Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Glenn Sumi's Reviews > Maurice

Maurice by E.M. Forster
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
28854579
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: classics, 1900-1960



E.M. Forster ( Howards End , A Room With A View ) finished this gay-themed novel in 1914, and though he showed it to some close friends, he didn't publish it in his lifetime. It eventually came out after his death, in the early 1970s.

What a gift to have a novel about same sex love written a century ago by one of the premier 20th century British authors!

When Forster penned Maurice, homosexuality was so taboo that there was no name for it. For a man to be with another man was a criminal offense. One of the most touching things about this very moving book is seeing the protagonist � the closeted, very ordinary stockbroker Maurice � struggling to describe who he is and what he's feeling. He eventually comes up with something about Oscar Wilde. So very sad.

But how triumphant for Forster to have written this book and dedicated it "to a happier year." No one would argue that this is Forster's best novel. But it's an invaluable document about a group of men who experience the love that dare not speak its name (to borrow from Wilde).

I appreciate the fact that Maurice, unlike Forster himself, is a very unremarkable man: he's conservative, a bit of a snob, not very interested in music or philosophy and rather dull. But he's living with this extraordinary secret that affects his entire life. And the book shows how he deals with it, in his secretive relationship with his Cambridge friend Clive Durham, and later with gamekeeper Alec Scudder.

It would have been so easy for Forster to write a novel about a sensitive, soulful, brilliant, sympathetic character. How could we not love him, even though he's gay? But that seems to be part of his point. Maurice is a middle-class Everyman � certainly he's not as intelligent as Clive � but isn't he as worthy of love as anyone else?

Some details in the book are dated. The language at times feels stilted. The class system isn't as pronounced today as it was then. And of course there's a whole new attitude towards homosexuality and thousands of books to reflect that.

But there are still people and organizations trying to "cure" others of homosexuality (think of the group Exodus); young people are still committing suicide because of their sexuality; gays and lesbians are still choosing to live a closeted life by marrying members of the opposite sex; and let's not forget that in some parts of the world, being gay is cause for death.

So really: how dated is this book?

Considering that authors decades after Forster wrote veiled gay characters in straight drag, or killed off one or more characters (see: Brokeback Mountain), how revolutionary is it to have a gay love story with a happy ending?

It's absolutely revolutionary.

Now: who's going to write the sequel?
496 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Maurice.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 27, 2014 – Started Reading
March 27, 2014 – Shelved
March 27, 2014 –
page 81
36.49%
April 1, 2014 – Finished Reading
January 29, 2015 – Shelved as: classics
January 29, 2015 – Shelved as: 1900-1960

Comments Showing 1-47 of 47 (47 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee I read this book at age fifteen and remember thinking it was fantabulous!!!! Thanks for the review and the reminder that I may have to re-read at some point.


message 2: by Jo (new)

Jo Lisa This review is beautiful! It makes me want to read this book.. Thank you for sharing!


message 3: by Suzy (new)

Suzy What a moving review, Glenn! I will put this on my tbr.


Helle Thanks for this review! For some reason, it's the one book by Forster I've never gotten round to although I've read most of his other books several times, and they've been dear to me since my early university days. I've always been put off by critics and reviewers who claimed this novel was inferior to his other works, but I now feel a renewed curiosity to see for myself.


Glenn Sumi Jaidee wrote: "I read this book at age fifteen and remember thinking it was fantabulous!!!! Thanks for the review and the reminder that I may have to re-read at some point."

Hi Jaidee: Yeah I first read it back in university and thought it was just okay. Recently reread it for a book club and found it very moving, like a discovered artifact.


Glenn Sumi Jo wrote: "This review is beautiful! It makes me want to read this book.. Thank you for sharing!"

My pleasure! Hope you enjoy.


Glenn Sumi Suzy wrote: "What a moving review, Glenn! I will put this on my tbr."

Hi Suzy: It's definitely worth reading. As I point out, it's not his best work by any means, and the female characters aren't very well developed, but it's fascinating. I think most editions include a "Terminal note" Forster wrote in 1960, which you must also read.


Glenn Sumi Helle wrote: "Thanks for this review! For some reason, it's the one book by Forster I've never gotten round to although I've read most of his other books several times, and they've been dear to me since my early..."

Hi Helle: You're welcome! It's not his best work. I wonder if he'd had an editor to work with if it would have become a better novel. But I find it incredibly moving that he wrote it in secret, perhaps knowing there'd be a day when society would be different. What a gift to us now.

That's great that you've read all his other books. I still haven't read Where Angels and The Longest Journey. And I'm very curious about Damon Galgut's recent Arctic Summer, which uses EMF as a character.


message 9: by Karen (new) - added it

Karen Beautiful review. I have most of his books but haven't read them yet. I did enjoy the movie and the books are almost alwAys better.


Rowena Great review! I adored this book. The movie was pretty good too.


Glenn Sumi Karen wrote: "Beautiful review. I have most of his books but haven't read them yet. I did enjoy the movie and the books are almost alwAys better."

Thanks Karen. Forster is a lovely writer. And agree that books are almost always better than the movie. Sometimes I don't even want to see an adaptation because I've enjoyed reading a book so much and don't need to "see" it realized onscreen.


Glenn Sumi Rowena wrote: "Great review! I adored this book. The movie was pretty good too."

I agree, Rowena. How liberating it must have been for Forster to write exactly what he wanted about the subject, knowing/hoping that readers decades later would discover it and that it would speak to them.


Glenn Sumi Thanks Mike! Loved your review, spread-eagled Hugh Grant and all! And it provoked a great discussion. Speaking of which.... a Maurice sequel, by an openly gay writer, could be brilliant.


message 14: by Cecily (last edited Dec 16, 2015 04:52AM) (new)

Cecily Excellent review. Regarding how things have changed, in the UK, homosexual acts were still illegal until a year or two after I was born (and I'm not especially old) - yet we now have marriage equality. What a long way we've come. Still some way to go, though.


Glenn Sumi Cecily wrote: "Excellent review. Regarding how things have changed, in the UK, homosexual acts were still illegal until a year or to after I was born (and I'm not especially old) - yet we now have marriage equali..."

Incredible. Long way, indeed.


Vvincentv I'm going to read this novel for my thesis!!! It's a good read.


Glenn Sumi Vvincentv wrote: "I'm going to read this novel for my thesis!!! It's a good read."

Vvincentv: Great! What's your thesis on?


message 18: by Greg (new) - rated it 4 stars

Greg Glen, about a sequel. I simply like the "they lived happily ever after but not so much for Clive" ending we have here. You're right, this was and still is a revolutionary novel. And you're right, Forster's "Room with a View" and "Passage to India" are both better, and perhaps "Howard's End" is also.


Glenn Sumi Greg wrote: "Glen, about a sequel. I simply like the "they lived happily ever after but not so much for Clive" ending we have here. You're right, this was and still is a revolutionary novel. And you're right, F..."

Thanks, Greg. I agree: re happily ever after, but I just think it'd be fascinating to see what "became" of the other two characters, especially for the societal changes. It's so trendy to revisit classic books. I'd definitely read a sequel. Perhaps some other Forster characters could make it in, too! ;)


message 20: by Cecily (new)

Cecily Write your own fan-fic?


Glenn Sumi Ooo � I might just!


message 22: by [deleted user] (new)

I'd volunteer my services for a sequel. c: <3


Glenn Sumi Lydia: Do it! I love the question you ask in your review about other books that might have been... even a book like Highsmith's Carol/Price Of Salt was pretty radical when it was published.


message 24: by [deleted user] (new)

Glenn wrote: "Lydia: Do it! I love the question you ask in your review about other books that might have been... even a book like Highsmith's Carol/Price Of Salt was pretty radical when it was published."

Aw, thank you. And yes, I wonder how many lost manuscripts there are of books like these. Maybe we'll find more soon. <3


message 25: by Greg (new) - rated it 4 stars

Greg Glenn, after reading this book, it seems to me that time has been very good to this book, where as, for example, Vidal's 1940's "The City and the Pillar" is extremely outdated.


Glenn Sumi Greg: Thanks! I've been meaning to read The City And The Pillar. Sad to hear it hasn't aged well. But Vidal is such a good writer.


message 27: by Greg (new) - rated it 4 stars

Greg Glenn, Vidal's "City" is a good story. And though I've only read two books by Vidal, he is a gutsy writer! But there are certain words he uses that are still in use, and have been dated for many, many years. And Vidal's personal attack on Capote within "City" is absolutely obvious and totally unnecessary.


7jane Also loved the ending, and masterful use of language, so 'delicious'. The movie was also lovely, though when I read the book I thought of Maurice as a brunette, not blond haha 8)


Glenn Sumi Thanks, 7jane: I agree! I always thought of Maurice as dark-haired, too. I’m due for a rewatch of the film.


message 30: by Paula (new)

Paula Hagar To answer your final question in this great review Glenn: YOU are the one who should write the sequel! I'd buy it in a heartbeat!


Glenn Sumi Paula wrote: "To answer your final question in this great review Glenn: YOU are the one who should write the sequel! I'd buy it in a heartbeat!"

Paula: Awww, thank you. You are too sweet. Maybe one of these days I'll go back to trying to write fiction. ;)


Rhianna What a lovely and precise review


Glenn Sumi Thanks, Rhianna! And thanks for the friend request. Look forward to sharing more thoughts about some great books.


Manny Arocho A beautiful book. It touched me very deeply. One of the best books I have ever read.


Glenn Sumi Manny wrote: "A beautiful book. It touched me very deeply. One of the best books I have ever read."

Thanks, Manny. What a gift to have this book literally from another era. Imagine the courage it must have taken to write it in that time.


message 36: by Misty (new)

Misty What an incredible review!


Rhianna Glenn wrote: "Thanks, Rhianna! And thanks for the friend request. Look forward to sharing more thoughts about some great books."

Me too :)


Glenn Sumi Misty wrote: "What an incredible review!"

Thanks, Misty!


message 39: by Kevin (last edited Jan 27, 2019 01:24AM) (new)

Kevin Ansbro Fantastic, heartfelt review, Glenn. E. M. Forster was a forward-thinking author - you only have to read The Machine Stops to see that /book/show/4...
- so his dedication to "a happier year" delighted me. Almost a time capsule of a book, waiting to be dug up in a future where discrimination no longer exists.
Humankind clearly has a long way to go, but Forster's forty-year relationship with Bob Buckingham would have been blissfully less complicated had they the ability to time-travel to modern-day England.
I wasn't previously aware of this book, Glenn, and my respect for this genius is even greater as a result. Thank you.


Glenn Sumi Kevin: Thanks for the lovely comment! I’m glad you now know about the book, which indeed is like something from a time capsule. And thanks so much for the info about The Machine Stops. I’ve been hoping to read Forster’s (ahead of their time) stories, too.


Lesley What a great review, thank you. I’ve just finished the book and you’ve summed up my feelings about it perfectly.


Glenn Sumi Lesley wrote: "What a great review, thank you. I’ve just finished the book and you’ve summed up my feelings about it perfectly."

Lesley: What a nice comment! Thanks so much. I thought again about the book when I saw the play The Inheritance on Broadway last winter. Forster is a character, and he interacts with a group of contemporary gay men in New York.


Glenn Sumi Gregory wrote: "So I would really like to teach this book to my public school 10th grade students, but we are a pretty conservative district, and before I dive into the book, I wanted to ask everyone if there were..."

Hi Gregory. It's been several years since I last read this, but I'm pretty sure there are no "graphic" scenes. At most, "he fell into his arms" or some such language. But you might want to read it over before just to be safe. Good luck & thanks for the follow.


Nathaniel William di Canzio apparently
It's called Alec and it came out last year.

Just finished Maurice and my dying to read it now myself.


Glenn Sumi Nathaniel wrote: "William di Canzio apparently
It's called Alec and it came out last year.

Just finished Maurice and my dying to read it now myself."


Nathaniel: Thanks! Definitely going to check it out.


message 46: by April (new) - added it

April Great review!


message 47: by Aru (new) - added it

Aru Please tell me I did not just get spoiled for Brokeback Mountain of all things


back to top