ŷ

Lilyya �'s Reviews > Caraval

Caraval by Stephanie Garber
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
142709713
's review

liked it

2.75 stars

� My little liar, Julian mouthed.�


The writing held a contradictory connotation, to my opinion. It rocked from a polished, opulent vocabulary and exquisite metaphors to an atrociously neglected characters� depth and world building. Some scenes were vividly and graphically descriptive from the costumes to the atmosphere surrounding our protagonists but they lacked explanation when it came to Scarlett’s feelings and thoughts, she partially felt shallow except from some verbal jousts with Julian. Plus, the magic orbiting around The Caraval, Legend and the actors was nonchalantly mentioned. Perhaps it was intentional and some of the questions will be answered and clarified in the next books in the series but, for me, the way the folklore wasn’t sufficiently distilled through the chapters to offer a perfect understanding of the magical world made it difficult to go through the story, therefore I didn’t feel completely connected to either the storyline nor the characters.

"Legend’s special guest had made Scarlett feel privileged. For the first time in her life, she’d felt special. Chosen. But once again, rather than feeling as if she were playing the game, it seemed as if the game were playing with her."


Everything was a subterfuge. A game, from the side characters� intentions and motives to why the story started in the first place. When you feel like a guest you are in reality just a piece of chess in the grand scheme of The Caraval. And I got played all along with Scarlett. I was angry at first but, I completely understand the author’s vision, it’s honestly brilliant from the start to near, near the end . However, it was poorly, barely sorted. The ending felt rushed and Scarlett made some compromises and decisions that I don’t understand, at all.


P.S.:Julian carried the book until he didn’t.🫶🏼

•~•~•~•~
tella WTH girl?????? the last chapters? im speechless. rtc

~*~*~*~*~*~
monique is joining the julian fan club, hope yall r happy now! idk who the hell he is

buddy read with lila and Aliki🫶🏼
324 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Caraval.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 22, 2023 – Started Reading
May 22, 2023 – Shelved
May 26, 2023 –
21.0% ""Crimson"😮‍�

and gn."
May 27, 2023 –
26.0% ""My little liar, Julian mouthed"

im blushing."
May 29, 2023 –
33.0% ""Julian’s lips were curving into that same mocking twist that appeared whenever she mentioned Legend’s name."

istg if my theory is right..😭"
May 31, 2023 –
63.0% "he- WHAT? he knew??"
June 1, 2023 –
72.0% ""I don’t care about what happens to me.�
“But I care,� Scarlett said"


stooooop, im a mess rn😭"
June 1, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 152 (152 new)


message 1: by Rowida (new) - added it

Rowida Happy reading Monique


mai ༉‧⋆˚. So exciting 🤭🤭🤭


becca ୨୧ happy reading luvs!! 🫶🏼


message 4: by Dani (new)

Dani Happy reading! Hope this is everythingg. I'm excited to read this one some day 🥳


Lilyya ♡ @Rowida- thank youu!!🫶🏼


lulu you better love him my little liar


Ellie °• semi-hiatus Omg enjoyyyyy✨️🙌🙌🙌


Lilyya ♡ @mai- yaaaay im really excited 🤭


Rebecca (life's chaotic catching up) Happy Reading beautiful ladies! I hope you guys have fun and love this series! JACKS JUST JACKS!!! 😍😍😍


anmol i wanna say something but im afraid of lulu 😔


anmol you gotta love him tho idc 🔪


message 12: by Huda (new) - added it

Huda 😂 can't wait for your thoughts💖


Lilyya ♡ @becca- aw thank u ml!🫶🏼


jolie omg yes i’m so happy for u 🤭🤭 julian is amazing, can’t wait to hear ur thoughts on him!! happy reading loves 💘


message 15: by lila � (new) - added it

lila ⋆ lmfao not you NOT knowing who he is 🤭 thats so u. i'm so excited to see monique come out w her bitchiness in this br 🥰


Lilyya ♡ @Dani- tysm!! can’t wait for u to finally pick it up!❤️


Lilyya ♡ @lulu- like, am i ur lil liar or HE IS ?


Lilyya ♡ @Elli- thank youuu!!<33


Aliki (semi hiatus) WUHUUU I AM SO EXCITEEED TO MEET JULIAN AND JACKS 🤭😍😍


message 20: by alayla ! (new) - added it

alayla ! AHH happy reading love, i hope you adore it sososo much 💞


wolfydragon1 OKAY BUT DANTE AND JACKS


Lilyya ♡ @Rebecca- thank you, gorgeous!! JACKS duly noted🫡❤️


Lilyya ♡ @anmol- since when u r afraid of lulu🫢? ima love him, keykey


eliana_sophiaa happy br babess! i'm a little scared of getting canceled by the julian stans but lemme tell you -- you'll love jacks sm more 🤭


Lilyya ♡ @Huda- im gonna rant 😭😂😂


Lilyya ♡ @jolie- yaaay, it sounds promising!! thank you babes !!💖💖


♯  ahmaya. AHH SO EXCITED FOR YOU. YOU BETTER LIKE IT OR YOU'LL GET BRUTALLY MUDERED BY THE REST OF THE BOOK PEOPEL read: me. WISHING YOU LUCK PRETTY GIRL, HOPE YOU ENJOY 🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽


message 28: by lulu (new) - rated it 3 stars

lulu @anmol you’re always up to no good 🤨

@lilyya yes 💗


vio no longer here Have fun my loves 💖💖 can't wait to see what you think about this series 🫶🏻


Lyra (Cardan's tail's version) Happy reading my loves!


♡Gabi♡ [life & work is chaotic hiatus] happy reading babes!!🥰💗


Lilyya ♡ @lila- love how u know monique so well🥲 and ofc she’s gonna bitch around 😭😭 but i just need to finish tomorrow’s exam and then im gonna spam gr with updates 🤭


سار&;#1349; I love this book/series!! I hope u enjoy reading it<33


message 34: by maya (new)

maya "you little liar" rings some bells monmon? that was julian, like uff that line 😮‍� happy br my loves


message 35: by Alex (new) - rated it 3 stars

Alex ❣️ Ohmigodd! Can't belive u started it! Happy reading gurls and hope u will join the Legend fan club as well!;-)


krys ~♡~ (scarlett's version) Ahhhh!! Omgg happy br, ml! I hope you love Julian this book 🤭💖


Lilyya ♡ @Aliki- me too babes me too😭😭


Lilyya ♡ @Alayla- thank u my love!! fingers crossed 🤭💖


Lilyya ♡ @ninispublicdiary- DULY NOTED MA’AM 🤭


message 40: by Iqra (new) - added it

Iqra BROO this book is stalking me 🫣


Pluto_reads I have a question, how do you @ people on gr?


Lilyya ♡ @eliana- u r so real for it! lulu can be scary sometimes 😭 thank u, love!!💖


Lilyya ♡ @Ahmaya- STOP SCARING ME 😭😭😭 but i think im gonna love him and book 🤭🤭


Lilyya ♡ lulu wrote: "@anmol you’re always up to no good 🤨

@lilyya yes 💗"


omg why so mean


message 45: by Han (new) - rated it 4 stars

Han Monique must love Julian! 🤭 Happy reading, babe!! 🥰


Lilyya ♡ @vio- thank you, my love!!🫶🏼


Lilyya ♡ @Lyra- thank u, beautiful !


Lilyya ♡ @Gabi- thanks babes!!💖


Lilyya ♡ @Deema- as long as i can be obsessed with a fictional character 🤭 thank you, gorgeous !💖


message 50: by tima (new) - rated it 4 stars

tima OMG YESS, THE BEST SERIES IN EXISTENCE, HAVE FUN GIRL


« previous 1 3 4
back to top