Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Rose Rosetree’s Reviews > The Giver > Status Update

Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 27% done
As I ponder this dystopia, I'm especially struck by the lack of opportunity to make the use of free will, the relegation of personal choices to only the most trivial matters, never meaningful decisions.

I found it appalling that the Twelves would have their one kind of work, for the rest of their lives, be chosen by committee.
Aug 28, 2023 11:44AM
The Giver

3 likes ·  flag

Rose’s Previous Updates

Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 79% done
Today I had a phone visit with my son. He's a Millennial. I asked if he ever read "The Giver."

He did. He considered it to be an exceptionally thought provoking book.

Now here's the shocker: "The Giver" was required reading for him in elementary school. Fascinating how he could understand the significance when still so young.

Seems to me, in one's seventies one can find even more.
Aug 31, 2023 05:07PM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 77% done
The Giver has a plan?

Please, please, please.
After Jonas learned what he did about his father and his community and his favorite girl? All so powerfully written; to me, feeling absolutely true.
Aug 30, 2023 05:43PM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 62% done
Another important distinction, arising from Jonas's education: The shallowness of emotional life, despite all the constant discussions of emotions.

Very big resonance with what I've blogged about concerning "Why Human Talk Matters" -- if any of you search on that, you'll find what I've written. Just be sure to include the quotation marks around the search term.
Aug 29, 2023 06:01PM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 52% done
This time I'm the one who's shocked: When Jonas learns about the color red.

Why am I shocked. Because I learn that color is one of the attributes of dystopian life that has been removed.
Aug 28, 2023 05:46PM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 45% done
Jonas is shocked, shocked, when the Receiver turns off the montoring device in his room. It has an OFF switch.

Jonas has never known life, anywhere, without constant surveillance.
Aug 28, 2023 05:24PM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 27% done
This free will question reminds me of a blogpost I published just today. Currently you'll find it here on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ.

Or else you can find this article on Medium, or at my personal blog, by googling on this:

"Your Soul-Based Desires Are So Much More� than Your Story" -- Include the quotes in your search.
Aug 28, 2023 11:53AM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 27% done
In real life, the freedom to make personal choices can sometimes feel burdensome, even overwhelming. Yet when each of us makes a significant choice, we may grow a lot -- both in terms of personal development and also in terms of our spiritual evolution.
Aug 28, 2023 11:52AM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 26% done
When Jonas, age 12, reports for his first day at his new assignment, he discovers that the Receiver's door is locked.

Never before in his life had he encountered a locked door in his community.

-- Geesh, talk about no privacy in this dystopia!
Aug 27, 2023 12:22PM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is 26% done
As a person, as a parent, the horror registers within me over what this dystopian society makes common practice:

No privacy. Absolutely no privacy. Not even privacy about one's dreams at night.

Witness what is done about sexual "stirrings." The need to confess them, the need to receive medication to take those stirrings away.


Somehow Lowry makes this seem okay-ish. It's absolutely not.
Aug 26, 2023 03:36PM
The Giver


Rose Rosetree
Rose Rosetree is on page 12
An apple, not a ball. I meant to write in my updates today that the hero, Jonas, was playing with an apple.

If there's a way to edit these updates without deleting them completely, I'd appreciate comments from you peeps about how to do that.

Yes, Jonas was throwing an apple, not a ball.
Aug 25, 2023 11:56AM
The Giver


No comments have been added yet.