Dolors's Reviews > Plainsong
Plainsong (Plainsong, #1)
by
by

The stories displayed in this novel are simple and unadorned, both by the mundane events going on in the lives of these ordinary characters, and by the sober style of Haruf’s prose, which brings them to life. But when you sing these plain tunes together, a canon of imitations of melody, recurrent patterns and apparently disparate circumstances, compose a more colorful, richer symphony that is anything but simple.
In the small community of Holt, Colorado, Tom Gurthie, a high school history teacher, is trying to endure his wife’s long-term depression while dealing with concerning issues in the classroom that might bring an untimely end to his career. His two young boys Ike and Bobby face a motherless future that forces them to enter the world of adulthood prematurely.
Victoria is a teenager who is thrown out when her mother finds out that she is pregnant. The McPheron brothers, two elderly and lonely farmers, will offer her shelter and, quite unexpectedly, a solitary farmstead might become a warm, sweet home.
The pace of the storyline moves forward without giving way into easy dramatizing, alternating realistic situations that invite the reader to pause and reflect on the plausible obstacles the characters confront on a daily basis and a vital cadence that pulsates underneath the toned-down narration.
The scenarios the novel features might seem unrelated on the surface, but they are essentially the same when one takes a closer look, as there is nothing trivial in the tragedy that the complex business of living entails. Sorrow has a counterpart, the other side of the coin, like everything else, and even if it is not visible to the eyes; like the sun, the stars or the motes of dust that are suspended in the air, it doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist. Contentment is within our hands� reach, if only we make an effort to feel it.
This is the beauty of Haruf’s novels; this is the genius of his art, of his vision of the world. He gives enough perspective and soul to his characters to find beauty in the bigger picture, even if there are some raw, dark, cruel dots that disturb the harmony of the physical and psychological landscape that they inhabit.
Generosity, delicate and charming, abounds in parenthesis amidst the commonplace suffering described in the pages of this novel; an unorthodox family might be possible in the imaginary plains of Holt that might reach mythical grandeur and will preserve the essential values of life. Well-rounded happiness is possible because there is a matching piece somewhere for every lost soul. Just keep your eyes open.
In the small community of Holt, Colorado, Tom Gurthie, a high school history teacher, is trying to endure his wife’s long-term depression while dealing with concerning issues in the classroom that might bring an untimely end to his career. His two young boys Ike and Bobby face a motherless future that forces them to enter the world of adulthood prematurely.
Victoria is a teenager who is thrown out when her mother finds out that she is pregnant. The McPheron brothers, two elderly and lonely farmers, will offer her shelter and, quite unexpectedly, a solitary farmstead might become a warm, sweet home.
The pace of the storyline moves forward without giving way into easy dramatizing, alternating realistic situations that invite the reader to pause and reflect on the plausible obstacles the characters confront on a daily basis and a vital cadence that pulsates underneath the toned-down narration.
The scenarios the novel features might seem unrelated on the surface, but they are essentially the same when one takes a closer look, as there is nothing trivial in the tragedy that the complex business of living entails. Sorrow has a counterpart, the other side of the coin, like everything else, and even if it is not visible to the eyes; like the sun, the stars or the motes of dust that are suspended in the air, it doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist. Contentment is within our hands� reach, if only we make an effort to feel it.
This is the beauty of Haruf’s novels; this is the genius of his art, of his vision of the world. He gives enough perspective and soul to his characters to find beauty in the bigger picture, even if there are some raw, dark, cruel dots that disturb the harmony of the physical and psychological landscape that they inhabit.
Generosity, delicate and charming, abounds in parenthesis amidst the commonplace suffering described in the pages of this novel; an unorthodox family might be possible in the imaginary plains of Holt that might reach mythical grandeur and will preserve the essential values of life. Well-rounded happiness is possible because there is a matching piece somewhere for every lost soul. Just keep your eyes open.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Plainsong.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 27, 2014
– Shelved
October 1, 2017
–
Started Reading
October 1, 2017
–
13.95%
""But the air was turning sharp, with a fall feeling of loneliness coming. Something unaccountable pending in the air.""
page
42
October 3, 2017
–
36.88%
""Well, look at you. You're going to die some day without ever having had enough trouble in your life. Not of the right kind anyway. This is your chance.""
page
111
October 5, 2017
–
77.41%
""In bed she felt unbelievably warm and smooth and she was the most generous woman he'd ever known. He could feel her like satin all along his body.""
page
233
October 5, 2017
–
Finished Reading
October 6, 2017
–
100.0%
""They ate a lunch there in the freckled shade of the trees and came back in the late afternoon with the sun sliding down behind them, making a single shadow of them and the horse together, the shadow out in front like a thin dark antic precursor of what they were about to become.""
page
301
Comments Showing 1-50 of 57 (57 new)
message 1:
by
Katie
(new)
-
added it
Nov 29, 2017 11:16AM

reply
|
flag






Great line, Dolors!

Great to hear so, Katie. I read the three volumes in this trilogy in no time and loved them all. Hope they work for you as well!

And your prose exudes elegance and grace, Ilse. Haruf is not overly fond of flourishes, I guess I exceeded myself in the review. His prose is rather stark and very contained, but the feelings underneath are as vibrating as words can get. Thanks for taking the time to read and to encourage me, my friend.

I just read yours, Laysee. So many good points. The sense of reality in Haruf's un-polished stories, where there are no neat ends, but a continuation of uncertainty, just like in real life; the heart-breaking realization of the moment when children become adults without notice.... You brought up key issues in your review, and I am glad my muddled thoughts resonated with you. Thanks for taking the time to read and to comment.

Thanks to you, Cecily! Your reviews inspired me not to delay Haruf any longer. There is not a lot of lyricism or musicality to be found in his simple prose, but somehow, the stories achieve those qualities on their own. Haruf was a generous writer and his big heart is written all over his novels. I want to read more!

Your memory is spot-on, Jo. I read "Benediction" first because I owned it already, and then I bought "Plainsong" and "Eventide". I didn't mind not reading the books in order, although there was a small spoiler in Benediction regarding the fate of Harold McPheron...but it took me a while to discover it. I loved the three books and would find it difficult to choose only one though...

Thanks, dear Markus! This book is gentle, and so are you, so my instinct tells me you and Mr. Haruf would get on quite well! :)

Great line, Dolors!"
Thanks, Fionnuala!


I just read yours, Laysee. So many good points. The sense of reality in Har..."
Thank you, Dolors, for checking out my review. You may wish to read 'Eventide' which picks up the story of the McPheron brothers and the girl they welcomed into their home.


Same here, Raquel! Thanks a lot for taking the time to read and to post your kind comment.

I have loved all of Haruf's novels so far, Lisa. This was no exception. Thanks for your shiny response! :)

Totally agree, Marita. Thanks to you for always taking time to encourage me.

Well Manuel, your comment could very well be a review on its own accord. You capture the essence of Haruf's "soul" and embellish it with references to your own life experiences. How great to become so enriched not only by the authors we read but also by the readers we share our literary trips with. Thanks for this graceful, lovely response.

Thanks profusely for taking time to read and to comment and to encourage this enthused reader, Glenn. It's really good to see you around here.

Well, I haven't read Our Souls yet, but I did love this trilogy. I bought the premises in all of them and swallowed characters, situations and atmosphere as if I would never have enough. I hope this works better for you Debbie, and if not, I will have an awesome time reading your refreshing critique! :)

I just read yours, Laysee. So many good points. The sense of..."
Oh, I already have, Laysee. I will post a review soon! :))

Geez Deyanne, your kind words sent me soaring cloud high, thanks so much for your kindness and encouragement!
Haruf insipired me. It's funny that my language is more contrived than Haruf's, but he inspired me in ways I didn't anticipate.
I am glad you also found his storytelling moving, if not as melodious for its simplicity as I did.

Thanks a bunch for your kind comment, Stephen!


Oh glad I could make you change your mind, Henry... Haruf's prose is very straight-forward, no flourishes and little poetry, but the narrative threads compensate for his stark style. At least, it did for me!

Glad you thought so, Zoeytron!
I just read your review and I totally identify with this sentence:
"Not sure how such spare, simple writing managed to penetrate my stony exterior, but it did."

Glad you thought so, Zoeytron!
I just read your review and I totally identify with this sentence:
"Not sure how such..."
I do thank you, Dolors. It's hard to accept there will be no more from Haruf.


I also want to read that book, Simi! As always, you read my thoughts and expand them with your incisive and so well phrased remarks. Haruf's prose is easy to read but his characters are complex and the realities they live so plausible that it's likely one might end up caring for them way too much... I am sort of hoarding "Our souls at night" for the right moment, knowing there are not more titles by Haruf...
Thanks for paying me another shining visit, my dear!:)

I now that feeling - with several authors. The other thing with Our Souls is that I am not the only one to think it is not quite as good as Plainsong and Eventide. Still wonderful, but not quite as wonderful. Read carefully and at the right time.


I now that feeling - with several authors. The other thing with Ou..."
I think that is as good advice as I can ever get. Thanks, Cecily.

Thanks a bunch to you Flo, for making time out of your crazy schedule to read and to post such a thoughtful comment. You are so right. Sometimes we are so focused on what is lacking in our lives that we miss the bigger picture, that we are blind to realize what we have, but most importantly, what we could easily have if we only opened our eyes to the people that surrounds us.
Haruf's books do exactly that; they make us aware of the potential riches we all have within our reach, and he does it beautifully.


Sorrow has a counterpart, the other side of the coin, like everything else, and even if it is not visible to the eyes; like the sun, the stars or the motes of dust that are suspended in the air, it doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist.

You're never late, Deea....never, the party doesn't really start till you get here!;P
You put it so well. The ordinariness of Haruf's characters is what makes them so real. And their real life problems and the way they become messy, entangled and not neatly solved makes his purpose even more admirable; that of proving there is beauty even when everything seems to be collapsing around us.
Thanks for the gift of your insight and your company, my dear friend!:)