Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Melanie's Reviews > Pitch Dark

Pitch Dark by Renata Adler
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7574349
's review

it was amazing

"Is it always the same story, then? Somebody loves and somebody doesn't, or loves less, or loves someone else. Or someone is a good soul and someone a villain. And there are just these episodes, anecdotes, places, pauses, hailings of cabs, overcomings of obstacles, or instances of being overcome by them, illnesses, accidents, recoveries, wars, desires, welcomings, rebuffs, baskings (rare, not so long), pinings (more frequent, perhaps, and longer), actions, failures to act, hesitations, proliferations, endings of the line, until there is death. Well, no. I have a wonderful, fond memory, about love and trust and books."

How could you not fall in love with a book like that?

The blue-est book that I have ever read. Blue in all its variations. The blue of melancholy and the blue(s) of jazz. The ominous blue of dusk and the luminous blue of dawn. The blue of veins which, through a stunning trick of light, hides the sensual, bloody red of life.

How else to tackle heartbreak but sideways? An evocation of grief through the depiction of places, homes, foreign lands, familiar vistas and nightmarish nights that never seem to end on the other side of the world. Landscapes and dislocation as the rugged geographies of the heart.

We all know these frail, elegant, intelligent, sensitive, quick-witted and impossibly neurotic women who simply cannot choose between the ardent life of love and the cold facts of reality. Renata Adler knows them well. And what a superb work of art this is.
66 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Pitch Dark.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 22, 2013 – Shelved as: to-read
May 22, 2013 – Shelved
January 18, 2014 – Started Reading
January 21, 2014 –
page 27
17.53%
January 22, 2014 –
page 37
24.03%
January 22, 2014 –
page 57
37.01%
January 23, 2014 –
page 97
62.99%
January 24, 2014 –
page 142
92.21%
January 24, 2014 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Melanie Nick wrote: "Five stars! Wooooooooooooooooo!"

Bewitching. Light at the centre of a black hole.


message 2: by Lexie (new) - added it

Lexie Melanie, thanks! Based on this review, I'm going to read *Pitch Dark*. I especially like the words "baskings" and "pinings" so close together. Your last paragraph -- "We all know these frail, elegant..." -- Wow! What a perfect wrap-up of a singular personality.


Brian God, you make me want to read this again right now. Superb review.


Melanie Lexie wrote: "Melanie, thanks! Based on this review, I'm going to read *Pitch Dark*. I especially like the words "baskings" and "pinings" so close together. Your last paragraph -- "We all know these frail, elega..."

Thank you! I think you will love it! Such incisive and graceful writing...


Melanie Brian wrote: "God, you make me want to read this again right now. Superb review."

Aww thank you Brian... Now I'm dying to read "Speedboat". She's quite a voice.


message 6: by Michael (new)

Michael You sell me on the "How else to tackle heartbreak but sideways?". And the linkage of place to the interior of the characters is something I love.


message 7: by Teresa (new)

Teresa All those 'blues' reminds me of your book, Melanie!


message 8: by Rowena (new) - added it

Rowena I always end up adding the books you rate 5 stars.Thanks, Melanie:)


Stephen P(who no longer can participate due to illness) Such a difficult book to capture and review. Definitely a 5 star review. Your comment about it being a blue book and what that means nailed it. Do read Speedboat Melanie.


message 10: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala The well-chosen quote, and your own well-chosen words, make this book sound unmissable.
Speedboat is on my list but perhaps I'll start with this one - it sounds so like Proust - all the ingredients are there: love, longing, illnesses, war, cab rides, nightmarish nights, a super-sensitive narrator and the colour blue. I almost feel I've read it already...


Melanie Michael wrote: "You sell me on the "How else to tackle heartbreak but sideways?". And the linkage of place to the interior of the characters is something I love."

You would love this then... The heartbreak is constantly pushed away yet it inhabits every single scene... It's quite a feat and the writing is just superb.


Melanie Teresa wrote: "All those 'blues' reminds me of your book, Melanie!"

You of all people will understand why this particular book resonated so much with me! :)


Melanie Rowena wrote: "I always end up adding the books you rate 5 stars.Thanks, Melanie:)"

Aww thanks Rowena, that's high praise indeed! And I don't give 5 stars lightly. :)


Melanie Louisa wrote: "Melanie, your review is just sublime."

Aww thank you Louisa, so lovely of you to say. :)


Melanie Stephen wrote: "Such a difficult book to capture and review. Definitely a 5 star review. Your comment about it being a blue book and what that means nailed it. Do read Speedboat Melanie."

Thank you so much Stephen! It was a hard book to review! I just held on to the quintessential emotions that were left with me when I finished. I cannot wait to read "Speedboat".


Melanie Fionnuala wrote: "The well-chosen quote, and your own well-chosen words, make this book sound unmissable.
Speedboat is on my list but perhaps I'll start with this one - it sounds so like Proust - all the ingredient..."


Thank you Fionnuala! I also decided to start with this one instead of "Speedboat", I don't know why... It's such a quiet yet powerful voice, so delicate and fiercely intelligent...


message 17: by Margitte (new)

Margitte And what a great work of art your review is. Beautiful prose!


Melanie Margitte wrote: "And what a great work of art your review is. Beautiful prose!"

Thank you so much Margitte! :)


message 19: by Douglas (new)

Douglas Great review. Going to have to get a NYRB copy of this so I don't mess up my hardback and start reading! Strand had signed copies earlier last year. I should've got one. This sounds great.


Melanie Douglas wrote: "Great review. Going to have to get a NYRB copy of this so I don't mess up my hardback and start reading! Strand had signed copies earlier last year. I should've got one. This sounds great."

Thanks Douglas! Damn, I wish I had gotten a signed copy as well! Looking forward to your impressions of this one... :)


message 21: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue You've caught my attention and captivated me with this review. I will have to check the out.


message 22: by Teresa (new)

Teresa Melanie wrote: "You of all people will understand why this particular book resonated so much with me! :)"

Yep. :) Not just the color blue, but the tackling of heartbreak sideways reminded me of your book as well.


Melanie Sue wrote: "You've caught my attention and captivated me with this review. I will have to check the out."

Aww thanks! I hope you get to it. She's quite a haunting and powerful voice...


Melanie Teresa wrote: "Melanie wrote: "You of all people will understand why this particular book resonated so much with me! :)"

Yep. :) Not just the color blue, but the tackling of heartbreak sideways reminded me of yo..."


Indeed, the movie scenes were my personal landscapes...


message 25: by Teresa (new)

Teresa Melanie wrote: "Indeed, the movie scenes were my personal landscapes..."

Exactly what I was thinking. :) I do plan on getting to this; it does sound like something I would love.


Melanie Teresa wrote: "Melanie wrote: "Indeed, the movie scenes were my personal landscapes..."

Exactly what I was thinking. :) I do plan on getting to this; it does sound like something I would love."


I think you absolutely would! I'd love to know your impressions of it.


message 27: by Mikki (last edited Jan 25, 2014 06:40PM) (new)

Mikki "How could you not fall in love with a book like that?"

Or the author. I had planned on starting with Speedboat but after reading your incredibly poetic review, I'm now unsure. Though one can probably not go wrong with either choice! Thank you, Melanie


Melanie Mikki wrote: ""How could you not fall in love with a book like that?"

Or the author. I had planned on starting with Speedboat but after reading your incredibly poetic review, I'm now unsure. Though one can pr..."


Aww thank you Mikki... I don't know why I chose to read this one before "Speedboat"... The theme spoke to me and it seemed to be the darkest of the two... I'm really looking forward to reading the other one now. Looking forward to your thoughts on Renata Adler!


message 29: by Ian (new) - added it

Ian "Marvin" Graye Melanie wrote: "How else to tackle heartbreak but sideways?"

How could you not fall in love with an insight like that?


Melanie Ian wrote: "Melanie wrote: "How else to tackle heartbreak but sideways?"

How could you not fall in love with an insight like that?"


Aww thank you... :)


message 31: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich Lovely review! Okay, this sounds great. I've owned this for years but never got around to it, now I definitely will!


Melanie Thank you so much! Yes, you should! Let me know what you think if you get to it!


message 33: by Caren (new)

Caren Melanie... I could just read your reviews instead of the books. Sheer poetry.


back to top