ŷ

Patrick's Reviews > A Spot of Bother

A Spot of Bother by Mark Haddon
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
692475
's review

did not like it

I pretty much hated this book. It was the type of book that you read because you liked the author's other work, but it's so aggressively bad that it makes you reconsider whether or not you actually liked the author's previous work upon closer consideration.

So what was so bad about it? Well, for the one the characters simply didn't ring true. They all felt poorly sketched out, just a bunch of people having what Haddon would have you believe are constant epiphanies about their sad little lives. He writes in such a way that you can tell he wants the reader to think it's a stunning revelation that this character is having, when it's just another dull moment in a rather dull story. If I had a dollar for every time Haddon made a one sentence paragraph meant to reveal some larger truth about the character's personalities, I'd be a rich man. He also has a nasty habit of ending each "chapter" (there are well over 100 of them, most 2 pages or less) with some half-assed "cliff-hanger", something better suited to the James Pattersons and R.L. Stines of the world.

Haddon doesn't seem to understand his characters, and he doesn't seem to care to, either. He simply throws a jumble of people into awkward situations and has them (over)react like a bunch of unlikeable, selfish jerks and then comment to themselves that, perhaps, they are acting like unlikeable, selfish jerks who are overreacting to what are, in reality, fairly mundane situations. They're sad, selfish little people, yet Haddon seems to think they are endearing.

Finally, he ends the book fairly abruptly and with a neat little bow on top that doesn't suit it. Everything works out for everyone involved, yet no one seemed to learn anything or grow as people. They all ended exactly where they began with no growth whatsoever. I've heard people who are familiar with autism claim that Haddon's sketch of the child in 'A Curious Incident of the Dog in the NightTime' was actually woefully inaccurate and quite offensive, and seeing the way he handles his characters' problems in this story, I'm much more inclined to believe that. Just an awful, awful book. Haddon seems to think he's writing a British version of 'The Corrections', but he's painfully mistaken. I'll probably not read anything by Haddon again.
128 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Spot of Bother.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
December 1, 2007 – Finished Reading
December 17, 2007 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by John (last edited May 25, 2008 09:41AM) (new) - rated it 1 star

John Sullivan I hear ya Patrick. I felt the exact same way. I couldn't even finish it, so you're a better man than me for at least doing that.


Caitriona I'd like to cut and paste your review to use it as my own. This book was so awful especially after the lovely 'Curious Inciedent...'.


Shelly Smith I LOVED Curious Incident... which is why I read this one... but I agree... it was painful to get through... it took me a LONG time to finally finish this book.


Jolien Spot on.


message 5: by MJ (last edited Aug 23, 2011 06:46AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

MJ Nicholls This wasn't exactly rich in deep character insight, I agree, but I'd be wary of slamming a book because you didn't like the characters. It's a wee bit


Patrick Perhaps, MJ, but I think it was much more than unlikeable characters that caused me to slam this book. I literally found nothing redeeming in the text, be it the characters, the plotting, the writing, or even the about the author blurb. It sucked, plain and simple.


message 7: by MJ (new) - rated it 4 stars

MJ Nicholls Patrick wrote: "Perhaps, MJ, but I think it was much more than unlikeable characters that caused me to slam this book. I literally found nothing redeeming in the text, be it the characters, the plotting, the writi..."

Well, that's pretty conclusive. Your edition has a nicer cover at least.


Diane Absolutely and utterly agree with your review. Boring and I did finish it.


Michael I appreciate all your comments, but I still will start reading that book and try to have my own opinion. I promise to come back to you telling, you were wrong or right, though this is always a very personal decision.


Daniel I very much agree. Haddon also had an annoying habit of trying to "enrich" his characters by going off on irrelevant tangents of past experiences the characters had that don't in any way add to the story and only cause confusion. I also purchased "The Red House" and am reluctant to even start it.


message 11: by Elena (new) - added it

Elena I bought Spot & Red House cos I love Curious Incident. Time & again, it pays to read reviews here. Can't bring myself to finish both.


Karishma Absolutely spot on.


Sarah Bee I read this book a few years ago and really enjoyed it. Sometimes the slower, less exciting novels can actually be the most meaningful if you have the patience to get through it.


message 14: by Michael (new)

Michael Curtis I only read a few pages before I quit and came to look at the reviews here. Yours was the first that came up and matches how I already feel about it. It felt like a terrible 90s sitcom with all the stereotype characters you'd expect. Do they become enlightened and better people by the end? I don't care


message 15: by Blair (new) - added it

Blair I quit it halfway thru. Rubbish.


message 16: by Toni (new) - rated it 5 stars

Toni Reese Sorry you felt his way. Don't give up on Haddon. Maybe you could try another of his and if you don't like it, stop before you waste too much time on it. Life is too short to read anything you don't like.


message 17: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Heeter I’m 70 pages into this book and not liking it all that much. I borrowed it from the library because I love Mark Haddon’s collection of short stories “The Pier Falls.� Not sure I’m going to last the distance.


Winnie I'm reading for book club and struggling. I was having trouble putting into words why I was hating this book and you nailed it. Well said. I agree with you. I will finish it only because it's a book club book.


Ralph Tattersall I completely agree. I read this because of Curious, and then I began to second-guess myself, in that, "Is this really by the same author?" kind of way


back to top