Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Abigail's Reviews > East of Eden

East of Eden by John Steinbeck
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4478548
** spoiler alert ** This book hits me on a personal level in a couple of different ways. Before I ever read this book, I came to know this story when I worked at a video store many years ago and I used to always put on the mini series version of it to watch in the store while I worked. Not the James Dean version, which isn't really like the book at all, but the 1981 mini-series which from what I know is a much more true adaptation of the story. However as the movie is so long, I would usually only see the beginning and so I came to be most familiar with just the FIRST part of the story and never knew the ending, which was good for me going into my reading of the book.

My favorite character from the mini-series [and now the book] is Cathy, who I have always been truly fascinated by as I can't recall ever reading a character so cold, evil and inhuman to the point that can send chills down your spine. Now that I finally read the book I came to know the many other lovable characters in the story such as Lee, Samuel Hamilton, Adam/Charles and Aron/Cal. Not only did I get to know these characters, but I KNOW these characters from real life. Well mostly Cathy I should say, as I mentioned I know this book on a personal level - I actually have seen with my own eyes a person very similar to Cathy and when you meet someone like that in your life you will never forget them. I give this book 5 stars because of the moments. There is a biblical message here but I saw past that and what I took from the story are those special "moments." Just like Steinbeck has done in previous books, he will take his characters, place them in a situation that he guides you through then suddenly smacks you on the head with a sometimes subtle, sometimes shocking and earth shattering "moment" of revelation, surprise, humor, or sadness. **spoilers** A couple of these scenes I enjoyed the most involved Lee, one of the most lovable and "good" characters in the story. I loved when he told his origin story involving his parents incredible and amazing struggle when his mom was pregnant with him. Also one of my favorite scenes in any of the Steinbeck books I've read [I've read around 3 prior to this one] is when Lee decides to leave the Trask family, but as the boys knowingly predict, he comes back after only a few days. When Lee really shines is in his early interactions with Sam Hamilton, the other truly "good" character in the story, and I saw Lee and Sam together as somewhat of a balance to the deep evil of Cathy. One more of my most favorite scenes is when Sam and Cathy are alone in the room together as Cathy is giving birth, which, in an unintentionally funny personal coincidence reminds me of another good vs. evil bedroom scene I saw in a book I read last month The Exorcist! There are dozens of these types of moments as we witness entire lifetime spans of some of these people from birth to death. It was an epic and beautiful story to me and I am left feeling good and satisfied after completing the journey.
6 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read East of Eden.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 5, 2013 – Shelved
March 13, 2013 – Started Reading
March 18, 2013 –
64.0% "I was pleasantly surprised to read Adam visiting the "San Francisco Chop House!" Being a Bay Area resident living near San Francisco, I had always heard of the Chop House being famous. Now I know one of the reasons why!"
March 22, 2013 – Shelved as: 2013-goodreads-book-challenge
March 22, 2013 – Shelved as: favorites
March 22, 2013 – Finished Reading
December 23, 2013 – Shelved as: james-books
January 12, 2014 – Shelved as: audiobooks
January 12, 2014 – Shelved as: top-10-favorite-audiobooks

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Chrissie (last edited Mar 15, 2013 03:26AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Chrissie I am so happy to be reading this! The parallel to Cain and Abel is strong, in the Charles and Adam relationship!


message 2: by Abigail (last edited Mar 15, 2013 07:16AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Abigail I just looked up Downpour.com! It never occurred to me to check out another audio book website since I am an Audible member but now that you have brought it up I realize there ARE a few titles I've been searching for that Audible doesn't have. So I plan to check for those on Downpour and if they have even a few I want that Audible doesn't it would be worth it for me to become a member and cancel later. Thanks so much for that tip!


Chrissie I gave you the link to downpour at my review of this book, but I guess you didn't need it! I am so bad at finding stuff so I always think others have trouble too.


Chrissie I am having serious trouble with Cathy. I have read 17 chapters, and you?


Abigail I'm on Chp. 20 and look forward to more progress into the story this weekend if I can! I just made a long comment on your review re: Cathy, check back with me about her at the end to see if any of your opinions changed by the time it all wraps up at the conclusion! I'm interested to see where it all leads to as even though I watched the mini series many times, it was so many years ago that thankfully I don't recall how the story ends.


Chrissie I am in chapter 20 now too! I left a comment at my review too!


Chrissie I think your having know a "Cathy" in real life makes you see this book very differently than I do. Your review shows me another perspective. good review!


Chrissie The like button is gone! Where did that go?!


Abigail That was strange, for a while there I couldn't see the 'like' button either, I had to restart my computer and hit refresh a few times?!! But as I commented on your review, it does help me to read other views on a book because mine are always so personal to the point of even making me somewhat biased to most of what I read. I find that these are the books I enjoy and 5 star the most, the ones that I am able to find something to relate and hook onto on a personal level. The more personal a story is for me, the more I will come to love and embrace it. Lacking that personal point of entry to the story, if the characters are well written, fascinating, unique or funny to me then I'll also end up getting into the story that way as well. Lucky for me EoE had all those levels to enjoy. Hopefully I'll catch another book at the same time as you again someday! That was fun!


Chrissie I agree that it is the books that you attach to on a personal level that you end up liking best! But simply HOW an author writes is so very important. I cannot say that am in any way familiar with the people of McCann's themes but still the writing pulls me in. Think if one could really make a formula for the good writer! I VERY much enjoyed reading this with you.

Re GR, did you see how yesterday they had "pick" for when you added a book. Why do they always have to change everything around!


back to top