Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Cynthia Armistead Newman's Reviews > Alpha

Alpha by Rachel Vincent
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
792884
's review

did not like it

** spoiler alert ** Well, that was disappointing. I'm honestly sorry that I ever read that first book (which I got free somehow?). I remember being annoyed at the spelling of the main character's name, "Faythe." I should have stopped then.

The way the plot wound up, for the most part, had no real surprises. Anybody who has followed the series has to have figured out what was going to happen by now. It's been foreshadowed - heck, shouted from the rooftops.

No, my disappointment is in the way the damned romance thing was handled.

If you've bothered to read this but haven't read the series, I'm surprised. Anyway, we have a classic love triangle between Faythe, Marc, and Jace. The setting is supposed to be current day America with a twist - the characters are werecats, part of a hidden subculture.

We all know that mainstream Americans are supposedly monogamous but more serially monogamous and closet - something - in practice. Anyway, werecat society is fiercely monogamous. Females are rare, and they're supposed to hit puberty, get married, and produce the next generation with their One True Love. Period. No other options.

So Faythe has defied tradition so far. She went to college. Good for her! She had a boyfriend there. Even better! A non-Pride boyfriend. Great! (To my way of thinking, not her subculture's). She left her guy, Marc, standing at the altar to do all that, though. Eww - not classy.

But after she goes back home, she gets back together with Marc. Hmph.

Then she "connects" with Jace. That means "has sex with." Ooo, bad idea, since she was in a committed relationship with Marc at the time. Very bad idea. But Oh, They were Grieving! Together! For her brother and his best friend, who had just been treacherously killed by enemies! So of course the way to do that, instead of talking about their memories of him, is to roll around naked in the middle of a public room, right?

Um, not the way I'd do it, but, apparently that's their way. They do their grieving with a lot more alcohol than I would too, though.

They don't get caught, at least - not then. No, an enemy figures it out due to how the three interact, and tells Marc, and he believes the enemy (because everybody believes enemies over allies in the heat of battle). And they're all too immature to put the crap behind them and just deal with the fact that they're in the middle of a "war," too.

I kept wanting to spank all of them, and it wasn't because I found any of them sexy.

I did hope, at first, that bringing Jace in as a love interest - and Faythe does repeat, over and over and over again, that she loves Jace, that it wasn't "just sex" - might mean that there was hope for some sort of surprise in the end of the book. That would have been nice, right? Something of a twist that didn't lead to an unhappy ending? I would have loved to see that!

She's going to be the first female Alpha, so why not the first Alpha with two husbands? She'll be the first Alpha who has to deal with pregnancy, so why not have one husband to protect her while she's pregnant and another to get deal with what has to be done in person? What a concept?

My hope was buoyed by the fact that Vincent deliberately developed Jase as a decent potential partner, showing him taking care of Faythe well when she's injured, supporting her as she would need to be supporting when she takes over the Pride as Alpha, and working well with Marc and others repeatedly.

Marc, on the other hand, is a jerk, slamming doors, stomping around, and doing everything but pissing on the furniture to mark his territory.

Just once, I want to see a hero or heroine walk away when someone says, "I cant live without you!" I want to see someone say, "Whoa - that's WAY unhealthy, babe! You need THERAPY!"

Instead, Faythe's father tells her to "Choose the one you can't live without." UGH. Thanks, Daddy! Codependent much?

Do I think she chose the wrong Tom? Absolutely. But - she's a spoiled brat, and she chose a jealous ass. They deserve each other. Let the sweet, loving man go find the sweet, loving woman he deserves. Hopefully he'll stop the drunken escapades and keep it in his pants from now on. Maybe Kaci will grow up to be his Tabby?

Anyway, there you have it. Volume Eleventy Billion and thirteen of How To Do Dysfunctional Relationships.

Next, please!
50 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Alpha.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 19, 2009 – Shelved
October 16, 2010 – Started Reading
October 16, 2010 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Hope (new)

Hope This was a fun review to read :)


Cynthia Armistead Newman I didn't think anybody ever read them - thanks :-)


Jessica I liked the series, until the end. OBVIOUSLY, the book was not going to end with Malone taking over the whole council and Faythe losing. The good guys always win- duh. So I, like you, was hoping the love-triangle might bring some unpredictable aspect into the plot. But, no. Instead of choosing the sweat,caring Jace, stupid Faythe chooses the almost-abusive Marc. Yeah, Marc- the guy who doesn't slam doors when he's angry, he breaks them. Marc, the guy who had sex with Faythe, dumped her on the barn floor, and COMMANDED her not to take a shower so she would smell like him. Yeah, good choice Faythe! It's nice to know someone else is frustrated with books always ending with a the heroine falling for a guy no matter how many times she's portested her independance.


Cynthia Armistead Newman The more I think about it, the more disgusted I am that this kind of behavior is essentially being promoted in a series that is pretty clearly marketed to the YA market. So how do we encourage authors (and, more importantly, publishers) to change things?


message 5: by Hope (new)

Hope I think talking about the problems in books like this, and encouraging the folks writing healthy relationships is probably a good start.


Sara Oh for the love of literature, unhealthy relationships are not being promoted in this book. *sigh*

People are jealous. It's very damn real. What of his good traits? His forgiveness? His sticking by her?

And why do you focus on Marcs anger? Everyone showed anger. It too, is a real emotion. The main characters are half animal. You really have to take that into consideration.

Also, she made the choice.
So all this talk of her not being independent even though promoting she was is also false. She always has the upper hand. She is tough as nails and still very much conflicted with feelings all women can relate to. I wish I read more books blessed with these kind of characters. I'm sick of reading books about women who make "safe" decisions. Women who never do anything to make anyone angry. It's ridiculous.

Also, this is NOT marketed as a teen book. It very clearly is adult and I never had any misconception before reading that it was anything else. Its in my fiction section of the bookstore.

It's fine to disagree.
Its even fine if you don't like it.
But its sad you wish authors should write or show only one kind of relationship.

I may not be a teen anymore but even as a teen, I was never mislead into silliness because of a novel. Give kids credit.

Thanks.


Cynthia Armistead Newman Yes, people are jealous. Healthy, rational people recognize that they are jealous and talk about it instead of acting like idiots. Assholes punch walls, throw things - or humiliate their girlfriends by fucking them and refusing to allow them to shower when they're surrounded by people who can tell that they've just had sex and who they've had sex with. Essentially, marking territory when the "territory" is a person. That's abusive behavior. That goes way beyond jealousy.

The characters may be "half animal" but they are "animals" with a lifetime's experience controlling the animal, and who place a very high value on not being feral. The author establishes that.

Yes, the main character made the choice. I'm not quibbling with that. If anyone else had made the choice for her, I would be screaming to the high heavens. E-books cannot be satisfactorily thrown, but I would have worked to find a way - perhaps I would have done a secure wipe of it or something. Who made the choice doesn't change the fact that she made the very traditional, expected choice, and I would have been far happier if she had refused to choose. Saying, "the man who forces me to choose loses" would be more my style.

Honestly, I don't read many books about characters who make "safe" decisions, but maybe we read very different books. (Um, yeah, looks like we do - Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ says we only have 1.58% of my library and 7.89% of your library in common. Of the ones we have in common, there are a lot where one of us have something marked to read that the other has read, or our ratings differ a lot. But we see eye to eye on A Wrinkle in Time and New Moon!)

In any case, I'd recommend moving to other genres - many female science fiction and fantasy writers do well with that. Some of the paranormal authors do as well, although some of those are more romance than I prefer - but if you like romance, that might please you. Sharon Lee and Steve Miller's works are very popular with people who self-report as Regency fans, as are Lois McMaster Bujold's.

Um, only one kind of relationship? How many books show anything but one on one relationships? I mean, other than those e-book only or print-on-demand erotica things or a few other pretty rare works. The vast, vast majority of works in publication are still showing monogamous relationships.

I would like to see the occasional polyamorous or polyfidelitous relationship portrayed as a reasonable alternative. Is that too much to ask?

Maybe the novels aren't being promoted to teens now, but I promise you - when the first in the series was being promoted in stores, it also had a display in the teen/YA section. My daughter (who loves all things feline) remarked on it and I told her I'd already received a free copy elsewhere.

In any case, I'm not complaining about just this series, but the fact that dysfunctional relationship patterns are shown over and over again, in every form of media, as perfectly normal. They are used as the reason for plots, as if there is no way to have any excitement without causing arguments or stirring up bullshit arguments. What happens when you do discuss your feelings instead of flying off the handle, stomping around and throwing things? You have a chance to work things out like reasonable adults. It doesn't make for a very interesting story, because there's less conflict - but the conflict can come from outside factors, and it does from such in other some authors' books (see Lee & Miller, for instance).

I realize that, unfortunately, there are many dysfunctional relationships in our society. I can only hope that as more people learn healthier ways and spread them by example, things will get better. One of the ways we do that is through books and other media. I don't see why so many damned books have to keep showing those old bad ways, except that apparently their authors don't know anything else, and that's sad.

If I thought I could do better, I would. I only write non-fiction. My attempts to write fiction end up with almost no conflict - go figure. So I'll have to keep promoting the few authors who do get it right and talking about what I hope to see and hoping to find something better.


message 8: by Jen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jen WOW... I don't think we read the same book.That is not what I got form the story at all.Marc was none of those things..He loved her and never let her down.she never loved Jace.She just felt guilty and didn't want to hurt him.


message 9: by M. (new) - rated it 3 stars

M. This was a fun review to read. Yeah, Marc wasn't my top pick either for several reasons. I'm not denying he loved her, but he did act like a caveman, and for someone who claimed to love being independent, I don't see how Faythe could have chosen him in the end. The book was pretty predictable and I was hoping that she would pick Jace or have 2 husbands. Honestly, I didn't believe Faythe loved either of them. Her actions contradicted her words big time. If she truly loved Marc desperately and she didn't love Jace, why on earth would she hurt her true love over and over again? That is totally BS. She only did that because Marc was a total pussy when it came to Faythe and Jace had nothing to lose. So being the spoiled brat she was, she didn't feel like she really had to choose.


Siobhan Great review really made me chuckle, I am from the absolute polar opposite in opinion. I 5 star loved them. All those things that annoyed you made me think great - people are flawed. Your urge to spank - to quote a solid british phrase "Cracked me up", what would Freud make of that. Thanks for the alternative perspective.


Jenny From The Bog Just....THANK you for both this review and your response in the comments. I'm so creeped out by the seeming brainwashing that has gone on that makes women think dysfunctional/abusive relationships are just passionate. *shudder*


Kaylee I DESPISED Marc from the beginning and this review is just perfect. Totally agree. The fact that Jace wasn’t chosen really dampened the series for me to be honest.:(


Christine I am glad I am not the only one who disliked Marc from the beginning and wished she had chosen Jace. The moment he scent marked her and she almost bit his foot off, I knew that he was more about what he wanted than what she wanted. And he never changed, even though she did. How a man loses tells you his character, and Marc was mean.


back to top