Cheryl's Reviews > Rebecca
Rebecca
by
by

Cheryl's review
bookshelves: vintage, fiction, women-and-books, the-psyche, mesmerizing
Nov 12, 2012
bookshelves: vintage, fiction, women-and-books, the-psyche, mesmerizing
Manderley,
"today we we pass on, we see it no more, and we are different, changed in some infinitesimal way. We can never be quite the same again."
It's such a sensation, when you read a book and a place is so memorable that it stays with you. To have place, plot, and person in such congruency, this is a treat; it is when you know an author is at her best. When I remember this book, I won't think of Rebecca, the deceased wife, nor will I recall the nameless narrator and gullible young bride of the rich Max de Winter. Instead, I will remember Manderley and everything that happened there that is so palpable within this first person narrative. If I do think about these characters, I will think of them when I think of Manderley. And this is strange, because I think this is the first book that has placed such a reminder of place within my reading memory.
I love my copy, because not only does it have an author's note from Daphne du Maurier, which tells of her writing experience, but there's also an essay she wrote of her own house, Menabilly, the "house of secrets" that Manderley is modeled after. She saw the house after it lay in ruins and she visited it for years, feeling somehow drawn to the forsaken mansion. Later, it would become hers. She was thirty years old and stationed with her soldier husband in Alexandria, when she began writing this story. "I lose myself in the plot as it unfolds, and only when the book is finished do I lay it aside," she said. Judging from the splay of this plot, it is obvious that she did lose herself in it. Two hundred and seventy pages in, a new story arc emerges and yet manages to remain true to the rest of the book. And Manderley is still the main character.
Manderley, its "colour and scent and sound, rain and the lapping of water, even the mists of autumn and the smell of the flood tide, these are memories of Manderley that will not be denied." In the midst of scent and sound, there is mystery and deceit. The glorious mansion has its hidden flaws, its dark secrets, and as the story unfolds, the narrator, a young, poor, orphan, strives to become the sophisticated wife that she thinks her older husband desires. She is alarmingly annoying, and her housekeeper, Mrs. Danvers, peculiarly frightful, yet what I found fascinating is how characters and themes seem to be balanced on a beam.
What makes you happy? What terrifies you? How do you deal with trauma? How do you deal with guilt and shame? Do you try to fit in, or do you choose to become the most comfortable with who you are? What is the essence of partnership? What about consequences? Who are you, without everything and everyone around you, who are you, really?
Gloom resides at Manderley, and because of this, we view the mansion from a distance, in retrospective narrative tense. Manderley, "secretive and silent as it had always been…a jewel in the hollow of a hand." Our protagonist has experienced pain and trauma and love and life and she can never go home again, this much is clear from the first sentence, "Last night I dreamt I went to Manderley again."
I love my copy, because not only does it have an author's note from Daphne du Maurier, which tells of her writing experience, but there's also an essay she wrote of her own house, Menabilly, the "house of secrets" that Manderley is modeled after. She saw the house after it lay in ruins and she visited it for years, feeling somehow drawn to the forsaken mansion. Later, it would become hers. She was thirty years old and stationed with her soldier husband in Alexandria, when she began writing this story. "I lose myself in the plot as it unfolds, and only when the book is finished do I lay it aside," she said. Judging from the splay of this plot, it is obvious that she did lose herself in it. Two hundred and seventy pages in, a new story arc emerges and yet manages to remain true to the rest of the book. And Manderley is still the main character.
Manderley, its "colour and scent and sound, rain and the lapping of water, even the mists of autumn and the smell of the flood tide, these are memories of Manderley that will not be denied." In the midst of scent and sound, there is mystery and deceit. The glorious mansion has its hidden flaws, its dark secrets, and as the story unfolds, the narrator, a young, poor, orphan, strives to become the sophisticated wife that she thinks her older husband desires. She is alarmingly annoying, and her housekeeper, Mrs. Danvers, peculiarly frightful, yet what I found fascinating is how characters and themes seem to be balanced on a beam.
What makes you happy? What terrifies you? How do you deal with trauma? How do you deal with guilt and shame? Do you try to fit in, or do you choose to become the most comfortable with who you are? What is the essence of partnership? What about consequences? Who are you, without everything and everyone around you, who are you, really?
When people suffer a great shock, like death, or the loss of a limb, I believe they don't feel it just at first. If your hand is taken from you you don't know, for a few minutes, that your hand is gone. You go on feeling the fingers. You stretch and beat them on the air, one by one, and all the time there is nothing there, no hand, no fingers.
Gloom resides at Manderley, and because of this, we view the mansion from a distance, in retrospective narrative tense. Manderley, "secretive and silent as it had always been…a jewel in the hollow of a hand." Our protagonist has experienced pain and trauma and love and life and she can never go home again, this much is clear from the first sentence, "Last night I dreamt I went to Manderley again."
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Rebecca.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 12, 2012
– Shelved
October 29, 2014
–
Started Reading
October 30, 2014
–
12.2%
"We can never go back again, that much is certain. The past is still too close to us. The things we have tried to forget and put behind us would stir again, and that sense of fear, of furtive unrest, struggling at length to blind unreasoning panic--now mercifully stilled, thank God--might in some manner unforeseen become a living companion, as it had been before."
page
50
November 2, 2014
–
62.2%
"This is the present. There is no past and no future. Here I am washing my hands and the cracked mirror shows me to myself, suspended as it were, in time; this is me, this moment will not pass...and I think how in that moment I have aged, and passed on, how I have advanced one step towards an unknown destiny."
page
255
November 3, 2014
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 56 (56 new)
message 1:
by
Dolors
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Nov 02, 2014 01:38AM

reply
|
flag
Yes! Very pleased to see those 5 stars :)

Excellent Cheryl, will be pending on that review! Thrilled like Lauren to see those 5 stars! :))




@Diane - Thanks and I hope you do manage to revisit it soon, Diane.
@Dolors - Well, she was a bit jealous of her husband's ex-fiancee :) Thanks for your tres beautiful comments, Dolors!
@Fionnuala - Yes, I was thrilled too to discover the real house behind the fictional one. Very interesting. Thanks, Fionnuala!

This is a title looooong on the tbr list that needs to be dealt with immediately. Hopefully before the year end.

I have so many that I hope to get through too before the year's end, Samadrita. Sigh. Psychological study this is! A story of self discovery, identity...you name it. I also saw a story of the unpredictability of life. I hope you manage to get to it soon.


Your passionate comment had me smiling, Julie. It's hard to describe a feeling that comes from reading this one--I'm glad to hear that I wasn't the only one having such difficulty. Thanks!




Ah-ha, there she is! I was just thinking how I haven't seen a Gar-review lately:) Thanks, and I hope you do read and review it someday because I can't wait for the lyrical web you will weave of your reading experience.



I don't think there's a bad place to start but the two that sounds the most interesting to me are Frenchman's Creek and Jamaica Inn.


@Debbie Thanks, Debbie. The first few pages are the older narrator's recollections of Manderley as she remembered it (in the epilogue you'll see how it changed), but later, the story unfolds slowly--a good kind of slow :)


Tiny point - Menabilly, on which she based "Manderley", was hers in spirit, nobody can deny that, but she did only rent it and was thrown out of it in later life. Sorry to be so literal when you were probably speaking metaphorically though ... :D


But I haven't read that particular essay, so must track it down! Thank you Cheryl :)


I knew this sounded familiar--I just revisited your wonderful review! Thanks to you, I think my second read will be My Cousin Rachel. The story about Menabilly truly saddens me...ouch.
The essay was lovely to read, to see her thoughts.

Thanks, Margitte! :)



:/ I'll kick myself for being lazy and try to come up with one soon.


I liked this at the time but never added a comment.
Looking at it now, I have a sense of envy (a dreadful trait to have and something that my parents always tried to stamp out of me and with 98% success) because when I read:
"I love my copy, because not only does it have an author's note from Daphne du Maurier, which tells of her writing experience, but there's also an essay she wrote of her own house, Menabilly, the "house of secrets" that Manderley is modeled after. She saw the house after it lay in ruins and she visited it for years, feeling somehow drawn to the forsaken mansion. Later, it would become hers."
What a beautiful book to have and with those comments! My.
I have a very battered blue hardback, with no cover and a broken spine. It begins at page 5 (nothing before it), the pages are yellowing with age, there are what appear to be water stains on it, there are loose pages and would you believe this but I absolutely love it. It smells of time and a sense of place.

I liked this at the time but never added a comment.
Looking at it now, I have a sense of envy (a dreadful trait to have and something that my parents always tried to stamp out of me and w..."
Lynne, sorry I just saw this! How disappointing, your book's pages are gone, but at least you have the story :) You've probably had yours for a while? I love that you love the sense and feel of it, and that you've cherished it this long. You've made me realize that I should do the same with mine, because each book reminds me of an instance. Thanks for the comment.

I liked this at the time but never added a comment.
Looking at it now, I have a sense of envy (a dreadful trait to have and something that my parents always tried to stamp o..."
Cheryl, It actually belonged to my father. He loved second-hand books and often went to these shops in Charing Cross Road in London. I sometimes went with him.