ŷ

s.penkevich's Reviews > Macbeth

Macbeth by William Shakespeare
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6431467
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: plays

This play always holds a place in my heart and the top spot of most embarassing moments in my life. To be fair it was probably my fault as I’d never heard the superstition about not calling the “Scottish play� by name, and since it was my role I’d been shouting Macbeth Macbeth Macbeth all day. In fifth grade we did a full production of this as our class play and I was honored to be cast as Macbeth (I went to a weird school). I still have many of my monologues memorized. Because memory loves embarrassing moments. And since embarrassing photographic evidence seems necessary, embarrassing photographic evidence is precisely what you shall receive:

Get a load of this asshole

Anyways, after months of rehersal the big day comes and they invite every 4th and 5th grade class to come watch along with all our parents and grandparents who wanted to be proud of me for a moment. When we get to the murder scene, the fake blood bottle exploded all over my hands and costume like I'd just murdered a whole army and not one little king.

So picture very sensitive, 9 year old me in an oversized medieval cloak my mom made with blood just dripping off my hands like a waterfall as you can also see an equal amount of blood draining from my face because I am very much overthinking it.
This play is getting dark and it's all going dark for me because somewhere mid-monolouge I both passed out and threw up allllllll over my fancy cloak (choose-your-own-adventure which came first).

I'm sure other things happened that year but this pretty much occupies my entire headspace for 5th grade. Oh, and this play rules. I’m particularly fond of Kurosawa’s adaptation of it as Throne of Blood, because who amongst us doesn’t have a slight crush of Mifune and him and I have shared a role. Put that on my tombstone.

In a way, one could view this play as the predictable fall-out from men having what is essentially a dick measuring contest and trying to be all most masculine man of the manor. Or castle. Whatever. But challenging ones “manhood� is the fuel to the fire throughout the play. Lady Macbeth just needs to question his masculinity in order to manipulate him, and Macbeth calls the masculinity of his murderers into question to provoke them into offing Banquo. �Dispute it like a man,� Malcolm challenges, to which Macduff replies, �I shall do so. But I must also feel it as a man.� There is a direct line drawn between the cruel violence and this unhinged necessity to �feel it as a man,� and an entire kingdom hangs under the knife–it is also a reminder that being a king is about putting a kingdom first, the pull of proving ones masculinity centers insecurities of the self and tumbles into tyranny.

Its a tale as old as time that still brings about political chaos when the flexing of oneself as a “strongman� throws everyone in a temper to prove they are “man enough� or whatever weird toxic notions they want to project. One might recall politicians in their own day who used the same notion around masculinity in place of a personality. It also shows the threat of ambition for power can have violent consequences if it is not kept in check. As usual, Shakespeare’s legacy lives on from the ways his themes seem to remain relevant hundreds of years later.
402 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Macbeth.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
September 24, 2011 – Shelved
January 27, 2022 – Shelved as: plays

Comments Showing 51-78 of 78 (78 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 51: by Deviant Sam (new)

Deviant Sam Happy birthday! Your story made me laugh (sorry! haha), and the comments are just as priceless. That school sounds so weird, but kinda cool at the same time... poor you haha. But hey, being a book seller is pretty awesome!


Akemi G. “memory loves embarrasing moments� How true!
This play is far too much for 5th graders, really. Hope this consoles you a tiny bit


s.penkevich Nocturnalux wrote: "I laugh when I'm nervous, and the more nervous I get, the worse it gets...
A well meaning but woefully misguided teacher took it upon herself to stop me from dashing away and proceeded to address t..."


Haha oh no nobody wants that!
Oooooh that is amazing haha your poor mom. Okay that tops me for sure haha I can’t even imagine


s.penkevich Suhailah wrote: "You poor thing!! It sounds like it definitely scarred you for life! Ah the things you never forget in life!"

Haha I can laugh about it now but at the time I was like oh no nothing worse Can ever happen haha I still am not great with blood


message 55: by s.penkevich (last edited Jun 20, 2023 05:33PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

s.penkevich Deviant Sam wrote: "Happy birthday! Your story made me laugh (sorry! haha), and the comments are just as priceless. That school sounds so weird, but kinda cool at the same time... poor you haha. But hey, being a book ..."

Haha I’m glad, it is pretty hilarious to look back on. It was a wild program, it drew kids from several districts that were all the top test scores for our schools and put us together for 3 years. I guess I was supposed to be a promising young kid, sorry everyone haha. But yea I ran a bookstore for a few days as a class project, so I guess some things never change (I’m writing this sitting on the steps to the bookstore basement)
And thank you!


s.penkevich Akemi wrote: "“memory loves embarrasing moments� How true!
This play is far too much for 5th graders, really. Hope this consoles you a tiny bit"


Thanks! And right!? Like that play was well over an hour long, how did I ever do that? And then got to grapple with themes of murder, good times! Haha


Nocturnalux Akemi wrote: "“memory loves embarrasing moments� How true!
This play is far too much for 5th graders, really. Hope this consoles you a tiny bit"


It was actually very common for children to play very bloody tragedies in Shakespeare's time. There were whole companies dedicated to this, and they were immensely popular.

You even find snide remarks about them in Shakespeare's plays, Antony and Cleopatra, for example. Not too sure if it alludes to actual companies of children or to child actors in general, it's been a while.

s.penkevich wrote: "Nocturnalux wrote: "I laugh when I'm nervous, and the more nervous I get, the worse it gets...
A well meaning but woefully misguided teacher took it upon herself to stop me from dashing away and pr..."


Yeah...truly awful. I would probably have died on the spot.

My school had a massive inbuilt Catholic church- something people find very odd but was taken for granted- that is even open to the general public on Sunday.
Relatives who attended these functions were always very impressed at what they thought was a show of school spirit, and religious devotion when in reality these were mandatory. Any church activity that takes place during school hours and replaces a class, counts as one, and is mandatory. If you skip, it's counted as having skipped a class and this being a private school, with one single guarded gate (and I often wonder how things would go in case of a fire!), once you were on school premises, there was no leaving until school was over.

Which meant that you either skipped the entire day altogether- which very few people did, since that'd look very bad on the record- or you were stuck at church, pretty much.

This lead to some hilarity as I attended in my full goth gear, pentagram and black nails included, on many an occasion.


Kushagri Happiest Birthday Steven!! 🤗🤗

Wow! Your school thought, of Course, nothing screams “age-appropriate material� like introducing nine year olds to murderous world of Macbeth. As fifth graders are just known for their deep understanding of Shakespearean tragedies. What could go wrong?

But seriously, cool that you laugh about it now but as a child such a traumatic event 😢
Especially one that as an adult plays over as Director’s cut often in memory! 🥲


Cynda is preoccupied with RL Smile-laughing only because I live in an apartment. I wonder what howls of laughter I might let out otherwise. �


Paths and Pages, or just Em :) Happy Birthday, hoping it was one that had less embarrassing moments than the ones you just described with Macbeth in your younger years!
And thank you for mentioning Kurosawa's Throne of Blood. I love Macbeth as well, but have not seen that adaptation. I loved Kurosawa's Ran adaptation to King Lear, so I will have to hunt this one down as well.


s.penkevich Nocturnalux wrote: "Akemi wrote: "“memory loves embarrasing moments� How true!
This play is far too much for 5th graders, really. Hope this consoles you a tiny bit"

It was actually very common for children to play v..."


Hahaha perfect, I bet they loved that! Oh wow though, catholic schools are intense. I’m sort of amazed I wasn’t sent to one and did public school instead as my parents are very Catholic. But they were always very concerned I was gay (which was half correct, im bi) so I also think they figured an all boys school would ensure that haha.


s.penkevich Kushagri wrote: "Happiest Birthday Steven!! 🤗🤗

Wow! Your school thought, of Course, nothing screams “age-appropriate material� like introducing nine year olds to murderous world of Macbeth. As fifth graders are ju..."


Thank you my friend! Hahaha right? Like here, grapple with these thoughts, kiddos. I always think about reading Bridge to Terabithia as a similar odd choice. Like, “imagine your best friend. Now imagine they are dead and it’s sort of your fault. Have a good weekend kids!� Haha

“The directors cut of memory� I LOVE that. Haha yea I can’t hear Macbeth without thinking about it, though I do have to admit its pretty funny. I mean, if I ever trip or do something embarrassing in public I tend to go down already laughing because I Can appreciate how funny it is haha


s.penkevich Cynda wrote: "Smile-laughing only because I live in an apartment. I wonder what howls of laughter I might let out otherwise. �"

Hahaha good, I’m glad I can provide some volume appropriate laughter


s.penkevich Paths of Pages, or just Em :) wrote: "Happy Birthday, hoping it was one that had less embarrassing moments than the ones you just described with Macbeth in your younger years!
And thank you for mentioning Kurosawa's Throne of Blood. I ..."


Thank you! Far less embarrassing yet equally chaotic—our city’s power grid failed and the library fish tank drained through the ceiling onto our checkout computers when the backup generator kicked in hahah but at least I enjoyed that chaos.
Oooo yes, Ran is such a masterpiece! This one isn’t quite as epic but it really fun and the story transfers to being a Samuraii epic pretty well. The scene with the witches is amazing too, hope you enjoy!


Kushagri s.penkevich wrote: "Kushagri wrote: "Happiest Birthday Steven!! 🤗🤗

Wow! Your school thought, of Course, nothing screams “age-appropriate material� like introducing nine year olds to murderous world of Macbeth. As fif..."


Hope you had a fun day :D
“imagine your best friend. Now imagine they are dead and it’s sort of your fault. Have a good weekend kids!� Hahaha

Hehe that’s kind of my favourite phrase because my brain tends to record good moments as pirated teasers and cringe memories as 4DX director’s cut haha
That’s a really fun way to live!! I too do that because my spirit animal is a Malamute so I’m always tripping and tumbling lol so no other option as well!


message 66: by Julio (last edited Jun 22, 2023 08:13AM) (new)

Julio Pino A most happy birthday, S. P.! McBETH is my favorite Shakespeare and Polanski's film adaptation unsurpassed, even by Orson Welles. Topless witches! Strangely, or perhaps a tribute to his genius, Mc was Lincoln's best loved Shakespeare.


s.penkevich Kushagri wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Kushagri wrote: "Happiest Birthday Steven!! 🤗🤗

Wow! Your school thought, of Course, nothing screams “age-appropriate material� like introducing nine year olds to murderous worl..."


Hahaha excellent, a malamute is a great choice! Same though, I’m so lanky and not very coordinated haha that’s why I was always a runner and never a sports player. I’m absolutely awful at sports.
But yea, the late night reels of all the best embarrassing moments rolling out in order haha like cool, Can I recall any moments when I did something awesome? Nope? Okay then haha


s.penkevich Julio wrote: "A most happy birthday, S. P.! MCBETH is my favorite Shakespeare and Polanski's film adaptation unsurpassed, even by Orson Welles. Topless witches! Strangely, or perhaps a tribute to his genius, Mc ..."

Thank you so much! Oh wild I didn’t realize Polanski did a version as well. Now I have to see that, I love anything Macbeth. He WOULD do that with the witches haha. And Woah, didn’t realize that was the Lincoln fav, good choice Abe! Definitely mine as well, but I’m sort of biased. Somewhere a recording of our play exists and I hope to never ever find it.


Ulysse Happy birthday s.!


message 70: by Mere (new)

Mere Rain Nocturnalux wrote: "I laugh when I'm nervous, and the more nervous I get, the worse it gets...
A well meaning but woefully misguided teacher took it upon herself to stop me from dashing away and proceeded to address t..."


No theater tales as I was a Bad Kid and thus discouraged from participating in activities, but I share the nervous laughter. Once a kid with whom I'd been fighting and I were getting chewed out together by the teacher and he started laughing, so I couldn't help laughing as well, then we got detention for disrespecting the teacher.

Anyway, happy birthday! I see your dramatic talents in your bookstore videos.


Lesley R M Perfect review s.penkevich!! I just ordered this book! 💕thanks for your amazing thoughts!!


s.penkevich Lesley wrote: "Perfect review s.penkevich!! I just ordered this book! 💕thanks for your amazing thoughts!!"

Ooo yay I hope you enjoy this one! There’s a really cool Kurosawa adaptation worth watching when you finish too, much better than the one I was in haha though I need to remember to get a photo from that to add to this review


Sasha I think this is the best review I've read in 2023.


Thedeadromantic That was hilarious. The review ......not your 5th grade incident .That was amusing though.


s.penkevich Sasha wrote: "I think this is the best review I've read in 2023."

Thanks!


s.penkevich Thedeadromantic wrote: "That was hilarious. The review ......not your 5th grade incident .That was amusing though. "

Haha thank you!


Sophie I am probably biased, being the Scottish lass that I am, but I think this along with Hamlet are Shakespeare's best work. I will randomly quote the "Is this a dagger that I see before me?" or "Tomorrow and tomorrow and tomorrow" soliloquy, because why not! Excellent review, as always. Also, love the dedication your mum made to the cloak for you, bless her!


s.penkevich Sophie wrote: "I am probably biased, being the Scottish lass that I am, but I think this along with Hamlet are Shakespeare's best work. I will randomly quote the "Is this a dagger that I see before me?" or "Tomor..."

That is a totally fair bias. Its SO good though. YES haha that is amazing. I should start randomly quoting it as well. And thank you so much. My mom somehow got roped into making a lot of the costumes for that show and I thanked her by puking alllllll over it I guess haha


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top