Julie G's Reviews > Loved and Missed
Loved and Missed
by
by

Julie G's review
bookshelves: the-british-invasion, grandchildren-on-your-knee, you-ve-got-a-friend, you-ll-need-a-hankie, worthy-of-another-read, on-death-and-dying
Jan 25, 2025
bookshelves: the-british-invasion, grandchildren-on-your-knee, you-ve-got-a-friend, you-ll-need-a-hankie, worthy-of-another-read, on-death-and-dying
Have you ever felt as though you deserved something better than what you've got? Ever thought your kids or a good friend deserved better than how they've fared?
Of course you have.
But, really, at the end of the day. . . do we really know or understand what it is we DO deserve? (And who says we deserve anything?)
Enter Ruth, our protagonist here. Our narrator, too.
As a reader, I embraced Ruth quickly. I understood her, felt as though she could easily be a friend of mine in real life.
It was natural for me to wonder if Ruth deserved what she got.
Ruth and her mother were abandoned by Ruth's father, early in her life, and Ruth's beloved mother died right around the time Ruth turned 30. Ruth grew up without siblings, and she was impregnated about five minutes into a rare romantic affair, with a man who had a lot of requirements of her:
He liked me very light about everything, smiling, mild opinions, carefree. But beneath that he wanted me tender in my personality; it was how a woman should be, with intelligent courage, a careful imagination for the difficulties of others, soft laughter, delicate feminine instincts. A sense of duty. If you think of the way a doctor sometimes says with sympathy as he presses against you with his fingers, 'Is it tender here?' Like that. He could overlook a certain sadness as long as it wasn't twee, but anger would have struck him as unsightly.
And, just as Ruth's father abandoned his family, the father of Ruth's child abandons her, almost immediately, and she is left to raise her own daughter without parents, siblings, or a partner.
When did I learn the more you wanted from people, the less they gave?
It is Ruth's friends, all women, who show up for her, and they offer complicated and reciprocal relationships, both with the nuts and bolts of childcare and mutual aid, and with laughter and emotional support, too.
. . . each time you had ought to be a special thing, a special time, you made something out of it. An event to remember. That was life, that was living. . . it was important as you got older to take pleasure seriously.
These friends are the ones who cringe in despair and disbelief as they witness Ruth's only child, Eleanor, turn away from her mother and her privileged existence to a life of erratic behavior, drug abuse, and complete indifference toward her family.
And Eleanor, like her father and grandfather before her, abandons her mother and newly born daughter.
Ruth. . . sob. . . my sweet friend Ruth. I am so sorry, my friend. Good God, woman, I am so grateful you had shelter, you had friends, and you had clear-headed and loving Lily, but still, lady, you deserved so much more than you got.
Didn't you, dear?
Of course you have.
But, really, at the end of the day. . . do we really know or understand what it is we DO deserve? (And who says we deserve anything?)
Enter Ruth, our protagonist here. Our narrator, too.
As a reader, I embraced Ruth quickly. I understood her, felt as though she could easily be a friend of mine in real life.
It was natural for me to wonder if Ruth deserved what she got.
Ruth and her mother were abandoned by Ruth's father, early in her life, and Ruth's beloved mother died right around the time Ruth turned 30. Ruth grew up without siblings, and she was impregnated about five minutes into a rare romantic affair, with a man who had a lot of requirements of her:
He liked me very light about everything, smiling, mild opinions, carefree. But beneath that he wanted me tender in my personality; it was how a woman should be, with intelligent courage, a careful imagination for the difficulties of others, soft laughter, delicate feminine instincts. A sense of duty. If you think of the way a doctor sometimes says with sympathy as he presses against you with his fingers, 'Is it tender here?' Like that. He could overlook a certain sadness as long as it wasn't twee, but anger would have struck him as unsightly.
And, just as Ruth's father abandoned his family, the father of Ruth's child abandons her, almost immediately, and she is left to raise her own daughter without parents, siblings, or a partner.
When did I learn the more you wanted from people, the less they gave?
It is Ruth's friends, all women, who show up for her, and they offer complicated and reciprocal relationships, both with the nuts and bolts of childcare and mutual aid, and with laughter and emotional support, too.
. . . each time you had ought to be a special thing, a special time, you made something out of it. An event to remember. That was life, that was living. . . it was important as you got older to take pleasure seriously.
These friends are the ones who cringe in despair and disbelief as they witness Ruth's only child, Eleanor, turn away from her mother and her privileged existence to a life of erratic behavior, drug abuse, and complete indifference toward her family.
And Eleanor, like her father and grandfather before her, abandons her mother and newly born daughter.
Ruth. . . sob. . . my sweet friend Ruth. I am so sorry, my friend. Good God, woman, I am so grateful you had shelter, you had friends, and you had clear-headed and loving Lily, but still, lady, you deserved so much more than you got.
Didn't you, dear?
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Loved and Missed.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 15, 2025
–
Started Reading
January 15, 2025
– Shelved
January 17, 2025
–
22.6%
"Odd to be so proud and so furious with yourself all at once. At certain times I felt almost too embarrassed to exist."
page
47
January 20, 2025
–
25.96%
"The pain of cohabiting with someone who despised you, who thought you quite a few rungs lower than human. Bracing, that. A particular species of domestic violence."
page
54
January 20, 2025
–
35.1%
"She had long ago lost the art of the mechanics of eating, the simple up-down of knife and fork; her body sharp and empty as if she had no hospitality to offer herself."
page
73
January 23, 2025
–
59.13%
"I wondered how long I could keep her at my side. People haven't stuck to me particularly in life. I've dealt myself out of things, without meaning to or realising."
page
123
January 24, 2025
–
73.08%
"They said the treatment was more likely to take if you had a companion with you. Life punished the lonely at every turn."
page
152
January 24, 2025
–
82.21%
"I sometimes wondered if there were quite long stretches of life in which you couldn't afford to be yourself."
page
171
January 24, 2025
–
85.1%
"She said it was important as you got older to take pleasure seriously. "You must grab it by the lapels," she said."
page
177
January 24, 2025
–
92.79%
"Terrible in life when you wanted to give everything and there wasn't anyone willing to receive you."
page
193
January 25, 2025
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)
date
newest »


Sadly, I am not done with my 30s project yet. It feels like it's taking f-o-r-e-v-e-r. I just had to take a break and decided to read something entirely different. The writing is spectacular. Truly.






The writing in this novel is some of the best contemporary writing out there. I think you will be very moved by Ruth's story.

Too true, but, though this is a story about estrangement. . . I found it much more a story of the generational harm of abandonment, and resilience among women, facing their ever increasing disappointment in men.

It is a sad story, but a beautifully crafted one. It was definitely not a disappointment.
Most of my favorite female writers are British: Jane Austen, Penelope Lively, Elizabeth Taylor, Beatrix Potter, Rachel Joyce, J.K. Rowling. . . they've all made my life so much richer. (Agatha Christie is up-to-bat soon, as well, at the tail end of my 1930s project).



As a parent who is currently dealing with a "no contact" estrangement from my oldest, I thought that would be the part of the novel that would have the most of my focus. Surprisingly, it was not. To be honest, I had zero compassion for Eleanor, and I basically wanted her to fall off of a moving train. What a waste of oxygen! It was dear Ruth who had all of my attention, and rightly so. As my friend's grandmother used to say, "No good deed goes unpunished." For shit sure.




It is a heartbreaking story, and I both gasped and sobbed in parts, but, overall, it is so well-written, it kept me turning the pages. To be honest, I can't even say it's "uplifting" or it has a satisfying ending (how are those for selling points??), but I do think it is a robust offering that deserves attention. I suspect I will reread it, and I also think I'm going to have a hard time forgetting it.

I have a friend, in California, at this very moment, who is driving around with her daughter's birth certificate in her f*cking car because there are three immigration checkpoints right near her house and her daughter is originally from Guatemala. The poor child is having freaking panic attacks, fearing she'll be at the mall or something and end up being taken away from her mother and deported. God, there goes my blood pressure. Let me get back to REBECCA and immerse myself in fiction.




(P.S. What's a reasonable amount to mop one's house?)




You're right; it is an emotional book. I have found myself thinking of it, for sure. I think it would pull you right in and keep you there. Very British!
A few of the usual suspects have raved about this one, so it's on the list. I hope you are loving it.