ŷ

Kinga's Reviews > A Discovery of Witches

A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
110812
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: pub-2011

Well, this was the dumbest shit I’ve read in quite a while.

I picked it up thinking it would be some good escapist fantasy book with some romance thrown in but it turned out to be Twilight meets Instagram. We had some vampires, demons, and witches but they never did anything remotely interesting. It was all about yoga, fitness routines, early morning runs, elaborate and photogenic meals, wine drunk in old chateaus, cosy interiors and, I swear to you, there was a scene where the heroine drew her knees up and held a mug of hot beverage with both hands. This is something you only ever do if are posing for Instagram or pretending you’re in the Marks&Spencer Christmas ad.

There were 600 pages of this nonsense and whatever action or danger did occur it was swiftly dealt within 5 pages so we could go back to characters having some idiotic conversations where they constantly quibbled over nothing in particular. The narrative switches between the first person from the heroine’s point of view and the omniscient third person to explain all the things the heroine couldn’t know about. The whole thing is very lazily executed and there is no change in the voice at all, so I constantly had to keep checking which narrative it is when I thought the heroine fainted but somehow she is still talking.

When our witch heroine met the vampire hero she still had brains and I was hoping she would put an end to his brand of romance which included gaslighting the heroine, controlling her every move, ordering her about, infantilising her and all the other techniques overbearing assholes like him like to employ. It would be like Twilight The Remix. Sadly it was just Twilight The Extended Cut. Diana quickly lost all the brains that she had and also seemingly some of her size. When we meet her she is a tall and athletic woman, but as soon as she falls in love with Matthew she becomes pocket-sized. He constantly scoops her up and carries her about (in his pocket I assume). Every now and then she tries rebel against his constant ordering her about but it’s always presented like a silly childish tantrum and we are to assume she is being foolish for protesting such thoughtful commands.

Due to his vampire abilities Matthew knows everything about her � when she is sleepy, tired, hungry, when she is on her period. And he orders her to sleep, eat etc. Because in her twenty odd years she clearly hasn’t mastered dealing with basic body functions. That fucking guy even buys her birth control pills and orders her to take them, even tells her what day she should take them (he does know those things better, of course). And check this, he also refuses to have sex with her for no fucking reason whatsoever. Here, honey , take loads of hormones with a bunch of side effects, because who knows how powerful my seed is, maybe I can impregnate you just by thinking about it. What in the puritanical hell is that? And that is AFTER they were married, which brings me to the clusterfuck that was their ‘wedding� (?). What happened was he went on some trip, came back, kissed her and told her he loved her. She is like ‘cool beans�. And then he says: “oh, by the way, in the vampire culture that thing means we are now married and mated for life�.

Is she mad as fuck that dude tricked her into marrying him, literally married her without even asking if this is something she might be interested in? No, of course not, that’s not weird and creepy at all. Supa romantic. That halfwit of a heroine embraces it and goes on to call all the people he has turned into vampires over the years, some of whom are a few centuries old, “OUR children�. She literally met that dude a few weeks before and now she is calling his three-hundred-year-old “son� � MY son. Sure, go hard or go home.

Also, another thing we are supposed to find romantic is that whole alpha-maleness and ‘pack animal behaviour�. All the men never stop acting idiotically protective over “their women� and growl at each other for no logical reason. It is supposed to show us they are all alpha males fighting for dominance. Wow. How exciting. You’re basically dating a German shepherd. We are told that Matthew the vampire is endlessly brilliant and eternally patient, but he acts neither. He withholds information from the heroine for no reason other than to be controlling, he acts rashly, he can barely control his anger fits and basically has an emotional complexity of a fighting dog. Whatta man, whatta man, whatta man.

Oh, and did I mention all the characters smell of flowers, spices and minerals that no mammal has any business smelling of? And why is a man smelling of cloves and cinnamon sexy? Are we supposed to shag him or sprinkle him over a latte?

AND ALSO. Tiny bit of advice from me for Diana � if someone gives you a bunch of ingredients and very strict instructions how to make them into some tea, and tells you to make it exactly like that every day, and drink it at the same time every day, then maybe don’t it because it’s hella fishy. Or at least, I don’t know, ask why, you absolute nincompoop!

I am not reading another instalment of this bloated abomination. I heard the characters are going back in time. They should go back to the Middle Ages where they belong and then die from the plague.
406 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Discovery of Witches.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 12, 2011 – Shelved
August 25, 2018 – Started Reading
September 2, 2018 –
page 181
30.57% "So that settles it then. I could never date a vampire. I like a healthy complexion on my men, and fussy eaters drive me up the wall."
September 21, 2018 –
page 450
76.01% "This book is getting worse and worse. Why is she referring to her husband per 'the vampire' when talking about him. Dude, so weird, stop that."
October 1, 2018 – Finished Reading
April 8, 2020 – Shelved as: pub-2011

Comments Showing 1-50 of 57 (57 new)


message 1: by Lawrence (new)

Lawrence FitzGerald A wonderful review. I laughed all the way through it. I wish you had written one for Twilight.


message 2: by Stefanie (new)

Stefanie Smith Loved this review! I will gladly stay away from this, but at least the review could be entertaining.


message 3: by Tony (new)

Tony So, bought #2 yet? :o)


Kinga Tony wrote: "So, bought #2 yet? :o)"

Lol.

No.


message 5: by Chris (new)

Chris Blocker My favorite reviews of yours are the ones where you really rip into a book. This was great! I live for these moments.


message 6: by Cassy (new)

Cassy Great review. You have some zingers in there!


message 7: by Elissa (new) - added it

Elissa Ah. I was looking for something satisfying to read. So glad it was this review. Thanks.


Kylie Blair WOW! Amazing review. I found this book quite good (for the escapism), but now I won't be able to look at it in the same way again haha


message 9: by carol. (last edited Oct 04, 2018 11:10AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

carol. Ha! Funny review. A well-deserved skewering.


message 10: by Karina (new)

Karina LMAO! You only needed that first line in your review to say it all....


message 11: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer I've known more reasonable German shepherds, personally. Epic review! I read just enough of this one to be 100% certain I didn't want to read any more.


message 12: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Kylie wrote: "WOW! Amazing review. I found this book quite good (for the escapism), but now I won't be able to look at it in the same way again haha"

That's me, ruining guilty pleasures for people since 2008


message 13: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Jennifer wrote: "I've known more reasonable German shepherds, personally. Epic review! I read just enough of this one to be 100% certain I didn't want to read any more."

I felt a little bad wrtiting that line as my childhood dog was a German shepherd and was mostly level-headed


Donna (will never finish her TBR) Well, I’ll be removing this from my shelf after reading your review lol. Thanks for the heads up of this Instalight shite :)


message 15: by Rita (new)

Rita I almost didn't continue reading your review after you said how awful it was, but I loved the line:

"It is supposed to show us they are all alpha males fighting for dominance. Wow. How exciting. You’re basically dating a German shepherd."


message 16: by Rita (new)

Rita Sometimes, though, I wonder why you bother even looking at such books, when there are SO MANY good ones available, even in the more escapist categories... or aren't there?


message 17: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Well, this looked like it was going to be good! And I had a free copy. My problem is I am unable to stop reading a book. Even if it’s really bad. It would feel like walking around with a stone in my shoe... forever.


Melissa Perfectly encapsulates my feelings on this book! >.<


Samantha Omg ahahahahaha love this review and agree so much! I just quit about a third of the way through and am so happy I did by the sounds of it. I truly don't understand how this was a bestseller.


message 20: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Sam wrote: "Omg ahahahahaha love this review and agree so much! I just quit about a third of the way through and am so happy I did by the sounds of it. I truly don't understand how this was a bestseller."


Me neither. Im now reading Downside Ghosts series and the unfairness of the fact that A Discovery of Witches is being made into a tv show and Downside Ghosts never broke into the mainstream is making me burn with rage.


message 21: by Jessie (new)

Jessie R Brilliant!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻


message 22: by Lori (new)

Lori I couldn't agree with you more--I cannot understand the love for these books. And now a television series? No.


message 23: by Eva (new) - rated it 2 stars

Eva I cackled at “You’re basically dating a German shepherd,� and then howled at “Are we supposed to shag him or sprinkle him over a latte?� Thank you. Perfect.


message 24: by Heather (new) - added it

Heather Your review was hilarious! This has been on my TBR list for ages but I’m glad I can pass it up now!


Kaitlyn tldr!! but why 1 star? i think there’s no reason to pick a book apart just because your depressed and angry with you’re life.. we all have problems but if all you do is take down other people you’re inner dramas will never really improve.. please don’t be mad at me because i don’t mean bad!! i think yoga helps a lot with anger issues, i used to be very ballistic and salty but now i am a very evolved human being and all i want is to reach out and help others!! yes. you can do it too!!


carol. ^hahahahahahahaha


Brittany (Lady Red) Bless you for this review it summed up my feeling exactly. And I was very disappointed because I love witchy books


message 28: by Sonia (new)

Sonia This review made me laugh, thanks.


message 29: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Kaitlyn wrote: "tldr!! but why 1 star? i think there’s no reason to pick a book apart just because your depressed and angry with you’re life.. we all have problems but if all you do is take down other people you’r..."

tldr! by why so many exclamation points? i think there is no reason to comment on a negative review of a book you liked because you're* depressed or angry with your* life. We all have problems but if all you do is leave patronising comment your* inner dramas will never really improve.. please don’t be mad at me because i don’t mean bad!! i think yoga helps a lot with anger issues, i used to be very ballistic and salty but now i am a very evolved human being and all i want is to reach out and help others!! yes. you can do it too!!
next time you see someone gave 1 star to a book you liked you can just NOT leave a comment and do some yoga instead! I only want to help.


Kaitlyn sorry but i don’t know why your repeating my comment?? is it just me or your being really negative here.. jeeez!! no need to be peeved just because i’m suggesting you should manage you’re wrath.. it worked great for me!! pls don’t take offense ms. king.. i think a vacation also helps a lot and personaly for me i also gave up all meat because the cruelty in meat and dairy farms can cause actual damage and rage problems in humans.. ah and watch that movie “mean girls� it has a very nice lesson in the end.. we should never fly into a rage.. be nice and the whole world will smile back at you!!


message 31: by Melissa (last edited Dec 19, 2019 01:35PM) (new)

Melissa Vegan here, pls dont use the cruelty of the meat and dairy industry as a reason to be rude to people (while comepletely pulling that out of your ass, meat consumption/farms doesnt/dont make anyone more angry, stupid comments do tho)


message 32: by Melissa (new)

Melissa back to the review, this was hilarious, def stepping away from this book!


message 33: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Hahah. Thanks. If Kaitlyn is doing all this these things to control her anger and become a more evolved person why is she still getting so worked up over a humorous review?

Judging from her comments all that yoga and Vegan diet have turned from an aggressive person to a passive aggressive one.


message 34: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Seriously, stop you absolute troll. Go and meditate. Take your passive aggression out of my space. We don’t want this sort of negativity. And if you don’t see how passive aggressive and annoying you are, then you still have a lot of evolving to do.


message 35: by Tony (new)

Tony Foxhoven That review was amazing,. I think I enjoyed the review more than you enjoyed the actual book haha


message 36: by Manny (new)

Manny I find it disturbing that this kind of book is so popular. When did it become sexy again to have your mind and body controlled by an amoral übermensch? I seem to recall there was a reason why that went out of style for a few decades.


message 37: by Barb (new) - rated it 2 stars

Barb Nelson I know, I have no idea why this book is so popular. Great review. I couldn’t get through it.


message 38: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Thanks all, I'm glad this review is bringing you joy and vindication. :)


message 39: by Sam (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sam Livingston Hahaha, I think Kaitlyn might be someone making fun of the type you described in the book " the yoga type". It can't be a real person...


message 40: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Sam wrote: "Hahaha, I think Kaitlyn might be someone making fun of the type you described in the book " the yoga type". It can't be a real person..."

I genuinely hope so.


message 41: by Nylana (new)

Nylana You absolutely nailed it! I couldn't agree more. haha


message 42: by S.K. (new) - rated it 2 stars

S.K. Conaghan Thank you. Needed that laugh. I'm 1/4 of the way through this and just found a strange contradiction where the heroine declares her ancestor was "found guilty of witchcraft" and two lines later says she "was found innocent of practicing witchcraft" and I'm thinking, did I miss something? Is that not a really easy-to-spot editing mishap? Or is that not a contradiction in the world of this novel? Also, after the 16 page chapter in which Matthew and his best friend in the whole world talk about three things which turn out to be life altering personal facts they never knew about one another over wine, wine, soup, tea, chess, billiards (PS: thanks for the billiards lesson, Ms. Harkness) and stalking (but not eating) a deer, I started thinking perhaps I should read some reviews... not sure I'll be able to give time to finishing this, especially if the action only begins in the second and third novels as some reviewers mention. Thanks for your comical review. I'm going to go read it again (speaking of productive expenditure of time).


Emilie Amazing. Absolutely amazing. Not really into glorifying domestic abuse!!! Loved this review


message 44: by Shera (new)

Shera This review had no business being this funny lol. I recently watched the tv series and I thought I’d give it a read but this review has brought a lot to light. Thank you for saving me some time.


message 45: by Lawrence (new)

Lawrence FitzGerald Brilliant review!


message 46: by Wathi (new)

Wathi This review is all I ever need to read about this book or any that come after it.
Thank you for the summary. Brilliant.


message 47: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Thank you all for all your lovely comments. ŷ has long ago stopped informing me of new comments under some of my reviews, so I had no idea you commented


Skyler I am dying laughing over this. I enjoyed your review much more than the book


message 49: by C.C. (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.C. I'm reading reviews for research and, I must say, yours was entertaining and laugh-out-loud funny! Your last sentence, especially, drew a loud guffaw. Thank you for making my reading research more bearable. ~CC


message 50: by Kinga (new) - rated it 1 star

Kinga Again, thank you all. My pleasure :D


« previous 1
back to top