ŷ

jolie's Reviews > Caraval

Caraval by Stephanie Garber
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
154946604
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: physical-books-read

3.75 stars

“She imagined thinking falling for him would be like falling in love with darkness, but now she imagined he was more like a starry night: the constellations were always there, constant, magnificent guides against the ever-present black.�

“With Julian it wasn’t about protection—she just wanted to be with him. The boy who saved her in more ways than one.� ❤️‍�

“Two people choosing to give tiny vulnerable parts of themselves to each other. That’s what Scarlett wanted. That’s what she deserved.�


alexa? play maroon by taylor swift!

this was a pleasant surprise. i truly wish i could say this book was perfect. in almost every aspect, it definitely gave off an amazing energy and the writing was absolutely impeccable. this book was able to shatter my heart while at the same time put it back together. i was so immersed within the world of caraval and everything! this is the one instance where i enjoyed the insta-love.

every scene with scarlettjulian was amazingly written. need i say more? i feel like every scene that was considered intimate felt like so much more to them which was so touching to me. it was like the way they understood each other went farther than words could describe. i will never get over the way julian protected her and cared for her despite the risks he knew he was taking. with every plot twist i felt a part of my heart shrivel up but this book always knew how to make me feel better. the conflict was solved a bit too fast for my liking but i’m so excited to continue this trilogy! i haven’t written a long review in a long time but i hope this covers up everything to explain my rating

spoilers from this point on!!

i feel like there were times where scarlett came off as too stubborn and prioritizing her sister made her feel denial for anything else. don’t get me wrong, i definitely loved her dedication but i thought there were times where she was too much abt it. when she refused to admit saving her sister wasn’t her greatest desire despite the odds fighting against her while buying a dress. i didn’t like how she refused to have any other answer and decided giving 2 days of her life was better. i also thought she would stretch how much she actually cared for her sister and it was a bit much.

another thing that irked me was how they often brushed over the romance by adding in the mystery aspect. it was like with every romantic thing that happened, something just had to come along to prove that tella would always be more important than julian was to scarlett. it was like a constant reminder that they had better things to do rather than cherish the scenes that they shared.

to add on, the reunion between tella and scarlett was so disappointing. i legit started crying the moment tella trusted “legend� over scarlett bc despite everything scarlett went through and how much she prioritized her, it was sad seeing tella wouldn’t do the same for her. it just shows how truly different they were & the miscommunication between them killed me. i expected so much more from them given how they are sisters and claim to love one another

as i’ve mentioned before, i loved the writing SO much. it was so easy to get lost into the writing and despite the beginning being confusing, everything else i loved. i also felt that the slow burn was the perfect amount. it was excruciating but i still ate up every scene with them 😋 anyways my love for julian expands to the end of the world. he was literally the definition of perfectly written—from the way he strutted as he walked to the nickname “crimson�.

i loved scarlettjulian so much more than i expected to in this book!! however, their reunion was just disappointing. it was just heartbreak as a way to put off the romance until the very end. and the fact that julian stopped calling her crimson? i couldn’t believe it. it was like none of them knew what to say and just kept making everything worse. however i did like how their reunion ended. they were just amazing. i still can’t believe the ending. it was so sad to learn that the role he played as an actor was different than who he actually was. i sympathized with scarlett and how she felt.

series review! `� ˑ ִֶ 𓂃⊹✩
legendary
finale
spectacular
159 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Caraval.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 23, 2022 – Shelved
November 23, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
February 27, 2023 – Shelved as: physical-books-read
March 4, 2023 – Started Reading
March 4, 2023 –
page 24
5.97% "the time has come."
March 4, 2023 –
page 44
10.95% "is it bad i’m lowkey falling for julian"
March 5, 2023 –
page 81
20.15% "AM I SENSING SOME FAKE DATING?? 🤭🤭"
March 6, 2023 –
page 87
21.64% "“Don’t look at me like that. It doesn’t work on me�
“That’s why it’s so fun�
HELLO I’M FREAKING OUT"
March 6, 2023 –
page 103
25.62% "THERES NO WAY HE JUST CALLED HER MY LITTLE LIAR AHHH"
March 6, 2023 –
page 121
30.1% "oh my gosh i love this book so much already"
March 8, 2023 –
page 155
38.56% "slight spoilers!!?

pls tell me she doesn’t marry the count i’m begging"
March 8, 2023 –
page 173
43.03% "“Sometimes he gazed at her as if he wanted to be her undoing, but just then it was as if he wanted her to undo him.�
WHY ARE THEY SO.."
March 8, 2023 –
page 206
51.24% "SPOILERS AHEAD!!

scarlett babe ily but ur denial to accept something is more desirable than saving ur sister is killing me 😭😭 (i got the feeling her greatest desire is julian 🤭)"
March 8, 2023 –
page 208
51.74% "YESSSSS JULIAN SAVING SCARLETT FROM DANTE"
March 8, 2023 –
page 210
52.24% "SPOILERS AHEAD!

“I’m going to try giving you a day of my life�
OH MY GOD JULIAN?! 😭😭"
March 8, 2023 –
page 221
54.98% "WHAT"
March 9, 2023 – Started Reading (Other Paperback Edition)
March 9, 2023 –
page 228
56.72% "i can’t handle this angst i just woke up ☹️"
March 9, 2023 –
page 263
65.42% "“He had a look on his face that suggested he wanted to toss her over his shoulder and keep her locked away and hidden from the rest of the world�
I AM NEVER GETTING OVER HIM"
March 9, 2023 –
page 273
67.91% ""She remembered thinking falling for him would be like falling in love with darkness, but now she imagined he was mote like a starry night: the constellations were always there, constant, magnificent guides against the ever-present black" YES. YES."
March 9, 2023 –
page 278
69.15% "THAT WAS SO WORTH IT OMG"
March 9, 2023 –
page 278
69.15% ""I'm not afraid of your secrets."
"I wish I could say you shouldn't be."
SCREAMING AND CRYING RN"
March 9, 2023 –
page 281
69.9% "THE WAY HE REACHED FOR HER DESPITE THE RISKS IS KILLING ME"
March 9, 2023 –
page 298
74.13% "SPOILERS!!!

“No wonder Julian hadn’t appeared more excited at the sight of all the balconies at the beginning of the game. They were fifty cruel reminders of what he had lost.�
SOBBING RN"
March 9, 2023 –
page 307
76.37% "WTF IS HAPPENING"
March 9, 2023 –
page 311
77.36% "EXCUSE ME."
March 9, 2023 –
page 312
77.61% "SPOILERS AHEAD!!

“I guess I’m better than i thought.� Julian’s smile turned vicious, the kind made for breaking hearts.
NO NO NO"
March 9, 2023 –
page 331
82.34% "OK NOW WHO TF IS LEGEND I NEED TO KNOW"
March 10, 2023 –
page 349
86.82% "stop bc i feel so bad after everything scarlett’s been through ☹️☹️ she deserves the world 💞"
March 10, 2023 –
page 379
94.28% "STOP I CANT HANDLE THIS PAIN AGAIN PLS"
March 10, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Debbie90 My favorite series of 2022!


message 2: by dia (new) - rated it 4 stars

dia scarlett my beloved


message 3: by jolie (last edited Mar 10, 2023 10:25AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

jolie dia � wrote: "scarlett my beloved"

i love her so so much


rania ★ Caraval wasn’t my favourite book ever, (a bit slow for me) but this review did perfect in covering all the stuff I did enjoy. And never apologize for using that quote. Stephenie Garber really does have a way with words. Lovely review ❤️‍�


kaley ❥ great review!!! i read this back in 2021 and reading your review has convinced me i definitely need to reread it ❤️‍�


jolie rania (warner’s version) wrote: "Caraval wasn’t my favourite book ever, (a bit slow for me) but this review did perfect in covering all the stuff I did enjoy. And never apologize for using that quote. Stephenie Garber really does ..."

thank you!! i definitely understand where you're getting at with it being a bit slow & i can agree with u a bit in the beginning. i'm glad u thought i covered the stuff u enjoyed :')


jolie kaley � (kaleysreads) wrote: "great review!!! i read this back in 2021 and reading your review has convinced me i definitely need to reread it ❤️‍�"

OMG THATS SO SWEET THANK YOU!!! 🥹🥹


bookobsessed love ur review!! and scarlett and julian are just my favs ❤️‍�


jolie bookobsessed wrote: "love ur review!! and scarlett and julian are just my favs ❤️‍�"

awwe tysm!! <33 i love them sm they have my heart


Heather  Lovick ❤ I looooved this series so much. I am definitely going to re read it someday.


jolie Heather wrote: "I looooved this series so much. I am definitely going to re read it someday."

omg i so agree it's amazing!! i have such an attachment to the characters its crazy


✧ hayley (the sugar bowl) ✧ i’m so glad you loved this!! stephanie’s writing is so beautiful. Hope you enjoy the rest of the series <3


message 13: by jolie (last edited Apr 11, 2023 03:15PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

jolie � hayley (the sugar bowl) � wrote: "i’m so glad you loved this!! stephanie’s writing is so beautiful. Hope you enjoy the rest of the series <3"

thank uu!! her writng was definitely captivating from the start. and i did enjoy the rest of the series!


message 14: by vee! (new) - rated it 4 stars

vee! i love this book sm!!! so glad you enjoyed it <33


jolie vee ୨୧⋆。˚ � wrote: "i love this book sm!!! so glad you enjoyed it <33"

omg i'm glad u loved it too!! <3


♯  ahmaya. AHH I LOVE THIS REVIEW 🫶🏽🫶🏽. I really need ot re-read this series and rate it because I read it 2 or 3 years ago and I don't exactly remember much. I gave it a five stars though. I feel like you're right on that, Tella was deff not appreciative enough of Scarlett, and it made me so mad! And exactly! The Romance scenes were always brushed over because they "remembered" what was actually happening, but damn they had me giggling and shit 🤭🤭


jolie @ahmaya AWW THANK U SM ML 💘💘 i hope u enjoy ur reread!! these books are truly magical � so glad u enjoyed it and gave it 5 stars! honestly tella and scarlett did not give off the sister vibes they were supposed to 😭 and even if they brushed over the small romance scenes i ate it up every single time, it was so good 🤭


♯  ahmaya. jolie ୨♡� wrote: "@ahmaya AWW THANK U SM ML 💘💘 i hope u enjoy ur reread!! these books are truly magical � so glad u enjoyed it and gave it 5 stars! honestly tella and scarlett did not give off the sister vibes they ..."

OMG PLS IGNORE THE 5 STARS 😭😭. People call me out on all my old reads that have 5 stars, i swear i need to RR it 😭🤚🏽. I enjoyed this series SM but I was 11, blind, and in dire need for glasses 💀💀. AND REAL. Even dunno if you've read the 2nd one (view spoiler). This series will forever own my past, blind as shit 11 year old's heart 🫶🏽🫶🏽


jolie � ˚。⋆� Ahmaya ୧⋆ ˚。⋆ wrote: "jolie ୨♡� wrote: "@ahmaya AWW THANK U SM ML 💘💘 i hope u enjoy ur reread!! these books are truly magical � so glad u enjoyed it and gave it 5 stars! honestly tella and scarlett did not give off the ..."

HAHAHA DW IDM I PREVIOUSLY RATED IT 5 STARS WHEN I FIRST READ IT TOO 😭 i don't blame you, it was still definitely a good book 🤭 and yes i have read the second book !! (view spoiler) i hope you still enjoy once u reread babes <33


♯  ahmaya. jolie ୨♡� wrote: " � ˚。⋆� Ahmaya ୧⋆ ˚。⋆ wrote: "jolie ୨♡� wrote: "@ahmaya AWW THANK U SM ML 💘💘 i hope u enjoy ur reread!! these books are truly magical � so glad u enjoyed it and gave it 5 stars! honestly tella and ..."

THANK YOU GORGEOUS! And real! I adore his lines like anythignelse. (view spoiler). I'll deff update you along my way <33


jolie � ˚。⋆� Ahmaya ୧⋆ ˚。⋆ wrote: "jolie ୨♡� wrote: " � ˚。⋆� Ahmaya ୧⋆ ˚。⋆ wrote: "jolie ୨♡� wrote: "@ahmaya AWW THANK U SM ML 💘💘 i hope u enjoy ur reread!! these books are truly magical � so glad u enjoyed it and gave it 5 stars! h..."

he certainly had a way with words !! i was gushing with every word that he spoke 🤭🤭 (view spoiler) can't wait to see ur thoughts ahh give me all of them <333


Lilyya ♡ I’ll read this masterpiece-review when I finish the book🤭


jolie @lilyya aww stop ur so sweet 😚 i hope u enjoy it love!! 💞💞


⋆ ˚。⋆୨ ana ୧⋆ ˚。⋆ that falling in love w darkness quote is my favorite😭😭😭


jolie @ana mine too i love it 😭


back to top