Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness)'s Reviews > A Fine Balance

A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11602286
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites

A book, along with two others which mysteriously appeared on my living room couch. My wife, equally at a loss had no idea where they came from. No one had been to the house previously, certainly not the dear family friend who just finished A Fine Balance and asked if I would read it. Reluctantly taking a break from Walser and The Tanners, I began my 600 page responsibility to a person who has always been there for us.

The book's first four pages were partially folded from use, not to signify any important passage or point. The remainder of the pages were white and crisp except for the occasional single letter or short word erased from use. It wasn't clear whether they were fading or attempting to emerge. No name of ownership or penned notes showed anywhere or any other sign the book hand been read in another's hands.

On a good day I can read thirty pages. Immediately the words vanished and one hundred pages were completed each day. Immersed in a foreign culture, India, 1975, under the brutal reign of Prime Minister Indira Ghandi and her State of Emergency, the tortures of a caste system, the mass murders of a government discarding citizen rights and reaching for complete and lasting control, left me as fearful as the characters whose lives I lived. The world of death and torture was hideous, the stench of relentless fear. Other manners of the denial of life emerged more silent yet still brutalizing the living of a life. In small villages in order to provide safety for oneself and one's family life had to be ordered according to one's station as provided within the unwritten sanctions of caste. Aspirations, dreams, uniqueness were sacrificed to live as one was expected to live by the citizen's of the town. The hope flourished that children would follow suite, marrying and having their children quietly dragging the yoke of this life, participating in the small happinesses of the allotted conventions. In the large and growing cities life also was abdicated by the grasp for power where no matter where it was found there was a higher power controlling it, or the striving for upper or middle class existence with its conformity, safety, accoutrements, and agreed upon cliche's which passed off the burden of hypocrisy, the breath-quickened unreasoned reason for the, "Necessary," flood of blood. Precious life was taken, but also discarded by buckling to what others thought, the pronounced model of success, being, "Right," kneeling before the altar of arbitrary convention created to support the edifice of reigning power.

The great vampire that sucked the blood out of life was, time. It devoured individuals. Families were crushed, their ways of life vanishing, then vanished. This is the work of the world, the passage of time lost opening to its precarious renewal in different forms. A tragedy in this story is that time passed but did not open onto a new time for the many that might provide a continuation or a new existence with further meanings. Many reached a dead end as did the repetitions of the changing of power in new vestments with old designs of clothing hidden beneath.

Yet, there was a woman who defied custom and went off to make a life on her own despite the expectations that she was chosen for success within the fence-lined beliefs of her village. It was always difficult, one obstacle after another, then another waiting in line to follow. She was not the customary hero, nor never sought that trophy. Her heroism was in being herself and trying to survive where odds said she could not. This question hung in the air till near the end of the story, survival. Over time she found unexpectedly a familial love with the two tailors and a young border who lived with her in her small flat. Concern, giving, and caring sprung from people I never imagined could, would. The evil also carried hearts which could warm at times. Did she make the right choice? It could have been easier if she listened to the insistence of her brother and married at an early age, or marry at all. Tough, with all the difficulties she did live her life, patch-worked as it may have seemed to those doing what they were supposed-to-do. Those readers who love quiet heroes, this is a woman to adore, a story to adore, who can adore unexpected small gestures of kindness that flourish tender within bleakness.

This is beautiful and seamless writing that does not call attention to itself but gifted to the reader for the telling of this story. As I write I am understanding why when I finished and since, I have been emotionally wrought. I wanted to get back to reading Walser, a newspaper, listening to music, anything. This may be due to something personal within me and my identification with these characters and this story, or the literary accomplishment, or both. Although writing about it has now helped me to understand it there is still no resolution. I sit here embroiled. The past tells me to allow it to rage within and not get in its way. In the end it will open up for me, as great books do, a life with a fuller meaning.



67 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read A Fine Balance.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 15, 2013 – Started Reading
March 15, 2013 – Shelved
March 15, 2013 – Shelved as: favorites
April 14, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-34 of 34 (34 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jason Everyone's reading this lately!


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Jason wrote: "Everyone's reading this lately!"

I didn't even know about this book until my friend insisted I read it. It isn't even the kind of book I would choose. I am more about internal conflict and struggle not political and external events. Though internal struggle is shown through action and behavior here. People are reading this for good reason. He has his own formula and it works.


Garima Great review Stephen and loved the ending paragraph.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Garima wrote: "Great review Stephen and loved the ending paragraph."

Thanks Garima. It means alot to me.


Praj Excellent review, Stephen! This is one of my favourites.


message 6: by peg (new) - rated it 5 stars

peg I have to ask, what were the other two books you found on your couch?


message 7: by Stephen (last edited Mar 16, 2013 12:22AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) peg wrote: "I have to ask, what were the other two books you found on your couch?"

Ha. The question that needed to be asked. They were not literary. Both were bestseller surface at best that I put in the goodwill donations bag. A Fine Balance, due to its cover and summary, a quick look at some pages, seemed intriguing enough to at least keep around. When my friend asked if I would read it and get back to them I didn't know where I put it. This time no magic appearance, I had to hunt. All part of the strange and wonderful journey. Thanks for asking Peg.


message 8: by peg (new) - rated it 5 stars

peg You found a winner! A Fine Balance is among my favorites.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Praj wrote: "Excellent review, Stephen! This is one of my favourites."

Thanks so much Praj. What a great find and great experience. It is so inspiring the resilience and strength some people have to insist on creating a meaningful life in the face of such horrible brutality. I am going to read other of his books and explore other Indian authors. If you have any suggestions I would sure appreciate it.


message 10: by peg (last edited Mar 16, 2013 12:31AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

peg I also enjoyed The Death of Vishnu and Cutting for Stone.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) peg wrote: "I also enjoyed The Death of Vishnu and Cutting for Stone."

Thanks Peg.


Dolors "The great vampire that sucked the blood out of life was, time. It devoured individuals. Families were crushed, their ways of life vanishing, then vanished. This is the work of the world, the passage of time lost opening to its precarious renewal in different forms. A tragedy in this story is that time passed but did not open onto a new time for the many that might provide a continuation or a new existence with further meanings. Many reached a dead end as did the repetitions of the changing of power in new vestments with old designs of clothing hidden beneath."

Feel like quoting whole passages of your reviews. Have I been really missing all these outstanding reviews?? Please, do tell me you are writing a novella...


Lit Bug I've never seen anybody's review so magnificently, accurately perceive and articulate the socio-political situation of the Emergency. This is a completely just review of the amazing novel, I doubt if it could be bettered. Multiple likes for this one!


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Lit Bug wrote: "I've never seen anybody's review so magnificently, accurately perceive and articulate the socio-political situation of the Emergency. This is a completely just review of the amazing novel, I doubt ..."

And multiple thanks. :) I really do think the author deserves most of the credit. At the same time I do take this as an incredible compliment. What a great book. I was stunned how I was taken into, for me a foreign culture during a foreign time. I lived there, every moment. A fine example of what the magic of literature can do. Thanks again Lit Bug.


Lit Bug Yes, and I liked the review a lot more than others' because despite being a stranger to cultural issues, you caught every single nuance. The book has too many complex themes, political statements going on at the same time beneath the top-most layer of a historical fiction tragedy, it is difficult to pin them down all. Mistry is an amazing writer, but it takes a discerning reader to note them down all and a good writer to incorporate them in a review comprehensively and cohesively.

Do try Mistry's Swimming Lessons and Other Stories from Firozsha Baag too, if you haven't - I loved that too.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Lit Bug wrote: "Yes, and I liked the review a lot more than others' because despite being a stranger to cultural issues, you caught every single nuance. The book has too many complex themes, political statements g..."

I am humbled by your words. Thank you for the Mistry recommendation and link. Will go immediately on my TBR and To Buy lists.


Michael So eloquent in capturing the full experience of the book. Love it how you move from doubt over the book, to getting swept away, and then to how to digest your experience. I liked most the virtual family the main character created with her neighbors. Instead of the scenario of Dr. Zhivago seeking over vast distances a one true love amidst disintegrating society, we get a hope in the sustainability of our humanity in the kindness of near strangers.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Michael wrote: "So eloquent in capturing the full experience of the book. Love it how you move from doubt over the book, to getting swept away, and then to how to digest your experience. I liked most the virtual..."

Michael I am moved. That was a beautiful review of my review, eloquent too. Thank you my friend. I think this book was listed in the Boxall 1001 books needed to be read before...I'm not sure when that, before, is because I'm still hoping that I get to continue reading after my death. It is a fine and inspirational book which took me into this vast culture from within as close as words can accomplish this. Thanks for reading the review and your very thoughtful comment.


Himanshu What a great review of Mistry's masterpiece, Stephen. How weird it is when lives across the globes being so distinctive affect us unexpectedly and with such a blow. It was great to come across this review of one of my beloved books. Thanks


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Himanshu wrote: "What a great review of Mistry's masterpiece, Stephen. How weird it is when lives across the globes being so distinctive affect us unexpectedly and with such a blow. It was great to come across this..."

This is a masterpiece, Himanshu. Mistry's skills did not reveal another culture to me but brought me inside, to live within it. Yes, I think it is true how technology can be used to reduce distances and through great literature, sites like GR, can truly help us to understand one another.

Thank you for reading through this and your kind compliment.


message 21: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita Beautiful, poignant reflection of a story which feels like the coarse yet nurturing texture of Mistry's narratives that I experienced in another of his works, Family Matters. His stories are indeed about the quiet heroes whose inspiring travails, if only could be documented, are second to none. Thank you for always bringing the soul of a book in such kaleidoscopic brilliance.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Seemita wrote: "Beautiful, poignant reflection of a story which feels like the coarse yet nurturing texture of Mistry's narratives that I experienced in another of his works, Family Matters. His stor..."

Thanks so much Seemita. I think Mistry himself is an unsung hero of literature. I think his talents far exceed his popularity. He helped me to live inside a culture I knew nothing about and to learn about the people and their travails. His writing lends itself to digging for the essence of his work. Besides, it is what I read for these days. No longer the beauty of the words, the authorial mesmerizing voice, I get out my shovel as I open the book and start digging away. Who knew? A step forward or back?

But if I was able to communicate the soul of this book in any way I am grateful and honored. It really is a wonderful book. Thanks Seemita for the recommendation of, Family Matters.


message 23: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King Stephen,

A beautiful review. I must be the only person who has not read this book!


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) No,no,no, Lynne. I think he is much under-read. He put me right into a culture that was foreign to me. A difficult challenge. A truly fine writer, an amazing book, that is searching for a reader such as yourself.


message 25: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King Stephen wrote: "No,no,no, Lynne. I think he is much under-read. He put me right into a culture that was foreign to me. A difficult challenge. A truly fine writer, an amazing book, that is searching for a reader su..."

Well Stephen. I've ordered the book and will let you know what I think of it!


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Lynne wrote: "Stephen wrote: "No,no,no, Lynne. I think he is much under-read. He put me right into a culture that was foreign to me. A difficult challenge. A truly fine writer, an amazing book, that is searching..."

:)


message 27: by Lee (new)

Lee What a fascinating review. Certainly has piqued my interest. Which means I need to thank you.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Lee wrote: "What a fascinating review. Certainly has piqued my interest. Which means I need to thank you."

Actually Lee I think we both need to thank Mistry. The book was highly talked up to me by a trusted friend and it turned out quite a bit better than I even imagined. My guess is the same might happen to you. Enjoy.


message 29: by Ted (new) - added it

Ted Wonderful review, Stephen. I so want to read this book, and certainly intend to.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Ted wrote: "Wonderful review, Stephen. I so want to read this book, and certainly intend to."

Thanks so much Ted. Knowing your interest in history, politics, fiction, the warmth of your readerly heart, this book may have been written for you. I'm not gushing when I say it is not an experience to be missed. It expands the world in a way no other medium can reach. I hope you get to it when it feels right.


message 31: by Samadrita (new) - added it

Samadrita I liked this review from the phone last night and couldn't post a comment. But I just want to say this is a most sublime piece of writing, brimming over with an understated compassion and sympathy. I hope to read Mistry soon.


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Samadrita wrote: "I liked this review from the phone last night and couldn't post a comment. But I just want to say this is a most sublime piece of writing, brimming over with an understated compassion and sympathy...."

An amazing experience for me to live within a culture, the people, who I had little knowledge of. All the better that it was threaded through the magic of literature. Whenever you get to it I'll be glued to the screen to see what you think of it.


message 33: by Ted (new) - added it

Ted Wonderful review now bookmarked


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Ted wrote: "Wonderful review now bookmarked"

Hey Ted. Thanks so much. Mistry was able to perform the magic of writing in its purest form. I found myself placed in the midst of a very foreign culture enduring its hardships and its small wonders.

Thanks Ted for the kind words and the bookmark!


back to top