Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Carmel Hanes's Reviews > Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents

Caste by Isabel Wilkerson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
44095345
's review

it was amazing

I've read a number of books on systemic racism before and always found them informative and thought-provoking. Some are more academically based and inclined, and others a bit more accessible to the general public. I'd add this one to the latter group.

I was especially interested in the concept of systemic racism as a reflection of "caste", and the comparisons Wilkerson provided in drawing parallels between our U.S. history with the caste system of India and the treatment of Jews in Germany during WWII. To think the Nazi's took their playbook from things going on here is especially disgusting, but not hard to believe. While there are some differences between a more traditional caste system and what occurs in the United States, such as in the degree of "acceptance of place", the framework discussed did shed light on how embedded some practices and beliefs are in our current culture, along with the damage done as a result.

Wilkerson outlines 8 "pillars" that these hierarchies rest on in order to be maintained. She likened it to a corporation that seeks to maintain its existence with the established structures in place. Throughout the explanations, she pulls in high-profile events (in our news with frustrating regularity) to hammer home the personal and societal damage these subtle (and not so subtle) practices create; discussing how the absorption of toxic elements pervades the social order to the point things aren't even questioned, but appear predestined or logical. And, dishearteningly, she helped me understand how some will seek to maintain their sense of dominance even at the risk of self-harm in countless other ways.

This book provided good reminders, additional perspectives, and more food for thought as we continue to struggle as a culture to truly live up to our stated ideals. It was worth my time as I continue my quest to expand my understanding and awareness of what others have been forced to experience. It gave me additional words with which to dialogue with others about the state of our polarized country/world. And it gave me greater "field of vision" as I interact with others around me, watching for those embedded practices that I need to guard against or fight against.
19 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Caste.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 19, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
September 19, 2020 – Shelved
January 14, 2023 – Started Reading
January 31, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Angela M (new) - added it

Angela M Excellent review, Carmel. It’s been on my list for too long .


message 2: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen An impactful review, Carmel. Sounds like a tough one but an eye opener of one.


message 3: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi A splendid review, Carmel. I would really like to read this. I was really impressed by Wilkerson's The Warmth of Other Suns and expect this will be equally informative.


Carmel Hanes Angela M (On a little break) wrote: "Excellent review, Carmel. It’s been on my list for too long ."

Thanks much, Angela! I was late to this one, too, but I'm glad I spent the time with it.


Carmel Hanes Jen CAN wrote: "An impactful review, Carmel. Sounds like a tough one but an eye opener of one."

Thank you, Jen. You are quite right. I keep hoping we will evolve to the point we don't need this kind of teaching...


Carmel Hanes Candi wrote: "A splendid review, Carmel. I would really like to read this. I was really impressed by Wilkerson's The Warmth of Other Suns and expect this will be equally informative."

I've not read her other one, so I can't say....but I think you'd find this has much to offer. And thanks for your kind words.


Libby Your review encapsulates and reminds me of many of the feelings I had while reading this book, Carmel.

Your sentence, 'It was worth my time as I continue my quest to expand my understanding and awareness of what others have been forced to experience,' captures one of the main reasons I read, and I'm sure, many others.

Sometimes, it takes books like this one, to show us just how deeply embedded these practices are, especially regarding the past, which surrounds and soaks the soil in which we grow. I believe it was this book that enlightened me to the uprising in Wilminton, NC in 1898, about which I had no previous knowledge. I'm thankful that Wilkerson and others like her are writing about the past in ways that help us understand where we've been and where we need to go :-)


Carmel Hanes Libby wrote: "Your review encapsulates and reminds me of many of the feelings I had while reading this book, Carmel.

Your sentence, 'It was worth my time as I continue my quest to expand my understanding and aw..."


Perfectly said, Libby. And I completely agree. I've learned a lot and had my perspective widened and deepened by this kind of read. It's made me more aware of all the subtle "messages" that we are bombarded with all over the place. I've especially noticed what you see in movies and shows and even on the news and in commercials. Like....white people in most commercials, rooms full of white people when political things are being shown. Every book of this nature has added to my awareness and resolve. Since I grew up and have lived my entire life in a bit of a bubble, there were things I didn't have firsthand experience with and was not as aware of as I'm now becoming. I appreciate the learning others have provided me with.


message 9: by Claire (new)

Claire I just moved this up the TBR having realised it has sat too long unread, I loved The Warmth of Other Suns and look forward to this book. A timely and erudite review Carmel.


Carmel Hanes Claire wrote: "I just moved this up the TBR having realised it has sat too long unread, I loved The Warmth of Other Suns and look forward to this book. A timely and erudite review Carmel."

Thank you, Claire. I look forward to your own thoughts on the content....thoughtful as your reviews always are.


Carmel Hanes Elyse wrote: "Wonderful review�. I love Isabel Wilkerson� BOTH BOOKS �.
Nobody comes close to doing what she does and how she does it!! �
I appreciate what the book gave you too Carmel �. expressed so well!"


Thanks, Elyse! This is the only one I've read, but there was much to appreciate in what she put together.


back to top