ŷ

s.penkevich's Reviews > All Systems Red

All Systems Red by Martha Wells
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6431467
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: sci-fi, fun, series

I liked the imaginary people on the entertainment feed way more than I liked real ones, but you can’t have one without the other.

What would you do if you were a powerful killing machine that suddenly had free will? If you are Murderbot, you’d do a half-ass job at work in order to get back to watching your tv series, and, okay fair, that is a great choice. Welcome to All Systems Red by Martha Wells, a snarky good time of sci fi mystery and action when an expedition team discovers someone is trying to kill off any competition on the planet. But luckily they have Murderbot to protect th--�in their corner all they had was Murderbot, who just wanted everyone to shut up and leave it alone so it could watch the entertainment feed all day�--erm, okay yea but at least Murderbot will mostly help and do it while being �indifferent and vaguely annoyed.� With which I can TOTALLY EMPATHIZE (sorry to anyone who has ever needed a library card while I was reading a book…I mean, doing important work on my computer). This book also has a fascinating look at emotions and interpersonal interactions, and while an AI feeling emotions and people wondering if they deserve human rights or not may not be a fresh idea, but Wells explores them in interesting and unique ways that does. All Systems Red is a blast, being way more fun and thought provoking than you’d expect from its tiny length and as gripping as Murderbot’s mechanical hands prying open the mouth of some carnivorous alien in order to save the crew.

It’s not like I cared about them personally, but it would look bad on my record, and my record was already pretty terrible.

There hasn’t been a robot this badass and heroic since . Murderbot (a name they have self-selected, mind you) is a security unit programmed to protect and murder that gets sent out on contract jobs, but as they admit �we’re cheaply produced and we suck.� But still good enough to murder, or discover how to hack their governor and give themself free will.
I could have become a mass murderer after I hacked my governor module, but then I realized I could access the combined feed of entertainment channels carried on the company satellites. It had been well over 35,000 hours or so since then, with still not much murdering, but probably, I don't know, a little under 35,000 hours of movies, serials, books, plays, and music consumed. As a heartless killing machine, I was a terrible failure.

The narration in this book is just a delight as Murderbot is snarky as fuck and drags their feet through everything despite showing up and being awesome when needed. There are so many great one liners and admissions like �I didn’t want to get into how little I pay attention to my job,� and how much they just sort of don’t care unless they are required too. Good news, without the governor they don’t have to care about anything and �you may have noticed that when I do manage to care, I’m a pessimist.� Wouldn’t have thought I’d relate so hard to a robot killing machine but HERE WE ARE. I love it.

It took a tremendous effort for me not to rip his arm off, and I’d like that noted for the record, please.

The real spice of this book is all of Murderbot’s internal anxieties over talking with people because on one hand, they have to ensure they don’t reveal they are free from their programming and on the other, they simply don’t want to. �I can’t do even the half-assed version of this stupid job if I have to talk to humans,� because �murderbot + actual human = awkwardness.� This is only made worse by the fact that the team with Murderbot happens to come from a planet that gives AI rights and has an interest in speaking with them, which Murderbot can only register with pure horror. Murderbot happens to have organic human features under the armor and being out of it is a great metaphor on vulnerability as it also ‘humanizes� them to the humans and makes everything more awkward.
So, I’m awkward with actual humans. It’s not paranoia about my hacked governor module, and it’s not them; it’s me. I know I’m a horrifying murderbot, and they know it, and it makes both of us nervous, which makes me even more nervous.

I’ve heard several people mention this book seems to nudge at ideas of , which makes sense and if so it feels like respectful and positive representation. I also love how the book constantly reminds you Murderbot is, in fact, an AI machine with constant precise data (Murderbot will tell you a human paused for 2.4 seconds, for instance) or their system going offline during a fight and leaving you with gaps in the story. It’s all super creative and well done.

All the ideas in this book are great and the interpersonal anxieties might steal the show, but the actual plot that carries the ideas is quite excellent as well. �These weren’t intrepid galactic explorers,� Murderbot reminds us when shit hits the fan, �they were people who were doing a job and suddenly found themselves in a terrible situation.� And so we are treated to Murderbot having to save the day—half begrudgingly—and let me tell you did I crack up when they admit all their planning was just based on how they saw things go down in tv shows. It is a fun story with a lot of giggles to be had, and while it does end rather abruptly and feel far too short, it also just feels like a pilot episode establishing character and prepping to launch more. Which there is, the Murderbot Diaries is still going strong with a Hugo Award for best series and another book coming out this year. I think I’ll be catching up for it.

So if you enjoy things that are good, All Systems Red is for you. If you enjoy things that suck, well, All Systems Red is still probably for you and its cool, I enjoy things that suck too. Besides, Murderbot admits their system sucks because they are the cheap model. But when it comes down to it, Murderbot has a lot of heart and through this sentient AI, Wells explores the ideas of what it is to be human. It’s all very clever and rather heartwarming. This is a fun story with a lot of laughs and some great ideas at play. I can’t wait to read more.

4/5
239 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read All Systems Red.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 26, 2023 – Started Reading
April 26, 2023 – Shelved
April 26, 2023 – Shelved as: sci-fi
April 26, 2023 – Shelved as: fun
April 26, 2023 – Shelved as: series
April 26, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

reejy the way that so many people can relate and that murderbot can connect so many people's experiences really is something special.

the way i've come to love these small books in part because they get to the heart of so many aspects of what it is to be human.


s.penkevich reejy wrote: "the way that so many people can relate and that murderbot can connect so many people's experiences really is something special.

the way i've come to love these small books in part because they ge..."


That is a great way to put it! Yea, I love that aspect that through basically an AI she explores the ideas of being human...and turns out much of it is being annoyed at work haha. Totally relate.


message 3: by Amina (new)

Amina Oh wow, this sounds like a wild ride, but with a touch of heart! 💞 And the fact that it's a start to a series makes me wonder what other facets of being human can be addressed simply by having an AI experiencing it. Would definitely make for an intriguing read. Wonderful review as always, S! 🌟


s.penkevich Amina wrote: "Oh wow, this sounds like a wild ride, but with a touch of heart! 💞 And the fact that it's a start to a series makes me wonder what other facets of being human can be addressed simply by having an A..."

It's SO good! A friend had been telling me about this for years and I thought it might be kind of corny but it just really worked for me. Me too, I'm really excited to see where this heads, I think the books are all fairly episodic but are starting to build more towards something. Hope you enjoy if you get to it, it can easily be read in a day so that was nice haha.
And thank you so much :)


Ruxandra Grrr As a long time Murderbot fan (I've even read the two short stories!!), I officially welcome you to the club. I adore this series (the one novel so far is my favorite, even though the novellas do act like a series, with deepening of characters and what I call a journey of personhood for our begrudging hero). I am super excited for the second novel coming this year!

I'm curious about the audiobooks, since Murderbot isn't gendered and I've noticed that people tend to ascribe a gender to it depending on their own gender. (I read them in English, but I know that the Romanian translation used masculine pronouns ugh) Hope you read more soon! I probably will do a re-read, first listen.


s.penkevich sunny (ethel cain’s version) wrote: "lovely review! 🤖 🔪"

Thank you so much!


s.penkevich Ruxandra Grrr wrote: "As a long time Murderbot fan (I've even read the two short stories!!), I officially welcome you to the club. I adore this series (the one novel so far is my favorite, even though the novellas do ac..."

Yay thank you! I'm pretty excited and halfway through the second one now. I'm glad you mention the audiobook because I'm actually listening to this one and the voice sort of threw me at first as a relatively masculine voice was not how I imagined it. Its interesting as I was wondering if at any point in the series a character would gender them by accident and what they would choose, and what their face looks like or their voice (cleverly Murderbot doesn't really have a reason to describe their voice or face so that never needs to come up), though in my head I personally assumed them to be more feminine?

But yea I just looked it up and I have until November to catch up in the series haha, which seems do-able. I like how it is mostly novellas and if I do audiobooks I can get the whole thing done in about 2 dog walk sessions. So...more to come!


Beth It's always interesting to me to see what pronouns reviewers attribute to Murderbot. I'm an "it" person, and have also seen they, he and she.


s.penkevich Beth wrote: "It's always interesting to me to see what pronouns reviewers attribute to Murderbot. I'm an "it" person, and have also seen they, he and she."

Ha yea I was sort of surveying reviews to see what other people used between they or it, I found it quite clever that Wells managed to really avoid ever addressing that in the text.


The Girl with the Sagittarius Tattoo Yay! I love this series, although some books are better than others. I look forward to your reviews of the rest of the series. :)


s.penkevich The Girl with the Sagittarius Tattoo wrote: "Yay! I love this series, although some books are better than others. I look forward to your reviews of the rest of the series. :)"

Super excited to read more, got the second one going right now! I figure I should catch up that way i can read the new one when it comes out this year. Just so much fun.


The Girl with the Sagittarius Tattoo s.penkevich wrote: "Super excited to read more, got the second one going right now! I figure I should catch up that way i can read the new one when it comes out this year. Just so much fun."

Yeah, they are fun. Some books you look forward to because earlier entries just made you feel good to read them. This series is like that.


s.penkevich The Girl with the Sagittarius Tattoo wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Super excited to read more, got the second one going right now! I figure I should catch up that way i can read the new one when it comes out this year. Just so much fun."

Yeah,..."


That’s a good way to put it. Just instant good mood vibes. And like weirdly empathizing with a robot that is annoyed about doing their job haha I love it


Marquise So lovely! I also finished the book a bit ago and loved it for pretty much the same reasons. :)


s.penkevich Marquise wrote: "So lovely! I also finished the book a bit ago and loved it for pretty much the same reasons. :)"

Thank you so much! What a cool and fun book right? I just read your review and it is spot on. Pretty excited to keep going with the series.


message 16: by Bryn (new) - rated it 4 stars

Bryn Lerud I’ve read all the Murderbot novellas and novels. I understand there are some short stories out there somewhere. I’ll get to them. I love Murderbot. I love the voice; so skeptical and loving at the same time. Murderbot is a robot and robots are not gendered. Im good with that. Every time a friend discovers Murderbot I want to go back and read them all over again. Oh, for some more time�..


s.penkevich Bryn wrote: "I’ve read all the Murderbot novellas and novels. I understand there are some short stories out there somewhere. I’ll get to them. I love Murderbot. I love the voice; so skeptical and loving at the ..."

Skeptical and loving is a the right way to put it haha, this book was so fun I’m glad to hear they all hold up! Pretty excited to keep going through them. The new one is out in November so I figure that gives me just enough time to catch up


Nataliya Welcome to Murderbot Fan Army :) There is no turning back now.

I never thought about MBot being on the autism spectrum; I've always read it as a case of serious social anxiety, but who knows?

>>>sorry to anyone who has ever needed a library card while I was reading a book…I mean, doing important work on my computer<<

If I am ever in Michigan, I am so stopping by your library to demand a library card, just so that I can evilly distract you from reading...


s.penkevich Nataliya wrote: "Welcome to Murderbot Fan Army :) There is no turning back now.

I never thought about MBot being on the autism spectrum; I've always read it as a case of serious social anxiety, but who knows?

>>>..."


HURRAH I'm so glad to be here haha. Almost finished with Artificial Condition now, I'm fully hooked.
And true, thats sort of how I was reading it just like extreme anxiety but then a coworker pointed out the eye contact aspects and how the humans treat Murderbot and I was like ahhhh I can see it sure.
Hhaha, please do, I will attempt to not let it show on my face that I'm trying to read...and failing at it haha, I miss mandatory masking at work haha. Speaking of which it has taken me 10min and 3 customers to finish this reply lol


s.penkevich Nataliya wrote: "Welcome to Murderbot Fan Army :) There is no turning back now.

I never thought about MBot being on the autism spectrum; I've always read it as a case of serious social anxiety, but who knows?

>>>..."


OOOO okay so I was curious if anyone had written anything on the topic and just found this article. Side note but I LOVE Tor's reviews and essays, they always go hard and address sci fi books like its hard-academia and I LOVE IT.
tor [dot] com/2022/06/21/murderbot-an-autistic-coded-robot-done-right/


Marquise Seconded on the Tor pieces, even when they do overanalyse things (not a criticism per se, we fans are that passionate and I've been guilty of that too) they always make good points. :)


s.penkevich Marquise wrote: "Seconded on the Tor pieces, even when they do overanalyse things (not a criticism per se, we fans are that passionate and I've been guilty of that too) they always make good points. :)"

Haha hard same, sometimes you have to get way to in a book and your own head haha. But yea, they are fantastic, I love when I discover they have a big essay up about a book I enjoy.


Daniel Fletcher I adore this book! So glad you liked it!


s.penkevich Daniel wrote: "I adore this book! So glad you liked it!"

It was SO fun! Almost finished with the second already, just a good mood read for sure.


Southern Lady Reads Great review! The quotes are quite vi0lent! 😂


s.penkevich Southern Lady Reads wrote: "Great review! The quotes are quite vi0lent! 😂"

Thank you so much! Haha yea this book goes there, it’s kind of great. Yet is ultimately pretty heartwarming


message 27: by Lee (new) - added it

Lee How on earth do you read so much?


s.penkevich Lee wrote: "How on earth do you read so much?"

The short answer is probably anxiety haha. The long answer is luckily both of my jobs allow for opportunities to read and like this series I’m doing on audio (when I walk my dogs, when I pull holds at work or drive) and then i always have a book going on the library ereader for downtime at my public facing desk (at the library or bookstore) and then I’m always reading a physical book and also always have either a poetry or short story collection going. Plus I tend to prefer short books. So basically that’s it, and reading counts as working since I have to be able to recommend books. Wow this all sounds sad and weird reading it back haha


richa ⋆.˚★ ^always wondered but now I know the answer. totally relate to you, I basically enjoy reading and diving into a completely new world. somehow makes my days better :)


s.penkevich richa wrote: "^always wondered but now I know the answer. totally relate to you, I basically enjoy reading and diving into a completely new world. somehow makes my days better :)"

Yea, I read somewhere recently reading being described as expanding infinity into the cracks of your day which seems about right ha. Existing in all the stories in the gaps of your own story, which sometimes I admit feels like an overload when I've got 4 going at once haha. Oh, though apparently a study says it helps you live longer (couldn't find the quote I was looking for but this popped up and is pretty cool):
theguardian [dot] com/books/2016/aug/08/book-up-for-a-longer-life-readers-die-later-study-finds


richa ⋆.˚★ s.penkevich wrote: "richa wrote: "^always wondered but now I know the answer. totally relate to you, I basically enjoy reading and diving into a completely new world. somehow makes my days better :)"

Yea, I read some..."


What an interesting article, thank you for the link ! I can now use expanding my lifespan as one of the reasons for why I read books 😁


s.penkevich richa wrote: " What an interesting article, thank you for the link ! I can now use expanding my lifespan:..."

Haha exactly, we can call it healthy living practices. Have you ever seen the movie About Time? In it the father just uses his ability to time travel to go back and read all the books he wants—which, not a bad use of time travel haha


back to top