastic and fast-paced review. I could tell you were wagging your tail the whole time!
(I'm not quite sure I grasp the comparison to Alien. Could you expand your thoughts on this?)
xoxo


Adan Amazing review! No doubt about the mathematical precision of the plot and command of language, these were the things that struck me first as well.


message 5: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Anne (on semi-hiatus) wrote: "Joe, fabulous review. Thanks for extra info about the title and Christie. Love the book and the movie."

Thanks, Anne. It wouldn't surprise me if we'll get a new film version of this soon. I haven't seen it but Kenneth Branagh directed a pretty well-received adaptation of Murder on the Orient Express and his take on Death on the Nile is awaiting release. Agatha Christie is box office again.


message 6: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Gina wrote: "Great review. In my top 10 all time favorite books."

Strong pick, Gina. Thank you for commenting.


message 7: by Joe (last edited Apr 06, 2021 07:35PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Julie wrote: "What a fantastic and fast-paced review. I could tell you were wagging your tail the whole time! (I'm not quite sure I grasp the comparison to Alien. Could you expand your thoughts on this?) xoxo"

Thank you, Julie. Yes, this novel had all the best elements of a screenplay--terse descriptions, fast pace, compelling characters, strong dialogue, vivid atmosphere--and none of the flaws, like a flat ending. I was a dog with a bone.



Alien is framed like a gothic thriller where characters are isolated and killed until there's only one left. That is the comparison to Agatha Christie that's been made.


message 8: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Adan wrote: "Amazing review! No doubt about the mathematical precision of the plot and command of language, these were the things that struck me first as well."

Very well expressed, Adan. Why didn't you tell me about this book earlier? The fact that we've only been friends for a week might have something to do with it.


message 9: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Itzel wrote: "Great review, Joe! Love the book."

Thank you, Itzel. It's endearing to see readers from so many different countries share their ardor for the same novel.


Julie G Ah. Thank you. I understand what you mean now.
(Okay, I'm starting the Paula Fox tonight!).


message 11: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Julie wrote: "Ah. Thank you. I understand what you mean now.
(Okay, I'm starting the Paula Fox tonight!)."


I'm waiting for my copy to download. See you at the bookstore!


Lorna What a splendid review, Joe. Agatha Christie's mysteries are among my favorites. And a phonograph record playing in the evening, indeed! Again I have to applaud you for your year of the women authors.


message 13: by Joe (last edited Apr 06, 2021 08:59PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Lorna wrote: "What a splendid review, Joe. Agatha Christie's mysteries are among my favorites. And a phonograph record playing in the evening, indeed! Again I have to applaud you for your year of the women authors."

I find it sad that phonograph records have come to mean horror or something terrible happening. Whenever you hear old music in a movie, run! Thank you for your compliment and for coming along with me on this jag. Lorna.


Lorna Joe, I agree with you but I think vinyl may be coming back in limited circles. And if I may recommend a delightful book about phonograph records and the fight to keep them relevant, The Music Shop by Rachel Joyce.


Robin I'm thrilled to see your five stars, Joe! As you probably know, I adore Agatha Christie. I haven't read her in years, but she's never far from my thoughts - she had such an impact on me at the tender age of 9, and I've read most if not all of her work (aside from the romances that she wrote under a pseudonym).

Anyway, if you ever want to read another of hers, I suggest The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Murder on the Orient Express, or Cards on the Table.

PS - I enjoyed your comparison to "Alien". I remember my editor telling me once that Alien is actually a gothic story, but set in the future, and most people never see it that way!


Fran Joe...Great review. One of my Agatha favorites!


Holly  B (slower pace!) My favorite from Christie (so far anyway)!!


message 18: by Joe (last edited Apr 07, 2021 08:22AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Lorna wrote: "Joe, I agree with you but I think vinyl may be coming back in limited circles. And if I may recommend a delightful book about phonograph records and the fight to keep them relevant, The Music Shop by Rachel Joyce."

You're right that vinyl has grown in its niche fetish popularity while CDs have become obsolete with file sharing.


message 19: by Joe (last edited Apr 07, 2021 08:42AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Robin wrote: "I'm thrilled to see your five stars, Joe! As you probably know, I adore Agatha Christie. I haven't read her in years, but she's never far from my thoughts - she had such an impact on me at the tender age of 9, and I've read most if not all of her work (aside from the romances that she wrote under a pseudonym).

I'm forming an image of Young Robin reading Agatha Christie on the school bus and moving on to something darker while her peers were dancing around to Paula Abdul. Christie's clarity when it comes to both language and plot are awesome. I'll add your recommendations to my reading docket.

Robin wrote: "PS - I enjoyed your comparison to "Alien". I remember my editor telling me once that Alien is actually a gothic story, but set in the future, and most people never see it that way!"

Please tell me you've seen Alien. Both the narrative and the art design are masterful but the fact that the screenplay was written so that any part could be played by a man or a woman was so far ahead of its time that it hasn't been attempted again, not every role. I saw it at just the right age for it to scar my psyche in the best possible sense. My favorite thing as of late are YouTube reaction videos of Millennials watching it for the first time.




message 20: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Fran wrote: "Joe...Great review. One of my Agatha favorites!"

Holly wrote: "My favorite from Christie (so far anyway)!!"

Thank you, Fran and Holly. It's difficult for me to imagine how Christie topped this novel, but I shall investigate.


message 21: by Jill (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jill Hutchinson What a review!!! This is one of my favorite Christie book although it began life with a rather unfortunate title.....Ten Little Ns" which thankfully was changed to Ten Little Indians and then to the title with which we are most familiar. The story did not change, just the title.


message 22: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Jill wrote: "What a review!!! This is one of my favorite Christie book although it began life with a rather unfortunate title......"

Thank you, Jill. I was fascinated to learn about the title. You know something was offensive when Americans of 1940 worried you'd stepped over a line.


message 23: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Bok I read my first Christie mystery too recently and was very impressed by the compactness and efficiency of her writing. In case you're interested, the Reading the Detectives group is reading one of her more obscure, non-Poirot books a month this year. I can also recommend a book she wrote under a different name, Mary Westmacott: Absent in the Spring. I recall it being an extraordinary account of a person’s mental revolution—and then devolution.


message 24: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Abigail wrote: "I read my first Christie mystery too recently and was very impressed by the compactness and efficiency of her writing..."

Thank you for those recommendations, Abigail. It's terrific to know that Christie excelled at more than one type of book. It seems like that becomes rare the more success a writer has.


Ginger Great review Joe and glad to see you loved this one!


message 26: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Ginger wrote: “Great review Joe and glad to see you loved this one!�

Thank you, Ginger! I’m doubly excited when an author born in the 19th century throws me across the room.


Ginger Joe wrote: "Thank you, Ginger! I’m doubly excited when an author born in the 19th century throws me across the room."

That's the truth! AC has the amazing ability to keep staying relevant with her books. Such great writing and imagination!


message 28: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Ginger wrote: "AC has the amazing ability to keep staying relevant with her..."

There's something about authors who learned to read before they learned to watch TV. I haven't read any contemporary authors who write like Rudyard Kipling or H.G. Wells. They had to be clear because no one had ever seen the things they were describing before on a screen.


Ginger Joe wrote: "There's something about authors who learned to read before they learned to watch TV. I haven't read any contemporary authors who write like Rudyard Kipling or H.G. Wells. They had to be clear because no one had ever seen the things they were describing before on a screen."

Great way of looking at it Joe and I completely agree with you!


message 30: by Lori (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lori Great review! I'm glad you are checking out one of the best of the best of the old classics and that you judged it worthy:)


message 31: by Joe (last edited Apr 09, 2021 01:43PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Lori wrote: "Great review! I'm glad you are checking out one of the best of the best of the old classics and that you judged it worthy:)"

Thank you, Lori. I wish all that could fit on a stamp.


Jenny How did I miss this?! I’m so happy you read and enjoyed a Christie novel, Joe 😊


message 33: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Jenny wrote: "How did I miss this?! I’m so happy you read and enjoyed a Christie novel, Joe 😊"

I rang the bell at the counter but I think you were busy at the back of your bookstore, Jenny. I'm definitely looking to my next excursion with Christie.


message 34: by Andi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Andi Excellent review, and an Alien shoutout! This is the autumn of comfort reads for me, just finished some of my favorites and looking forward another read of this perfect mystery!


message 35: by Joe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Joe Andi wrote: "Excellent review, and an Alien shoutout! This is the autumn of comfort reads for me, just finished some of my favorites and looking forward another read of this perfect mystery!"

Thank you, Andi. Alien is my favorite movie of all time. I don't know if I'll revisit it for Halloween, but I usually do when I need a reminder of why I became a writer.


back to top