ŷ

Scribble Orca's Reviews > A Modest Proposal

A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4402387
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: defies-a-shelf

Goodreaders, my Friends, “…who peruse this [Review], Be not offended, whilst on it you [chew]: Denude yourselves of all depraved affection, For it contains no badness, nor infection: 'Tis true that it brings forth to you no birth Of any value, but in point of mirth; Thinking therefore how sorrow might your mind Consume, I could no [more] apt subject find; One [plume] of joy surmounts of grief a [duration]; Because to laugh is proper to the [rational person].�–R
49 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Modest Proposal.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 30, 2013 – Shelved
March 30, 2013 – Shelved as: defies-a-shelf
March 31, 2013 – Started Reading
March 31, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ted (new)

Ted 23.2. Gulp


Scribble Orca There were too many statistics about what happens over 22 for me to leave it higher :).


Luke Pure genius.


message 4: by Mosca (new)

Mosca Have you ever considered investing your considerable skills towards a vocation in Economics?

Or perhaps Religious Leadership?

Gosh I'm hungry.

I wonder what's for supper?


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

I still think it is a good idea to eat the Irish...just saying.


message 6: by Scribble (last edited Mar 30, 2013 05:31PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Scribble Orca Aubrey wrote: "Pure genius."

It's the Gioas in us.

Mosca wrote: "Have you ever considered investing your considerable skills towards a vocation in Economics? Or perhaps Religious Leadership?

An anarchist would be materially and spiritually conflicted in either role.

Anthony wrote: "I still think it is a good idea to eat the Irish...just saying."

Stewed?


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

Stewed?

I imagine something a little more easier to handle for the person on the go. McDonalds has been tossing some ideas around that we feel are quite promising.


message 8: by Scribble (last edited Mar 30, 2013 05:46PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Scribble Orca Anthony wrote: "I imagine something a little more easier to handle for the person on the go. McDonalds has been tossing some ideas around that we feel are quite promising."

Let's see: Flannery's Finger Food; Finnegan's Balls; Nell's Nuggets; Dana's Dip n Dunk; Sean's Slivers...must be keeping the marketing department quite moreish.


Brian Holy shit, Scribbs. Amazing.


message 10: by [deleted user] (new)

Scribble wrote: "Anthony wrote: "I imagine something a little more easier to handle for the person on the go. McDonalds has been tossing some ideas around that we feel are quite promising."

Let's see: Flannery's F..."


Or we just go the route of Taco Bell, and take any old part and shove it inside a taco shell made out of Doritos. That way we'll knock out any kind of moral objections from the word go. "Yes, human life is precious, sure, but did you know we now have Spicy Nacho flavor shells?" Win/win for everyone.


message 11: by Scribble (last edited Mar 30, 2013 09:25PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Scribble Orca Brian wrote: "Holy shit, Scribbs. Amazing."

I'm just a flunkey monkey astride the scapulae of the already scribed.

Anthony wrote: "Or we just go the route of Taco Bell, and take any old part and shove it inside a taco shell made out of Doritos. That way we'll knock out any kind of moral objections from the word go. "Yes, human life is precious, sure, but did you know we now have Spicy Nacho flavor shells?" Win/win for everyone."

Hmm. Commodisation for the less-then-choice chops, yes. But I think you'd want to keep the premium price bracket associated with named titbits.


Garima You killed it! This is ah-ma-zingggg.


message 13: by Kalliope (new) - added it

Kalliope One of those reviews to be printed and read carefully, savoring each word.


Scribble Orca Garima wrote: "You killed it! This is ah-ma-zingggg."

Kill being the operative word.

Kalliope wrote: "One of those reviews to be printed and read carefully, savoring each word."

May I recommend a light herb seasoning to complement the degustation?


message 15: by Traveller (last edited Mar 31, 2013 09:39AM) (new)

Traveller Heheh. Well done. Now, I wonder who has deft skills in replicating style? :)


message 16: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Wow, where do I have to sign? Maybe you could pass by Bcna, and give a speech, someone might get inspiration and start changing things! It's about time!


message 17: by Rakhi (new)

Rakhi Dalal Back with a Bang!!!( applies aptly in this case)... Great one, Scribble!


message 18: by Francisco (new)

Francisco Very good!


Kelly (Maybedog) Good job, Scribble.

I forgot how much I love this essay.


message 20: by Steve (new)

Steve How can I fail to like an essay that includes phrases like "panting and puce-faced", "fatigued and underfunded" and "mountains of Menschen"? I was a little surprised this didn't come with a pop-up ad for Soylent Green!


Scribble Orca Traveller wrote: "Heheh. Well done. Now, I wonder who has deft skills in replicating style? :)"

Thanks, Trav. Camel eon is in, right now.

Mike wrote: "Solves the problem of Flicka, Fury, National Velvet, Black Beauty, Black Stallion, Misty, The Red Pony, and Brighty in the (human) food supply chain, while giving The Horse Whisperer so much more t..."

Grist to the mill, Mike. Just think of the increase in available blood and bone fertiliser, too.

Dolors wrote: "Wow, where do I have to sign? Maybe you could pass by Bcna, and give a speech, someone might get inspiration and start changing things! It's about time!"

A petition is being organised and a rally is surely soon to follow.

Rakhi wrote: "Back with a Bang!!!( applies aptly in this case)... Great one, Scribble!"

In for a penny, in for a pound, and back with a Burger, Rakhi! :D

@Francisco, Kelly: Thank you :)

Steve wrote: "How can I fail to like an essay that includes phrases like "panting and puce-faced", "fatigued and underfunded" and "mountains of Menschen"?

(view spoiler)

I was a little surprised this didn't come with a pop-up ad for Soylent Green!"

With Rob Fleischer as the director? I couldn't, Steve, really I couldn't.


message 22: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala I only weigh 56kilo but I feel targeted...must be the colour of my passport...


Scribble Orca You're forgetting the magic number, Fionnuala (oh, and my great great grandmother was arrested for rioting. Red hair, maybe?)


Garima What happened here???


Lynne King Scribble, I hate to admit that I've never heard of this book and so I'd better purchase it!


Lynne King I have the Kindle version as it was free (public domain) and if I like it, I will purchase the paperback.


Scribble Orca Lynne, well worth reading as the definitive introduction to satire. Succinct and sharp and lends itself to appropriate appropriation.

(Never hate to admit you've not heard of a book. If we all did that....)


Lynne King Scribble, I read this essay when I was in the dentist this morning. What a brilliant piece of work and I just loved it. I'm glad that I saw your review.

Jonathan Swift at his best.


Scribble Orca Glad to hear you read it, Lynne. It is excellent, yes.


Lynne King Incidentally why did you change your avatar Scribble? It was nice seeing the last one. Just for a change I guess? Why don't you put another one of yourself doing something different. I'm sure that your husband could suggest something.


Scribble Orca I just like Hypatia, Lynne. I sometimes adopt her when I need to feel beautiful :D and persecuted :DD and martyred :DDD. But you're right - you've given me an excellent idea. I'll put it in motion in the next little while.

Hope everything went well at the dentist!!


Lynne King Scribble, DDD beautiful, persecuted and martyred. Intriguing. The last two?

A root canal! Dreadful!


Scribble Orca Lynne wrote: "Scribble, DDD beautiful, persecuted and martyred. Intriguing. The last two?"

Oh no, it's a personal joke - nothing to be treated with any degree of seriousness! Take it in its Swiftian sense :)

Hoping you are out of the canal zone!


Lit Bug Oh dear! Such a brilliant piece of writing on one of the most viciously satirical works ever written!


Scribble Orca Lit Bug wrote: "Oh dear! Such a brilliant piece of writing on one of the most viciously satirical works ever written!"

Lit Bug, you've caught me out! I haven't reposted it! I will, though, I promise. Perhaps not here, but somewhere....a new collection of book-inspired pieces?


Lit Bug Scribble wrote: "Lit Bug wrote: "Oh dear! Such a brilliant piece of writing on one of the most viciously satirical works ever written!"

Lit Bug, you've caught me out! I haven't reposted it! I will, though, I pro..."


That should be a lovely idea - I much endorse the subtle brilliance of your review, though it is in indirect proportion to the shock-value of Swift. Title the collection "An Immodest Proposal", perhaps! :)


Scribble Orca I shall keep that suggestion in the forefront of my mind, Lit Bug, thank you!


message 38: by Traveller (new)

Traveller Oh dear, now you've truly killed it... :P


Scribble Orca Thanks Ernie - for the actual pissofwork, please see Verbivoracious Festschrift Volume Two: Gilbert Adair.


back to top