Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Ian "Marvin" Graye's Reviews > Memories of My Melancholy Whores

Memories of My Melancholy Whores by Gabriel García Márquez
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5022264
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: marquez, read-2014, reviews, reviews-4-stars

Immortified

I’ve wondered for a long time how to talk to you about this. How to explain myself, if such a thing is necessary or possible. Should I even bother? Would you understand? Will you be able to see things from my point of view? Could you find it in your heart to forgive me?

Ironically, perhaps, if you believe in God, the Holy Spirit, then you might be more likely to understand me and therefore to forgive.

My desire is not so much that you understand what I have done. It’s more important that you understand who or what I am. Therein lies the path to forgiveness. It depends on understanding me, my nature, not what I do.

Perhaps, you have already reached the point where you don’t want to understand or listen to me? Anyway, I will begin my explanation now.

I have had to live with myself for 91 years. During almost every day that I can remember, I have asked myself the same questions: who am I? What am I? Perhaps you have asked yourself the same things?

Every day, I have looked at my body, I have scrutinized my mind, and I have thought that this is not the real me. I am something different.

The best way to explain this is to say, in the simplest way possible, that I am my soul. I am not my body, I am not my mind, I am my soul. I am separate from them.

Before this body and this mind, I resided in other bodies and minds. I have no way of telling how many or for how long. These things are not revealed to our souls. However, I feel confident that there have been many. Speaking to my friends and comparing pasts, I have resolved that I, my soul, am at least 5,394 years old. Sometimes I wonder why I am not older.

I’ve transitioned 15 times that I know of. It fascinates me whether the body or the mind will succumb first, but usually the time between deaths is not long. It doesn't really matter. The important thing is to be close to another carrier, so that I can embark on the next stage of my journey.

With all due modesty, I’ve inhabited some pretty special humans, some merely from the point of view of their minds, some from the point of view of their bodies.

Still, it’s difficult for a soul to relate to a mind or a body.

Bodies, in particular, seem to be driven by DNA. They want to fuck all the time. When they’re not fucking, they’re thinking about fucking. Well, in that case, their minds are thinking about fucking. At least, that’s a pretty fair description of the males I’ve inhabited. The females aren’t as bad, but, to be honest, they’re not that much better. Certainly they’re not as virtuous as they would have you believe.

I’m 90, almost 91 now, in body years. Ironically, Delgadina is only fourteen. I say ironically, because in soul years, she is older than me, not by much, she’s 5,678 years old. She’s had almost four extra earth experiences than I have. Nineteen versus fifteen mightn’t sound like much, but you’d be surprised.

The strange thing is that our soul age counts for nothing on earth. No matter how religious somebody might be, they still judge us by our body age, not the age of our mind or our soul.

Even though Delgadina is technically an adult at age fourteen, people still think of her as a child. Little do they know, her mind is superior to mine. Just because she speaks less than I do, doesn’t mean that she is dumber. In our most recent life before this one, she topped our college in her last year. Sometimes, for her own benefit, I wish she would speak out more in this life, so people appreciated her mind, not just her body. Perhaps, that will come with time. I'm already teaching her to read, write and paint.

We almost didn’t meet in this life. In the last, we had actually been married, but only in our seventies. She had enjoyed a long marriage. I had remained faithful, well, as best I could after 622 lovers. So many of them had been whores, but they were still women, all of them. Delgadina was determined to find out what it had been like to be one of my whores. She knew me well enough, after four earth relationships, to know that the best way to get my undivided attention was to manifest herself as a fourteen year old girl.

I didn’t recognise her at first. She was promised to me. Well, her virginity was. Several times, we went through a ritual whereby I was supposed to deflower her. Each time, I slept next to her, and did nothing but caress her or kiss each centimeter of her body. It was as if my 90 year old body wasn’t up to the task, whatever the capacity of my mind, let alone my soul. I even began to question myself, which was a first for me.

People judge me as if I have done something wrong. Sometimes I wonder if they imagine that I have done only what they would like to have done, or in Delgadina’s position, might have wanted me to do to them.

I wonder whether these people know what it means to be a soul. To be condemned to live forever (although is it really such a condemnation?). To wander from body to body in search of another soul. To, at last, find a soul to whom you can relate, let alone, in my case, one who coincidentally I have loved before.

These are things that mean something to you in eternity. True love. Not whether one of you is 90 or 14. These are just numbers. Notches. Hands that move in a circular fashion around the watch face of time. They mean nothing to someone, to two lovers, like us, whose soul lives have already lasted almost six millennia and show no signs of giving up.

When I think of Delgadina, I don’t think of her legs, her breasts, her lips, even her mind, these things that somehow I have touched or kissed. Instead, I think of her soul. Meanwhile, she smiles when she thinks of how much more experience of life she has had than me. If only I could die now and start another life ahead of her. But, vain man that I am, I have resolved that, in this life at least, I want to see out a century. It comforts me that, when I lie awake in bed, sometimes I can derive some pleasure from observing her naked, legs apart, breasts spread across her chest, dreaming of me, her 90 year old stallion.



Playboy Seeks Sex Toy

The more I read Marquez' post-Nobel Prize works, the more I'm convinced that his modus operandi is to invent characters and situations that will outrage many, if not most, readers.

Here, a sexually-active nonagenarian is offered a fledgling 14 year old virgin whore to celebrate his birthday.

Whether or not he deflowers the girl, whether or not he might only have watched the girl sleeping, he would be condemned by the reader. Society objects not just to the act, but to both the desire and the intention.

The problem is that Marquez employs beautiful language in his enterprise.

In fact, I've always suspected that, as I suspect of Nabokov, he writes a straightforward tale of love and sex, then, only then, twists or perverts it, by adding an element of the forbidden, the taboo, the immoral, the illegal.

Without the perversion, it would be a work of beauty. What happens when he tweaks the ages of the participants? Would a story of love and sex involving a 40 year old male and a 30 year old female be acceptable? Well, what happens when the age of the male is dialled up to 90 and the girl down to 14?

Something in our minds registers, this should not be happening, something is wrong.

Marquez might not explicitly ask, why is it wrong. He might not be expressly challenging morality. It exists, whether we like it or not.

However, I think he is asking us whether, as a work of art, it is any less beautiful because it is transgressive.

Part of what he is doing is questioning the aesthetic nature of transgression.

The novel is inspired by Kawabata's "House of the Sleeping Beauties", which I hadn't read when I read this novel.

In the epigraph from that book, old Eguchi is warned by the madam not to do anything in bad taste. The specific caveat is not to "put his finger into the mouth of the sleeping girl".

Different things are forbidden at different times and in different cultures.

The act of writing the novel doesn't mean that Marquez advocates child abuse in real life. He just wants to ask these questions and explore these issues within the realm of art.

Again, like Nabokov, he wants to treat art and literature as a playground. He wants to explore not just desire and intention, but the imagination as well.

By doing so, he asks of the reader that we suspend moral judgment and engage pure aesthetic judgment. Not all of us will want to, not all of us will be able to.

In this way, he doesn't just confront us with his subject matter, he confronts us with our own temperaments. He utilises the response of the reader as part of his creative enterprise.

His works are all the greater, because they involve and implicate us.



VERSE:

Angels Surround the Bed of Delgadina

Let us share a bed.
You can sleep if you need to.
I'm content to watch.


Breathless

I kissed your body.
I inhaled your wild fragrance.
It made me breathless.


Dear Girl

I'll write words for you.
"We are alone in the world."
I'll teach you to read.


The Abominable No-Man

It does more damage
For authors to write in chains
Than to write freely.



SOUNDTRACK:

Memories of My Melancholy Whores (Title Sequence)



Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds - "Breathless"

54 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Memories of My Melancholy Whores.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 31, 2011 – Shelved
February 26, 2014 – Shelved as: marquez
March 8, 2014 – Started Reading
March 9, 2014 –
page 1
0.78% "My copy comes courtesy of the Butt-Holdsworth Memorial Library in Kerrville, Texas:



The Library's mission is to ensure that everybody gets their butt-holdsworth out of whatever they read."
March 9, 2014 –
page 21
16.41% "My hypothesis is that, with a Nobel Prize already under his belt, Marquez felt free to indulge in Nabokovian games in which the participants were literature and morality."
March 10, 2014 –
page 45
35.16% "I hung up the phone, filled with a sense of liberation I hadn't known before in my life, and free at last of a servitude that had kept me enslaved since the age of thirteen."
March 10, 2014 –
page 63
49.22% "Incredible: seeing and touching her in the flesh, she seemed less real to me than in my memory."
March 10, 2014 –
page 69
53.91% "Sex is the consolation you have when you can't have love."
March 11, 2014 –
page 128
100.0%
March 11, 2014 – Shelved as: read-2014
March 11, 2014 – Shelved as: reviews
March 11, 2014 – Shelved as: reviews-4-stars
March 11, 2014 – Finished Reading
September 12, 2022 –
page 69
53.91% "Sex is the consolation you have when you can't have love."

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rand (new)

Rand It is indeed tempting to equate representation with endorsement, (view spoiler)


message 2: by Ian (last edited Mar 11, 2014 01:56PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Thanks, Rand. I hope I can respond adequately when I read and review the book. Before then would be preemption on my part, (view spoiler).


message 3: by Gregsamsa (new)

Gregsamsa Have you gone off your meds again??


Kelly You seem to be going through all my favorite authors lately. :D


Praj Brilliant!!You are on a reviewing spree and I'm loving every bit of it.

Virgin souls
melancholic love
Reverie of a reader.

Btw, a kind request, the absence of a poetic verse is deeply felt , thus write some to make it the quintessential Mr. Graye's stylish appraisal.


message 6: by Garima (new)

Garima Lovely review, Sir Ian.


message 7: by Julio (new)

Julio Genao marvelous.


message 8: by Agnieszka (new) - added it

Agnieszka Brilliant !


message 9: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Praj wrote: "Btw, a kind request, the absence of a poetic verse is deeply felt , thus write some to make it the quintessential Mr. Graye's stylish appraisal."

Your wish is my command. See above.


message 10: by Praj (last edited Mar 11, 2014 01:42PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Praj Ian wrote: "Praj wrote: "Btw, a kind request, the absence of a poetic verse is deeply felt , thus write some to make it the quintessential Mr. Graye's stylish appraisal."

Your wish is my command. See above."


Thank you so very much!!! I love this review, especially the whole Nabokov and Kawabata take on the respective prose and of course the poems, they are always a treat!!


message 11: by Mala (new)

Mala Ian wrote:We almost didn’t meet in this life. In the last, we had actually been married, but only in our seventies. She had enjoyed a long marriage. I had remained faithful, well, as best I could after 622 lovers. So many of them had been whores, but they were still women, all of them. Delgadina was determined to find out what it had been like to be one of my whores. She knew me well enough, after four earth relationships, to know that the best way to get my undivided attention was to manifest herself as a fourteen year old girl.

Haha! Very clever. So you think Marquez recycles his characters? Like the soul's various incarnations,his characters also assume new names and identities- I can easily visualise Ariza as the nonagenarian here.


message 12: by Soheila (new) - added it

Soheila I just can't express how heartfelt were the feelings your review provoked in me... It was perfect! Just perfect!!
I could always feel something ethereal about the story which was too vague for me to be expressed by words... I feel relieved now reading your review... The puzzle is kinda solved. Thanks dear Ian.


message 13: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Thanks, Soheila. I hope my review helps you to write down your thoughts on the two books you've been reading. It would be wonderful to read your reviews.


Julia In fact, I've always suspected that, as I suspect of Nabokov, he writes a straightforward tale of love and sex, then, only then, twists or perverts it, by adding an element of the forbidden, the taboo, the immoral, the illegal.

Without the perversion, it would be a work of beauty. What happens when he tweaks the ages of the participants? Would a story of love and sex involving a 40 year old male and a 30 year old female be acceptable? Well, what happens when the age of the male is dialled up to 90 and the girl down to 14? [...]

I think he is asking us whether, as a work of art, it is any less beautiful because it is transgressive. Part of what he is doing is questioning the aesthetic nature of transgression.


A beautiful review, I particularly enjoyed the above passage, it is so true.


message 15: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Julia wrote: "In fact, I've always suspected that, as I suspect of Nabokov, he writes a straightforward tale of love and sex, then, only then, twists or perverts it, by adding an element of the forbidden, the ta..."

Thanks so much, Julia.


message 16: by Greg (new) - rated it 5 stars

Greg An impressive review, Ian. This brings to mind a line from a poem by Robert Adamson, Eurydice in Sydney. The second line "Was his brain still doing time in his head,"
I have Memories of My Melancholy Whores on the short list. I was discussing the book last night while out at dinner.
Your review is fascinating. To begin.


message 17: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian "Marvin" Graye Hi, Greg. Here's a link to the poem (which I hadn't previously read):



It's interesting how evocative of Sydney it is. Eurydice in Melbourne would be such a different work and have such different connotations.

This is also worth reading:



I like this line:

"turn, and unlade my eyes of all their cargo"

Also, this:




back to top