Sign in with Facebook
Manny's Reviews > Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China
Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China
by
by
At a conference dinner some time in the mid-90s, I found myself sitting next to this extremely impressive Chinese woman researcher - bunch of frequently cited publications, well-read in three languages, manages to look gorgeous as well. I cast around for something to say.
"I liked that Wild Swans book," I hazarded. "Do you know it?"
She looked at me scornfully. "Any Chinese woman could have written that!" she replied. "There are a hundred million stories just like it."
I must admit I had a little trouble believing her. But would Professor Fung have lied to me? That seems even less plausible.
"I liked that Wild Swans book," I hazarded. "Do you know it?"
She looked at me scornfully. "Any Chinese woman could have written that!" she replied. "There are a hundred million stories just like it."
I must admit I had a little trouble believing her. But would Professor Fung have lied to me? That seems even less plausible.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Wild Swans.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
January 1, 1992
–
Finished Reading
January 12, 2009
– Shelved
March 17, 2011
– Shelved as:
history-and-biography
Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Robert
(new)
Mar 17, 2011 02:15PM
According to my colleague, Ping, you should have tried talking about Monkey or The Stone Book; they are Chinese classics. I still haven't read either of them...
reply
|
flag
Even if it's true that any Chinese woman could have written it, perhaps the point is that they didn't (or that they didn't get it published).
I am a little reluctant to believe that a hundred million other Chinese women have Jung Chang's writing skills. But what do I know about it?
You're probably right - hence the lack of a hundred million, or even just a hundred, other versions.
That sounds a bit sour, maybe you could answer: "but it's only Chang who write it down!"
And, isn't that the point? We need to know about these stories? How else would be learn from history and prevent something like this from happening elsewhere to have a better understanding of those who lived through events like these?
Was that a "my kid could have drawn this Jackson Pollock painting!" situation?
Hal wrote: "Was that a "my kid could have drawn this Jackson Pollock painting!" situation?"Have a look at Why Your Five-Year-Old Could Not Have Done That: Modern Art Explained.
Thank you for the recommendation! 😊
Eva, I'm sorry if I offended you. I know very little about China, though I wish I was less ignorant. Just passing on Professor Fung's comments, and it sounds like you more or less agree with her...
lol I think I accumulated alot of bitterness and anger while reading through all these reviews and reflecting on how they tie to the many racist acts committed in the past year. The point still stands but in less angry and inappropriate terms. My apologies.
I don't have any close Chinese friends, but pretty much all of my professional interactions with Chinese people have been positive. If you look me up on Google Scholar you'll see I have several joint papers with Chinese coauthors, and it has been an absolute pleasure to work with them.I can see why you might be a little trigger-happy after the last four years!
I'll have you know that I've had many Bobo friends. I just wish they'd keep their China Bat pets to themselves.
Hi Manny, just come across your comments you posted 9 years ago. Of course there were not (and still are not) 100 millions women in China possessing such writing skill. I suppose you know that scornful lady was actually saying what Jung Chang depicted in her book were everyday lives of every Chinese woman in those years.
So much suffering, i had no ideia!
