ŷ

Emily May's Reviews > The Dry

The Dry by Jane Harper
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4622890
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: mystery-thriller, 2018

Luke Hadler may have had a light on waiting for him when he came home, but something else from this wretched, desperate community had seeped through that front door and into his home. And it had been rotten and thick and black enough to extinguish that light forever.

The Dry actually makes me feel vindicated in my rating and review of Ritter's Bonfire last year. I got some criticisms that I was being too harsh toward a debut author; that a lot of thrillers follow a familiar format but that doesn't make them bad. Then, in swoops Harper here, a debut novelist, writing a mystery/thriller story whose foundations are very similar to Bonfire (and other works in the genre) and yet it is utterly gripping.

You know how the bare bones of these stories go. The protagonist is a small-towner who leaves and becomes a cop (lawyer, P.I., etc.) in the big city, then returns to his/her hometown to figure out some unfinished business from the past and solve a new crime. They, of course, get caught up in the small town politics and tensions.

Bonfire tried on this premise - unsuccessfully, in my opinion. Flynn did something very similar in Sharp Objects. The whole notion of "genre" generally relies on authors playing by a certain set of rules. Whether these recycled narratives work, however, depends on the details. Are the characters interesting? Is the writing compelling? Do we care? I think Harper did a great job on all three.

Firstly, The Dry is atmospheric to an intoxicating extent. Harper uses really evocative description to make you feel the burning heat and the suffocating lack of moisture amid the drought in this rural Australian community. The sun blazes. The blowflies hover. It's the perfect place for a murder.

Aaron Falk returns to his hometown after twenty years away to attend a funeral. The funeral is for his old friend Luke Hadler, Luke's wife Karen, and his six-year-old son Billy. The story goes that Luke cracked under the stress of financial pressure and shot his family, leaving only baby Charlotte alive, before putting a bullet in himself. But there's just enough doubt to make Falk question this popular verdict.

Along with local police newbie, Raco, Falk finds himself drawn into the case, as well as the lives, tensions and conflicts of the people in the town. His own past gets dragged up and Falk is forced to question whether there might be some connection between what happened to Luke's family and what happened all those years ago.

The author expertly leads us down several roads that turn out to be red herrings and manages to pull out a dramatic and surprising conclusion. If you're a suspicious mystery reader like me - as in, you suspect everyone - then you might guess who did it, but I doubt very much you will guess the whys. And I personally think this is what makes a good mystery - the unveiling of the tale and the whys of the crime are good enough to make it okay if you guess whodunnit.

A really impressive start to this new series starring Aaron Falk. Sign me up for the next book!

| | | |
623 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Dry.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 4, 2018 – Shelved
January 6, 2018 – Started Reading
January 8, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-31 of 31 (31 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mermaid (new)

Mermaid My new years resolution is to review my books like you. If you could read my reviews of 2018 and give me any tips that would be great!


message 2: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura Wow. Sounds like a good one. So glad it proves, as you say, that debut authors can pull it off.


Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘ Yay! I love good mysteries but they're so rare. Great review!


PinkAmy loves books, cats and naps I love your reviews, even though you and I often have opposite reactions to books.


Zohal I loved this book and the sequel is almost as good :) It's insanely popular in Australia and has won quite a few awards.


Andrea Perfect review! So nice to see you reviewing an Aussie author! I love how diverse your taste is. I’ve been banging on about how good this book is for a whole, forcing friends to read it. The sequel is almost as good.


Tracie Payne Great review. I loved this one as well.


Erin Force of Nature was an excellent follow up. Possibly not as good as The Dry, but still captivating and atmospheric, and full of mystery.


Raina Singh Awesome review, thanks Emily!


message 10: by John (new) - rated it 4 stars

John Hollenkamp I have yet to read Force of Nature, as an Australian crime writer I was immediately drawn into the The Dry by her prologue. Her rich and colourful writing did not disappoint. A credit to our country's wonderful authors and stories, many of which are gritty, realistic and dry-witted!


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review! I just picked this up from the library today. Looking forward to it!


Natasha Loved The Dry! I finished Force of Nature a few weeks ago, and it is just as good. Harper's sense of place is great in that too - the land becomes a character.


Nadiko So glad you liked them Natasha!


message 14: by StarMan (new) - added it

StarMan Nice review. Thank you.... book added to my wishlist.


Colleen I loved this book too! Great review!


Sassenach I loved this book ... I guess setting the story in the australian bush really made it for me :)


message 17: by Shay (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shay This has been in my to-read list for a while. I think this stellar review will push it right to the top of the list!


Jenny I loved this book - wondering why you didn’t post a rating and review for Beartown?


Emily May Jennifer wrote: "I loved this book - wondering why you didn’t post a rating and review for Beartown?"

In truth, I didn't really like Beartown for a number of reasons, but it is such a widely-loved book (I haven't seen any of my GR friends give it less than 5 stars) that I felt like it might seem I was just hating on it because I could, or to be "different". I just don't have the energy to get into that argument right now :)


message 20: by Ale (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ale I completely agree with your review! I recently received the second Aaron Falk book and I’m really hoping it’s as great as the first in the series 😁


Ethan I’m so glad you liked it! It was one of my favorites from last year, and I can’t wait to read Force of Nature


Jenny On Beartown- that’s cool. Thx for responding. Was just curious bc your reviews on a lot of the books I read resonate for me. Looking forward to a review on Force of Nature.


Elizabeth R Spotted this on the bookseller recommends shelf at Powell’s and put it on hold at the library, where it currently awaits me! Excited!


Chelsea Humphrey So glad you enjoyed this one too!


message 25: by Amritha (new)

Amritha This book is very gripping ..almostunputdownable.The dry is what exactly a suspense thriller should be like.This is much better than sharp objects or the dark places


message 26: by Lily (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lily I loved reading the book. I liked all the different characters, and the intense worry that a childhood friend might have actually killed his whole family. I loved the whole atmosphere and the very intense reality of the drought and how it was affecting the whole community. Unfortunately, for me it all kind of fell apart when the fake ID with a different name than the hotel reservation was found in the backpack.


Polly-Alida That particular quote stood out to me too. I stopped and reread it several times and it gave me the chills. I'm eager to finish this book. Wish I didn't have work and life to take care of. Oh well, don't we all wish for more reading time. :)


Rachael Wonderful review. I loved this book!


William Thank you for the review.


message 30: by í (new) - rated it 3 stars

í Carvalho I was sooooo bothered by the weird "flashbacks". Like....what narrative voice is this? It ruined the experience for me a little bit.


Michelle Only Wants to Read This may be the first and last time we both agree on a book rating, lol.


back to top