ŷ

Ema's Reviews > House of the Sleeping Beauties and Other Stories

House of the Sleeping Beauties and Other Stories by Yasunari Kawabata
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5746897
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: japan, short-stories

I value the books whose plot has managed to stay etched in my mind. Some of the novels I've read are pleasant, but they are soon forgotten. The ones that shape me and teach me are the most valued, of course; but I keep a special place for those that I remember. Kawabata's story is one of those. And incidentally, it talks about memory, among other things. It also speaks about the fear of death and the desire to prolong one's life through the elixir of youth; about regrets and unfulfilled desires wept at the feet of high priestesses; about the wish for peace and reconciliation with one's life.

In a peculiar house, which can't really be called a brothel, beautiful virgins lie in deep slumber, naked, innocent and unconscious. Old men come to lie down beside them, awake, troubled, full of desire. They can't harm the virgins, they are not allowed to wake them. They can only touch their bodies and sleep beside them. Such defenseless bodies and oblivious minds, at the whims and mercy of old men. If you look at the picture this way, the story might make you feel contempt; and yet, it has a beautiful and poetic vein, despite its grain of ugliness.

From ancient times, old men had sought to use the scent given off by girls as an elixir of youth.

Eguchi comes to the house lured by this strange kind of pleasure. On a couple of nights, in the enclosed space of a room, he contemplates the obedient, exposed bodies of the young girls. Deep slumber is reminiscent of death in a way; in their sleep, some of the girls seemed more alive than others. Life was there, most definitely, in her scent, in her touch, in the way she moved. Eguchi experiences an array of feelings and memories awaken by the sounds, the smells and the sights. He remembers his youth, his children, the women he had affairs with. He fights with melancholy, with unhappiness, but also with the urge to do harm.

In their hearts, as they lay against the flesh of naked young girls put to sleep, would be more than fear of approaching death and regret for their lost youth. There might also be remorse, and the turmoil so common in the families of the successful. They would have no Buddha before whom to kneel. The naked girl would know nothing, would not open her eyes, if one of the old men were to hold her tight in his arms, shed cold tears, even sob and wail. The old man need feel no shame, no damage to his pride. The regrets and the sadness could flow quite freely. And might not the 'sleeping beauty' herself be a Buddha of sorts? And she was flesh and blood. Her young skin and scent might be forgiveness for the sad old men.

The story impressed me to such an extent that it entered the realm of my dreams. I have one short but weird story to tell, and I write it here because I want to remember it over the years. One night, after reading the story, I woke up with the feeling that somebody was lying awake behind me, watching me in the dark, keeping a hand on my breast. I felt slightly frightened but then I fell asleep again, or maybe I was never awake in the first place. In the morning I woke up confused, because I wasn't sure if what I remembered had been a dream or reality. When I asked my boyfriend about it, he said he had been sound asleep the whole night. Weird. And yet it felt so vivid, like a lucid dream...
The strange thing about all this is that the scene I experienced is also happening in the novel. It felt like I was projected inside the sleeping girl's mind. Like I was perceiving through her skin, through her senses, even though they seemed to be asleep. Maybe they weren't, maybe she could sense what was happening to her. An unconscious yet alert consciousness.
Well, I couldn't write this review without confessing the connection I had with the story.

My review is only for House of the Sleeping Beauties. If you read this, then you should also consider Memories of My Melancholy Whores and see how Márquez made use of the idea behind Kawabata's story.
51 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read House of the Sleeping Beauties and Other Stories.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
April 26, 2013 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Mariel You are right. It is haunting, the almost loss of what you wish was there, in their innocence or maybe they know all along, could wake up. As if the youth and the almost.... I could taste the almost. I felt twisted in the man's dreams.

I like a lot your haunting dream story.

The story about the man who would be God affected me a lot too.

I've thought about reading Marquez's book. No doubt Murakami was influenced as well for wind up bird. And the film by Jane Campion starring Emily Browning. I didn't see it.

Wonderful review.


message 2: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Mariel wrote: "You are right. It is haunting, the almost loss of what you wish was there, in their innocence or maybe they know all along, could wake up. As if the youth and the almost.... I could taste the almost. I felt twisted in the man's dream..."

Mariel, thank you so much for your thoughts! It's amazing how much you remember of this, because right now I was reading your review and I can see you wrote it two years ago. I guess the story is truly haunting and it didn't happen to me only. You are so right, the man was almost Godlike, endowed with the power of life and death...
I've read this after the Wind-up Bird and I must confess that I didn't make the connection. But you are right, a certain scene resembles Kawabata's story (the abuse of one of the sisters in her dream? Do I remember this correctly?)
I haven't seen that movie either.


message 3: by Garima (new)

Garima Fascinating review, Ema. Thanks for sharing your story. I'm sure it felt weird but it also conveys the power a book can exercise on its readers.


message 4: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Thank you, Garima. I was hesitant about sharing my dream, but I also wanted to remember it, and I'm no longer keeping a diary. Yes, the power of a story...


Mariel I found echoes of other writers in Murakami long after reading his books (a lot of Natsume Soseki,another favorite of mine, particularly in a wild sheep chase and dance, dance, dance). The prostitute who sleeps beside her clients. She is aware of the situation, unlike (possibly) these young girls.

It kills me I don't remember these better. Yours and Praj's reviews of my very favorite author! It is special to get them back through you two, though. I thank you! (the sound of the mountain means the world to me.)


message 6: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema I want to read more Japanese authors, Mariel. You are an expert on this field. Luckily I have access at a friend's library who is obsessed about Japanese literature. I think he has everything translated into Romanian from Kawabata, Kenzaburō Ōe, Inoue and Mishima. I'll have to make a subscription. :)
I'll go read Praj' review now. I'm glad my review brought back good memories.


Mariel Ooh that is lucky to have that library. I have read only two Inoue. The Hunting Gun I liked a lot. Tun-huang I kind of um well really hated.

I recommend The River Ki if your friend has it. It is much and so sadly overlooked.


message 8: by Dolors (last edited Sep 05, 2013 02:39PM) (new)

Dolors Disturbingly beautiful review Ema! Your unsettling dream shook me awake and left me wondering about the power of books. I don't know why but the image of sleeping girls brought reminiscences of Patrick Süskind's novel "The Perfume" and got me thinking about the symbolism attached to virgins, always revolving around purity, innocence and eternal youth. There is something sinister in girls being used like a kind of magic elixir...

After having recently discovered Kawabata's lyrical but perturbing prose I followed Mariel's advice and bought "The sound of the mountain" and I'm sure I won't be disappointed.


Mariel What you said does fit this book about youth and innocence. Very well.

I'm very, very, very, very much looking forward to that sound of the mountain review. I know you will hear what I cannot. My shell for an unapproachable sea, these memories and reviews. (I can't comment without sounding weird ugh. But I'm a kawabata need. This is exciting! I feel out over mountain, the lake and palm of the hand. SPECIAL...)


message 10: by Dolors (last edited Sep 05, 2013 02:43PM) (new)

Dolors I'm barely able to resist the temptation of hunting down your review on "The sound of the mountain", Mariel. I'm certain you hear more than most and I'm sure it'll show in your review. But I'm keeping it as a child keeps a sweet when he knows he'll be able to savor it better when nobody is watching...


Mariel I think you will be disappointed. Praj wrote a beautiful review. But it is one of those books I could read every review and want to reread it then and there. I'm afraid to watch the film version. There are a few Kawabata films, actually!


message 12: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Dolors wrote: "Disturbingly beautiful review Ema! Your unsettling dream shook me awake and left me wondering about the power of books. I don't know why but the image of sleeping girls brought reminiscences of Pat..."

Thank you so much, Dolors! Yes, you are right, I thought about Süskind's Perfume too, while writing the review, although I haven't read his novel and neither seen the movie. It's probably because of the quote about the scents of young girls. You were spot on with your remarks, without reading the story!

Ha ha, I can see that you and Mariel started quite a discussion! Mariel, you've worked your magic or something, because now I want to read more Kawabata too, although I was not so keen after finishing the stories from 'The Dancing Girl of Izu'. It seems there are a couple of his novels to look forward too, so I will pay a visit to my friend's library soon.

Dolors, I'm really eager to know your impressions on "The sound of the mountain" after you read it.


message 13: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Mariel wrote: "Ooh that is lucky to have that library. I have read only two Inoue. The Hunting Gun I liked a lot. Tun-huang I kind of um well really hated.
I recommend The River Ki if your friend has it. It is much and so sadly overlooked. "


No, I don't think this novel is even translated into Romanian, so he doesn't have it, unfortunately. I've indexed his library (almost entirely) and I kind of know what he has. I was utterly happy browsing his shelves, it was like discovering a treasure trove! 90% of my Gr shelf 'friends-library' belongs to him, he has such good tastes!


message 14: by Declan (new)

Declan From reading your reviews Ema I would say that you are a deeply empathetic person which might be why you had that dream. Dreams, fiction, films: they are all so interesting because they allow us to be other than we are.


message 15: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Thank you, Declan. It's nice of you to say that.


message 16: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Wonderful review and story. I think you need to ask your boyfriend what he dreamed of that night!


message 17: by Harry (new)

Harry Ema, such a delicate and carefully woven review...I liked it very much. I have not read this author (though I've been flirting with his The Lake and The Master of Go in passing). I've seen photos of Kawabata and there is this deep contemplation in his facial expressions, a searching for perhaps his own understanding of beauty and longing and struggle as one grows older...


message 18: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Harry, thank you for the nice words! I recommend this story if you want to read Kawabata, it's my favorite so far. I hear he has better novels still, so he's on my future reading list.


message 19: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Ian wrote: "Wonderful review and story. I think you need to ask your boyfriend what he dreamed of that night!"

Thank you, Ian! It's a bit too late to ask him now...


message 20: by Margitte (new)

Margitte Beautiful review! A unique story as well. wow.


message 21: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Margitte wrote: "Beautiful review! A unique story as well. wow."

Margitte, thank you so much!


message 22: by Samadrita (last edited Sep 19, 2013 06:44AM) (new) - added it

Samadrita I certainly envy your ability to get into Kawabata and appreciate his writings, Ema.
I think House of Sleeping Beauties might do the trick and make me see Kawabata in a whole new light. The Marquez connection is equally interesting.
Beautiful, elegantly written review.


rahul Wonderful review, Ema.
This story from Kawabata deserves our senses and trespasses our dreams without any permission.
I am looking forward to reading more Kawabata now.


message 24: by Ema (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ema Thank you, rahul! I still remember some of the story, it seems to have been imprinted on my mind. I think Kawabata is the Japanese author from whom I read the most books - with the exception of Haruki Murakami, but he doesn't count as, let's say, a "traditional" writer.


message 25: by Sin (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sin Sin I did also think about Marquez's novel while reading this book. Anyway, I keep asking "what kind of pills did the woman give to the sleeping beauties?. Kinda curious, hee


message 26: by Valerie (new)

Valerie I know this was many years ago, but just wanted to say that I really appreciate your review. I just finished “House of the Sleeping Beauties� and was looking for some other thoughts and opinions on the themes/how to wrap my head around the ending. Really appreciate your insights.


back to top