Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Claudia Lomelí's Reviews > Queen of Shadows

Queen of Shadows by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
13061577
's review

liked it
bookshelves: 2015

2.5 stars...

Okay okay okay so... THIS BOOK. I'm so conflicted, I hated half of the things that happened but loved the other half! I was going to let myself give it 5 stars just for the AWESOME ending (overall the whole second part of the book was AMAZING), but the first part was unbearable! I believe it took me one week to finish it, while the second part I read it only in one day because OMGITWASSOAMAZING and I couldn't stop. BUT YES, the first part: BORING and ANNOYING. There are so many pages in this book and I don't feel they were necessary, also, I wanted to punch everyone.

Another thing that I hated was what SJM did to my babies: CHAOL AND DORIAN. Especially to Chaol, he was so OoC most of the time! AND YES, I was a Chaolena shipper, (WAS, because that ship SUNK in this book and I'm so mad and sad and torn), but I wouldn't be as mad if SJM hadn't RUINED the character. She also ruined Chaolena's dynamics, she made them almost hate each other! At the end of the book everything is kinda better between them, but it will never be the same. So goodbye to my beautiful ship. Chaol didn't deserve what SJM did to him. And about Dorian... he wasn't in enough pages of this book. He was barely there (OH BUT AT THE END HE WAS SO AWESOME, I LOVE HIM SO MUCH).

I'm not really fond of the whole Rowan/Aelin thing. I MEAN, I love Rowan, I really do! But what I liked about them was their friendship! It's really hard to find something like that in a YA book and I loved it, BUT THEN in this book they are suddenly all in love with each other, it doesn't make any sense! I can accept them together, I know I can, but SJM could have done a better job in making them fall in love with each other slowly, so WE the readers could notice the change! It was so abrupt! And I was so tired of hearing them saying how stunning and perfect the other was. Bleh. And tbh, they mostly wanted to undress each other in every scene they had together.

SO... SHIPS I'M NOT ON BOARD:
- Rowan/Aelin: I think they can convince me, but right now I'm a little icky towards them.
- Chaol/Nesryn: I like Nesryn as a character, but SJM just put her in the book so Chaol could have a new couple, and it felt forced.

MY NEW SHIPS:
- Dorian/Manon: OOPS, am I the only one who ships them!? I mean, they surely can become a thing! The few encounters they had were some of the best parts of the book! And Dorian remembers her and FKDKDKGKGA. I don't wanna say much because SPOILERS, but yes, Dorian and Manon would be a powerful and really interesting couple.
- Dorian/Chaol: YES I SHIP THEM. Can they get married, like, right now?

And yeah... that's basically it. I just want to say that I absolutely LOVED the second part of the book. I couldn't stop reading! Dorian, Manon and Aelin are my heroes! GO, them!
.
.
.
EDIT: Just to add the thing I hate the most about this series! I absolutely HATE that EVERYONE IS SO IN LOVE WITH AELIN. Not just in this book, but in the WHOLE SERIES! Since book one! Sam, Chaol, Dorian, Arobynn, Aedeon, Rowan, even Lysandra... at some point of the series they have marveled at how stunning and beautiful and amazing Celaena/Aelin is, and I can't stand it! I mean, yeah she's awesome, I get it, but it's so unrealistic. Every male she befriends has to fall in love with her :/.
417 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Queen of Shadows.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 25, 2014 – Shelved
June 25, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
August 31, 2015 – Started Reading
September 1, 2015 –
page 80
12.35% "So... Aelin and Chaol are set on breaking my heart."
September 2, 2015 –
page 130
20.06% "I like Manon, I really do, but her storyline IS BORINGGGG. Hope it gets better!"
September 3, 2015 –
page 170
26.23% "Hmmm I hate everyone can Rowan come back pleaseeee?"
September 3, 2015 –
page 200
30.86% "ME ACABAN DE SPOILEAR. WHY. WHYYYYYYYY."
September 6, 2015 –
page 340
52.47% "I don't really like Aelin :(. I MISS CELAENA SARDOTHIEN."
September 7, 2015 –
page 450
69.44% "I must admit the whole Arobynn ordeal was exciting. BUT I'm still having trouble with the characters, I feel like I don't know them anymore."
September 8, 2015 –
page 554
85.49% "MANON. DORIAN. oMG."
September 8, 2015 –
page 600
92.59% "STUPID STUPID BOOK. I CAN'T STOP READING!!! OMG!!!"
September 9, 2015 – Shelved as: 2015
September 9, 2015 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 50 (50 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Denisse What? Como? Ya lo tienes?! D:


Michelle Haha I knowwww. The feels are to many!!


message 3: by Wendy (new) - added it

Wendy Soria OMG!!! Te tengo una super envidia (de libros... si es q eso tiene sentido.. xD ), Clau!!! Queen of Shadows!!!! OMG!!! OMG OMG!!! No hagas un wrap up con este. HAS UNA SÚPER RESEÑA!!!!! *.* OMG!! Por cierto, Clau, no comento mucho tus videos xq mi celular no me lo permite... PERO ERES MI BOOKTUBER FAVORITA!!! Saluditos y besitos desde Perú!!!!
PD: No te recomiendo q visites para nada mi país xq la delincuencia es desbordante


message 4: by Anna (new) - rated it 1 star

Anna Yo echo d menos a los personajes d antes. Estos no sé quiénes son.


message 5: by Eva (new) - rated it 5 stars

Eva Nieves Yo no quiero ni empezarlo, he leido tanto de lo que pasa en este libro que estoy en estado de negacion!! ME niego a destruir esta saga (lo hare eventualmente) :(


Melissa SJM has a habit of making the books boring up until the end just so you could get the next book. It's quite annoying


Claudia Lomelí Melissa (Ever So Mela) wrote: "SJM has a habit of making the books boring up until the end just so you could get the next book. It's quite annoying"

YES! I've noticed that pattern :/...


Ismi I really really miss this Chaol-Celaena-Dorian relationship *Tears*


Dimitri Chorian rules


Dimitri Manon era la curandera ¿cierto? Ya se me olvidó jaja


Claudia Lomelí Juan wrote: "Manon era la curandera ¿cierto? Ya se me olvidó jaja"

Hahaha, Manon es la bruja del Blackbeak coven, la líder de las Thirtheen.


Dimitri Holy crap. ¡Dorian y ella cruzan caminos! Ya decía yo que esa chica no cuadraba en la historia jaja. Ya entiendo.


Dimitri Holy crap. ¡Dorian y ella cruzan caminos! Ya decía yo que esa chica no cuadraba en la historia jaja. Ya entiendo.


Claudia Lomelí Juan wrote: "Holy crap. ¡Dorian y ella cruzan caminos! Ya decía yo que esa chica no cuadraba en la historia jaja. Ya entiendo."

OMG, cruzan caminos BIEN INTENSAMENTE, hahaha. Ya quiero verlos en el siguiente libro :D.


Dimitri Ya me emocioné


Dimitri Aunque la curandera me caía bien jaja


Dimitri Aunque la curandera me caía bien jaja


message 18: by Flor (new) - rated it 5 stars

Flor I agree with you in everything Chaol and Dorian, SJM made Chaol an asshole and what happened to him? Umbearable. But i still loved this book, and i'm a little ashamed but i'm a firm Rowaelin shipper.


Claudia Lomelí Flor wrote: "I agree with you in everything Chaol and Dorian, SJM made Chaol an asshole and what happened to him? Umbearable. But i still loved this book, and i'm a little ashamed but i'm a firm Rowaelin shipper."

I love Rowan, but I'm not convinced about him with Aelin... yet. It felt a little forced and most of the time they only wanted to undress each other.


message 20: by Kimi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kimi Great review :)


message 21: by Benjiprach (new)

Benjiprach ..


Judith No me he leído el tercer libro pero casi lloro, literalmente, al saber que la relación de Chaol y Celaena no continua como antes. Yo amaba a esta pareja y no puede ser verdad. ¿Aún hay esperanza de que acaben juntos o soy demasiado soñadora? De verdad que lloro.


Claudia Lomelí Judith wrote: "No me he leído el tercer libro pero casi lloro, literalmente, al saber que la relación de Chaol y Celaena no continua como antes. Yo amaba a esta pareja y no puede ser verdad. ¿Aún hay esperanza de..."

Creo que ya no hay esperanza. Sarah J. Maas destruyó el ship :(.


message 24: by Dana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dana quien es aelin?


Hannah Mae I am on board with your shipment for Dorian and Manon AND for Aedion with Lysandra! They're adorable! You can tell the relationship WILL develop between those couples


message 26: by Arantxa (new)

Arantxa (TheRoomWhereItHappens) Voy por Heir of Fire y ya me tuve que tomar un descanso porque no me gusta el rumbo que están tomando los libros -.-' no me gusta que los 3 estén separados y a pesar de que yo quería a Dorian con ella :( ahora creo que ella no lo merece u.u mi amor Dorian


Claudia Lomelí Hannah Mae wrote: "I am on board with your shipment for Dorian and Manon AND for Aedion with Lysandra! They're adorable! You can tell the relationship WILL develop between those couples"

I KNOW RIGHT? Hope their relationship develops, because with SJM we never know!


message 28: by Carly (new)

Carly  Patrick Clau, no sabia que eras de Monterrey, deberías hacer convivencia con tus fans.


Katia Pienso igual Clau, destruyó por completo a Chaol y es el personaje que amo, no puedo soportar lo que hizo de él y con él y chaolaena, ha transformado algo bello como fue su relación en nada, NADA, y no es justo de verdad que no, lloré por eso. y sobre Nesryn es exactamente eso, creo que la escribió y de pronto Chaol está perdeidamente enamorado de ella, solo para que Aelin pueda estar con Rowan.
No sé qué pensar o hacer me han roto el corazón aunque mi amor por Chaol es aún más grande, me duele leer/saber cualquier cosa de este fandom por el momento. En estos momentos me desagrada tanto Aelin, creo que Sarah se confundió en convertirla en super badass la hizo cruel con el personaje que amo, y si bien hay conflicto, no me parece justo su trato.
aah en fin, mi corazón está roto. *llora por siempre*


Shannon I WHOLLY AND UNEQUIVOCALLY SHIP ALL OF YOUR DAMN SHIPS. Especially Manon and Dorian. I thought I was the only one.


Stephanie How can any of you ship (view spoiler)


Sarah I feel the EXACT same way about the chaol/Aelin and Rowan/Aelin stuff! I don't mind them together but she didn't have to butcher chaol and his friendship with Aelin in the process! And his new girl... Yeah great he has someone but it was forced. And Rowan.. I do like him and I can even ship them, but Maas should have just come out and said in heir of fire that they were mates or likely mates or whatever and maybe we would have all been more prepared. Cuz it was left where fans of her and chaol still had hope...so I think that's why some of us were..uh...wtffff lol


Sarah Ps I ship Dorian and manon too! Glad I wasn't the only one feelin those vibes! But then again I felt chaol and cel vibes too and look where that went lol


nathalia borghi now I'm almost at the end of the book and I could read your review... and YEEEEES!! DORIAN AND MANON!!! They are my favorite characters of the series, nothing fairest than forming a couple <3


message 35: by N. (new)

N. C. Me too... I hated that SJMA destroyed that beautiful characters*cries*


message 36: by N. (new)

N. C. Me too... I hated that SJMA destroyed that beautiful characters*cries*


Karla V. H. Aún no he leído el libro, y aunque estoy amando la serie me parece genial que hablaras de lo que no te gusta con tanta sinceridad. Honestamente estoy temiendo mucho por donde va el personaje de Chaol (mi favorito hasta ahora :'() y ya, espero también que Sara por fin le deje una pareja a Aelin, primero Dorian, Chaol y Rowan ¿debería haber tenido siempre "algo" más que amistad en todas las ocasiones?
Tengo muchas ganas de leerlo ya. Gracias por tu opinión <3


Janell Ble yo tambien shipeo a Manon y a Dorian y a Lysandra con Aedeon


Nicole *TheRoseAndTheStar* You got it right with the Dorian/Manon ship. Totally love them


message 40: by Ana Maria (new)

Ana Maria Aelin is the biggest Mary Sue ever


message 41: by Natalia (new)

Natalia h This is when I stopped reading this series. The murder of the best dynamic in the first book was enough for me to hate the whole thing.


message 42: by Aorlando (new)

Aorlando good


Lindsay I just finished QoS and I'm glad I am not the only who felt Chaol was completely OOC. -_-' I love him so much and I was so pissed at how he was written.


message 44: by Tiffany Kai (new) - added it

Tiffany Kai I agree so much on all of this. I still dont know how I feel about this book


Viviana Almendra Rehbein Recien leí el libro, aunque si me gusto la primera parte, te apoyo en lo de Rowan&Aelin. Y estoy confunfida porque aunque me encanto Manon y Dorian (o sea, el hombre apenas toma control de su cuerpo y lo primero que hace es ligarla xD), también influencia Dorian y Chaol, es decir, veo que SJM lo profundizaba como hermanos pero mas bien parecian un matrimonio xD


Abigail Cruz Clau no manches vengo de YouTube toda emocionada para leer tu reseña de este libro Y ESTA EN INGLES!!!


Kristin Rowan was a much better friend because he was originally mentioned to be Celeana/Aelin's cousin. This is what is making me have a hard time. Sure they are probably very very distant cousins but I'm already so in love with the Chaol and Aelin


message 48: by Gili (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gili Levy AGREED. I SHIP CHAOLAENA FOREVER. I DON'T EVEN LIKE AELIN THAT MUCH AND I WANTED HER AND ROWAN TO BE FRIENDS NOT LOVERS. RUINED!!!


Brandi Vianello Totally on board with Dorian/Manon ship!!!!


Cam &#x1f495;&#x1f338; I agree, I love Aelin and Rowan’s friendship, more than the romance between them, and totally shipped Chaolena, I’m sooo disappointed by how their relationship evolved in this one 😢


back to top