ŷ

Andrew Smith's Reviews > The Nix

The Nix by Nathan  Hill
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5885760
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: netgalley

I’d glanced at ratings for this book - uniformly four or five stars from my book reading friends - and had read enough of the accompanying commentaries to know that this was a big book, at over 600 pages, covering a lump of time from the late 1960’s onward. I’d also gleaned that it was a family saga, with some political history thrown in for good measure. All good so far. What I’d no doubt have discovered if I’d dug a little deeper is that this book is brilliantly written in a style that reminded me of esteemed pensmiths such as Donna Tartt and Tom Wolfe. It also includes a wry and often hilarious look at how social media and online gaming have gained such a foothold in the lives of so many people in the 21st century.

It’s a book that jumps back and forth in time. Early on, we meet an eleven-year-old Samuel (Sam) Andresen-Anderson, a boy who cries a good deal. He is befriended by Bishop, a similarly aged, confident boy from his neighbourhood who already has career ambitions to be a soldier. Bishop introduces Sam to Bethany, his twin sister. Sam is instantly entranced by Bethany. The first major trauma in Sam’s life has already been signalled in the opening of the book but now it’s acted out in full: his mother, having clearly planned her escape in advance, walks away from the family home, never to return. Later, the loose ends left by these early encounters and events will be fleshed out � deliciously so.

As the story plays forward, we see that Sam has become an English literature professor and is having problems with one of his students. Laura Pottsdam decided some time ago that cheating her way to a degree is the way to go, and she’s not happy that Sam has rumbled the fact that her latest paper is an act of pure plagiarism Sam really is too busy keeping up with her vast array of acquaintances on the social network, I feel, to have time to actually research and write a paper of her own. Not one to bow down to authority, Laura will find a way of combatting her professor’s annoying accusation, that's for sure.

Sam is very much the lead character here, and it’s through him that we continue to meet the rest of the cast, even as we start to realise what a mess his life really is. It would appear that as an aspiring writer, he managed to secure a substantial advance for a book he has yet to write. The money is, of course, already spent, and the publisher is now demanding the return of the lucre. To add to Sam’s woes, he has no woman in his life and all his non-working time is entirely taken up by his addiction to an on-line game called World of Elfscape (easily identified as a close cousin of a certain ever expanding game my nineteen-year-old son seems similarly addicted to!) We will spend quite a bit of time in Word of Elsfscape, where we will also meet ‘Pwnage� the game name for a fellow gaming addict and acknowledged master Eflscape raider � and probably my favourite character of all.

I’m not giving much away here as all these events occur very early on. From this point, the fractured narrative takes us on a big ride through the decades as major events unfold, questions are asked and answered, and the lives of our characters are lived. It’s a truly spectacular piece of fiction. The novel mixes serious observation on real events (though the author has confessed he took some liberties with the fine detail), deep personal tragedy, and absolute hilarity. And it does all of this brilliantly well, whilst telling a complex and compelling story that kept me glued to the text throughout.

If I were looking for a criticism, it might be that there are some sections that do jabber on a bit. Could some passages have been selectively pruned? Well, yes, but I’m not sure that this would have improved the book. Instead, I think it would have been to its overall detriment. I believe these rambles are part of the soul of this piece. The writing is top drawer, and each character and each event has its place in the overall puzzle. At no point did I become lost in the maze or bored by a particular character or switched off by a protracted rant � it all fits together, it’s all part of the overall prize. Reading this book was a wonderful adventure, and I’m really sad I’ll not be waking up tomorrow to eagerly gobble up the next chapter or two. I already miss it.

My sincere thanks to Pan Macmillan and NetGalley for providing an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
149 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Nix.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 15, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
November 15, 2016 – Shelved
January 6, 2017 – Started Reading
January 6, 2017 – Shelved as: netgalley
January 9, 2017 –
14.0% "I sometimes like a big book I can lose myself in. This one feels grand in stature, like a Tom Wolfe novel. It's early doors but I'm already liking it a lot. It's clever and funny and with interesting characters, just my cup of tea."
January 12, 2017 –
52.0% "I'm sucked in deep on this one. There are bits I'm enjoying more than others, but I've bought into the leading characters and there's enough mystery here to ensure I have no idea where this story is going."
January 14, 2017 –
72.0% "It's good, very good. How the loose ends are wrapped up will will determine the rating, but I'm already convinced that this book - large as it is - is worth the significant investment in time it demands."
January 19, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Arah-Lynda (new) - added it

Arah-Lynda Wow that's quite an endorsement Andrew. I can relate for sure to missing a book and its characters in your life.


Melanie Your review makes me want to read this right away!


Andrew Smith Arah-Lynda wrote: "Wow that's quite an endorsement Andrew. I can relate for sure to missing a book and its characters in your life."

The last book that made me feel this way, I think, was The Goldfinch, Arah-Lynda. This may put some people off as Goldfinch wasn't everyone's cup of tea, but I loved it. I think this book has similar qualities. My belief is that it will be widely read and I really hope it will be be a major success. Time, of course will tell!


Andrew Smith Melanie wrote: "Your review makes me want to read this right away!"

I think it's a cracker, Melanie. It's a book to play with your emotions and draw you deep into the narrative. I'm aware that this is just a personal view, but the few reviews I've seen to date all seem positive.


message 5: by Violet (new) - added it

Violet wells Great review, Andrew. I've read lots of glowing reviews of this.


message 6: by PorshaJo (new)

PorshaJo Nice review Andrew! Every time I see a glowing review like this one I *can't wait* to get to this one. Just waiting on my library.


Andrew Smith Violet wrote: "Great review, Andrew. I've read lots of glowing reviews of this."

Thank you, Violet. And yes, I've cast my eye around a little and the book does seem to be getting a good deal of praise - and rightly so, I think.


Michael Great review, I keep seeing this book on library shelves but always pass it up. I may give it another chance.


Andrew Smith PorshaJo wrote: "Nice review Andrew! Every time I see a glowing review like this one I *can't wait* to get to this one. Just waiting on my library."

You'll need a sturdy table to rest this one, PorshaJo, but I do hope you get as engrossed in it as I did. I'll keep an eye out for your thoughts.


Andrew Smith Michael wrote: "Great review, I keep seeing this book on library shelves but always pass it up. I may give it another chance."

Many thanks, Michael. It's a biggie and therefore quite a commitment, but I think it's certainly worth a look. If you do decide to give it a go do let me know what you think of it.


message 11: by Ɗẳ� 2.� (new)

Ɗẳɳ  2.☊ Great review, Andrew.


Andrew Smith Ɗắ� 2.� wrote: "Great review, Andrew."

Thank you, kind sir!


message 13: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Very nice review, Andrew!


Andrew Smith Deanna wrote: "Very nice review, Andrew!"

Many thanks, Deanna :)


message 15: by Diane S � (new) - added it

Diane S ☔ Excellent review, Andrew.


Andrew Smith Diane S � wrote: "Excellent review, Andrew."

Thank you, Diane :)


message 17: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Great review, Andrew. I keep reading great reviews of this one.


Andrew Smith Esil wrote: "Great review, Andrew. I keep reading great reviews of this one."

Thanks, Esil! And yes, there are some really positive reviews of this book out there. One of the best I've read in a while.


message 19: by JanB (new) - rated it 4 stars

JanB Nice review! I've heard only good things about this one so despite it's size I just may have to add it to my list.


message 20: by Larry (new)

Larry H Fantastic review, Andrew! I have this one--I just need to get around to it!


Andrew Smith JanB wrote: "Nice review! I've heard only good things about this one so despite it's size I just may have to add it to my list."

Many thanks, Jan. To me this is a big book the feels like a small book - if that makes sense! There's always something going on, so I didn't get bored. And it's not so complex I lost the thread (something I can easily do). But there are a lot of pages, so it is a significant commitment.


Andrew Smith Larry wrote: "Fantastic review, Andrew! I have this one--I just need to get around to it!"

Thanks Larry. I think you might enjoy this one :)


message 23: by Wendy (new) - added it

Wendy Wonderful review Andrew!


Andrew Smith Wendy wrote: "Wonderful review Andrew!"

Many thanks, Wendy! :)


message 25: by John (new) - rated it 5 stars

John I also thought of Tom Wolfe when I was reading this.


Andrew Smith John wrote: "I also thought of Tom Wolfe when I was reading this."

Yes, the scale and the style of the book certainly brought him to mind for me, John. Hope you enjoyed this one.


message 27: by Kenny (new) - added it

Kenny What an amazing review. I must read this.


Andrew Smith Kenny wrote: "What an amazing review. I must read this."

Thanks, Kenny. It really is a terrific book.


Ellen Wonderful review, Andrew. I also loved this book-I loved the "bigness" of it, the themes of family and politics, the historical and the personal. I agree that it probably could have used some pruning but on the whole I loved every minute of it so...

I miss it too. It's so exciting to find a book that is so engaging.


Andrew Smith Ellie wrote: "Wonderful review, Andrew. I also loved this book-I loved the "bigness" of it, the themes of family and politics, the historical and the personal. I agree that it probably could have used some pruni..."

Many thanks, Ellie. It is a wonderful book, isn't it. It really drew me in too. I wish there were more books like this!


Richard Murphy Great review Andrew and I scored it a 4.5 and the 0.5 it lost was down to the length and the exact point you make that in some small areas it does go on a little too long.


Andrew Smith Richard - Thank you. And yes, I get the rationale for your deduction. Great book though 😁


Richard (on hiatus) A fine review Andrew ...... one of my favourite books of recent years.


Andrew Smith Thank you, Richard - mine too!


Jessica H Loved this book!


Andrew Smith Jessica - yes, brilliant book isn’t it 👍


message 37: by Skip (new)

Skip Guess I need to move this up in the TBR pile....


Andrew Smith It’s a good one, Skip - miss out on this one at your peril :))


message 39: by JanB (new) - rated it 4 stars

JanB I loved this book! The scene with Laura and Sam was hilarious. Terrific review Andrew. A great story despite the jabbering on 😉


Andrew Smith Thanks, Jan. Yes, that scene was absolutely hilarious! I recall that the book had quite a bit of publicity at the time of its release. I expected that it’d been overhyped, but was pleasantly surprised.


Lisa - spends more time reading book reviews than she does books- Thanks Andrew, can’t wait for this one.


Andrew Smith Lisa wrote: "Thanks Andrew, can’t wait for this one."

Lisa - like Christodora, it's a big story and one of my favourite books from the last few years.


Lisa - spends more time reading book reviews than she does books- Christodora was the other book on my Kindle that I couldn’t remember the name of but am really excited to get to. I am considering quitting my job so I have more time to read. Actually, it has been considered, and is a really bad idea 👎. Lol.


back to top