mark monday's Reviews > Ice
Ice
by
by

mark monday's review
bookshelves: mind-the-gap, world-of-insects, unstablenarratives, new-dimensions, after-the-fall, unicorn
Dec 20, 2020
bookshelves: mind-the-gap, world-of-insects, unstablenarratives, new-dimensions, after-the-fall, unicorn
What does the future of the world hold for us little humans? Let us take a look.
The weapons of the atom deployed. The nations of men in battle. Borders and boundaries blurred, broken, crossed, lines drawn as if in the sand and just as easily erased. The small towns and villages suffer first, as always, but the cities and then countries will follow and fall. The world turns hot then cold, its people huddle and flee, the walls of ice encroach: a return to old forms, a slow domination by the world's true master. A new age shall begin: the wounds of the world healed with frost, its little parasites and their strange little ways finally eradicated. 'Tis the snowy season!
But what of the particular men that dominate this book, this world within Ice? That is their specific identity, these men: they dominate. They have dominated the world with their hot and cold wars and so they seek to dominate this woman. Our narrator is one such man, and his foe is another. His foe and his friend and his mirror reflection. Together they yearn to dominate the woman of Ice. Why is this so? Because their desires must be satisfied; they will travel the dying world to find this object of their desire.
But what of this woman of Ice, nameless as the men? Who is she?
Self Portrait, by Anna Kavan
First of all, as the author tells us, and tells us, and tells us, she is a victim. She is a victim. She is a victim. A victim of life, her mother made her into one. A victim of men, the men made her into one. A victim of the world, the world made her into one. A victim of herself, she made herself into one. She is a victim. She is a victim. She is a victim. She may deny it, but she is addicted to victimhood.
Second of all: she is the author. And she is not. She is the author and she is all women whose identity has been taken away by their family. And by men. And by the world. And by themselves. And by their addictions. And she is not. She is a blankness. There is no self-loathing because there is no self. Shall she reinvent herself? Can she even exist outside of the gaze of others? She'll never know, not this woman of Ice. She has only herself to blame, and everyone else.
But what of this author, Anna Kavan? This "Anna Kavan" did indeed reinvent herself: Helen Woods then Helen Ferguson took the name of one of her own characters, from her own novel. She changed who she was and yet was ever the same, struggling with mental health, with the toll of addiction, with the toll of life itself. Two of her children's lives ended early as she tried to end her own life early, again and again. And yet she lived as well! She loved and she traveled and she wrote and she made herself start again and again and again. A life of struggle but a life full of life as well.
But what of this book? It is about subjugation, addiction, and obsession. The relationships and the narrative are as unstable and alienated as the characters, as the writer herself. The book is culmination, excoriation, a book of waking dreams, a book of travel, a book of love, a book of death, a scourge that lashes the world of men, the world of men and women, the world of Anna Kavan.
Woman with a dish of fruit, by Anna Kavan
It is a painful book: do not read this if you are depressed. And yet I left the book invigorated: Kavan transformed her pain into something terrible and beautiful.
It is an angry book: anger at the world, at men, at the self.
It is a feminist book, a political book:
It is a hallucinatory book: do not read this if you are easily confused. And yet one must embrace the confusion, the dreams and dream logic and hallucinations and the stories and characters blending, bleeding into each other. It is a demanding book and yet the world of the book is so easy to enter, to slip into. They say that death in the snow is the easiest death of all.
It was her last book: Anna Kavan died a year after it was published. And yet a writer's brilliance may outlive their earthly torments.
It is a book that was easy for me to admire but hard for me to love. The book is 4.5 stars, rounded up. Something in me can't give it that trifling additional .5 - I can't make it a favorite. I can't. I can't. I can't. A book this bleak can't be a favorite. It can't. It can't. It can't.
Three nudes on plinths, by Anna Kavan
Does this book written in 1967 foretell our future, on this eve of our twenty-first year in this cold, angry, deadly new millennium? Let us take a look.
The weapons of the atom deployed. The nations of men in battle. Borders and boundaries blurred, broken, crossed, lines drawn as if in the sand and just as easily erased. The small towns and villages suffer first, as always, but the cities and then countries will follow and fall. The world turns hot then cold, its people huddle and flee, the walls of ice encroach: a return to old forms, a slow domination by the world's true master. A new age shall begin: the wounds of the world healed with frost, its little parasites and their strange little ways finally eradicated. 'Tis the snowy season!
But what of the particular men that dominate this book, this world within Ice? That is their specific identity, these men: they dominate. They have dominated the world with their hot and cold wars and so they seek to dominate this woman. Our narrator is one such man, and his foe is another. His foe and his friend and his mirror reflection. Together they yearn to dominate the woman of Ice. Why is this so? Because their desires must be satisfied; they will travel the dying world to find this object of their desire.
But what of this woman of Ice, nameless as the men? Who is she?
Self Portrait, by Anna Kavan
First of all, as the author tells us, and tells us, and tells us, she is a victim. She is a victim. She is a victim. A victim of life, her mother made her into one. A victim of men, the men made her into one. A victim of the world, the world made her into one. A victim of herself, she made herself into one. She is a victim. She is a victim. She is a victim. She may deny it, but she is addicted to victimhood.
Second of all: she is the author. And she is not. She is the author and she is all women whose identity has been taken away by their family. And by men. And by the world. And by themselves. And by their addictions. And she is not. She is a blankness. There is no self-loathing because there is no self. Shall she reinvent herself? Can she even exist outside of the gaze of others? She'll never know, not this woman of Ice. She has only herself to blame, and everyone else.
But what of this author, Anna Kavan? This "Anna Kavan" did indeed reinvent herself: Helen Woods then Helen Ferguson took the name of one of her own characters, from her own novel. She changed who she was and yet was ever the same, struggling with mental health, with the toll of addiction, with the toll of life itself. Two of her children's lives ended early as she tried to end her own life early, again and again. And yet she lived as well! She loved and she traveled and she wrote and she made herself start again and again and again. A life of struggle but a life full of life as well.
But what of this book? It is about subjugation, addiction, and obsession. The relationships and the narrative are as unstable and alienated as the characters, as the writer herself. The book is culmination, excoriation, a book of waking dreams, a book of travel, a book of love, a book of death, a scourge that lashes the world of men, the world of men and women, the world of Anna Kavan.
Woman with a dish of fruit, by Anna Kavan
It is a painful book: do not read this if you are depressed. And yet I left the book invigorated: Kavan transformed her pain into something terrible and beautiful.
It is an angry book: anger at the world, at men, at the self.
It is a feminist book, a political book:
It is a hallucinatory book: do not read this if you are easily confused. And yet one must embrace the confusion, the dreams and dream logic and hallucinations and the stories and characters blending, bleeding into each other. It is a demanding book and yet the world of the book is so easy to enter, to slip into. They say that death in the snow is the easiest death of all.
It was her last book: Anna Kavan died a year after it was published. And yet a writer's brilliance may outlive their earthly torments.
It is a book that was easy for me to admire but hard for me to love. The book is 4.5 stars, rounded up. Something in me can't give it that trifling additional .5 - I can't make it a favorite. I can't. I can't. I can't. A book this bleak can't be a favorite. It can't. It can't. It can't.
Three nudes on plinths, by Anna Kavan
Does this book written in 1967 foretell our future, on this eve of our twenty-first year in this cold, angry, deadly new millennium? Let us take a look.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Ice.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 22, 2013
– Shelved
December 6, 2020
–
Started Reading
December 20, 2020
– Shelved as:
mind-the-gap
December 20, 2020
– Shelved as:
world-of-insects
December 20, 2020
– Shelved as:
unstablenarratives
December 20, 2020
– Shelved as:
new-dimensions
December 20, 2020
– Shelved as:
after-the-fall
December 20, 2020
–
Finished Reading
December 8, 2022
– Shelved as:
unicorn
Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
³§Ì¶±ð̶²¹Ì¶²Ô̶
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Dec 20, 2020 03:22PM

reply
|
flag


Excellent, thanks for the recommendation & link, Peter!
I just finished this and have such a feeling of wanting to start it again right now.
I wonder at my hesitation in giving it that additional .5 to make a full 5 stars. Maybe I can't help but hold a novel as unforgiving & uncompromising as this one at arm's length rather than fully embracing it as a favorite. I blame my warm blood.
Ria wrote: "yes! such a good writer!"
Indeed! I am a new fan, despite having a copy of this in my possession for over a couple decades. Curious as to why I hesitated for so long. Possibly the cover didn't inspire me:


Well there's good problematic, and bad problematic. IMO, Mark's cover is in the latter category, unfortunately.



It's very goofy to me, and makes the She of Ice into someone more powerful in appearance than she is depicted in the book. And also more voluptuous. although i do appreciate how it is from an actual image detailed within the book - an early one, perhaps the first hallucinatory image, of her character facing approaching walls of ice, naked with her arms raised.
Nate D wrote: "I'm hanging on to (the pure mood of) my ex-library copy ..."
I love how stark that cover is. the weirdly simplistic shapes are awesome.
Ria wrote: "I have (had?) that edition. truthfully, I made several attempts and still haven't finished Ice. I don't know why I have had trouble with this particular book by her."
Make it a New Year's Resolution to complete! Oh wait, don't do that because if you are anything like me and 99% of the world, that means you won't actually accomplish it.

And I definitely know what you mean, its so bleak and i want it to be a favorite but then...I always recommend this book to people and later stress about what they must think of me saying I love this book so much haha.
Great review!

Thanks! The novel certainly deserved more than my original so-called review.

Thank you! :)
I think the feminism is both blatant and subtle. The novel certainly does not offer up any examples of strong, empowered, independent women. In some ways, I was reminded of Tanith Lee's Electric Forest. I think the feminism is of a scouring sort: it instead shows a woman who is seen almost solely through the male gaze. And so it is not an uplifting experience, as we're seeing what happens when a woman is pure object of desire and not her own self. She lacks Self. I also love the point made in the article I linked to that Kavan is connecting both the domination of women with humanity's domination of both itself (nation vs. nation) and the world itself.
That said, Kavan is also very careful in showing that the woman of Ice is actually not completely a victim. Despite the writing literally saying she is a victim, again and again. And yet she rejects both men, again and again, both passively and actively. Even if that rejection could lead to her own annhilation, she scorns both and she sees both the obviously dominating villain and the only slightly less dominating protagonist who wants to save her as extensions of each other, as basically the same man. I love those many moments of stubborn almost mulish defiance at the prospect of being rescued by her would-be knight. Although that defiance eventually melts away... but only in what feels like the last few moments of the book.


Same here, no room for love in the realm of this book. But somehow, somehow, over the years, affection for it has crept in to my book memory. And so it was extra good to revisit the realm of Ice alongside you, Mark.
Best wishes for the year end and the new one to come.


I wish you the same, Fionnuala! I'm very happy to see the end of 2020.
Jack wrote: "Excellent review of one of my faves, Mark. I'd always wanted to write a review but had no idea how to encapsulate this book in a few paragraphs. Good thing I don't have to now, as you summed it up ..."
Thank you, Jack!







