ŷ

Rachel (APCB Reviews)'s Reviews > Queen of Shadows

Queen of Shadows by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
12502667
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: disappointments

Post-reading: WOW. No words for this book. 95% love for this book, but the first 300 pages had issues I can't deny. But overall I just love love love how the plot developed!

Full review:

Check out my review @

**Spoilers from previous books. Slight QoS spoilers about romance.

Throne of Glass has been one of my favorite series for a few years now, so I've been impatiently waiting for Queen of Shadows and building the expectations to the highest degree. The fourth installment wowed me yet had some flaws I can't ignore.

As much as I'd like to blindly give myself over to the epicness of this series and say "It was perfect, and everything was amazing" I can't do that as a reviewer. Nor can I do that as a reader/person in general. I refuse to trick myself! Overall though, I have so many positive things to say about this book,and a few negative things to discuss.

The Plot

First let's start with the plot development. I bow down to Sarah J Maas and her brilliant plotting. I am astounded by all the ties and connections reaching so far back to The Assassin's Blade. There are lots of ah-ha and mind-blowing moments. Everything connects in some way, and Maas is a magnificent plotter. The pacing was a bit slow for the first 300 pages, but there's so much plot build-up and development that keeps us engaged. Maas' writing has progressively matured into a beautiful story-telling talent. There's an ominous edge to it that perfectly matches the tone of the series. I feel this series is getting darker and darker; it's often pitched as a less promiscuous YA Game of Thrones. There are some bloody scenes, lots of death, and quite a bit of pain. Action is interspersed throughout the story too.

The Characters

Let's talk about the characters! In Heir of Fire, I had a few issues with the various POV switches, but I thought the transitions were smoother in Queen of Shadows, and I actually like Manon and her story a bit more in this book. Elide is also introduced, and while her POV was my least favorite, her character is pretty tenacious and smart, so I can't wait to see where she goes next. Lysandra is re-introduced, and I love her sassy and snarky character. Nesyrn is a rebel who is part of the city guard. She's pretty stoic and strong-willed, and I like her! Aedion will always be a bright star with his unending devotion and loyalty to Aelin. Dorian's character and POVs were painful and sad to read. I love him and thought his tenacity and decisiveness were admirable.

Squad assembled in this book, and I was so happy about that!! I love Aelin's court/group and seeing them all come together was definitely one of my favorite parts. Light banter and strong female friendships prevail, and I approve! Arobynn comes back into this novel and oh geez I forgot how cynical and ruthless he is. Sam has such a presence in this novel which was equal parts surprising, somber, and up-lifting.

Let's talk about Rowan, Chaol, and Aelin. Such fun. While I loved all the other characters mentioned above, I had so much trouble with these three. Please don't stone me, but I'm going to call BS and say these people were SO out of character for the first 300 pages. I liked Rowan a bit better in this book, but whoa has he changed. No longer is he the tight***, brutal and unemotional warrior. He's now reduced to a horny teenager who pines over Aelin. I failed to see many similarities between this Rowan and the one from HoF. Chaol, oh my sweet Chaol. Honorable Captain of the Guard, now disgraced and rebel-turned. His bitterness has reached his peak just as his character and his POV has been diminished. I still hold on to the hope he'll achieve redemption. Chaol has grown so much throughout this series, yet he still needs time to grow. He's used to his beliefs and blindly and honorably follows his king. Now that everything he knows and loves is being threatened and challenged, he's had to change, and not everyone reacts the same way to change. He's made progress!

Aelin has turned malicious and bitter. I love how bad*** she is and how she fights for what she believes in, but I missed her sarcastic nature. I missed the girl who loved reading and dresses yet also loved to show people her girl power and how awesome she is. She lacked the confidence and humor I associate with her. Just because she and Celaena have different goals, I don't think that should mean her character takes a 180 turn. Most of all Aelin is highly hypocritical, especially towards Chaol. Aelin and Chaol are both mad at each other for both reasonable and unreasonable things. Personally I think they were both being hypocritical as they slung insults and accusations at each other at their first meeting in QoS. I see faults on both sides, but I think they'll work through it eventually.

The Romance

Speaking of Aelin and Chaol, you've probably heard about the romance news. I'll be honest, this ship is sunk and blasted to smithereens. They want and need different things, and it would never work out. It twinges my heart and makes me wonder about the so-called significance of the words exchanged on Crown of Midnight. Some things literally do NOT make sense. Aelin even says something to the effect of "Even though I said I'd always pick you, I didn't mean I'd actually always pick you." I feel like books 1 and 2 were so insignificance and fake now in regards to the romance. I think it's fresh and unique to see how realistic the portrayal of falling into and out of love is, but it still hurts. I feel like we were led on in Crown of Midnight, and you can't deny all the words they said to each other.

Jumping to the romance, I do not understand it nor will I get on board with it. I'm not being a stubborn Chaolaena shipper (okay maybe a little bit), but I fail to see Rowaelin in the long run. Rowan is the type of guy Aelin needs right now. I just don't understand how things progressed from Heir of Fire as a platonic friendship to a lusty and yearning attachment in Queen of Shadows. I feel like I missed an extra novella or something. Rowan had his one true mate AND is three hundred years old. This romance does not compute. That being said, there actually isn't much romance in this book, it's more promises to come in the next book.

As Cait from Paper Fury pointed out, there are so many conveniences in the romance department. Nesryn will take Celaena's place in Chaol's heart, so Aelin and Rowan can be happy together, and everything is all sparkly rainbows and wonderful now. I feel like this is such an easy way out. The Chaolin breakup was brutal, and I'm sad to see how it wrecked their friendship too.The last 150 pages of the book are insanely epic and wonderful. The characters grow into their own a bit more as well.

Overall the amazing plot, squad assemblage, and writing make this book wonderful while the romance and earlier portrayal of the characters sorely disappointed and confused me.

Update 5/22/15

Queen of Shadows is 672 pages long. *sinks in*

OH MY GOSH I AM SO FREAKING EXCITED!!!!!!!!

Update 3/10/14

LOOK AT THIS BEAUTIFUL COVER





Ahhh, she's so badass!! AND SHE'S GOT THE SWORD!! She's ready to take back her crown, all hail Queen Aelin!!!! Bwhaha a red cover means action and blood to come, right? Preferably the King of Adarlan's?

Update 1/27/15 A TITLE: Queen of Shadows

Eeeek! I love it.

AND Sarah J Maas stated that Queen of Shadows is longer than Heir of Fire




Update 1/5/15 Apparently there will be no arcs for book #4. *cries*

Words can not convey my excitement for this book!! It's going to be EPIC.

HEIR OF FIRE REACTIONS:



MY HOPES/REQUIREMENTS/NEEDS FOR BOOK #4:

-Save Dorian
-Save Aedion
-Chaolaena get back together
-Rowan come backkkkk
-Find the wyrdkey
-Kick Arobynn's ***
-Kill King of Adarlan Jerk-Face
-Form alliance with Wendlyn
-Build this rebellion!!!!!

I also need....

ACTION:


CHAOLAENA:


BADASSERY & EPICNESS:


Until Book #4 comes out....





Me attempting to wait for book #4:

407 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Queen of Shadows.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 20, 2013 – Shelved as: to-read
August 20, 2013 – Shelved
September 1, 2015 – Started Reading
September 1, 2015 –
page 1
0.15% "Oh lord please help me."
September 1, 2015 –
page 100
15.43% "I like it, but these characters aren't the same as I remembered them from last book.... Like no transition, just *bam* they're different."
September 2, 2015 –
page 200
30.86% "It's getting better and the plot is epic, but gosh these characters. Abraxos is my favorite now <3"
September 6, 2015 –
page 500
77.16% "This is so intense! My ship is sunk, yet I somehow still love this book."
September 7, 2015 –
page 573
88.43% "YAAS DORIAN YAAS"
September 7, 2015 – Finished Reading
January 23, 2016 – Shelved as: disappointments

Comments Showing 1-48 of 48 (48 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tamara (new) - added it

Tamara Cant wait for this book :)


Victoria Clawson I'm literally crying right now because I have to wait for this book. I had promised myself no more series that I had to wait for books but no throne of glass had to be inticing


message 3: by Soper (new) - added it

Soper I know what you mean i have a few series im reading that im waiting for the next book and its killing me that why i began to read this series so i wouldnt be bored out of my mind so what should i do while im waiting for all the new books :-( :-( :'(


message 4: by Mindy (new) - added it

Mindy you've missed a spot dear, MAKING SURE AROBYN PAYS FOR SAM. PAY WITH BLOOOOOOD


message 5: by Susana (new) - added it

Susana may I just say, this is exactly how I feel


message 6: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura your list is perfection


Sierra Shepherd This review is perfection. I wish I could do jump out of window, while bashing my face against the wall, while also screaming for no reason at all except because I have nothing better to do UNTIL HEIR OF FIRE #4 FRIGGING COMES OUT! So basically, this review describes my feels, so thank you for writing such a review that I can relate to. Now excuse me while I do the actions I have just said...


...




...




...




Ok, I'm good.


Wait...

....

...

Ok now I'm done.

LONG LIVE CHAOLAENA


message 8: by Alexandra (new)

Alexandra Ray I agree with all of thee above. CHAOLAENA NOW!


Basma Heir of Fire was my favorite book in 2014 !!
Can't wait for book #4.


message 10: by Cindy (new)

Cindy De I LITERALLY CANNOT WAIT UNTIL BOOK NUMBER 4. HoF left so many cliff hangers...I just want some Chaolaena action. I MISS THEM SO MUCH. AND OMG DORIAN, I WAS LITERALLY IN TEARS.


Shari X Insanity I agree with everything on that list, except minus the Chaolaena back together. I want them to have closure, talk and settle things, and reunite as friends, and same thing for Dorian, and king and Abrobyn Hamel's asses being kicked the shit out of, and Aedion bring saved so the cousins can reunite, but I really don't want Chaolaena. They broke up, it didn't work, so don't try it again. I want Celaena with Rowan, please. Rowlaena, por favor!!! And lots of it!!!


Rachel  (APCB Reviews) Shari wrote: "I agree with everything on that list, except minus the Chaolaena back together. I want them to have closure, talk and settle things, and reunite as friends, and same thing for Dorian, and king and ..."

But Rowan and Celaena are just FRIENDS!!!


message 13: by [deleted user] (last edited Jan 19, 2015 02:08PM) (new)

Update,The Release Date is September 1st,Not The 10th Because The 10th is When it's Out In The UK


Marija IT HAS A NAME!


message 15: by Rachel (last edited Jan 22, 2015 02:35PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Rachel  (APCB Reviews) Hannah wrote: "Where did you hear there wouldn't be any ARCs??"

Can't remember where I heard it, but it makes sense. Really successful series, fourth book? Not really a chance of ARCs being made, this series already has its following! :)


Sofia Is it only me that ships Celaena with Sam? But... He's dead


Marija Sofia wrote: "Is it only me that ships Celaena with Sam? But... He's dead"

I ship Celaena and Sam too, at least I shipped them while reading the novellas. And I don't dare reading the last one.
:(


message 18: by meg (new) - rated it 5 stars

meg ⭐️ CHAOLAENA


message 19: by josh (new) - rated it 5 stars

josh i agree with everything except Chaolaena... #celorian sorry no sorry


Michelle Chaolenaa O.O Love them!!


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)

SO, I Was Just Looking at The ŷ Page For Queen of Shadows

and

I Noticed This


BLURB For Queen of Shadows Released!!!!!!!!!!

Sarah J. Maas's New York Times bestselling Throne of Glass series reaches new heights in this sweeping fourth volume.

Everyone Celaena Sardothien loves has been taken from her. But she's at last returned to the empire—for vengeance, to rescue her once-glorious kingdom, and to confront the shadows of her past . . .

She will fight for her cousin, a warrior prepared to die just to see her again. She will fight for her friend, a young man trapped in an unspeakable prison. And she will fight for her people, enslaved to a brutal king and awaiting their lost queen's triumphant return.

Celaena’s epic journey has captured the hearts and imaginations of millions across the globe. This fourth volume will hold readers rapt as Celaena’s story builds to a passionate, agonizing crescendo that might just shatter her world.


message 22: by Carm (new) - rated it 5 stars

Carm OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG


message 23: by No (new)

No YYYYEEEESSSS!!!!!


Cameron Cassidy but it says this book is only 384 pages not longer than Heir of Fire


Rachel  (APCB Reviews) Cameron wrote: "but it says this book is only 384 pages not longer than Heir of Fire"

384 is a page length holder that they always just put in to begin with. Sarah has confirmed QoS is longer than HoF :D


Cameron Cassidy Oooooooh! Yay! I'm so pumped for Celaena to kick some arryobyn ass and to find some wyrd keys!


Nikki I can't even express how excited I am for this book!!!!! I'm counting down every agonizing second until it comes out. I think I died somewhere inside when I saw that I had to wait until fall. WHY!!!!!!!!!!


Britt Form alliance with Manon and conquer the freakin world


Julia Li OH MY GOSH SOMEONE WHO CAN UNDERSTAND EXACTLY HOW I FEEL! THIS POST IS ON POINT!


message 30: by [deleted user] (new)




Emily Gaskill-Keyes Beyond excited!!


message 32: by [deleted user] (new)




message 33: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey Perfect.


Tyler Thorpe Has any body noticed that celaena has short hair .....wat ...im pretty sure thats short hair ....did she cut it ..wat ...


Tyler Thorpe Is that short hair i can see ....i think celaena has sjort hair ....what ....did she cut it why ...what ....no ...


Popadora the Bibliophile the monsters at the end of HoF fight cut off part of her braid with a sword.
Don't worry, it'll grow back thoug


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

THE FIRST 3 CHAPTERS!




Bella Wait am I the only one who still ships Celorian??? Oh my God...


Priscilla I'm still shipping Celorian too lol but I'm afraid it's not going to happen... But every other thing about this review is perfecttttttt


Jessica Kam I am dying to wait anther week!! I act wait!!


message 42: by Dani (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dani Wait, wait. What. Got what sword? (SOOOOO freaking excited!!!! Fast forward to September, please!!!)


Natalia Don't worry TWO MORE DAYS we make make it! We all can make it to the book store in time! I saved my money for moths, wish fana my comes true!


Priscilla I NEED MY LIBRARIES TO GET THIS NOW!


message 45: by [deleted user] (new)

What Did You Think?????


message 46: by Carie (new) - added it

Carie Rachel, is this worth my reading time if I'm (view spoiler)? :( What’s your advice? I’m more than a little distressed here :�(


Rachel  (APCB Reviews) Carie wrote: "Rachel, is this worth my reading time if I'm [spoilers removed]? :( What’s your advice? I’m more than a little distressed here :�("

This was my concern too! In regards to your question (view spoiler)


message 48: by Carie (new) - added it

Carie Rachel wrote: "Carie wrote: "Rachel, is this worth my reading time if I'm [spoilers removed]? :( What’s your advice? I’m more than a little distressed here :�("
This was my concern too! In regards to your ques..."


Thanks! That gives me some food for thought…and I’m SO happy to know that I’m not alone in my feelings about this :) I loved the (view spoiler)!

Thanks so much for the advice!!


back to top