ŷ

Emily May's Reviews > A Court of Mist and Fury

A Court of Mist and Fury by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4622890
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: pnr, new-adult, fairy-tales, 2016

I was not a pet, not a doll, not an animal.
I was a survivor, and I was strong.

Oh damn. That was so unexpectedly good. And to think I almost didn't take a chance on this after not loving the first book...

So, here it is: I present to you 7 reasons why this book is a million times better than A Court of Thorns and Roses.

1) Less romance.

Oh, don't worry, there's romance. There's lusty, slow-build, flirtatious romance that somehow manages to be completely absent from the first book, even though romance was more central to the plot. But there's also so many other things here. It's a fantasy with romantic elements, not the other way around.

I always say I tend to become more invested in love stories when they're subplots and the book itself is not actually about the love story. I like it when the characters come together around and between all the rest of the action and drama. That's what's happening here. Because there is a whole shitstorm of other things going on - which, by the way, has led to better world-building, more exciting action and reveals, and a fascinating overarching story.

2) Feyre's growth and development.

And, in fact, the growth and development of many characters. Maas spends some quality time on character histories and backstory to strengthen our understanding of them. I absolutely love it when characters show realistic growth over time and I think that's especially important with Feyre here.

Feyre is not the character she was during A Court of Thorns and Roses. How could she be after the events of that book? Naturally, she has changed and found that her needs and aspirations have changed too. Once upon a time, back when she was weak and starving, she longed for a strong protector like Tamlin. Now she is strong, and she needs freedom to train her newfound strengths.

3) I hate Tamlin.

Honestly, if you happen to be a diehard Tamlin fan, I can see this book being a huge disappointment. Luckily for me, I pretty much despised him. He's never been anything but a pretty-faced control freak. I'm glad Feyre has seen that and rebelled against it.

I should warn you that Tamlin is absent for about 70-80% of this book. And that was just fine by me!

4) I love Rhysand.

I foresee the "oh no, it's a love triangle" comments rolling in, but I really don't think it is. I actually think this is a great book about growing up and discovering that you're a different person who longs for different things. I don't get the sense that Maas is trying to play out the Tamlin/Feyre/Rhysand angst; she is merely showing a young woman having a change of heart.

AND can we just talk about how much better Rhysand is. There's all the superficial stuff like he's exciting, flirty, dangerous and I love the story behind him. He's more fun than Tamlin and I like fun. His banter is wonderful. But I'm also talking about a more important level. Rhysand is, despite being the "bad boy", thoughtful and selfless. He doesn't want to stifle Feyre's strength and lock her away for her own protection - he wants her at his side, an equal, a partner in crime. And I love that so much. I like men who see value in strong women.

5) Less sexual.

I'm sorry, you horny readers, but I just need to put this out there: I really dislike Maas' sex scenes. Maybe Tamlin had something to do with it but, in general, I think they're overwritten and melodramatic. I also think she does a lot of "telling" you that it's hot, instead of "showing" how it is, which is a common writing mistake, but is far worse when in a sex scene. It's unconvincing.

And by "overwritten", I mean that she describes kissing as "branding", thrusts as "breaking", and sex moans as "prayers". Literally none of those things are sexy. She gets the flirtations and banter right - that bit is hotter than the actual sex - but I start to cringe when the clothes come off.
A brush of his tongue against the seam of my lips had me opening fully for him, and he swept in, claiming me, branding me.

Also, is it really necessary for the male characters to "growl in approval" during sex? Not just once - and arguably one growl is one too many - but several times. I'm supposed to be fanning myself with desire and all I can think about is . Mercy. Rawr.

6) New characters.

A Court of Mist and Fury introduces many new characters, and the difference between this book and the first is that I found them all memorable, not just the main three characters. Maas has definitely not neglected her characterization and character detailing here. Everyone who comes in and out of the novel has an important purpose, is fleshed out with personality and history, and makes an impact.

My favourite was Amren, but I also loved Cassian and Azriel. Our brief introductions to the Bone Carver and the Weaver were highlights too.

7) The ending.

Take note: this is how to ensure your reader needs to get their hands on the next book. It's not a cliffhanger, but it is still EVIL. In the best possible way. I loved everything about it. It's the kind of emotional high that leaves you somewhere between wide-eyed horror and smiling gleefully. How will I last a whole year?

| | | | |
4227 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Court of Mist and Fury.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 17, 2016 – Shelved
May 2, 2016 – Started Reading
May 5, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 284 (284 new)


Emma How do you like it so far?


Emily May I haven't actually started it yet XD I marked it as "currently reading" and then got distracted by the new Percy Jackson book.


Emma Well, I'm looking forward to that book too so it's win-win ;)


message 4: by Sammy (last edited May 04, 2016 07:27AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sammy Prepare to love and be peeved at this book at the same time XD


Sammy All that deux ex machina happening in this book is just going to drive you crazy


Lisa Oooh, you started reading it! Can't wait to see what you think, since I'm actually slightly nervous for this one. Absolutely loved ACOTAR but I was also kind of on-and-off with her Throne of Glass series so I hope it won't disappoint :)


Emily May Lisa wrote: "Oooh, you started reading it! Can't wait to see what you think, since I'm actually slightly nervous for this one. Absolutely loved ACOTAR but I was also kind of on-and-off with her Throne of Glass ..."

I *might* not be the best judge for you because I didn't really like ACOTAR, lol. That being said, I'm enjoying this one much more because I like Rhysand. I seriously hate Tamlin, though.


message 8: by Maria (new)

Maria What does pnr mean?


Emily May Maria wrote: "What does pnr mean?"

Paranormal Romance.


message 10: by Maria (new)

Maria OK, thanks :D


Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ Ooh you're also reading it! How are you liking it? Honestly, I hated ACOTAR and Tamlin (ugh, that guy), but this one is working way better for me so far (mostly because of Rhysand and Feyre finally doing something, lol)


Emily May Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Ooh you're also reading it! How are you liking it? Honestly, I hated ACOTAR and Tamlin (ugh, that guy), but this one is working way better for me so far (mostly because of Rhysand and Feyre finally..."

My thoughts exactly! She seriously better not go back to Tamlin after what he did. I'm afraid it's going to be excused because he "just cares about her" or some other crap used to excuse control freak behaviour.


message 13: by Alienor � French Frowner � (last edited May 04, 2016 05:50PM) (new)

Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Ooh you're also reading it! How are you liking it? Honestly, I hated ACOTAR and Tamlin (ugh, that guy), but this one is working way better f..."

See, I don't understand why people are saying that he is going out of character. He was SUCH a control freak in ACOTAR! He wanted her to stay at home to paint, joked about the fact he bit her because "she shouldn't have gone outside as he asked her to" (no matter that he never told her that she would most likely be raped if she did) and their "love" was only sex for me. So, no, I am not surprised the guy's a prick. The only character who interested me in ACOTAR was Rhysand, and I love that he wants her powerful and in charge.


Emily May Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Ooh you're also reading it! How are you liking it? Honestly, I hated ACOTAR and Tamlin (ugh, that guy), but this one is wo..."

Yeah, I thought the same about Tamlin in ACOTAR. I also didn't like how their whole romance was so dull and seemed solely based on Tamlin's physical perfection. If she sticks with Rhysand, I could really enjoy this series.


Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Ooh you're also reading it! How are you liking it? Honestly, I ha..."

Agreed. I'm actually pleasantly surprised about the message the book is sending so far. I will always prefer a hero who helps the heroine to become independent and develop her abilities to a controlling one who thinks that he must decide everything "for her own good". Also, Rhysand is just so much more interesting XD


Emily May Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Ooh you're also reading it! How are you liking ..."

Indeed he is. I'm also really glad that Feyre addressed her own growth - about how she needed Tamlin back at a point when she was weak and needed protecting, and now she needs the training and freedom that Rhysand gives her. I like it when characters realistically change and grow.


Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE) wrote: "Emily May wrote: "Alienor � French Frowner � (of badger and SNAKE..."

Yes exactly! I almost stand up when she said that - because it is indeed realistic and completely understandable. I also liked that she was bored at the Spring Court and questioned the "after-HEA" and her immortality. I always thought that there was something immensely frightening in an immortal life, and for once it's addressed.


message 18: by merireads (new) - added it

merireads I am so excited to read this now...I've been hearing so many good things about it and your review was great!


message 19: by Emma (new) - rated it 3 stars

Emma Ha, you liked it more than me! That's unexpected :) I thought that Maas's writing was too dramatic for me, although I like Rys more than Tamlin too.


Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ YES!! I'm only at 66%, but so far I agree with everything. I do not feel like it's a love triangle either, but a realistic growth. I mean, why in the world should a woman stay with the same person all her life, especially when it's obvious that she changed? Rhysand's character is very well-rounded (and sexy, and just the right amount of infuriating^^). I also think that it will be hard for readers who loved Tamlin in the first place but... As you said, the guy was already a control-prick. Great review - Off to come back to Rhys :P


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)

OMG YOU LIKED IT. That means this is absolutely fantastic, and now I really need this. ❤️


Chelsea Your review has me even more excited to read this now, and I was pretty pumped already! I loved Rhys even in the first book back when all my friends were obsessed with Tamlin. I was desperately hoping Rhys would be more prominent of a character in this book, so hearing that he is...


message 23: by Kaye (new) - added it

Kaye I was waiting for your review of this book, now I think it's safe to read.


message 24: by Sammy (last edited May 05, 2016 10:21AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sammy Great review! But was it less sex? Maybe my memories shot but I think the first book didn't have scenes in such details.

As much I loved Feyre's development, I hated the whole can do anything thingy. I agree with Tamlin but I was not happy about the many things that made the plot too convenient. That was one thing that made this one so ughh I don't know, I was peeved in some parts.

I enjoyed everything else but this. I don't want something like George R.R. Martin killing everyone buuuut there should have been one death at least with how easy Feyre handled her powers. (view spoiler)


Trish ~ Great review Emily! I'm still a bit uncertain whether I should pick this book up or not though. I've been spoiled about the relationship status of this book and even though I left ACOTAR without shipping Feyre with anyone I didn't particularly like the way her and Rhys relationship "started", the whole controlling and making her drunk in the last book made me really skeptical about him as a character; so I wanna ask you if that is somehow addressed or "explained" in this book? I mean, do we find out more about Rhys and about his actions? Are able to understand him better?


Emily May Sammy wrote: "Great review! But was it less sex? Maybe my memories shot but I think the first book didn't have scenes in such details.

As much I loved Feyre's development, I hated the whole can do anything thi..."


Thank you. Definitely (view spoiler) XD. I don't know for sure, but I really felt the whole last book and their relationship was built up around sex. I also found the road to the sex here slower, and with more tension.


Emily May Patricia wrote: "Great review Emily! I'm still a bit uncertain whether I should pick this book up or not though. I've been spoiled about the relationship status of this book and even though I left ACOTAR without sh..."

I would say absolutely yes! We learn lots of things about Rhysand's character and past here that make a lot of sense.


message 28: by Dev (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dev feyre's character growth really was the best part of this book


message 29: by Henz (new) - added it

Henz Oh Em .. it makes me crave this book so much... honestly because of Rhysand but it makes me anxious that Maas is going to killing ships like that of Throne of Glass .. I just hope this series will not disappoint .. Fantastic Review!


Emily May Henz wrote: "Oh Em .. it makes me crave this book so much... honestly because of Rhysand but it makes me anxious that Maas is going to killing ships like that of Throne of Glass .. I just hope this series will ..."

Yeah, that was one of my thoughts too. Maas really likes to massacre her ships... at least this one seems to be going the way I want for a change.


Emily May Aida wrote: "I thought to skip this series after your negative review of the first book, but now your are saying this book is worth reading and I dont no why but just reading the description of Rhysand makes me..."

Thank you (they're my weakness too, hehe). So far, 3 books have been added on ŷ but I don't know for sure. I really hope it doesn't turn into one of those neverending series.


message 32: by Cris (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cris This book was everything I hoped it would be. I'm so glad you like it too ^^


message 33: by Gabriela (new)

Gabriela This book sounds interesting. Is it necessary to read the first one?


Monique V Wow. I was thinking that I probably was not going to like this book. One because Rhys did not make an impact on me in the first book like it did to many other readers. SeconD because I hate when an author changes the original ship. But after reading your review I will defenately be picking up ACOMAF.


Emily May Gabriela wrote: "This book sounds interesting. Is it necessary to read the first one?"

Yes, unfortunately :/


Aeron Trahaearn Brilliant review but...less sex?? hahaha
seriously I enjoyed Rhys's sex scenes with Feyre way more than I enjoyed Tam and Feyre's also I was totally team Rhys from the moment I read about him! (also him being her ____? I already guessed that!) I loved your review! you voiced out what I couldnt after That spectacular ending!


Ashley Reading people's reviews about the bastardization of Tamlin is baffling. He's always been a boring prick. He was also extremely controlling. Why didn't he teach Feyre some basic survival skills just in case she got captured? Instead he kept her locked up in a house for her own "safety". Even in the first book, it was clear Rhys was just there for her but that's besides the point, I adored Mass acknowledging that love shouldn't consume you. How Feyre killed for love, killed for Tamlin and it broke her. The book was a fantastic growth story. There was romance but it definitely wasn't the plot. I love your review


Alexis Yeah I agree about the sex. Not that it was there, but was just too loud, overly descriptive. I wanted to shut my eyes but couldn't.


message 39: by Becca (new)

Becca Hmm.. I really wasn't impressed with the first one at all, and had no plans to continue. Your review has me reconsidering!


Maellis I didn't enjoy the first book as much as I wanted (I agree with you, TOO MUCH love story in ACOTAR and I didn't like that) but because of you I need to get my hands on ACOMAF asap. Thanks Emily ^^


message 41: by M F (new) - added it

M F I really enjoyed this book but I have to agree, I'm not a fan of the sex scenes. I don't find them appealing... at all. And sure, I'm very, very picky. But there's picky and things that are just unattractive!

I didn't like Rhysand at all in b1 but understanding his motives here made me like him. And I really enjoyed how feminist the book was.


message 42: by Diane (new)

Diane ACOTAR has very little actual excitement until way past the half way mark. I hated Heir of Fire for this reason as well. Boring. Do things of relevance happen plot wise before the last quarter? In the past I've felt she could tell the same story in half the pages. I'm tempted because so many people like this, but so often am disappointed. Agree on her sex scenes, super awkward.


Emily May Diane wrote: "ACOTAR has very little actual excitement until way past the half way mark. I hated Heir of Fire for this reason as well. Boring. Do things of relevance happen plot wise before the last quarter? In ..."

I am with you 100%. I thought the last book was 90% pretty boys and sex, and only 10% actual plot. I personally think this one is very different. Lots of other things are happening with the world and royal politics from the beginning.


message 44: by inq (new) - rated it 5 stars

inq I just finished this book last night and I agree with every single point you mentioned here! Especially about the sex. I'm so glad I wasn't the only person that found them a little cringe worthy. But that last sentence was an act of savagery to leave off with, I can already see myself re reading this to fill the void that will be a year for the next installment.


Kylara Jensen I decided I want to read this book because I loved Corwn of Midnight SO MUCH MORE than Throne of GLass, so I was hoping that would be the case here. I'm glad you thought so.


message 46: by Kenz (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kenz The Dragon Queen I haven't read ACOMAF yet, but your review is making me even more eager to. Your a tough critic to please, and everything in your review is exactly what I was hoping to get from ACOMAF. Thanks!


message 47: by Leah (last edited May 05, 2016 01:36PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Leah I am SO glad you liked this. I really trust your reviews a lot, and I've heard some negative things about it; I was so worried.


Emily Harris YES GIRL. Great review. I loved this book. I'm still swooning over the Feysand scenes.


message 49: by Azizia (new)

Azizia I dont know how im going to last a whole year either, do you know if this is a trilogy (or six books like ToG) but in september Empire of Storms will tide us over, until ACOTAR 3 comes out. I was sooooo happy with this book, I wasnt a fan of Tamlin in the first book, he was fine, its just that they're relationship didnt seem genuine at all. The moment we were introduced to Rhysand I was like "HELL YES" and I had an inkling of what was to come, and the way SJM weaved the story just made me love Rhysand even more, and makes me love SJM more than how much I did after QOS. This book was Epic, tbh I was questioning reading this book because the first disappointed me (not bad, but not as good as I was expecting), but I am sooo glad I did read ACOMAF. Now I'm going to go back and reread ACOMAF and QOS and debate whether I love Rowan more or Rhysand (I'm leaning towards the latter).


message 50: by Azizia (new)

Azizia Ashley wrote: "Reading people's reviews about the bastardization of Tamlin is baffling. He's always been a boring prick. He was also extremely controlling. Why didn't he teach Feyre some basic survival skills jus..."
I feel the exact same way!!


« previous 1 3 4 5 6
back to top