ŷ

aly ☆彡's Reviews > The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy

The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy by Megan Bannen
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
113225804
's review

liked it

It doesn’t feel fair that I couldn’t get into the book at first because I found the story a bit flat—though I think it had a lot to do with Hart and Mercy not interacting much early on. I already knew what I wanted to rate this before it completely proved me wrong, making me laugh, cry, and end up having me enjoying it way more than I expected (*꒦ິ꒳꒦�)

I know this book was well-loved way before I picked it up and I do trust my ŷ friend for the greater good, but I find myself disappointed because I was expecting a romance, and for the first half � it felt like I wasn’t getting it. The characters barely interacted, and honestly, if you think about it, that’s a pretty long stretch of time for a romance to develop. They were more like ideas we were told about—this whole "we hate each other" dynamic—without them actually being together. We just get a lot of Mercy and Hart griping about their lives in the beginning and although the letters were a nice touch, they didn’t feel like enough.

And so, the sudden shift into romance almost felt out of place. Fortunately, I am a very simple person because I dive into this book to enjoy the romance, and when delivered with one - I am a happy person.

Now, what could have been better? Well, a lot could have been better; especially the worldbuilding.
While the author introduces interesting concepts like fantastical animals, locations, and in-world folklore, there’s barely any description or explanation to make them come alive. Every creature, place, and idea seemed so promising at first, but I never really got to know it. Would you believe me when I said I didn't know this book was supposed to be about zombies until I read other's reviews? (ᵕ—ᴗ�) The world had so much potential, but it ended up feeling underdeveloped and confusing.

Also, whereas I enjoyed the moments between Hart and Mercy, do not confuse into me actually thinking it was well executed. When I said it felt out of place, I really meant it wasn’t fitting. The miscommunication trope was a big issue here—it was a classic case of "if only they talked," and the reason for not speaking up was weak, as it often is.

Not to add, Hart and Mercy treat each other terribly for reasons that are never fully explained. It's hardly digestible why they were enemies in the first place when their line of work would have them communicate with each other. Near the end, Hart also claims that he thought Mercy was profiting off deaths, but that explanation too � feels forced and unbelievable. Plus, Mercy easily forgives her ex but is stubborn with Hart. The lack of clear motivation behind their conflict makes it hard to buy into this 'enemies to lovers' trope.

Moving past that, I still think the book has its merits, particularly in displaying the intricacy of its characters. Despite its shortcomings, the romance between Hart and Mercy feels earned because it’s about two people overcoming their insecurities and emotional baggage to truly connect. Their personalities are both strong and shattered in their ways, and their friendship is what allows them to recover, demonstrating how love and connection can alter people who appear to be worlds apart.

Is this book perfect? Far from it.
Do I still enjoy the book? Absolutely, yes.

The writing style was solid, and the story itself is still an enjoyable read with plenty of charm and cuteness. And as someone with a heart as tender as mine, thank you for writing a book that made me cry, laugh, smile, and long for a love so deep it broke me a little post-reading this.

ps: I originally skipped this book from my Fairyloot subscription for reasons I can't quite explain (maybe the cover didn’t appeal to me at the time), but now I regret that decision and am on the lookout for anyone willing to resell it, please-
99 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Undertaking of Hart and Mercy.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 6, 2025 – Started Reading
January 6, 2025 – Shelved as: to-read
January 6, 2025 – Shelved
January 18, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by JustJJ (new)

JustJJ That's fair 💙 Glad you enjoyed it in the end Aly!


message 2: by Darcey (last edited Jan 27, 2025 05:42PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Darcey so glad you ended up loving the last half!!! these two are so adorable for sure <33 amazing review lovely!


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Completely understand! It's tougher to enjoy a grumpy vs. grumpy book until they are grumpy no more. :D But glad that you ended up liking it. Looking forward to your review, Aly!


message 4: by emma (new)

emma it's so nice to see your reviews popping up on my feed again! lovely words, as usual <3


Kezia Duah Fantastic review Aly!! I understand a book not being perfect but still enjoying it!!


message 6: by Yun (new)

Yun Great review, Aly! Glad you ended up enjoying it despite some flaws. :)


message 7: by aly (new) - rated it 3 stars

aly ☆彡 JustJJ thank you! im glad it did turn into my favor too *was almost rioting 😆


message 8: by aly (new) - rated it 3 stars

aly ☆彡 Darcey im upset we didnt get more of them after /that/ happened but theyre an adorable bunch that i really love sigh


message 9: by aly (new) - rated it 3 stars

aly ☆彡 Rosh now that you mention it, i think the grumpy x grumpy dynamic does contribute to making the book feel longer than intended, since it's supposed to make it difficult in softening both characters but glad it works out in the end <3


message 10: by aly (new) - rated it 3 stars

aly ☆彡 emma aw thank u emma! uve always been the loveliest 🥰


message 11: by aly (new) - rated it 3 stars

aly ☆彡 Kezia thank u kezia! im glad u still find this book somewhat enjoyable too <3


message 12: by aly (new) - rated it 3 stars

aly ☆彡 Yun glad the author was able to turn the table despite the rough starts. thank you yun! <3


message 13: by Federico (last edited Jan 31, 2025 05:39AM) (new)

Federico DN Even though many things could've gone better, glad this imperfect unconvincing turtle paced romance full of charm and cuteness in the end finally won you over lol. Sounds like we got one happy Aly full of emotions right there <3<3<3. Sweet review!


message 14: by aly (new) - rated it 3 stars

aly ☆彡 Federico hehe thank you federico! im glad it does even tho theyre doing it in a very imperfect unconvincing turtle paced of romance 😝


back to top