Dorie - Cats&Books :) 's Reviews > Us Against You
Us Against You (Beartown, #2)
by
by

Dorie - Cats&Books :) 's review
bookshelves: literature, netgalley-feedback
Apr 21, 2018
bookshelves: literature, netgalley-feedback
Read 2 times. Last read June 7, 2018.
*NOW AVAILABLE*
I have read all of Fredrik Backman’s books and Beartown was probably my favorite. I know I’m in the minority here but “Us Against You� just didn’t elicit the same emotions for me, it was a bit of a disappointment. After I read Beartown I felt as though it was complete story and so I was a little surprised that the author chose to revisit the town again.
The first 30% of the book dealt pretty much with getting the reader caught up with the characters from Beartown and what had happened the previous year. This part for me was a skip through because I already was knowledgeable about what had transpired. That said, Mr. Bachman’s writing was again outstanding as he summed up all characters and what they had gone through emotionally and physically the past Fall and Winter.
Now it’s summer and the kids are free to try to heal as are the parents. A new character, Richard Theo, a politician, is introduced and adds his twisted, manipulative narrative to this new season for the hockey team. A lot of time is spent on what he is doing, but not so much on why he is doing it? We are left with wondering if he is just incredibly selfish and wants notoriety for himself or if there is something else that is going on? I really couldn’t understand how someone could care so little about the people he was about to hurt.
A lot of time is spent on “The Pack� and it’s influence in the town. I felt myself growing tired of Teemu, Woody and Spider and the rest of the group. I have a hard time believing that such a small group of men could hold so much sway in the feelings of the townspeople. Not not only did they seem to control the hockey team’s endorsement but also the town’s feelings about the rape, the homosexual issues, the woman coach and how much violence was used to get what they wanted. I had had enough of them by the end of the book!
Benji and his sisters play a large part in this book and those moments with them are definitely some of my favorites. His sisters are committed to their brother and want so much to protect him from some of the things he is about to do, but he is almost a grown man and they are left with just loving and supporting him, which was a wonderful thing to see.
Hog is an amazing character and a great father. He is so supportive of Bobo and understands his son’s strengths and weaknesses. He wrestles with the loss of his wife but the family is a strong unit and seem to be able to survive this great tragedy.
I was disappointed that nothing was included about David and the boys who left to play for Hed, they are still residents of Beartown to my understanding and I would have liked to know what their thoughts were now that they decided to play for the opposing team. I’m sure it was not an easy decision for many of them.
As if there haven’t been enough changes in Beartown, a woman coach is hired to resurrect the Beartown hockey club. She is tough, skilled and treats all of her players equally. This is a woman I was glad to see introduced into the story. I also loved how the ending was pulled together with her and one of the other players.
In the end I was glad to have read this book but I don’t think it “measured up� to Beartown or “Britt Marie Was Here�, two of my very favorite Backman books. I’m sure many, many people will be glad to revisit the town but for me it was bittersweet and the ending still left with me with lots of unanswered questions. I will of course be on the lookout for the next Fredrik Backman novel as he has been added to my list of favorite authors.
ADDENDUM: Since I published this review yesterday it has come to my attention that there is to be a Beartown #3 and that the author always intended a trilogy. I thought it was interesting but I don't know that I need a third book, I'm not a series kind of person (with the exception of Harry Potter)
I received an ARC of this book from the publisher through Edelweiss.
I have read all of Fredrik Backman’s books and Beartown was probably my favorite. I know I’m in the minority here but “Us Against You� just didn’t elicit the same emotions for me, it was a bit of a disappointment. After I read Beartown I felt as though it was complete story and so I was a little surprised that the author chose to revisit the town again.
The first 30% of the book dealt pretty much with getting the reader caught up with the characters from Beartown and what had happened the previous year. This part for me was a skip through because I already was knowledgeable about what had transpired. That said, Mr. Bachman’s writing was again outstanding as he summed up all characters and what they had gone through emotionally and physically the past Fall and Winter.
Now it’s summer and the kids are free to try to heal as are the parents. A new character, Richard Theo, a politician, is introduced and adds his twisted, manipulative narrative to this new season for the hockey team. A lot of time is spent on what he is doing, but not so much on why he is doing it? We are left with wondering if he is just incredibly selfish and wants notoriety for himself or if there is something else that is going on? I really couldn’t understand how someone could care so little about the people he was about to hurt.
A lot of time is spent on “The Pack� and it’s influence in the town. I felt myself growing tired of Teemu, Woody and Spider and the rest of the group. I have a hard time believing that such a small group of men could hold so much sway in the feelings of the townspeople. Not not only did they seem to control the hockey team’s endorsement but also the town’s feelings about the rape, the homosexual issues, the woman coach and how much violence was used to get what they wanted. I had had enough of them by the end of the book!
Benji and his sisters play a large part in this book and those moments with them are definitely some of my favorites. His sisters are committed to their brother and want so much to protect him from some of the things he is about to do, but he is almost a grown man and they are left with just loving and supporting him, which was a wonderful thing to see.
Hog is an amazing character and a great father. He is so supportive of Bobo and understands his son’s strengths and weaknesses. He wrestles with the loss of his wife but the family is a strong unit and seem to be able to survive this great tragedy.
I was disappointed that nothing was included about David and the boys who left to play for Hed, they are still residents of Beartown to my understanding and I would have liked to know what their thoughts were now that they decided to play for the opposing team. I’m sure it was not an easy decision for many of them.
As if there haven’t been enough changes in Beartown, a woman coach is hired to resurrect the Beartown hockey club. She is tough, skilled and treats all of her players equally. This is a woman I was glad to see introduced into the story. I also loved how the ending was pulled together with her and one of the other players.
In the end I was glad to have read this book but I don’t think it “measured up� to Beartown or “Britt Marie Was Here�, two of my very favorite Backman books. I’m sure many, many people will be glad to revisit the town but for me it was bittersweet and the ending still left with me with lots of unanswered questions. I will of course be on the lookout for the next Fredrik Backman novel as he has been added to my list of favorite authors.
ADDENDUM: Since I published this review yesterday it has come to my attention that there is to be a Beartown #3 and that the author always intended a trilogy. I thought it was interesting but I don't know that I need a third book, I'm not a series kind of person (with the exception of Harry Potter)
I received an ARC of this book from the publisher through Edelweiss.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Us Against You.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 25, 2018
– Shelved
February 25, 2018
– Shelved as:
to-read
April 15, 2018
–
Started Reading
April 17, 2018
–
30.0%
April 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
literature
April 21, 2018
– Shelved as:
netgalley-feedback
April 21, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Started Reading
June 7, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Sonja
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Apr 21, 2018 10:13PM

reply
|
flag

I have to tell you Jan, I was disappointed,maybe I expected too much :( How about you?

Sonja, it's called "Us Against You" and comes out this August

I have to tell you Jan, I was disappointed,maybe I expected too much :( How about you?"
Yeah, same here. It wasn't awful but it won't be on my favorites shelf! I need to write my review..I'm procrastinating.

I have to tell you Jan, I was disappointed,maybe I expected too much :( How about you..."
Come on Jan I had to do it now it's your turn, ha! Sometimes it's so hard. I think it took me an hour to write mine, my husband kept saying why are you still on the computer????


I have to tell you Jan, I was disappointed,maybe I expected too much :( ..."
hahaha!!!!! Yours is so good I fear I won't be able to do the review justice - I wish I could just link to yours 😉😂


I’m still glad I read it - but I, too, was disappointed."
Kindred spirits Elyse and hope you are feeling better :)


I guess you should just give it a try if you already have it and see how you feel about it. Perhaps my expectations were just too high :)


Please don't get me wrong, I'm still a huge fan of this author, but that doesn't mean that I have to love every book he writes, correct?

Oh, no, absolutely. You can love an author's writing without loving every book. I was just articulating what I myself thought when having similar thoughts: why doesn't he write more about this character or that one ... with so many characters some are more likely to be given more airtime than others. I hope the next novel will focus on the female coach and other characters that were less prominent in this one.


Well Barbara I just found out that there is going to be a #3 so I guess if you are interested in the entire trilogy you should definitely read this one :)

Well Barbara I just found out that there is going to be a #3 so I guess if you are interested in the entire trilogy you should definitely read this one :)
..."
Thank you for the tip. 🎈

I am glad that you still liked this book considering. Nice fair, honest review my friend!

Thanks Susanne. I'd like to see the author go with something entirely different than a third book about Beartown :( I had no idea that a trilogy was planned until someone else alerted me to the fact.


thanks Cheri. I will always be a fan of his writing, just would like something different, still a good novel :)


If you loved all of his other books as I did you will want to continue reading, it did get better for me, however as I said I really don't know why he decided to make this a trilogy :)

that's interesting Denise, we're all different :) It did end up enjoying it as I said, a 4* from me means it was really good, just not great :)

