ŷ

Sasha's Reviews > Emergency Skin

Emergency Skin by N.K. Jemisin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3056563
's review

liked it
bookshelves: fiction, science-fiction, short-stories, hugo, positive-science-fiction, speculative

This short novella starts many generations after our planet's transformation into a nearly uninhabitable hell. We join the protagonist years after a handful of people packed their money bags and moved out of the Solar System to form an independent utopia - where they would be free from the proletariat that had oppressed them with their labor.

The main character has come back to Earth on a mission to find what resources may remain on the planet - which was, surely, devastated by the too-large population of hungry, imperfect humans that the utopia's founders left behind.

But the main character is in for a surprise. The rivers that had gone dry during the human climatocalypse are now flowing again. The atmosphere has been restored to its natural balance. The inhabitants of Raleigh, North Carolina, sound like emigrants from the surfer neighborhoods of San Diego. In short, the protagonist expected a wasteland, but found a paradise instead.

I would have loved to enjoy this novella for story's sake. I wish its political message was subtle enough to be effective without pulling me out of the fictional world. Alas, that wish was not fulfilled. And my formative years in the post-Soviet space are largely responsible for my skewed experience of Emergency Skin.

Those who have lived under the Soviet regime often gravitate towards two camps. One group's worldview goes thusly: 🍄 Communism is Satan's ploy to torture humans, suck the joy out of life, and strengthen toxic social hierarchy. It creates a hypocritical reversal of the shared goodness that communism promises.

The other group appears to live with modified memories that lead them to believe that going back to the Soviet times is the best way to solve their current problems.

From my phrasing, you can probably tell which post-Soviet school of thought I'm part of.

Thus, I arrived at the door of N. K. Jemisin's Emergency Skin with a political background that didn't make me the most receptive to the story's central message. Here's a summary:

Ultra-rich capitalists are the root of all evil that is endangering our species. Oh, did you say they want to leave the planet and move to a terraformed extraterrestrial world because of how unsafe Earth has become due to their pursuit of survival over all others? Well, perhaps that's exactly what we need. If the evil ones leave, we'll be left with (nine billion? I've lost count) intrinsically good humans who internalized preschool "sharing is caring" lessons much better than the ultra-rich did. Then our problems will find an organic solution. All we need is for this tiny group of power hoarders to disappear.


This idea sent my mind to the Russian revolution, where a major solution to human oppression centered around getting rid of the small group of power hoarders that ran the country. To read my interpretation of what happened next, please move to the part of this review marked with the poisonous mushroom "🍄".

OK, that's enough politics. Let's shift our focus to N. K. Jemisin's outstanding skill as a writer. I quite enjoyed the second-person narration here. It's written like a transcript of the things that the main character hears, most of them coming from the AI-run brain implant whose job it is to ensure that the protagonist doesn't veer off The Party's prescribed mission. The story doesn't mention "The Party", but the caricature of the extraterrestrial post-human society from which the protagonist hails reminded me of the governments that use information and propaganda to control its societies.

Oh no, did I say I was done with the political interpretation?
14 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Emergency Skin.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 5, 2024 – Started Reading
February 5, 2024 – Finished Reading
February 6, 2024 – Shelved
February 6, 2024 – Shelved as: science-fiction
February 6, 2024 – Shelved as: fiction
February 6, 2024 – Shelved as: short-stories
February 6, 2024 – Shelved as: hugo
February 6, 2024 – Shelved as: positive-science-fiction
February 6, 2024 – Shelved as: speculative

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

s.penkevich Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was just a short story that hits some basic ideas rather than trying to fumble with the mechanics. Though I guess at that point Le Guin already did that in Dispossessed with a world like this juxtaposed against both the capitalist and communist planets that oppose them (Jemisin did a retelling of another Le Guin story once so I wonder if this is pretty influenced by that novel?) so it would be redundant too.

Interesting breakdown of the two camps as well. I recently read Secondhand Time: The Last of the Soviets for a bookclub and she focused a lot of the latter part of the book on interviewing people of the second camp to try and understand that. But yea isn't the narration cool? I like how you never actually hear what the character is saying, only everyone else.


message 2: by Sasha (last edited Feb 06, 2024 08:15AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sasha s.penkevich wrote: "Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was just a short story that hits some basic ideas rather than trying to fumble with the mechanics. Though..."

Interesting comparison to Le Guin, who appears to have a lot of devoted fans. None of my efforts to read The Dispossessed have ever gotten far. Its characters don't come to life in my imagination, which makes the political side all the more pronounced... It's like a remote control for my mind's DVR of other stories lands buttons-up in my back pocket whenever I sit down to read The Dispossessed. I suppose I haven't tried reading her other works, maybe those won't fall as flat?

Oh, I loved Alexievich's Voices from Chernobyl! Great suggestion.

As for the narration in NK Jemisin's novella, my favorite part was

And oh, fascinating: the material of the platform looks like plastic... Please take a sample. The technorati in Biotech are always looking for new potential commodities�

Oh. Not even with the monomolecular blade? Hmm. Very well. Resume mission.


It skips the protagonist's response, as you say, but also doesn't have the AI reiterating it, because there's no need. Also, I immediately know what the jargon means even though I've never encountered "monomolecular" before. Now that is good writing.


s.penkevich Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was just a short story that hits some basic ideas rather than trying to fumble with t..."

Good point, shes able to convey what was said even in the absence of it. I like her world building a lot in her novels because she usually doesnt explain anything but just lets you pick it up from the context if that makes sense? Though I'm still not entirely sure what HeLa cells were I think I still get the gist? haha

Oh yea! I started that one once but after awhile I was like...well I'm sad and shelved it for a bit, but I should finish that one. And that makes sense about Dispossessed, of all of hers its very blatantly political theory via sci fi narrative, and gets super on the nose when the guy goes and criticizes both the capitalist and the communist countries, very un-subtle Cold War proxy war stuff. Would recommend Left Hand of Darkness though, that one is pretty fun! Or even Lathe of Heaven which is super critical against well-meaning idealism.


message 4: by Sasha (last edited Feb 06, 2024 09:06AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sasha s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was just a short story that hits some basic ideas rather than trying to..."

Sweet, thank you for the reccos - good to hear that The Dispossessed just happens to push the wrong buttons for me, and it's not a universal property of Le Guin's œuvre (that word is so fun to type).

As for Alexievich, I probably got desensitized to the catastrophe, since I've been hearing about Chernobyl since elementary school...

In positive news, coyotes have returned to my backyard woods with their nighttime harmonizing howls, and the past two nights have been so clear that I could see an actual starry sky, complete with the Pleiades.

And yesterday, I saw a horse rolling around in the mud on my way to work. It seemed to be really enjoying itself. I wonder how the blanket it was wearing on its back fared🤔

There are a lot of beautiful, uplifting things in the world.






message 5: by s.penkevich (last edited Feb 06, 2024 09:21AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

s.penkevich Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was just a short story that hits some basic ideas r..."

Haha that is indeed a great word!

Oh that’s amazing. We have a library event at the observatory coming up and I’m hoping it is a clear night because it has been so cloudy lately but we finally got a bit of sun over the weekend and it was so nice. And good for that horse haha speaking of cool nature, yesterday we had a Hawk land on the tree right outside our office with a squirrel and I spent way more time than I’d care to admit to my boss watching the hawk. Uplifting things indeed!

Alexievich is fantastic though. We read big passages from Zinky Boys for a class I had in college. Oh yea did you end up getting this one as the standalone story or the full collection. I’m curious how the other ones are.


message 6: by Sasha (last edited Feb 06, 2024 10:14AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sasha s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was just a short story that hits some..."

That's awesome. Birds of prey are fascinating. The Eurasian Eagle Owl is my favorite, because it's enormous, and the one I met on my honeymoon had no qualms showing its disdain for my pathetic attempts to speak Owl.

And then there's Flaco, hoo escaped from the Central Park Zoo just over a year ago and is the most stereotypical New Yorker ever.



Image source: Flaco The Owl's wikipedia page.

I got the full collection, so I'll review the other stories as I get through them!

Hope astronomy night goes well!


s.penkevich Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was just a short ..."

WAIT Flaco the folk hero owl is the story I needed haha thank you that just gave me so much joy. I looked up Flaco and NRP has an article from just a few days ago about how they still don't know who cut the hole in his enclosure. Now Flaco needs a novel like that book about P-52 the LA mountain lion I just read, Open Throat. So thank you!

Ooo excellent, I was hoping you'd say that! I'm curious about Amor Towles story as hes not one...I usually associate with sci-fi? And the cop from Stranger Things narrates it? Fascinating


message 8: by Cheryl L (new)

Cheryl L Really insightful review, Sasha! I think it has intrigued me enough to pick this up sometime.


Sasha s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Sasha wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Great review. Yea, this one is so heavy handed and idealistic which made me kind of glad it was..."

Haha a folk hero indeed! Open Throat sounds absolutely wild and actually one-of-a-kind. Super interesting. (although the words "elegiac prose" in the blurb tell me I'm probably not the reader it's looking for)

The short story collection is curated by Blake Crouch, and A Gentleman in Moscow is one of his all-time favorite novels. So he asked Towles to contribute a story to this collection.

Haven't watched Stranger Things, so I've got no context for the cop character, but hopefully that bodes well for the narration!


Sasha Cheryl L wrote: "Really insightful review, Sasha! I think it has intrigued me enough to pick this up sometime."

Thank you Cheryl -- that's great to hear. Hope you enjoy it!


Nataliya I liked this story, but now that I think about it I suspect the fascination was with the interesting way of narration through half a dialogue in the second person. I think that’s what made me go all starry-eyed over the story. But after you mentioned the disaster of communism, I can’t unthink and unsee it 😬


message 12: by Sasha (last edited Feb 07, 2024 05:37AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sasha Nataliya wrote: "I liked this story, but now that I think about it I suspect the fascination was with the interesting way of narration through half a dialogue in the second person. I think that’s what made me go al..."

Nooo! Unsee it, unsee it! I'm sorry to have spoiled the story for you.

I agree though; I quite enjoyed the narrative style. But once one image of the Romanovs showed up in my imagination, there was no turning back.

Shame, because I agree that it's clever and has lots in common with some of the best stories in classic sci-fi.


back to top