The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
SPRING CHALLENGE 2016
>
Spring Challenge 2016: Questions/Problems in Completed Tasks
Salem post 365
You used Choice Words for task 30.5, option 1. That book does not include the main page genre "Language."
Genres
Education 5 users
Teaching 4 users
Non Fiction 3 users
Academic > School 2 users
Also, any book that only exists in ebook/audiobook format must be verified for length in the Ebook verification thread.
You used Choice Words for task 30.5, option 1. That book does not include the main page genre "Language."
Genres
Education 5 users
Teaching 4 users
Non Fiction 3 users
Academic > School 2 users
Also, any book that only exists in ebook/audiobook format must be verified for length in the Ebook verification thread.
Salem post 367
Task 25.5 specifically states that books with the main page genre Childrens or Kids cannot be used for the task.
Hokey Pokey includes Childrens as a main page genre in several variations:
Fantasy 72 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 49 users
Young Adult 32 users
Fiction 29 users
Childrens 21 users
Young Adult>Coming of Age 19 users
Childrens>Juvenile 19 users
Magic Realism 10 users
Childrens>Chapter Books 6 users
Realistic Fiction 4 users
If you use this book for a different task, you will need to comply with the rules regarding childrens books. Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of childrens books, and the rules for the posting requirements for books with the main page genre childrens or kids. Posting Requirements #7.
Task 25.5 specifically states that books with the main page genre Childrens or Kids cannot be used for the task.
Hokey Pokey includes Childrens as a main page genre in several variations:
Fantasy 72 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 49 users
Young Adult 32 users
Fiction 29 users
Childrens 21 users
Young Adult>Coming of Age 19 users
Childrens>Juvenile 19 users
Magic Realism 10 users
Childrens>Chapter Books 6 users
Realistic Fiction 4 users
If you use this book for a different task, you will need to comply with the rules regarding childrens books. Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of childrens books, and the rules for the posting requirements for books with the main page genre childrens or kids. Posting Requirements #7.

Is there a reason my post 392 was not included in the Readerboard count through 400 on Completed Tasks?
Connie (Ava Catherine) wrote: "Ava Catherine
Is there a reason my post 392 was not included in the Readerboard count through 400 on Completed Tasks?"
Sorry, Connie - found and fixed.
Is there a reason my post 392 was not included in the Readerboard count through 400 on Completed Tasks?"
Sorry, Connie - found and fixed.
Mai post 401
Task 20.2, option c is a cover task, and the cover of your book must be included in your post.
Task 20.2, option c is a cover task, and the cover of your book must be included in your post.
JamminJenny post 405
You posted Terrifying Tales for task 20.5. That book appears to only be in ebook form - if you have already had it approved for length in the Ebook Verification thread, please repost, including the post # or line # from the spreadsheet. If not, you will need to get length verification in that thread.
You posted Terrifying Tales for task 20.5. That book appears to only be in ebook form - if you have already had it approved for length in the Ebook Verification thread, please repost, including the post # or line # from the spreadsheet. If not, you will need to get length verification in that thread.

My post 391 doesn't appear to be included in the Readerboard through 400. Will you please check?
Pat wrote: "Peakles
My post 391 doesn't appear to be included in the Readerboard through 400. Will you please check?"
I'll look at it when I get home from work tonight.
My post 391 doesn't appear to be included in the Readerboard through 400. Will you please check?"
I'll look at it when I get home from work tonight.
Pat wrote: "Peakles
My post 391 doesn't appear to be included in the Readerboard through 400. Will you please check?"
Sorry, Pat - found and fixed.
My post 391 doesn't appear to be included in the Readerboard through 400. Will you please check?"
Sorry, Pat - found and fixed.
Abayomi post 461
"Retellings" does not appear as a main page genre for O Filho das Sombras.
Fantasy - 1779 users
Romance - 238 users
Fiction - 153 users
Historical Fiction - 151 users
Historical - 94 users
Fantasy>Magic 92 users
Young Adult 57 users
Adult 54 users
Science Fiction Fantasy 52 users
Cultural>Ireland 47 users
If you had this genre noted previously, please repost with a link to the approval/verification.
"Retellings" does not appear as a main page genre for O Filho das Sombras.
Fantasy - 1779 users
Romance - 238 users
Fiction - 153 users
Historical Fiction - 151 users
Historical - 94 users
Fantasy>Magic 92 users
Young Adult 57 users
Adult 54 users
Science Fiction Fantasy 52 users
Cultural>Ireland 47 users
If you had this genre noted previously, please repost with a link to the approval/verification.
Queenbee Darlene post 486
20.2 option C requires that you include the cover in your post if you are using the cover color option.
20.2 option C requires that you include the cover in your post if you are using the cover color option.
JamminJenny
You claimed The Witch Tree Symbol. That book includes "Childrens" as a main page genre.
Mystery 238 users
Childrens 55 users
Fiction 55 users
Young Adult 53 users
Classics 16 users
Childrens>Juvenile 14 users
Adventure 12 users
Mystery>Detective 7 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 5 users
Suspense 5 users
Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of childrens books, and the rules for the posting requirements for books with the main page genre childrens or kids. Posting Requirements #7.
You claimed The Witch Tree Symbol. That book includes "Childrens" as a main page genre.
Mystery 238 users
Childrens 55 users
Fiction 55 users
Young Adult 53 users
Classics 16 users
Childrens>Juvenile 14 users
Adventure 12 users
Mystery>Detective 7 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 5 users
Suspense 5 users
Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of childrens books, and the rules for the posting requirements for books with the main page genre childrens or kids. Posting Requirements #7.

Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ Author tickets are no longer awarded. They have been replaced with:
20.4 GOLDEN OLDIES - Players may earn a ticket for each book FIRST published in or before 1950. See the current season's Rewards of the Challenge and Posting Requirements for more information.
Laurajay post 528
I am assuming that you meant this post to be for task 30.6, since that's the task this would fit. If that's correct, no need to repost, as that is how I've logged it on the spreadsheet.
I am assuming that you meant this post to be for task 30.6, since that's the task this would fit. If that's correct, no need to repost, as that is how I've logged it on the spreadsheet.

I am assuming that you meant this post to be for task 30.6, since that's the task this would fit. If that's correct, no need to repost, as that is how I've logged it on the sprea..."
Yes it is for 30.6. Apologies, I wrote the wrong task title.
Didi 3023 post 580
To use the one book option for task 15.4, the book must fit both criteria. An Autobiography does not have the main page genre science fiction or fantasy.
To use the one book option for task 15.4, the book must fit both criteria. An Autobiography does not have the main page genre science fiction or fantasy.
Catherine T post 592
Task 10.9 states that the title may contain only two words, and that all words count. The Thief Taker has three words in the title.
Task 10.9 states that the title may contain only two words, and that all words count. The Thief Taker has three words in the title.

To use the one book option for task 15.4, the book must fit both criteria. An Autobiography does not have the main page genre science fiction or fantasy."
Yikes - I did not see that it needed to be a certain genre. I will find a different book. Thanks.

Task 15.2 is a 2 book task. Please repost with both of the books required."
I will re-post with the second book. I just forgot to add it. Thanks.

To use the one book option for task 15.4, the book must fit both criteria. An Autobiography does not have the main page genre science fiction or fanta..."
I just realized that I had done option 1 for this task and not option 2 so I have re-posted. I have to pay more attention to how I have my spread sheet set up I guess. I made the same mistake for both tasks!
Donna Jo post 597
Task 5.8 requires "Read an autobiography or memoir- a non-fiction account of the author’s own life or experiences." From the description, The House of Twenty Thousand Books, does not appear to be an account of the author's life, but a biography of his grandparents. If this book is actually an account of Sasha Abramsky's life/experiences, please repost and explain how it fits the task.
Task 5.8 requires "Read an autobiography or memoir- a non-fiction account of the author’s own life or experiences." From the description, The House of Twenty Thousand Books, does not appear to be an account of the author's life, but a biography of his grandparents. If this book is actually an account of Sasha Abramsky's life/experiences, please repost and explain how it fits the task.
Masoodah post 602
Mirrorscape includes "Childrens" as a main page genre."
Fantasy 44 users
Young Adult 16 users
Fiction 7 users
Fantasy>Magic 5 users
Childrens 3 users
Adventure 2 users
Mystery 2 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 2 users
Science Fiction Fantasy 2 users
Young Adult>Teen 2 users
Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of Childrens books.
Mirrorscape includes "Childrens" as a main page genre."
Fantasy 44 users
Young Adult 16 users
Fiction 7 users
Fantasy>Magic 5 users
Childrens 3 users
Adventure 2 users
Mystery 2 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 2 users
Science Fiction Fantasy 2 users
Young Adult>Teen 2 users
Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of Childrens books.
Didi3023 post 606
Please check your totals - I show you with a total of 110 - 5.8, 10.4, 10.7, 10.9, 15.1, 15.2, 15.4, 30.4.
No need to repost - just want to keep our totals synched.
Please check your totals - I show you with a total of 110 - 5.8, 10.4, 10.7, 10.9, 15.1, 15.2, 15.4, 30.4.
No need to repost - just want to keep our totals synched.

Task 10.9 states that the title may contain only two words, and that all words count. The Thief Taker has three words in the title."
Argh! read it as "at least two words" soz
Papermaker post 640
Your post referred to task 5.10, but gave the title of task 5.4. You posted a different book for 5.4 on March 13. The book Speakers of the Dead: A Walt Whitman Mystery would not work for 5.4, because the word "Speakers" ends in "ers," and the task specifically states that plural forms do not work.
Since 5.10 is a free choice task, the book will work for that one, and I assume that's what you intended and where I've logged it in. If that is not what you wanted, please repost, removing the book from 5.10 and assigning it to a different task.
Your post referred to task 5.10, but gave the title of task 5.4. You posted a different book for 5.4 on March 13. The book Speakers of the Dead: A Walt Whitman Mystery would not work for 5.4, because the word "Speakers" ends in "ers," and the task specifically states that plural forms do not work.
Since 5.10 is a free choice task, the book will work for that one, and I assume that's what you intended and where I've logged it in. If that is not what you wanted, please repost, removing the book from 5.10 and assigning it to a different task.

Task 5.8 requires "Read an autobiography or memoir- a non-fiction account of the author’s own life or experiences." From the description, [book:The House of Twenty Thousand Books|..."
My goof. I have reposted the book to another task. (That's only the fourth book I've read since March 1 that didn't fit a task--luckily I caught the others before posting. Sorry.
Jayme (the ghostreader) post 647
Task 20.1 requires that the number of words or letters in the title be determined by the number card you drew. A 5 requires either a 5 word title, or a title with a total of 5 letters - Hush Puppy has 2 words and 9 letters, so will not work for a draw of 5.
Task 20.1 requires that the number of words or letters in the title be determined by the number card you drew. A 5 requires either a 5 word title, or a title with a total of 5 letters - Hush Puppy has 2 words and 9 letters, so will not work for a draw of 5.

I just wanted to check on my last post in message 649 if there was a problem. I don't see the points reflected in the readerboard.
Thanks!
Hina wrote: "Hi Sandy,
I just wanted to check on my last post in message 649 if there was a problem. I don't see the points reflected in the readerboard.
Thanks!"
Sorry, Hina, it appears to have slipped by me. Found and fixed - it will show up in the next update.
I just wanted to check on my last post in message 649 if there was a problem. I don't see the points reflected in the readerboard.
Thanks!"
Sorry, Hina, it appears to have slipped by me. Found and fixed - it will show up in the next update.
Abayomi post 674
Task 10.9 states that the title may contain only two words, and that all words count. Dengeki Daisy, Vol. 06 has more than 2 words, since "Vol. 06" is part of the title.
Task 10.9 states that the title may contain only two words, and that all words count. Dengeki Daisy, Vol. 06 has more than 2 words, since "Vol. 06" is part of the title.

So if you have a book with a 5 letter word in the title, should it be the only word in the title like if the book is called "Angel" that would work but not "Angel in the Sky". I just need more clarification because puppy is a five letter word in the title.
Jayme(the ghost reader) wrote: "Sandy wrote: "Jayme (the ghostreader) post 647"
So if you have a book with a 5 letter word in the title, should it be the only word in the title like if the book is called "Angel" that would work ..."
The task states
"if you draw a number card, this determines the number of letters OR words in the title. Aces are 1.
For example, if you draw a 2, you need a book with a two letter title like Us OR a two word title like Jane Eyre."
Not a title containing a 5 letter word, but a title that is either a total of 5 letters or a total of 5 words.
So if you have a book with a 5 letter word in the title, should it be the only word in the title like if the book is called "Angel" that would work ..."
The task states
"if you draw a number card, this determines the number of letters OR words in the title. Aces are 1.
For example, if you draw a 2, you need a book with a two letter title like Us OR a two word title like Jane Eyre."
Not a title containing a 5 letter word, but a title that is either a total of 5 letters or a total of 5 words.

Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ Author tickets are no longer awarded. They have been replaced with:
20.4 GOLDEN OLDIES - Players may earn a ticket for each book FIRST published in or before 1950. See the current season's Rewards of the Challenge and Posting Requirements for more information.

If you are claiming a BB ticket and you read an ebook or an audiobook, you must include a link to the paper edition used to establish length as well as a link to the edition you actually read. Please see the Posting Requirements.
Also, tickets for Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ Authors are no longer awarded. Please see post 42 in this thread.
If you repost to claim a BB ticket, please indicate at the TOP of your post that it is a repost only to claim a BB ticket and that it is not a new task posting.
MelissaH post 729
Best Friends Forever will not work for this task, because it has neither 7 words nor 7 letters in the title.
The task states
"if you draw a number card, this determines the number of letters OR words in the title. Aces are 1.
For example, if you draw a 2, you need a book with a two letter title like Us OR a two word title like Jane Eyre."
Not a title containing a 7 letter word, but a title that is either a total of 7 letters or a total of 7 words.
Best Friends Forever will not work for this task, because it has neither 7 words nor 7 letters in the title.
The task states
"if you draw a number card, this determines the number of letters OR words in the title. Aces are 1.
For example, if you draw a 2, you need a book with a two letter title like Us OR a two word title like Jane Eyre."
Not a title containing a 7 letter word, but a title that is either a total of 7 letters or a total of 7 words.
Chandni post 761
Bone & Bread will not work for 20.5, option 1. There is no ampersand in the target phrase, and an ampersand is not a punctuation mark, so cannot be ignored.
Bone & Bread will not work for 20.5, option 1. There is no ampersand in the target phrase, and an ampersand is not a punctuation mark, so cannot be ignored.
Ava Catherine post 769
Just an FYI - please check your totals. After your previous post, 766, you showed a total of 605 points. You added 55 in this post, for a total of 660.
No need to repost - this is just to keep our totals synched.
Just an FYI - please check your totals. After your previous post, 766, you showed a total of 605 points. You added 55 in this post, for a total of 660.
No need to repost - this is just to keep our totals synched.

Bone & Bread will not work for 20.5, option 1. There is no ampersand in the target phrase, and an ampersand is not a punctuation mark, so cannot be ignored."
Hi Sandy, I was going by the rule in the task description that said "only the letters should be considered.." Since all of the letters are in the phrase, can I try and get this book verified in the help thread?
Chandni wrote: "Sandy wrote: "Chandni post 761
Bone & Bread will not work for 20.5, option 1. There is no ampersand in the target phrase, and an ampersand is not a punctuation mark, so cannot be i..."
It says that punctuation marks can be ignored - and Catherine has reiterated in the help thread that an ampersand is not a punctuation mark. It's a symbol that substitutes for the word "and."
Bone & Bread will not work for 20.5, option 1. There is no ampersand in the target phrase, and an ampersand is not a punctuation mark, so cannot be i..."
It says that punctuation marks can be ignored - and Catherine has reiterated in the help thread that an ampersand is not a punctuation mark. It's a symbol that substitutes for the word "and."

Bone & Bread will not work for 20.5, option 1. There is no ampersand in the target phrase, and an ampersand is not a punctuation mark..."
Ok, thanks Sandy, I'll find somewhere else for it.
Emsreviewsbooks post 774
Task 20.6 option 4 requires that the author share a name with a guest from Series 18. Lily Allen appeared in Series 5 and Series 14, not in series 18.
Task 20.6 option 4 requires that the author share a name with a guest from Series 18. Lily Allen appeared in Series 5 and Series 14, not in series 18.
oma1229 post 780
High Rhulain includes Childrens and Childrens>Middle Grades as main page genres:
Fantasy 321 users
Young Adult 82 users
Fiction 80 users
Adventure 39 users
Animals 38 users
Childrens 36 users
Fantasy>High Fantasy 9 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 8 users
Science Fiction Fantasy 8 users
Animals>Animals Fiction
Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of childrens books.
High Rhulain includes Childrens and Childrens>Middle Grades as main page genres:
Fantasy 321 users
Young Adult 82 users
Fiction 80 users
Adventure 39 users
Animals 38 users
Childrens 36 users
Fantasy>High Fantasy 9 users
Childrens>Middle Grade 8 users
Science Fiction Fantasy 8 users
Animals>Animals Fiction
Please review the Rules of the Challenge for the use of childrens books.
Oma1229 post 782
Task 20.1 requires that you state in your post the genre you selected from the 3 choices for the suit you drew. Please repost with the missing information.
Task 20.1 requires that you state in your post the genre you selected from the 3 choices for the suit you drew. Please repost with the missing information.
JamminJenny post 783
all posts must include links to all books read. Please repost with the missing information.
all posts must include links to all books read. Please repost with the missing information.
Jordan FL post 802
Task 5.8 requires that you "Read an autobiography or memoir- a non-fiction account of the author’s own life or experiences."
From the GR description, Thinking In Numbers: On Life, Love, Meaning, and Math does not appear to be an account of the author's life, but rather a collection of essays on mathematics. If this is an account of his life, please repost explaining how the book fits the task.
Please note that this is not a task involving a main page genre - the book must fit the task description.
Task 5.8 requires that you "Read an autobiography or memoir- a non-fiction account of the author’s own life or experiences."
From the GR description, Thinking In Numbers: On Life, Love, Meaning, and Math does not appear to be an account of the author's life, but rather a collection of essays on mathematics. If this is an account of his life, please repost explaining how the book fits the task.
Please note that this is not a task involving a main page genre - the book must fit the task description.
♥Robin � post 807
Please include the task number/title in your posts. No need to repost this one, I could tell which one it was, but please do this in the future.
Please include the task number/title in your posts. No need to repost this one, I could tell which one it was, but please do this in the future.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Picture of Dorian Gray (other topics)The Picture of Dorian Gray (other topics)
The Picture of Dorian Gray (other topics)
Schooled (other topics)
The Ersatz Elevator (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kelley Armstrong (other topics)Kelley Armstrong (other topics)
Kelley Armstrong (other topics)
Ken Binmore (other topics)
Martin J. Osborne (other topics)
You claimed Snowball in Hell for task 15.3. It appears that the book only exists in ebook/audiobook format, so your post must include length verification from the Ebook verification thread.