ŷ

Megan Quinn's Reviews > We All Want Impossible Things

We All Want Impossible Things by Catherine Newman
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
100974303
's review

it was ok

This was a Real Simple rec, and I was coming down off the high of Lessons in Chemistry, hoping for a comparably great subsequent read. Kind of wish I hadn’t dived into this. The rec was so glowing, and I used to want to be a hospice nurse and served for a time as a hospice respite volunteer, so a fresh, “outrageously funny� take on a best friend going thru the hospice/palliative care process of dying seemed awesome and irresistible. But for the most part, this really wasn’t. There are redeeming qualities to it. The “I’m dying� and “it’s killing me� statements we all make and try to eject from our vocabulary when visiting someone in hospice who’s actually dying? Truth. But the main character is so wildly self-focused. I kept thinking “this chick needs so much damn therapy.� There’s a lot of self-reflection when a loved one’s dying, but hell. Ash is an irresponsible 14 yr old in a mom’s body. I just had no patience or tolerance for her. Spent half the book rolling my eyes at her.
43 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read We All Want Impossible Things.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 13, 2022 – Started Reading
November 13, 2022 – Shelved
November 15, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jenny I don’t like Ash. At all.


Denise Romero I feel totally the same!


Cszostak Hates Ash


Cszostak Talk Before Sleep by Elizabeth Berg has a similar story but much more depth and much better characters


Megan Quinn Thank you! I’ll check that one out!


Aneets Ash was honestly the worst!


Serena I was so annoyed at her and the story line of all of her sexual encounters and her daughter being completely aware and walking in on her all the time. Why was that necessary?


Kris Serena, same.


message 9: by Gail Moore (new)

Gail Moore Absolutely agree! About Ash and Talk Before Sleep.


Melanie Gamboa Serena, exactly!


Nikolina Same! Ash is a sad example of a middle aged woman so far away from the wisdom and kindness that should come with age!


Mooney I annotated in my book- ash is more immature than her teenage daughter. Who, BTW gives Ash a run for her money for being the most insufferable character. Amazingly wise and composed yet cutesy enough to wonder about platypus farms.


back to top