Wanda Pedersen's Reviews > Blue Mars
Blue Mars (Mars Trilogy, #3)
by
by

Wanda Pedersen's review
bookshelves: speculative-fiction, reading-project, public-library, read-in-2020
Aug 20, 2020
bookshelves: speculative-fiction, reading-project, public-library, read-in-2020
Sometimes I need a shove to get me moving. I've had this book out of the library for a while, but hadn't felt inspired to tackle it. I knew there would be a pile of (for me) yawn-inducing detail, both scientific and political. I'm sure Robinson must have read Frank Herbert's Dune series, but despite some similarities, that world captivated me and I struggle to care about this version of Mars. At any rate, I didn't click “renew" when I should have and found myself with only 5 days to read over 700 pages. I don't know whether to thank or curse the person who requested this title.
The anti-aging treatments that keep the original Mars settlers going and going seem to me to kind of petrify the new society. With little generational turnover, young people are stuck dealing with these elders who are rich in experience but short on flexibility. Like the Baby Boomers, they refuse to get out of the way and let younger folk explore new possibilities. Can you imagine if George Washington or Winston Churchill were still wandering around, wizened old things still trying to be relevant, sure they knew what was best for present societies? Perish the thought! Rather like the rock stars of the sixties struggling to stay hip without breaking a hip.
I thought it was quite perceptive of Robinson to have Maya approaching a youngish man at a gathering and being glad that he didn't act like she was “Helen of Troy or Lucy the habilene Fossil.� Close to the end of the book, as the ultra-elderly start dying, it gets a bit sad, but ask any 90 year old today about it. They are going through the same thing. My 86 year old aunt was watching all her friends die until she joined them. It gets lonely if you have a long life.
The issues that plague Mars society are also things that we are dealing with today. The Red Mars faction are devoted environmentalists who want to severely restrict development. There are debates over immigration from Earth and shady side deals are struck. Settlers are plunging onto the Martian surface illegally. Mars society is fractured into many groups with different world views and values. Leadership is essential, but its difficult for anyone to lead when public opinion is so splintered. Not to mention the generational differences mentioned above. In many ways Robinson seems to anticipate in 1996 many of the problems that face us in 2020.
I've got to hand it to Robinson, he has obviously done piles of research on terraforming, ground water management, space travel, geology, engineering and human memory & psychology among many other subjects. I wonder if Sax Russell is a kind of alter ego? It seems like they are both very familiar with obsessively researching interesting subjects. Like Sax, the whole trilogy held me at arm's length, not giving me much emotional purchase and making it difficult for me to truly connect with the story. Despite that, I did find the ending rather bittersweet and I'm ultimately glad that I read until the end. So, thank you, unknown requester of this library book, you got me to put some welly into the reading process and knock this title off this year's planned reading list.
Book number 375 of my Science Fiction & Fantasy Reading Project.
Cross posted to my blog:
The anti-aging treatments that keep the original Mars settlers going and going seem to me to kind of petrify the new society. With little generational turnover, young people are stuck dealing with these elders who are rich in experience but short on flexibility. Like the Baby Boomers, they refuse to get out of the way and let younger folk explore new possibilities. Can you imagine if George Washington or Winston Churchill were still wandering around, wizened old things still trying to be relevant, sure they knew what was best for present societies? Perish the thought! Rather like the rock stars of the sixties struggling to stay hip without breaking a hip.
I thought it was quite perceptive of Robinson to have Maya approaching a youngish man at a gathering and being glad that he didn't act like she was “Helen of Troy or Lucy the habilene Fossil.� Close to the end of the book, as the ultra-elderly start dying, it gets a bit sad, but ask any 90 year old today about it. They are going through the same thing. My 86 year old aunt was watching all her friends die until she joined them. It gets lonely if you have a long life.
The issues that plague Mars society are also things that we are dealing with today. The Red Mars faction are devoted environmentalists who want to severely restrict development. There are debates over immigration from Earth and shady side deals are struck. Settlers are plunging onto the Martian surface illegally. Mars society is fractured into many groups with different world views and values. Leadership is essential, but its difficult for anyone to lead when public opinion is so splintered. Not to mention the generational differences mentioned above. In many ways Robinson seems to anticipate in 1996 many of the problems that face us in 2020.
I've got to hand it to Robinson, he has obviously done piles of research on terraforming, ground water management, space travel, geology, engineering and human memory & psychology among many other subjects. I wonder if Sax Russell is a kind of alter ego? It seems like they are both very familiar with obsessively researching interesting subjects. Like Sax, the whole trilogy held me at arm's length, not giving me much emotional purchase and making it difficult for me to truly connect with the story. Despite that, I did find the ending rather bittersweet and I'm ultimately glad that I read until the end. So, thank you, unknown requester of this library book, you got me to put some welly into the reading process and knock this title off this year's planned reading list.
Book number 375 of my Science Fiction & Fantasy Reading Project.
Cross posted to my blog:
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Blue Mars.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 9, 2012
– Shelved
August 17, 2020
–
Started Reading
August 17, 2020
–
2.63%
"Dammit, I should have rewed this book yesterday when I had a chance. This morning there's a hold on it. I have 4 days to get it finished & I hate feeling rushed."
page
20
August 17, 2020
–
6.18%
"If you ever thought that semi-immortality was a good idea, you should read this trilogy. At some point, every society needs new perspectives & ideas, and the original Mars settlers are just in the way."
page
47
August 17, 2020
–
8.15%
"I know a couple of people like Sax, who don't understand how emotion shapes most people's decisions. They are difficult to deal with because they refuse to admit the value of emotion."
page
62
August 17, 2020
–
11.96%
"That last chapter reminded me of the greening of Dune. If we could terraform planets, would it be a good idea or would it lead to societal changes that we can't predict? Robinson & Herbert on the same track?"
page
91
August 17, 2020
–
21.16%
"Well thank goodness the constitutionaldebates are done. Shades of Green Mars."
page
161
August 18, 2020
–
36.14%
"How much more Ann can I take? She is one of my least favourite characters."
page
275
August 18, 2020
–
44.94%
"I much prefer Nadia's pov, but I wish there was more from younger people. I'd like to hear from Jackie!"
page
342
August 18, 2020
–
53.88%
"I wonder if Hiroko is alive or dead? As good a reason to keep on reading as any, I guess."
page
410
August 19, 2020
–
74.64%
"I think I've lost the thread....not sure where this novel is headed...."
page
568
August 19, 2020
–
74.9%
"She moved toward him slowly, as the group shifted into a more relaxed cocktail-party format, people wandering around to talk and look down at the canal and the docks. Finally she got a chance to speak to him,and he did not react as if approached by Helen of Troy or Lucy the habilene Fossil."
page
570
August 19, 2020
–
87.25%
"Okay, this is just getting sad. Too many funerals & aging problems!"
page
664
August 20, 2020
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)
date
newest »

Thank you for your review.