Lono's Reviews > Sin City Volume 1: The Hard Goodbye
Sin City Volume 1: The Hard Goodbye
by
Miller’s “The Hard Goodbye� is a noir masterpiece that would’ve given the great Jim Thompson a legendary hard-on. This was so obviously a labor of love for Frank. He was really at the peak of his career when he put pen to paper with this one. The descriptions and dialogue were hard-edged and to straight to the razor-sharp point, just like good noir should be. And because of it, this book might not be for the easily offended. Frank doesn’t pussy around with what he wants to say and words like “faggot� and “retarded� manage to find their way into the finished product. For me, words don’t offend, so I liked it when Frank cuts loose. I live and work in an environment where insensitivity reigns, the thin-skinned cringe, and these types of tactless remarks tend to bead off. Miller, much like myself, could give a rat’s ass about political correctness.
Frank’s portrayal of women could also be off putting for some. Strippers, hookers, and topless parole officers pretty much sum up the kinds of ladies that populate Basin City. A school boy’s fantasy that I’m ok with. The men of Sin City aren’t any better. They’re violent, corrupt, greedy, and always lead with their dick. Actually, that’s pretty much accurate everywhere. AND I LOVED EVERY GODDAMNED MINUTE OF IT.
Miller’s protagonist, Marv, is so fuckin� great. Tough, simple-minded, loyal to a fault, and as dangerous as they come. What you see is what you get. I like that he’s got a sense of decency. A brutal killer that’ll shoot you in the nuts or carve you up with a hacksaw, but still loves his mom and doesn’t hit dames. Miller’s own description of Marv as Conan in a trench coat pretty much hits the bullseye.
The artwork is magnificent. It’s almost unbelievable what Frank was able to produce with just a pen and some black ink. And it just got better and better as it went. Some of the best black and white comic art ever produced. And Miller did it ALL. Artwork, inking, and lettering. Fuckin� mind-blowing. I especially liked the rain effect. Sick.
So many fantastic moments, I was surprised it took Hollywood so long to put it on film. If you enjoy the book, check the movie out. Mickey Rourke kills as Marv. Frank peaked early with this book because most of what follows in the Sin City series falls a little short of the bench mark set by this one. I don’t think any of it was bad by any means, just that none of the later volumes were able to grab me by the short and curlies and command my full attention like meeting Marv for the first time. Loved him so much I named my dog after him. RECOMMENDED. Unless you’re a pansy. Right Marv?

Get this review and more at:
by


Miller’s “The Hard Goodbye� is a noir masterpiece that would’ve given the great Jim Thompson a legendary hard-on. This was so obviously a labor of love for Frank. He was really at the peak of his career when he put pen to paper with this one. The descriptions and dialogue were hard-edged and to straight to the razor-sharp point, just like good noir should be. And because of it, this book might not be for the easily offended. Frank doesn’t pussy around with what he wants to say and words like “faggot� and “retarded� manage to find their way into the finished product. For me, words don’t offend, so I liked it when Frank cuts loose. I live and work in an environment where insensitivity reigns, the thin-skinned cringe, and these types of tactless remarks tend to bead off. Miller, much like myself, could give a rat’s ass about political correctness.

Frank’s portrayal of women could also be off putting for some. Strippers, hookers, and topless parole officers pretty much sum up the kinds of ladies that populate Basin City. A school boy’s fantasy that I’m ok with. The men of Sin City aren’t any better. They’re violent, corrupt, greedy, and always lead with their dick. Actually, that’s pretty much accurate everywhere. AND I LOVED EVERY GODDAMNED MINUTE OF IT.

Miller’s protagonist, Marv, is so fuckin� great. Tough, simple-minded, loyal to a fault, and as dangerous as they come. What you see is what you get. I like that he’s got a sense of decency. A brutal killer that’ll shoot you in the nuts or carve you up with a hacksaw, but still loves his mom and doesn’t hit dames. Miller’s own description of Marv as Conan in a trench coat pretty much hits the bullseye.

The artwork is magnificent. It’s almost unbelievable what Frank was able to produce with just a pen and some black ink. And it just got better and better as it went. Some of the best black and white comic art ever produced. And Miller did it ALL. Artwork, inking, and lettering. Fuckin� mind-blowing. I especially liked the rain effect. Sick.

So many fantastic moments, I was surprised it took Hollywood so long to put it on film. If you enjoy the book, check the movie out. Mickey Rourke kills as Marv. Frank peaked early with this book because most of what follows in the Sin City series falls a little short of the bench mark set by this one. I don’t think any of it was bad by any means, just that none of the later volumes were able to grab me by the short and curlies and command my full attention like meeting Marv for the first time. Loved him so much I named my dog after him. RECOMMENDED. Unless you’re a pansy. Right Marv?

Get this review and more at:
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Sin City Volume 1.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-50 of 51 (51 new)
message 1:
by
Shelby *trains flying monkeys*
(new)
Aug 16, 2015 03:48PM

reply
|
flag

Ladies love that stubborn little bastard.

Love your dog...;)

Love your dog...;)"
Thank you Sensei, I hope you love it.

*mic drop*

Preach Sista, couldn't agree more. Love all the ladies of Old Town. And thanks, I'm sure Marv would love you too. He's a good judge of character. ;)

I'm offended by your offense at my lack of being offended by all the offensiveness... And the Dutch.


Thanks so much Cyndi. Feel free to join in any time. These folks are super cool and most of us are off probation.

If only I had a tool to get this frigging ankle bracelet off then we'd be all set.

*nods and preens*"


But the rest is still worth reading, especially if you already got used the violent streak, the swearing and the nudity that define the series.
thanks for a great review.

*nods and preens*"
I love you, because you embrace your trashy side. Not like these classy bitches...

But the rest is still worth reading, especially if you already ..."
And thank you kind sir. Your compliment is very much appreciated.

topless parole officers
Even thinking about this gives me a woody..."
MMMMMHHHHNNNN. I blurred out the nipples on the right so not to offend Gavin.


It's hard going through life with a perpetual boner..."
Heh, It's hard.

topless parole officers
Even thinking about this gives me a woody..."
MMMMMHHHHNNNN. I blurred out the nipples on the right so not to offend Gavin.
"
Because Gavin is so easily offended...

Mrs. Jeff is always ready...
...for trouble. "
Well, she since she's married to you, I assume she knows how to use a tazer.

Daddy likey.