ŷ

Diana's Reviews > The Four Agreements: A Practical Guide to Personal Freedom

The Four Agreements by Miguel Ruiz
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1105690
's review

it was ok

OK. So. I liked several parts of this book very much. I love that happiness is a choice. I especially appreciated reading about the third agreement: Don't Make Assumptions because communication is something I can always work on. I loved the parts about accepting and loving yourself and others. There is some amazing advise in this little book and I can see how it can be life changing for many people.

But.

I'm going to be honest and admit that Ruiz almost lost me at "Everything is God" in the introduction. Even though it sounds very pretty when said by a dude made of stars and fog, "Everything is God" is a meaningless statement. That's just something people say to blow everyone's mind and make themselves appear deeper than they actually are. Believe what you like about God, but saying everything is God is just the same as saying nothing is God, in which case you ought to go ahead and say what you mean and be a respectable atheist.

He almost lost me again at the John Lennon quote, just before the beginning of Chapter One. Little known fact: John Lennon quotes are a pet peeve of mine. Who knew- right? And then again when he kept using the word "dreamy-dream-dreamer" to make everything sound super emotive and enlightened. Not that there's anything really wrong with that- just not my thing.

And I admit I was annoyed by his over-simplifications, his vagueness about the evils of "the dream of the planet" (societal expectations) and again by his many generalizations- especially about how NO ONE is free to be herself because we're ALL "domesticated" (brainwashed) by society and our parents and teachers and church leaders, ALL blind, ALL narcissists. Which, you know, isn't entirely true.

I'm certainly not a conformist, but I believe there needs to be a balance- some things you should conform to. Like not stealing. Or speeding through residential neighborhoods. Whether I'm personally feeling it or not, many societal expectations aren't relative. They're necessary. On the other hand, if by "the dream of the planet" he means cultural customs like judging people for their hairstyle or the music they like then I agree that "the dream of the planet" is bad news. See, it would be helpful if he were slightly less mysterious in his approach.

Once I managed to sort through the new-age incense and magic (Not my flavor), I actually agreed with the four agreements. Imagine that. It turns out I've heard them before from Mother Teresa, C.S. Lewis, Dr. Seuss, Steven Covey, Jesus Christ, and many others. Life is infinitely better when you're honest and courageous enough to accept yourself, communicative in your relationships, positive, open and loving, forgiving of yourself and others, and continually trying to do your best. That is how we become a happy person. That is what most religions teach. That's what most schools encourage. That's what science shows. Its no secret- its just surprisingly difficult to remember and put into practice. Props to Ruiz for reminding me of this and for writing a book to help others. While his writing style made me vomit a little in my mouth, still he meant well and has assuredly encouraged many on the path to happiness.

I would add, it is my personal belief that our reason for being- our purpose on earth is to learn to be happy. And truly happy people are always good people. Not perfect, but good. And I would add further that it stands to reason that the better a person is, the happier she becomes. Which is where religion takes the four agreements a step further, claiming that we are eternal beings and if so then we are day by day over an eternity either becoming more like God, or less like God. We are either progressing towards perfect happiness or perfect misery. Christianity also adds that we don't need to do this on our own, which idea rings true and logical and brings me comfort.

Wow. Ruiz inspired me to write my own book.








242 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Four Agreements.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
January 29, 2013 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Diana I hope this isn't an offensive review. I tend to sound snarkier in print than I do in my head :)


Diana It really does! I re-read your review and was amused at our similar take on the book. There was definitely some good info- it was the presentation that kind of killed it for me.


message 3: by Amy (new) - rated it 2 stars

Amy I haven't gotten much further than the introduction and I'm definitely agreeing with both you and Chrystal so far. We'll see how far I can get.


message 4: by Kai (new) - rated it 2 stars

Kai Wonderful review and very thoughtful :)


message 5: by Amarah (new)

Amarah Strack When I look for a book to read I go to the ones that give it two or three stars. This way I get some honest opinions that a 5 star would not give. I like your take on seeing both sides. This book is one of my top books I have read but enjoyed your comments


message 6: by Bob (new)

Bob Haney Your review is very well written. Someone recommended this book to me but I think your review of the book might just be better than the book itself, from what I've read of the other reviews on this site.


Kelsey Cox I agree with all of your review. I'm so glad you put it out there though, because all I can get off my chest is "this book is so boring, I want to punch myself in the face."


message 8: by Adam (new) - rated it 1 star

Adam You sound totally Mormon (sorry if that's presumptuous). I'm noticing a trend among the most "liked" negative reviews of this book. Most of them appear to come from people who are LDS.


Brittany  Findley It's a metaphor. Lol.


message 10: by Benjamin (last edited Dec 28, 2019 07:57AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Benjamin Tran "Everything is god" - Perhaps you would be more comfortable if we reframed the notion of "god". Instead if we use the word "nature", or the "universe" - isn't everything nature, or the universe? I think that is what is meant by "God is everything". We need not separate ourselves from the word "God" as an individual being or entity. In many Eastern religions (Hinduism, Buddhism, Taoism, Catholicism arguably) this is indeed the belief. Everything "is", and the "isness" is respected. God is synonymous to nature. The free flowing force that governs everything, that we are all apart of.

John Lennon sang about the same sort of philosophies in his songs, which is why this quote fitted here, in my own opinion. If you'd give yourself some time to listen to: strawberry fields forever, watching the wheels, I'm only sleeping, Across the universe, or Let it be. Without biases/introjections in mind, perhaps the inherent message of the music becomes more clear! That's why I like music, it conveys nature in a way that is soothing, less rigid, more fluid.

On your mention of his "oversimplification" of concepts - perhaps if he was too specific about something, that leaves more room for misinterpretation. The simpler the teaching, the better it is (Occam's Razor). This is inherent in the Tao Te Ching, and many other books of philosophy that make an attempt to explain the nature of things, but not in a way that is misconstrued by the limited power of words. We are all domesticated, in the way that we have been taught concepts and ideas that govern our way of belief. When we truly let go of such beliefs, perhaps trust our own perceptions more than what we have been told to believe, insights on reality and consciousness become more clear. That's not to say to truly forget or let go of introjections, but to be wary of their biases. This is a central tenet of eastern philosophy.

I agree with you: our purpose on earth is to be happy. To find meaning, fulfillment, and to actualize ourselves as human beings. And this is all possible by letting go for the "dream of the planet" as the authour would say: and to tune in to what was always there. Independent of what you are taught, there is a certain intention that is always there if you let go of such beliefs. To love is in our nature, and so is facing the reality of things. This is what he means by a "Dream": when we don't acknowlege this, becoming too attached to our worldly preoccupations. When we attribute to our taught reality as "true", just like as you would in a dream, it becomes real, but you may not realize you are dreaming.


Brittany  Findley I agree with Ben lol.


Aleesha Wood I gave this book 5 stars, but I really do love your review haha. Your points are valid, and I agree with some of them. Still love this book! But I did find it "overly simple" at times.


message 13: by jakara (new) - added it

jakara this review sums up my feelings of this read.

follow up question: have you written that book yet?


Roberto Galindo You write so well, great review. 👍


Dr. Frank A. Reed Nice review. Gentle and to the point. I especially like your thoughts on God is Everything


Alexandra V. I completely agree with your review; you said exactly what I was thinking � about agreeing on certain fundamentals, but getting annoyed with the BS and new age, pretentious crap.


message 17: by Jevaughn (new) - added it

Jevaughn Smith Very nice review indeed


back to top