Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Scarlet's Reviews > The Bell Jar

The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3839903
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: classics, it-stays-with-you, for-my-future-library, lush-writing, favorite-author, most-loved

There is this scene in Chapter 10 of The Bell Jar where Esther Greenwood decides to write a novel.

"My heroine would be myself, only in disguise. She would be called Elaine. Elaine. I counted the letters on my fingers. There were six letters in Esther, too. It seemed a lucky thing."


I cannot help wondering, is that what Sylvia Plath thought when she wrote The Bell Jar? Did she, like Esther, sit on a breezeway in an old nightgown waiting for something to happen? Is that why she chose the name Esther? 6 letters - just like in Sylvia. For luck?

It's impossible to read The Bell Jar and not be affected, knowing what happened to Plath. I mean, it's everywhere. She is everywhere. All of Esther's musings are Plath's own. It's eerie. There's hardly any comfort even when Esther is freed from the bell jar; on the contrary, it's a brutal reminder that this book is ultimately, part fiction.

Plath's poetic prowess shows through her writing - especially the descriptions. They are so simple yet so fitting. There is one in particular I loved, where Esther compares her life to a fig tree (See the first status update). Here's another:

"I saw the years of my life spaced along a road in the form of telephone poles, threaded together by wires. I counted one, two, three...nineteen telephone poles, and then the wires dangled into space, and try as I would, I couldn’t see a single pole beyond the nineteenth."


The writing is remarkably unemotional and I don't mean that as a bad thing. Esther's (or Plath's?) commentary dwells entirely on thoughts and perceptions, never feelings. Depression is so often mistaken as a form of sadness. This woman, however, is not sad. She is empty. She is a shell. She contemplates killing herself with a kind of ease that's unnerving.

The Bell Jar did not make me cry but I wish it did. What I'm left with now is a deep sense of unhappiness that I don't think tears can fix.

Why is it that the most talented always fall prey to the bell jar? It's such a waste.
1800 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Bell Jar.
Sign In »

Quotes Scarlet Liked

Sylvia Plath
“The silence depressed me. It wasn't the silence of silence. It was my own silence.”
Sylvia Plath, The Bell Jar

Sylvia Plath
“I took a deep breath and listened to the old brag of my heart. I am, I am, I am.”
Sylvia Plath, The Bell Jar


Reading Progress

November 8, 2012 – Shelved
June 20, 2013 – Shelved as: to-read-soon
June 20, 2013 – Shelved as: classics
July 7, 2013 – Started Reading
July 8, 2013 –
page 10
3.4%
July 10, 2013 –
page 95
32.31% ""I saw myself sitting in the crotch of this fig tree, starving to death, just because I couldn’t make up my mind which of the figs I would choose. I wanted each and every one of them, but choosing one meant losing all the rest, and, as I sat there, unable to decide, the figs began to wrinkle and go black, and, one by one, they plopped to the ground at my feet"

That is a brilliant, brilliant analogy."
July 11, 2013 –
page 180
61.22%
July 15, 2013 – Shelved as: it-stays-with-you
July 15, 2013 – Finished Reading
March 7, 2016 – Shelved as: for-my-future-library
January 4, 2019 – Shelved as: lush-writing
January 4, 2019 – Shelved as: favorite-author
January 4, 2019 – Shelved as: most-loved

Comments Showing 1-50 of 63 (63 new)


Jill Such a good book. Wishing you happy reading! (Even if it's an absolutely unhappy book.)


Scarlet Thanks Jill! I've been meaning to read Plath for a long time, so I'm really excited :)


Anushka Are you a mind-reader, Scarlet? I was going to start this book today too!


Scarlet Great! How are you finding it??


Anushka I'm actually putting it aside for now, a friend of mine just gave me Bourne Identity and I'm gonna hop on it now. I've been dying to read that book since...forever!


Scarlet Sam wrote: "I wasn't sure how I felt about this cover at first, but it's starting to grow on me. I've been wanting to read this forever! Can't wait to see what you think. :)"

Me too Sam! I had one of Plath's poems in school and that was just lovely. I'm quite enjoying her writing in this :)


Samadrita Beautiful review once again Scarlet. I have to read this soon. And Plath's writing has that unflinching honesty to it that I find unnerving as well. She bares it all for the world to see.


Scarlet Samadrita wrote: "Beautiful review once again Scarlet. I have to read this soon. And Plath's writing has that unflinching honesty to it that I find unnerving as well. She bares it all for the world to see."

Thanks Samadrita. I want to read more of her poems. She was such a talented woman *sigh*


message 9: by Mal � (new)

Mal ✨ | Tales Of A Bookbug Awesome review!!I felt exactly the same way after reading the book.Plath was really a brave woman to write such an unconventional book in her time.


Scarlet Shrimalya wrote: "Awesome review!!I felt exactly the same way after reading the book.Plath was really a brave woman to write such an unconventional book in her time."

Thanks Shrimalya! I agree.


message 11: by Susieville (new) - added it

Susieville I just saw the movie "Sylvia" on cable TV and must read this book.


Scarlet Susieville wrote: "I just saw the movie "Sylvia" on cable TV and must read this book."

Gwyneth Paltrow as Sylvia Plath? Hmm. Did you like the movie?? It doesn't sound very exciting from what I read on IMDB/Rotten Tomatoes.


message 13: by Jill (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jill Esther's (or Plath's?) commentary dwells entirely on thoughts and perceptions, never feelings. Depression is so often mistaken as a form of sadness. This woman, however, is not sad. She is empty. She is a shell. She contemplates killing herself with a kind of ease that's unnerving.

Excellent analysis right there. It's so so true.

I read this about a year ago now, and I'm still haunted by it. Your shelf "it stays with you" is apt. One scene in particular (I bet you know which one) still horrifies me.


message 14: by Jill (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jill Samadrita wrote: "Beautiful review once again Scarlet. I have to read this soon. And Plath's writing has that unflinching honesty to it that I find unnerving as well. She bares it all for the world to see."

Whoa. I can't believe you haven't read this. It seems like SUCH a Samadrita book. I hope you'll love it.


message 15: by Susieville (new) - added it

Susieville Scarlet wrote: "Susieville wrote: "I just saw the movie "Sylvia" on cable TV and must read this book."

Gwyneth Paltrow as Sylvia Plath? Hmm. Did you like the movie?? It doesn't sound very exciting from what I rea..."


I know it didn't get a good review, but I really liked it since I didn't know that much about her life story.


Scarlet @Jill: This book is going to haunt me for a long time. It was so unflinchingly honest.

I'm not sure which scene you're talking about. Many horrified me (view spoiler)

@Samadrita: I like how Jill put it - it is a Samadrita book! Could not agree more.

@Susieville: I actually did not know there was a movie like that, so thanks for commenting. I'll check it out if I can.


message 17: by Jill (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jill (view spoiler)


message 18: by Susieville (new) - added it

Susieville And Daniel Craig was hot in this movie..I love him with dark hair!


Sherrie Another great review, Scarlet! Well done. :)


Scarlet Jill wrote: "[spoilers removed]"

(view spoiler)


Scarlet Sherrie wrote: "Another great review, Scarlet! Well done. :)"

Thank you Sherrie! I'm glad you liked the book too :D


message 22: by Samadrita (last edited Jul 16, 2013 07:18AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Samadrita Jill wrote: "Samadrita wrote: "Beautiful review once again Scarlet. I have to read this soon. And Plath's writing has that unflinching honesty to it that I find unnerving as well. She bares it all for the world..."

Oops sorry! Missed your comment somehow, Jill. Yes it seems like a terribly 'Me' book. But I have read some of Plath's earlier poetry and Ariel. Will make it a priority to read this soon. Good to know you liked it too. :)


Basuhi I don't think I understood your review when I "liked" it sometime back. Now I do, and what can I really say ?
Sylvia Plath's life and the novel go parallel the case of her suicide has really made the book extra difficult to read. Beside I kept thinking that, This is the real deal.
Amazing review Scarlet :)


Scarlet Basuhi wrote: "I don't think I understood your review when I "liked" it sometime back. Now I do, and what can I really say ?
Sylvia Plath's life and the novel go parallel the case of her suicide has really made ..."


Thank you for re-visiting this review and commenting, Basuhi. I'm glad the book had such a profound impact on you :)


message 25: by Riku (new) - added it

Riku Sayuj Wishing you had cried - wonderfully poignant response. Nice review.


Scarlet Riku wrote: "Wishing you had cried - wonderfully poignant response. Nice review."

Thank you :) Sad books that don't make you cry are the ones that haunt you the most, no?


message 27: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich Outstanding review! Such beautiful sentiments and insight!


Scarlet s.penkevich wrote: "Outstanding review! Such beautiful sentiments and insight!"

Thank you :)


Tom LA Fully agree with your review.


Scarlet Tabasco wrote: "Fully agree with your review."

I'm glad you felt the same way :)


Parthiban Sekar Stunning review, Scarlet!


Scarlet Parthiban wrote: "Stunning review, Scarlet!"

Thank you, Parthiban :)


message 33: by Vessey (last edited Feb 28, 2016 01:54PM) (new) - added it

Vessey And in contrast with Sylvia Plath’s writing your own is so full of raw emotion and passion. Scarlet, this was incredible. The final parts of this review contain a whole world in them. I am in awe. Knowing that you were able to write and feel this way at 21 I can’t imagine what you will be like in the years to come. Thank you.


Scarlet Vessey wrote: "And in contrast with Sylvia Plath’s writing your own is so full of raw emotion and passion. Scarlet, this was incredible. The final parts of this review contain a whole world in them. I am in awe. ..."

Thank you so much for that profusely generous comment, Vessey! It means a lot, coming from an accomplished writer/reviewer like you.

And I'm particularly touched that you worked out the age at which I wrote this, hehe ;)


Matilda L. I just finished reading the book and I am left in awe. I really enjoyes reading your Review for I share your sentiment about Plath and her writing. The book is truly a masterpiece with such sad connotations.


Scarlet Marie wrote: "I just finished reading the book and I am left in awe. I really enjoyes reading your Review for I share your sentiment about Plath and her writing. The book is truly a masterpiece with such sad con..."

Yes, it is. Thanks, Marie :)


message 37: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Exciting review !!


Scarlet Gaurav wrote: "Exciting review !!"

Thanks for taking the time to read, Gaurav :)


Matthias Beautiful review, Scarlet. Perfectly agree with your observations. The book also left me with that sense of unhappiness you described so well in your penultimate paragraph, leading to a less generous rating from my side.


Scarlet Matthias wrote: "Beautiful review, Scarlet. Perfectly agree with your observations. The book also left me with that sense of unhappiness you described so well in your penultimate paragraph, leading to a less genero..."

Thank you, Matthias! :)


message 41: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer That's the greatness of this book and her writing. She has lead you down the roads of her mind and without you even noticing she's made you feel exactly how she did. It's a master piece. As you stated so beautifully she's empty. This books allows all types of people to understand the suffrage that someone with depression hides along their lives.


message 42: by [deleted user] (new)

A great review Scarlet. The self same quote stood out to me too.


avid listener A perfect review. I read The Bell Jar with no knowledge of Plath's life, and now I think I should do her justice and re-read it.


message 44: by AJ (new) - rated it 4 stars

AJ This is an insightful review, you captured my thoughts perfectly!


Martina I wrote similar things as you when I read this book. It haunted me too for a long time afterwards. The demostration that Plath was a great writer.


message 46: by urwa (new) - rated it 4 stars

urwa i agree with op! I didn't exactly feel 'sad' reading this novel, there was this epty type feeling inside me. I think its mostly because i found it so hard to differentiate Sylvia from Esther. Despite the hopeful ending, i couldn't help but feel deeply remorseful


Kristin White I completely agree with your review. I just finished reading it. I often wondered if she was speaking from her inner self and it made me even more sad as I read on.


Kat loved your review, I wholeheartedly agree- her writing is so devoid of emotion but because of that it perfectly captures the monotony and quiet emptiness of depression.


message 49: by Sarah (new) - added it

Sarah Muchuti this review describes perfectly how I am feeling right now after reading the book, the last parte when u say u wish u did cry it was exactly what I was thinking towards the end of the story. I feel kind of empty and sad now that I’ve read it and that’s also part of the reason I couldn’t give 5 stars if that makes sense. It also made me think so many times that Esther’s thoughts were Sylvia’s own and that made me even sadder. anyway, completely agree with your review, very well described!


message 50: by Rita (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rita I love this!


« previous 1
back to top