Libby's Reviews > Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents
Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents
by
by

Libby's review
bookshelves: history, political, published-in-2020, read-in-2020, slavery, social-injustice
Sep 18, 2020
bookshelves: history, political, published-in-2020, read-in-2020, slavery, social-injustice
This may be the most important book I read this year. It’s timely, well researched, and well written. Non-fiction is not my primary reading material, but I found myself engaged and easily turning the pages. Isabel Wilkerson, Pulitzer Prize-winning author of another book, The Warmth of Other Suns: The Epic Story of America's Great Migration posits that African Americans are on the lowest rung of a caste system in American. In a systematic revelation of facts, Wilkerson shines a searing light on the history of enslavement in the South and compares it to the Third Reich’s treatment of the Jews and India’s caste system. The Jim Crow south continued to perpetuate inequality and worse. It’s a bone-chilling account and a call to personal awakenings of conscience.
Wilkerson writes of silent earthquakes rumbling deep within the earth long before the actual earthquake creates havoc and devastation. She states that “only recently have circumstances forced us, in this current era of human rupture, to search for the unseen stirrings of the human heart, to discover the origins of our discontents.� That is what she probes within these pages.
The eight pillars of caste as outlined by Wilkerson begin with ‘Divine Will and the Laws of Nature.� Just as some Christians point to the ‘curse of Ham� as justification for slavery, so does the ancient Hindu text of India provide for the caste system. It pains me to remember the sermons in my own church when I was growing up...that "integration is an act of communism," a reflection of the ignorance and unjustified fears of the time. I was eight years old when my school became integrated. The other children were just like me, only a different color.
Wilkerson points to the 2016 election as a consequence of a backlash against the presidency of the first African American, Barak Obama. Many people vote against their own self-interests when they perceive that their dominance is threatened. One would think that climate change, science, and coronavirus would be at the forefront of everyone’s agenda, seeing as how all those things have to do with the survival of humanity, but that is not the case. The protection of wealth, superiority, and entitlement seem to be just as valid these days.
Wilkerson compares how Germany faced the aftermath of what happened there with how American continues to subjugate blacks and other minorities. She imagines what life would be like if all people were celebrated, if everyone was allowed to reach his/her full potential. Noam Chomsky, celebrated linguist, scholar, and political activist recognizes the Black Lives Matters movement as a reason for hope and “the biggest social movement in American history with support beyond anything that’s ever been registered in the past.� (1)
I don’t believe I have ever read anything so thorough or revelatory about what it means to be black in America.
(1)
Wilkerson writes of silent earthquakes rumbling deep within the earth long before the actual earthquake creates havoc and devastation. She states that “only recently have circumstances forced us, in this current era of human rupture, to search for the unseen stirrings of the human heart, to discover the origins of our discontents.� That is what she probes within these pages.
The eight pillars of caste as outlined by Wilkerson begin with ‘Divine Will and the Laws of Nature.� Just as some Christians point to the ‘curse of Ham� as justification for slavery, so does the ancient Hindu text of India provide for the caste system. It pains me to remember the sermons in my own church when I was growing up...that "integration is an act of communism," a reflection of the ignorance and unjustified fears of the time. I was eight years old when my school became integrated. The other children were just like me, only a different color.
Wilkerson points to the 2016 election as a consequence of a backlash against the presidency of the first African American, Barak Obama. Many people vote against their own self-interests when they perceive that their dominance is threatened. One would think that climate change, science, and coronavirus would be at the forefront of everyone’s agenda, seeing as how all those things have to do with the survival of humanity, but that is not the case. The protection of wealth, superiority, and entitlement seem to be just as valid these days.
Wilkerson compares how Germany faced the aftermath of what happened there with how American continues to subjugate blacks and other minorities. She imagines what life would be like if all people were celebrated, if everyone was allowed to reach his/her full potential. Noam Chomsky, celebrated linguist, scholar, and political activist recognizes the Black Lives Matters movement as a reason for hope and “the biggest social movement in American history with support beyond anything that’s ever been registered in the past.� (1)
I don’t believe I have ever read anything so thorough or revelatory about what it means to be black in America.
(1)
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Caste.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 13, 2020
–
Started Reading
September 18, 2020
– Shelved
September 18, 2020
– Shelved as:
history
September 18, 2020
– Shelved as:
political
September 18, 2020
– Shelved as:
published-in-2020
September 18, 2020
– Shelved as:
read-in-2020
September 18, 2020
– Shelved as:
slavery
September 18, 2020
– Shelved as:
social-injustice
September 18, 2020
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 70 (70 new)
message 1:
by
Beata
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Sep 19, 2020 03:59AM

reply
|
flag


One would think that climate change, science, and coronavirus would be at the forefront of everyone’s agenda
This is a great line, along with the rest of the review. I hadn't heard of this book I'm ashamed to say. Thanks for reviewing it.
Excellent review.
Jim

Thank you, Beata. I was lucky to get it as a library book. For some reason, the queue at my digital library is often long while occasionally I have better luck in the queue at my physical library. I look forward to your thoughts Beata.

Holly, thanks so much. We don't live up to our constitutional promise to protect the rights of all our citizens and that is sad. So many layers of tragedy and sorrow.

One would think that climate change, science, and coronavirus would be at the forefront of everyone’s agenda
This is a great line, along with the rest of the review. I hadn't heard of this boo..."
Thanks for your comments, Jim. It was a GRs review that put me on to this one. I'm glad to have read it.



Thanks Orhan! Much to think about. The author makes a good case for it, but it is up for debate. For example, how did Obama win so handily in 2008 and 2012 if race was of such concern to an American populace? However, under Trump, the US has seen a resurgence of groups invested in white supremacy. I think what surprises me most is the denial of climate science, the denial of science altogether, as in what is happening with the coronavirus, which affects people of color disproportionately, often due to their jobs and access to healthcare.

Thanks Candi! This was my first read by her. She comes across as knowledgable and warm, a person I'd like to know. I hope to read The Warmth of Other Suns: The Epic Story of America's Great Migration, but I know it's lengthy, so that's holding me at bay, at least for now. I look forward to your thoughts on this one, Candi.

In Montenegro we are all "white", but the politicians always find a way to divide us. So, we have the anti-fascist and fascist. But all the Montenegrin people want is a better life in general. Although, this inflammatory rhetoric is negatively affecting some of the suburban less educated population and resurrecting these fascist ideals.
Anyhow, a very interesting book, thanks for sharing your review with us, Libby.

Our countries seem to share divisive politics in common, Orhan and the inflammatory rhetoric also. It seems you have had a shake-up in your Parliament with your own 2020 elections. I hope it works out to give Montenegrins a better quality of life.
Thank you for your comments Orhan.



Thanks, Angela! She made me see inside the problems as no other author has. I've never glossed over the history of slavery, but she made me feel as though I had. Lots of feelings come up, I guess, because here I am in North Carolina, and my state has an egregious history when it comes to slavery and Jim Crow laws. After reading her book, I feel like I never had a proper education in the history of everything that has happened. I hope her book becomes a high school textbook because this does not need to wait until the college level.

Thank you, Pam. I hope others read it because Wilkerson does such a good job of taking the reader into the heart of what it's like to be scapegoated and dehumanized. You're so right that it's white people who should be the target audience, to help us come to understand the depth of what has happened. She points a way forward as well.



Yes! I love that she points a way forward!! Let's vote and do it!!

Pam wrote: "Libby wrote: "Pam wrote: "That is the most beautiful and accurate review of this significant book. It is the most important book I have ever read in my lifetime. I am not exaggerating. Those of us ..."
Chris, thanks so much!


It is sad, Annette and yes, it worked well as a scare tactic. My parents believed what they heard at church, that integration was part of communism. It fueled a baseless fear. Thankfully, integration was effective in teaching the children about commonalities, at least that was my experience. As children our hearts were open.



Thank you, Julie! I look forward to your thoughts 🌹


Meredith, thanks so much! I hope you get to read it because I'd love to know your thoughts on this one.


Libby I think this is one my daughter who teaches sophomore English would like to know about, thanks again for the great review :)

Libby I think ..."
It would be a great one for teachers.

Beverly, thank you! It's well-written and offers insight into the history of racism in America. I grew up in the south but so much has been glossed over; Wilkerson gives a real accounting.