ŷ

chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) �'s Reviews > You Should Be So Lucky

You Should Be So Lucky by Cat Sebastian
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
42130592
This is, without hyperbole or exaggeration, one of the best romance novels that I’ve ever read. One of those books you buy in paperback and reach, reach, and reach for until they are tattered and yellowed and full of scribbled notes, which is to say, until they are well-loved.

If you had told me that a romance novel about a baseball player and the reporter begrudgingly covering his story would so thoroughly change the landscape of my life in less than two days, I would have said... yep, actually, that sounds about right. More seriously, I loved this book. Set in 1960s New York, You Should Be So Lucky speaks with insistence and quiet intensity to the beautiful density of queer existence, caught up in a world that refuses to accommodate it. Amidst so much unfreedom, the characters in this book build beautiful capacious lives and affirm the tenacity of queer love and the sustaining power of queer community against the routine brutalities of state-sanctioned homophobia and the scripted histories of death, violence, and uprooting. You might be forced to endure subjugation, the novel says, but that does not mean only living life as a subjugated person. And that—well, that hit home.

You Should Be So Lucky is also a deeply moving depiction of grief that refuses to relegate its dead characters to a numb aside, asking us instead to sit with the vast helplessness of mourning someone you're not allowed to love and thus not allowed to grieve. How do you build yourself out of such mourning? How do you begin to heal? This is a novel that is just so utterly kind and generous to its queer characters that I was left feeling nothing so much as grateful for it.

I cheered so hard for the characters� happiness. I believed in their belonging to one another and wanted so desperately for them to believe it too. I cried a lot, but I screamed joyfully even more. Please read it for yourself.
763 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read You Should Be So Lucky.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 7, 2024 – Started Reading
May 7, 2024 – Shelved
May 8, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by natewk (new) - added it

natewk ahhh your review is making me want to read it so bad 😭


Sage Parsley I felt this was about We Could Be So Good so I am so excited to read this one. Sebastian has really hit their stride!


message 3: by Jaya (new) - added it

Jaya CAT SEBASTIAN IS MY GOATTTT


message 4: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ i’m so excited for this 🤍 thank you for the rec


Sara R love this review <3 Cat is the best


message 6: by May (new)

May Your reviews are just so articulate and beautiful! 🩵


chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡ natewk wrote: "ahhh your review is making me want to read it so bad 😭"

I really hope you enjoy it <3


chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡ Sage wrote: "I felt this was about We Could Be So Good so I am so excited to read this one. Sebastian has really hit their stride!"

ooh I loved that book too and Andy and Nick make a cameo in this one!!


chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡ Jaya wrote: "CAT SEBASTIAN IS MY GOATTTT"

I was definitely not familiar with her game, but I want to read everything they've ever written now


chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡ len ❀ wrote: "i’m so excited for this 🤍 thank you for the rec"

hope you enjoy it, friend!!


chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡ Sara wrote: "love this review <3 Cat is the best"

aw thank you <3


chai (thelibrairie on tiktok!) ♡ May wrote: "Your reviews are just so articulate and beautiful! 🩵"

this is so lovely, thank you!! <3


message 13: by Lark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lark Van Just finished this book and your review says EVERYTHING I'm feeling. This book makes me feel like I have overrated every other romance novel I've read


The Porch Fantastic review, I just can't get over this book.


Lauren Completely agree. Cat Sebastian gave us another stunning novel to treasure.


message 16: by S (new) - rated it 5 stars

S Agree. I love baseball, and I loved this story. I’m so glad others did too!


Jennifer Really looking forward to reading this. Started with the audiobook but couldn't make it past three minutes. The narrator's voice was super irritating.


message 19: by e-Kay (new) - added it

e-Kay Oooh your review makes me so curious about this book. I’ve never read Cat Sebastian and clearly i should!


message 20: by solar drifter (new)

solar drifter wonderful review, i'll give it a try, thank you <3


message 21: by H. (new) - rated it 5 stars

H. Finally, a top-rated ŷ review that actually understands the book.


back to top