Lisa Vegan's Reviews > The Book Thief
The Book Thief
by
by

Lisa Vegan's review
bookshelves: orphaned-and-quasi-orphaned-kids, fiction, groups-buddies, reviewed, bookclub, favorites, novel, historical-fiction, young-adult, books-about-books, goodreads-author, 1-also-at-librarything, holocaust, readbooks-male-author-or-illust, z2008, zz-5star
Jun 07, 2007
bookshelves: orphaned-and-quasi-orphaned-kids, fiction, groups-buddies, reviewed, bookclub, favorites, novel, historical-fiction, young-adult, books-about-books, goodreads-author, 1-also-at-librarything, holocaust, readbooks-male-author-or-illust, z2008, zz-5star
I admit that I am perplexed about why this is considered a young adult novel and not an adult novel that could be read by those 12 and up. The title character is a young girl, but there are plenty of novels written for adults that have young main protagonists. And I have to say that I could have enjoyed it at 12 but perhaps it’s more appropriate for those 14 and up, although that obviously depends on the reader. But I know that I enjoyed it more reading it as an adult than I would have as a young adult. (This book has been on my to-read list for a long time, since before I joined Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ, and I am extraordinarily grateful to the Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ YA Book Club group for choosing this as the first book read/the April 2008 book, because it’s why I motivated myself to read it at this time, possibly ever given the number of books I want to read. And I’m glad to have the opportunity to “discussâ€� it with others.)
I have a penchant for reading books about the holocaust, and this is the most unique book about the Nazi era I’ve read; in fact, it’s one of the most unusual novels that I’ve ever read. Although not for the very first time, I was able to feel empathy for and care about the non-Jewish German population during the holocaust era. I really appreciated the viewpoints shown.
This book is lyrical and poetic and powerful, and thankfully at times funny. And I really got attached to many of the characters: Liesel, Hans, Max, Rudy, Rosa, etc., death also actually. But it’s the author’s choice of narrator that elevates the quality of this book. Death is the narrator and, in my opinion, the perfect one, although I’d have never thought of this plot device myself; without Death telling the story I doubt this would have been a 5 star book for me. I loved how all of the characters felt like real people and how they changed, and how my opinions of them then shifted as well. The writing was so full of vivid imagery that I felt as though I was right smack in the middle with the people and place, more so than in most of the books that I read. I loved the books and pictures within the book.
I found it to be both a sad and exhilarating book. Although I got choked up at several points, I did not feel that it was a depressing book. It’s about friendship and love, the power of words, loss and abandonment, that which saves/heals us, and life and death.
And reading the book struck me at the very core of my being. I really identified with Liesel in so many ways. Some of the events of her life felt similar to mine, although most of the details diverged significantly, but the emotional potency imparted in this book felt so real and influential to me.
Death the narrator both drew me in and also gave enough distance from the tale to make the events more bearable.
And I’m really happy that the library gave me the paperback version that contains some discussion questions and an interesting interview with the author.
I have a penchant for reading books about the holocaust, and this is the most unique book about the Nazi era I’ve read; in fact, it’s one of the most unusual novels that I’ve ever read. Although not for the very first time, I was able to feel empathy for and care about the non-Jewish German population during the holocaust era. I really appreciated the viewpoints shown.
This book is lyrical and poetic and powerful, and thankfully at times funny. And I really got attached to many of the characters: Liesel, Hans, Max, Rudy, Rosa, etc., death also actually. But it’s the author’s choice of narrator that elevates the quality of this book. Death is the narrator and, in my opinion, the perfect one, although I’d have never thought of this plot device myself; without Death telling the story I doubt this would have been a 5 star book for me. I loved how all of the characters felt like real people and how they changed, and how my opinions of them then shifted as well. The writing was so full of vivid imagery that I felt as though I was right smack in the middle with the people and place, more so than in most of the books that I read. I loved the books and pictures within the book.
I found it to be both a sad and exhilarating book. Although I got choked up at several points, I did not feel that it was a depressing book. It’s about friendship and love, the power of words, loss and abandonment, that which saves/heals us, and life and death.
And reading the book struck me at the very core of my being. I really identified with Liesel in so many ways. Some of the events of her life felt similar to mine, although most of the details diverged significantly, but the emotional potency imparted in this book felt so real and influential to me.
Death the narrator both drew me in and also gave enough distance from the tale to make the events more bearable.
And I’m really happy that the library gave me the paperback version that contains some discussion questions and an interesting interview with the author.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Book Thief.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
June 7, 2007
– Shelved
Started Reading
March 31, 2008
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-47 of 47 (47 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Sfdreams
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Apr 01, 2008 12:03PM

reply
|
flag

And I want to do more work on the review actually. It was a complex book. And I'm thinking more & more highly of it as the hours pass since I finished it.
(edited for a split infinitive ;-) )




And as far as I'm concerned, feel free to edit your review. :)

On the other hand...I was crying my eyes out at the end.I loved how the author made Death as the narrator.It gave the reader a new...perspective on reading the book.

Yes, I could have enjoyed this book when I was twelve also.
In my review, when I say for 12 or 14 & up, I was thinking of the level and type of violence and the seriousness of the subject matter, and also the ability to think abstractly about the big ideas this book addresses.
Yes, Death as narrator was wonderful, and I cried at the end too.


I have friends who see why it's ya, but it seems more for adults to me, although I would have liked it at 12 & older.
What matters is that it's a terrific and special book. It's really stuck with me.


It was published in Australia as an adult novel. When the U.S. publisher got it they decided to publish it as ya. I guess that shows how the genres can cross. I was reading adult books at 12 and love ya now.

I met him last night and he is just as down-to-earth and funny as I imagined. He said this book means everything to him and he gets choked up reading it.

I met him last night and he is just as down-to-earth and funny as I imagined. He said this book means everything to him and he gets choked up reading it."
Wow! Thanks, Annalisa for sharing that. Lucky you. Yes, hooray for the Australians!


Ann, It's definitely dark but so sweet too, and I didn't get depressed at all reading it. It's so inventive. THe pictures, the few there are, are great too. Maybe you could do a buddy read with Kathryn or someone, someday.







I actually can see this for 12 + up, but I do consider it a book for grown ups, an adult book. If your daughter is a teen it might have been fun to read it together and discuss it.
I suspect the ya designation was that in the U.S. it was thought ya would sell better. That's too bad. Money shouldn't be the reason books are assigned genres.

My daughter is 12 and just seems to be too busy with school to read. :-(

It's good to know about the audio being good. I think I have read only one audio book in my life but I'm actually interested in them. I even have an audiobook shelf, just sitting there waiting for some books.

I have about a 2 hour commute every day taking my daughter to & from school. 1 hour I'm alone, so that's when I listen! I'm really enjoying it & it's making the drive less of a burden & more of a time to enjoy!



BUT... on the back cover of the book the author " this book is narrated by death".. he gave it emotions, colour favourites, sensations of felling what vibration's it liked , and prejudice's what sort of humans it liked disliked , in fact he transferred the malice from the German ternary to death.... An essay on Edgar Allan Poe Preoccupation with Death. Edgar Allan Poe shows a fascination with death, disease, and decay in his stories and poems, ...also A person who feels dead or detached experiences a group of symptoms that have been mentioned They include:Despair/hopelessness •Indifference
•Loss of interest in pleasurable activities
•L±ð³Ù³ó²¹°ù²µ²â
•Social withdrawal
•this giant leavathian that uncontrollable mass of negativity that hangs like the ozone layer it has touched so many country's sinst 1945
•starlin and the 20million in the gulags of Siberia, then there are others Fidel Castro , Nicolai Ceausescu, François "Papa Doc" Duvalier,
•Francisco Franco, Muamar el-Gadhafi,Saddam Hussein, Mao Zedong,Benito Mussolini, Augusto Pinochet,Kim Il-Sung--,Josip Broz Tito...did death visit them with its fav-colour, and vibration ( a wise man can act stupid, but a stupid man can never act wise.)
•words have to be read in Order for them to come alive , this is how the Nazis burned books on a grand scale did death not like the books either by_governments reading this list should give you sleepless nights
� the life of this book is to read it and agree with the stupidly of the author, the arrogance of the publisher , who assumes that people will like this attempt that can only come from a ( a creative writing class).., that would not even pass for an O..level in English and another thing...very bad houses are never nervous..???..... they are dilapidated, with dated paintwork , structurally un sound, and derelict

Thank you, Carol. Yes, I really appreciated the unique approach. The narrator of course but mostly seeing German citizens during WWII who were good guys!

Hilary, It’s brilliant and a very touching book! I’m glad it’s high up on the top 100 list.

Amy, It's a wonderful book! If the premise appeals to you I definitely highly recommend it!

Thank you, Margie. This book was so good it inspired me to try to get something good written.

Thanks, Margie. I loved your review!