Jonathan's Reviews > The Waves
The Waves
by
by

Jonathan's review
bookshelves: favorites, signed-and-or-first-editions, worshiped-and-adored, 2015-the-modernists, the-top-ten, still-looking-for-signed-or-first
Oct 12, 2012
bookshelves: favorites, signed-and-or-first-editions, worshiped-and-adored, 2015-the-modernists, the-top-ten, still-looking-for-signed-or-first
Read 5 times. Last read December 16, 2015 to December 19, 2015.
The Waves Playlist
Pop songs, not classical or Jazz.
The characters
Rules: One song each. Gender matching. Must express as many of the key character traits as possible. I must love it.
Bernard: Bob Dylan � To Ramona
Susan: Kate bush - Mrs. Bartolozzi
Rhoda: Throwing Muses � Fear
Neville: Anthony and the Johnsons � Crazy in Love
Jinny: Julia Holter - Gold Dust Woman
Louis: Jeff Buckley - A Satisfied Mind
[Percival: John Cage - 4'33]
The novel
4 rules here - reference to water in title or song (mist or fog counts), thematic connection over and above this to the novel, something about the feel matches the novel too, and it has to be a song I love.
Grouper � Heavy Water/I'd rather be sleeping
Joanna Newsom - Time, a symptom
Joanna Newsom - Divers
Smog - Rock bottom riser
Judee Sill - Kiss
Julie Holter - Sea calls me home
Beach house - On the sea
****
This is It. This is The Book. The One. The collection of carefully crafted words I hold most dear in the world.
It is for this very reason I cannot write a reasonable review, I cannot simply tell you that this is a masterpiece, that this deals with the most profound and important issues of Being in the most beautiful ways imaginable, nor can I simply say that, though I have read it many times, I still find new pearls to treasure in almost every line.
So I will take a quote, a relatively famous one, and ramble on a little about what makes it so wonderful. From this one can extrapolate the rest�
Towards the end of the novel, Bernard says the following:
"How tired I am of stories, how tired I am of phrases that come down beautifully with all their feet on the ground! Also, how I distrust neat designs of life that are drawn upon half-sheets of note-paper. I begin to long for some little language such as lovers use, broken words, inarticulate words, like the shuffling of feet on the pavement. I begin to seek some design more in accordance with those moments of humiliation and triumph that come now and then undeniably. Lying in a ditch on a stormy day, when it has been raining, then enormous clouds come marching over the sky, tattered clouds, wisps of cloud. What delights me then is the confusion, the height, the indifference and the fury. Great clouds always changing, and movement; something sulphurous and sinister, bowled up, helter-skelter; towering, trailing, broken off, lost, and I forgotten, minute, in a ditch. Of story, of design, I do not see a trace then."
This is, of course, a comment by Woolf on her art, and illuminates some of her key concerns as they relate to the confused and tattered nature of reality. But I do not wish to speak of that here. I want to talk about the music of this passage, the song of her writing.
We begin with an old Rhetorical trick: repetition. He is tired, that much is clear, and do we not feel a similar fatigue? The fall of those sentences, like an exhausted sigh raising themselves up to the exclamation point at the end. Then alliteration, that echo of anglo-saxon origin, propels us through the next, short sentence. All those hard "d"s, the rippling between "life" and "half" (deep ripples those, though I will not explore them here)�
And the alliterative magic continues, bouncing like bows on taught strings, "L"'s for longing, little, language and lovers, the repetition of "words", shuffling the sentence like those feet on the pavement.
Then, as if to prove such shattering and shuffling inevitable, a sentence which falls on its own sword, ending with its feet over its head and undeniably unstuck.
But we shall right ourselves. Pulled back by the gentle arms of another "L", and those commas, like the beats of a conductor's baton, getting us back up to speed, ready for the pounding out of those key words "confusion", "height", "indifference" and "fury". And we understand how fury can be delightful, how indifference can fill us with joyous awe.
The next sentence is, according to Microsoft Word, incorrect. It is a fragment which I should consider revising. But how can one truly speak of the fragmented without using broken and un-finished lines? Here too all our alliterative friends return � those "C"s, "L"s, "D"s and "S"s, the repetition of "ing", like light and dancing footsteps following the music they themselves create.
This is Design. This is Song. This is the tension between the beauty and craft of great prose, and the dirty, broken Truth of the World. Woolf is the Master of this tension, she walks on the thin thread tied tight between them. And when the thread broke, she drowned and the World lost too much to be easily comprehended.
Of all books in the world, of all the voices I have been lucky enough to overhear through the magic of literature, hers is the one I love most, and the one I miss most. Read her. Read all of her. Then go back and start all over again.
Pop songs, not classical or Jazz.
The characters
Rules: One song each. Gender matching. Must express as many of the key character traits as possible. I must love it.
Bernard: Bob Dylan � To Ramona
Susan: Kate bush - Mrs. Bartolozzi
Rhoda: Throwing Muses � Fear
Neville: Anthony and the Johnsons � Crazy in Love
Jinny: Julia Holter - Gold Dust Woman
Louis: Jeff Buckley - A Satisfied Mind
[Percival: John Cage - 4'33]
The novel
4 rules here - reference to water in title or song (mist or fog counts), thematic connection over and above this to the novel, something about the feel matches the novel too, and it has to be a song I love.
Grouper � Heavy Water/I'd rather be sleeping
Joanna Newsom - Time, a symptom
Joanna Newsom - Divers
Smog - Rock bottom riser
Judee Sill - Kiss
Julie Holter - Sea calls me home
Beach house - On the sea
****
This is It. This is The Book. The One. The collection of carefully crafted words I hold most dear in the world.
It is for this very reason I cannot write a reasonable review, I cannot simply tell you that this is a masterpiece, that this deals with the most profound and important issues of Being in the most beautiful ways imaginable, nor can I simply say that, though I have read it many times, I still find new pearls to treasure in almost every line.
So I will take a quote, a relatively famous one, and ramble on a little about what makes it so wonderful. From this one can extrapolate the rest�
Towards the end of the novel, Bernard says the following:
"How tired I am of stories, how tired I am of phrases that come down beautifully with all their feet on the ground! Also, how I distrust neat designs of life that are drawn upon half-sheets of note-paper. I begin to long for some little language such as lovers use, broken words, inarticulate words, like the shuffling of feet on the pavement. I begin to seek some design more in accordance with those moments of humiliation and triumph that come now and then undeniably. Lying in a ditch on a stormy day, when it has been raining, then enormous clouds come marching over the sky, tattered clouds, wisps of cloud. What delights me then is the confusion, the height, the indifference and the fury. Great clouds always changing, and movement; something sulphurous and sinister, bowled up, helter-skelter; towering, trailing, broken off, lost, and I forgotten, minute, in a ditch. Of story, of design, I do not see a trace then."
This is, of course, a comment by Woolf on her art, and illuminates some of her key concerns as they relate to the confused and tattered nature of reality. But I do not wish to speak of that here. I want to talk about the music of this passage, the song of her writing.
We begin with an old Rhetorical trick: repetition. He is tired, that much is clear, and do we not feel a similar fatigue? The fall of those sentences, like an exhausted sigh raising themselves up to the exclamation point at the end. Then alliteration, that echo of anglo-saxon origin, propels us through the next, short sentence. All those hard "d"s, the rippling between "life" and "half" (deep ripples those, though I will not explore them here)�
And the alliterative magic continues, bouncing like bows on taught strings, "L"'s for longing, little, language and lovers, the repetition of "words", shuffling the sentence like those feet on the pavement.
Then, as if to prove such shattering and shuffling inevitable, a sentence which falls on its own sword, ending with its feet over its head and undeniably unstuck.
But we shall right ourselves. Pulled back by the gentle arms of another "L", and those commas, like the beats of a conductor's baton, getting us back up to speed, ready for the pounding out of those key words "confusion", "height", "indifference" and "fury". And we understand how fury can be delightful, how indifference can fill us with joyous awe.
The next sentence is, according to Microsoft Word, incorrect. It is a fragment which I should consider revising. But how can one truly speak of the fragmented without using broken and un-finished lines? Here too all our alliterative friends return � those "C"s, "L"s, "D"s and "S"s, the repetition of "ing", like light and dancing footsteps following the music they themselves create.
This is Design. This is Song. This is the tension between the beauty and craft of great prose, and the dirty, broken Truth of the World. Woolf is the Master of this tension, she walks on the thin thread tied tight between them. And when the thread broke, she drowned and the World lost too much to be easily comprehended.
Of all books in the world, of all the voices I have been lucky enough to overhear through the magic of literature, hers is the one I love most, and the one I miss most. Read her. Read all of her. Then go back and start all over again.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Waves.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
Finished Reading
Finished Reading
Finished Reading
October 12, 2012
– Shelved
February 20, 2013
– Shelved as:
favorites
April 23, 2013
– Shelved as:
signed-and-or-first-editions
May 24, 2013
– Shelved as:
worshiped-and-adored
July 21, 2014
– Shelved as:
2015-the-modernists
October 31, 2014
– Shelved as:
the-top-ten
December 16, 2015
–
Started Reading
December 16, 2015
–
1.95%
"5th (or 6th?) read as a reward for the year. Time to submerge myself once again in my favourite book."
page
5
December 17, 2015
–
23.44%
"But you understand, you, my self, who always comes at a call (that would be a harrowing experience to call and for no one to come; that would make the midnight hollow, and explains the expression of old men in clubs � they have given up calling for a self who does not come), you understand that I am only superficially represented by what I was saying tonight."
page
60
December 18, 2015
–
46.88%
"There is a red carnation in that vase. A single flower as we sat here waiting, but now a seven-sided flower, many-petalled, red, puce, purple-shaded, stiff with silver-tinted leaves � a whole flower to which every eye brings its own contribution."
page
120
December 18, 2015
–
50.78%
""Like" and "like" and "like" - but what is the thing that lies beneath the semblance of the thing?"
page
130
December 19, 2015
–
Finished Reading
May 20, 2016
– Shelved as:
still-looking-for-signed-or-first
November 19, 2021
– Shelved as:
2022-reread-project
(Other Paperback Edition)
November 19, 2021
– Shelved
(Other Paperback Edition)
November 19, 2021
– Shelved as:
favorites
(Other Paperback Edition)
November 19, 2021
– Shelved as:
worshiped-and-ad...
(Other Paperback Edition)
November 19, 2021
– Shelved as:
still-looking-fo...
(Other Paperback Edition)
November 19, 2021
– Shelved as:
signed-and-or-fi...
(Other Paperback Edition)
Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Garima
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jun 21, 2013 04:15AM

reply
|
flag


I know my comment won't be very constructive, but I LOVED that comment Kalliope. I just had to say it! :)

Kalliope - as mother of Orpheus, I hoped my Rilkean reference to Song would tickle your lyre strings, though how you gave the novel only three stars I shall never know�

Kalliope - as mother of Orphe..."
Excellent question, Jonathan, and I was afraid you would ask.
I do not know. I read it years ago and I only remember that there was not a lot of chemistry between us. I know I have to revisit Woolf (this one and To the Lighthouse), because my recent read of Mrs. Dalloway was very enjoyable.
I fear though that I am more of a Proustian than a Woolfian...

To be either is enough to garner both my respect and my affection...Though in a fight I think VW could probably have taken MP, one punch and he would have been out for the count ;-)

haha.. fair enough..
Anyway, I promise I will revisit VW.
This is what is wonderful about GR, than anyone can receive a good literary punch any minute, but that just makes one grow further...

haha.. fair enough..
Anyway, I promise I will revisit VW.
This is what is wonderful about GR, than anyone can rece..."
Very much agreed. Although... chemistry is a powerful component of literary love, as in real life, and there is nothing wrong with keeping a respectful distance from those writers who, whilst being technically gifted, and clearly "worthwhile", do not get our hearts racing. VW can be a snotty little so-and-so at times (as the Bloomsbury set were wont to be), and I can totally understand why she rubs people the wrong way.

Yes, it may have been something of the sort.. the self-consciousness that irritated me (plus may be that her very abstract English was a bit too much for mine at the time).
Anyway, I will look for you when I come back to her.. It is very inspiring to see someone so enthusiastic.

I'm devoting this summer, among other things, to re-reading Woolf. I started with A Writer's Diary, and was moved to read Woolf describing her approach to writing and revising and writing and revising in an attempt to realize her vision for each book. And I'm now reading Moments of Being, and am enthralled by her project of realizing the modernist understanding of the self and identity in her writing, fiction and autobiographical. There is so much to discover in her writing. I, like you, plan to continue to revisit her work throughout my life.

I'm devoting this sum..."
Wonderful and inspiring post, Kris...
All those readings are very inspiring. I am vey curious about A Room of One's Own as well. I did not know about Moments of Being.
This year, though, with Proust and T Mann, I have my plate full. I do not think I could handle at the same time another Modernist and have to square off, if not the circle, the triangle.

I'm devoting this sum..."
Thank you Kris. I agree entirely - I intend to re-visit her non-novel (but very novel, of course) output soon (Moments of Being in particular). It is the simple fact of her craft that amazes me so in many ways - her technique is impeccable.

And Jonathan, thank you. I agree -- Woolf's technique, and her commitment to honing it over and over, are inspiring. And it will deepen my enjoyment of her work to share my admiration with you and others who love her craft.

Why write a "reasonable review", when you can write one as imaginative and beautiful as this?
Yes!

Great review, Jonathan. And yes. I was very aware of the shape of this book. And of the rhythm. The voices were in my head even when I wasn't reading it.



Thank you, you are very kind...I hope you find something there to like in her work!



Thanks Alan - and for you to say that means I must be able to return the compliment....

