Karen's Reviews > The Covenant of Water
The Covenant of Water
by
by

Karen's review
bookshelves: adventurous, book-discussion-perfect, captivating, compelling, complex, conversational, creates-questions, easy-to-read, educating-moments, engaging, heart-felt, page-turner, thoughtful, wanted-less, why-so-many-pages
Sep 21, 2023
bookshelves: adventurous, book-discussion-perfect, captivating, compelling, complex, conversational, creates-questions, easy-to-read, educating-moments, engaging, heart-felt, page-turner, thoughtful, wanted-less, why-so-many-pages
I almost walked away. I was intimidated by the size of this book. 715 pages. I often wonder why an author feels they need this many pages to tell a story.
But…It was a library book, and I had waited months for it.
And…It was the talk because it was Oprah’s 2023 Book Club pick.
And…I don’t typically pick a book because she picked it. Just sayin�.
But…It was time to just�
Read.
At first, I was disturbed as I read about a 12-year-old being led off to marry a 40-year-old in the year 1900 on India’s Malabar Coast.
But…As I watched the unfolding of that relationship and family, I came to recognize how the world worked at that time. How he honored his wife until she came of age, how the relationship grew in love, and then what the story was truly meant to be about � this “condition� feared and how it would rock the family in such a devastating way.
And then…Another story emerged.
About a fellow named Digby.
A new timeline.
What?
Why confuse the reader?
And then…Back in time to our original story of our young girl, now grown, widowed, managing. They lovingly called her, Big Ammachi.
Would her story and Digby’s intersect?
The story is told in such a grand, spectacular, sweeping and utterly absorbing way, I found myself mesmerized. I kept turning pages, and surprised at how quickly the pages were melting away.
And yet…There were still so many more to read.
Why 715 pages?
Is it possible to still tell this story with less pages?
The book may have begun in 1900, with that 12-year-old girl preparing for her unwanted arranged marriage.
It ends in 1977, when that girl’s physician granddaughter arrives at a shocking discovery.
The family are Indian Christians, descendants of those first converted by St. Thomas in the first century A.D. They have led tough but often joyful lives, and they did make it in the world, despite the challenges.
To provide a plot synopsis would spoil the fun.
Let’s just say that this family loves and suffers in a variety of ways.
This book felt like reading a fairy tale � a good fable.
In reading the author’s acknowledgements at the end, he shares that it began with a notebook that Verghese’s mother wrote for an inquisitive granddaughter.
But mostly…It is an epic love letter to a country this author loves, that we can see and feel� to characters he has created that we can appreciate�
And…To a history he has imagined, rich in culture, and detail, and personal memories gathered and researched, that we as readers get to explore through those many, many pages.
But…It was a library book, and I had waited months for it.
And…It was the talk because it was Oprah’s 2023 Book Club pick.
And…I don’t typically pick a book because she picked it. Just sayin�.
But…It was time to just�
Read.
At first, I was disturbed as I read about a 12-year-old being led off to marry a 40-year-old in the year 1900 on India’s Malabar Coast.
But…As I watched the unfolding of that relationship and family, I came to recognize how the world worked at that time. How he honored his wife until she came of age, how the relationship grew in love, and then what the story was truly meant to be about � this “condition� feared and how it would rock the family in such a devastating way.
And then…Another story emerged.
About a fellow named Digby.
A new timeline.
What?
Why confuse the reader?
And then…Back in time to our original story of our young girl, now grown, widowed, managing. They lovingly called her, Big Ammachi.
Would her story and Digby’s intersect?
The story is told in such a grand, spectacular, sweeping and utterly absorbing way, I found myself mesmerized. I kept turning pages, and surprised at how quickly the pages were melting away.
And yet…There were still so many more to read.
Why 715 pages?
Is it possible to still tell this story with less pages?
The book may have begun in 1900, with that 12-year-old girl preparing for her unwanted arranged marriage.
It ends in 1977, when that girl’s physician granddaughter arrives at a shocking discovery.
The family are Indian Christians, descendants of those first converted by St. Thomas in the first century A.D. They have led tough but often joyful lives, and they did make it in the world, despite the challenges.
To provide a plot synopsis would spoil the fun.
Let’s just say that this family loves and suffers in a variety of ways.
This book felt like reading a fairy tale � a good fable.
In reading the author’s acknowledgements at the end, he shares that it began with a notebook that Verghese’s mother wrote for an inquisitive granddaughter.
But mostly…It is an epic love letter to a country this author loves, that we can see and feel� to characters he has created that we can appreciate�
And…To a history he has imagined, rich in culture, and detail, and personal memories gathered and researched, that we as readers get to explore through those many, many pages.
1037 likes · Like
�
flag
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Covenant of Water.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 9, 2023
–
Started Reading
September 9, 2023
– Shelved
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
adventurous
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
book-discussion-perfect
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
captivating
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
compelling
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
complex
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
conversational
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
creates-questions
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
easy-to-read
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
educating-moments
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
engaging
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
heart-felt
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
page-turner
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
thoughtful
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
wanted-less
September 21, 2023
– Shelved as:
why-so-many-pages
September 21, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 223 (223 new)
message 1:
by
Christina
(new)
-
added it
Sep 21, 2023 04:35AM

reply
|
flag

Thank you Christina. This is a book I took my time with - I had NO choice - it was a LONG one! ;)



Thank you so much, Mitzi. Be patient with yourself and this reading experience! :)

Oh Jayme, it was a journey for sure! Thank you!

Thank you so much Ellen! Be patient with it. :)

Thank you so much Patti. I know what you mean. There are so many mixed reviews - and a 715 page book...well, you have to make a decision about - should I or shouldn't I?! ;)

Thank you Heather. And yes, honker is a good term! ;)

Thank you Julia. I have read some reviews where the audio really made them love the book, so maybe that will make the difference for you. The author is the one who does the audio. :)


I know exactly what you mean, Cheri. And thank you. I was happy that her husband waited. It made it easier to read and fall in love with the characters and their story. :)


Thank you Stephen. Yes! And I am going to be completely honest about how I feel about them, too! As you know. They are imperfect, as well. Still, too many pages....

Thank you so much Kelani. I look forward to your thoughts on it! :)

Thank you Suzanne. Wow! Yes, the ending was powerful. I hung on to that one for awhile. :)


Thank you Diane. I know I was thrown off when Digby entered the picture, I was so enthralled with Part I. But... patience.... :)
Beautiful review Karen between your friend Suzanne and your review, I felt compelled to add this to my read list.
As always, enjoy your reading!
As always, enjoy your reading!

Wow, Zainab! Thank you so much! :)

As always, enjoy your reading!"
Good to know that there are a couple of us who have convinced you that maybe, just maybe this 715 page book, might be something worth reading or listening to....so...be patient with it, Cheryl! ;)


Thank you Candi. Yes, I went up and down with it because of the size of the book - so I took my time with it because of that. I still would have preferred it to be a shorter book. Good luck with your decision! :)



You are so welcome skketch. I think we all have to be ready for this size of a book - and recognize what level of patience we have for it... : )

Thank you so much Rosh. : )

Thank you so much Karen. I know this one didn't work for you, as much...

Thank you so much Kara. Just be patient with yourself and the length of the book... ;)

Thank you Linda. I have heard...I have to believe listening to the author gives it an even better feel... enjoy the experience... :)



Emma, thank you so much! It seems like it is best if it is a library book. At least it did for me. But, others have said they have appreciated it as an audio because the author is reading it. I think we all have to find what works best for each of us. :)

Thank you Jen. You know, we all are going to react in our own ways. It is and was truly daunting. I just had to sit with it awhile and let myself sink into it. Once I did, I felt it. And that is what carried me. Others were carried through the audio version. That might be more appealing... :)


Thank you so much Tara. :)