ŷ

Candi's Reviews > Outline

Outline by Rachel Cusk
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: contemporary-literary, series-book-in-series

“� this was a story in which I sensed the truth was being sacrificed to the narrator’s desire to win.�

How do we piece together the stories we tell one another? Aren’t all of our stories inherently about the way we perceive events and other people? If the narrative had been told from another’s point of view, it might look quite different. It’s not that we are necessarily being deliberately untruthful. Our own experiences and inner thoughts shape the way we pass information on to the next person. We may also decide to hold back, just a little bit, wary of telling all the details up front. After all, we would like to be seen in a positive light.

“He began to ask me questions, as though he had learned to remind himself to do so, and I wondered what or who had taught him that lesson, which many people never learn.�

I can’t think of very many times when in a few short days I’ve had meaningful conversations with people I know quite well, much less with strangers or mere acquaintances. Yet, the narrator of this novel did just that while on a trip to Athens to teach a writing workshop. I’m a bit envious of her, to be honest. I generally don’t find people to be all that open upon introduction, or even during second or third encounters. People chat, sure, but usually it’s all quite casual. I often wish those I know more personally would open up further as well. Conversations typically skim the surface rather than diving deep. In any case, Cusk’s narrator gets involved in a number of thoughtful and sparkling dialogue with mainly other writers, publishers, students, as well as an airplane companion. I’d like to live in this world- one in which people communicate openly! While the narrator, Faye, learns about these others, we in turn get to know Faye more intimately.

“� among other things a marriage is a system of belief, a story, and though it manifests itself in things that are real enough, the impulse that drives it is ultimately mysterious.�

While this novel has no real plot to speak of, there are some themes that are returned to frequently as the characters engage with one another over food or drink, in cafés, on planes and boats. Marriage, divorce, children, love and relationships, and the writing process are all explored through these exchanges. Some conversationalists are more loquacious than others, reflecting a greater sense of loneliness. As I was drawn into the heart of the novel, the pain became more and more palpable, particularly that of the narrator. In the end, I was left questioning whether opening up to others is in fact healing, or if it leaves us with an even greater ache, sensing the misunderstandings and chasms between others no matter how hard we try. In the end, my feelings were scattered. I felt somewhat like the wilted flower in the vase here on my table, yet delighted and energized by the scintillating prose and the brilliance of that Greek sun! I’d like some more Rachel Cusk in my life, please!

“� I was suddenly filled with the most extraordinary sense of existence as a secret pain, an inner torment it was impossible to share with others, who asked you to attend to them while remaining oblivious to what was inside you…�

“I felt that I could swim for miles, out into the ocean: a desire for freedom, an impulse to move, tugged at me as though it were a thread fastened to my chest.�
135 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Outline.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 6, 2019 – Shelved as: contemporary-literary
July 6, 2019 – Shelved
September 11, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
October 29, 2021 – Started Reading
November 1, 2021 – Finished Reading
November 7, 2021 – Shelved as: series-book-in-series

Comments Showing 1-50 of 64 (64 new)


JimZ This for the first 50% of the book was edging to be a DNF for me and it ended up as a 4-star reading for me. I grew to like it very much. Please keep or bump up on your TBR list!


Candi JimZ wrote: "This for the first 50% of the book was edging to be a DNF for me and it ended up as a 4-star reading for me. I grew to like it very much. Please keep or bump up on your TBR list!"

I'm glad it improved quite a lot, Jim! I will keep it on my list for sure :)


message 3: by Angela M (new) - added it

Angela M Sounds fascinating. Terrific review, Candi. Much food for thought.


message 4: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa I have quite a few of these conversations in my life. I think whether or not they are healing depends on the speaker and the receiver. When both parties open their hearts it can be an amazing experience. And the speaker has to be discerning enough to gauge the receiver and then brave enough to reach out without 100% certainty that she/he will be heard/understood.
I understand that Cusk isn't for everyone. As I already have Second Place on my TBR. I think I'll start with that one and see what I think.


message 5: by Bonnie G. (new) - added it

Bonnie G. Wonderful review, Candi. I have been intending to dive into this trilogy for some time, and your review made me realized I need to do that soon. I was particularly intrigued by your words: "I was left questioning whether opening up to others is in fact healing, or if it leaves us with an even greater ache." What a thought, that human connection leaves us emptier. I don't believe that myself, but it makes me very curious about the book.


Left Coast Justin I've been wondering which Cusk I should read next. After reading your review I'm guessing it'll be this one.


message 7: by Nat (new)

Nat K What an amazing review Candi. You bring up so many ponderings which there are no answers for. I guess most people are guarded by nature, and those who can open up more easily are a rarity.


Candi Angela M wrote: "Sounds fascinating. Terrific review, Candi. Much food for thought."

It was very thought-provoking, Angela. I hope to read the next in the series. Thank you!


Candi Lisa wrote: "I have quite a few of these conversations in my life. I think whether or not they are healing depends on the speaker and the receiver. When both parties open their hearts it can be an amazing exper..."

I think that's just it, Lisa. The receiver has to be willing to understand where the speaker is coming from. I very often find that the receivers tend to listen from their own point of view. Perhaps it's a lack of empathy in some respects. The receiver then says things in return like "you shouldn't feel that way" or worse yet, tells the speaker exactly how they should feel. Receivers also tend to have their own agendas that someone close to them fits in a certain way, which then leads to responses that suit how they would like to see things, not as they are. Anyway, I'm just ruminating further here. Thanks for the thoughtful comment, which got me thinking once again, Lisa!


Candi Bonnie G. wrote: "Wonderful review, Candi. I have been intending to dive into this trilogy for some time, and your review made me realized I need to do that soon. I was particularly intrigued by your words: "I was l..."

Thanks so much, Bonnie. I found this to be quite unique. It's all about the ideas rather than the plot. Just people talking to one another. We get the inner thoughts of the narrator. That's about it! Oh, and the Greek scenery - can't complain about that! I think if you see my response to Lisa, you'll see a bit more what I mean about communicating. I think that when communication is attempted, but somehow fails in some way, then the speaker is left feeling that gap, that sense of loneliness. When the listener is truly a good one, then I think that gap closes and the experience is more rewarding. It has to go both ways, of course :) It's a very thoughtful book, and one that keeps on giving after finishing!


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "I've been wondering which Cusk I should read next. After reading your review I'm guessing it'll be this one."

Are you a fan of Cusk, Justin? Other than the next in this trilogy, would you recommend another? I definitely would like to read more of her work!


Judith E I think, once you speak, you are open to judgement and that keeps many thoughts internalized. Maybe if we could be anonymous speakers like anonymous writers, we would hear all sorts of things! Sounds like a book with a great premise.


Candi Nat wrote: "What an amazing review Candi. You bring up so many ponderings which there are no answers for. I guess most people are guarded by nature, and those who can open up more easily are a rarity."

Thanks very much, Nat! People are typically guarded, I believe. You know what I've found though - those that read as so many of us here do are the ones that seem to open up and truly listen more. As I said before, I think it has a lot to do with empathy, and reading gives an extra boost!


message 14: by Charles (last edited Nov 08, 2021 05:21AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Charles I've had extraordinary encounters while traveling and struck meaningful conversations when and where I least expected them. I had no idea the book featured these dynamics. Add the Triton's trumpet conch on the cover, which I always found impossible to ignore, and now your glowing review of the novel and... damn, I have to read Outline now. Great job in selling me this, Candi!


message 15: by Anne (new)

Anne Fab review, Candi. This novel sounds great but I wonder how well the narrative flows, meaning, I wonder if my mind would wander without much happening.....


message 16: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Great writing in this review, Candi. You manage to put your finger precisely where it needs to be, the introductory passages have not a wasted word. I often feel the same about conversation with good friends. We spend so much time skimming the surface of things instead of going deep into what moves us and explains who we are. I guess I'd feel envious of Cusk as well, but I am adding her as a writer to explore, sooner rather than later I'd say.


message 17: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue K H Your excellent review makes this sound intriguing, Candi. It sounds like you need to be in an introspective mood for it though. The novel seems to go back and forth about opening up as we probably all do. I think there is some healing power in it, but it's greater value is probably that it gives greater understanding to others about why we are the way we are and that's a good thing for those who care about us.


Violeta I love your review, Candi, even though I didn't exactly love the book.
I had read it almost upon publication, before it became fashionable. I stumbled upon it in an airport bookstore (!) and bought it without being remotely familiar with the author just because I was intrigued by the setting. Greece and airplanes: my life. I didn't warm up to her writing and I have a feeling that 'warm up' is not what she herself would have wanted from her readers. Her coolness works for some but not for me. Maybe because I'm familiar with the blazing sun and the 'heat' it generates in a boat in the Aegean and the protagonist's aloofness seemed so odd. I loved the last quote you chose, though; it's a compensation.

I'm happy it worked for you and I'm happy it gave you a taste of my corner of the world. If you ever decide to experience it firsthand, you know where to find me ;-)


message 19: by Left Coast Justin (last edited Nov 08, 2021 09:39AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Left Coast Justin Candi writes: Are you a fan of Cusk, Justin? Other than the next in this trilogy, would you recommend another? I definitely would like to read more of her work!

I've only read two Cusks, Candi, which were Aftermath and The Last Supper. They were both weird enough to keep me engaged. I wouldn't yet call myself a fan, but maybe I just need to pick the right book to be persuaded! Both of the books I read were non-fiction, and I'm curious about her fiction. But your review of this one is interesting enough that I'll try it before moving on to Outline.


message 20: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Fantastic review Candi!


Laura That first quote about the man who had LEARNT to ask questions also struck me - as I've found that so many men simply don't bother. It seems to create the sense of - not interested. I liked Cusk in this - I thought her observations acute and interesting - and yes that one about marriage makes me remember more and more. I was disappointed with Second Place, but I would like to get hold of the rest of this series.


message 22: by Pedro (last edited Nov 08, 2021 02:38PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Pedro Candi, I don't know if it's going to make any sense but I read this whole review as a big question mark. I can't speak for you or anyone else but I think it all comes down to masks. Not the ones we all have been wearing these past couple of years but the ones people usually wear out of fear. Also, I think we all have different definitions for what "meaningful conversations" are. I've learned that for lots of people a meaningful conversation is only considered meaningful if it is about them, I'm afraid.

And you wouldn't believe me if I told you about the sort of people that usually tries to start a conversation with me when I'm on holiday, for example. Scary stuff, really. Ahah.

Excellent review. Keep them coming. ;D


Candi Judith wrote: "I think, once you speak, you are open to judgement and that keeps many thoughts internalized. Maybe if we could be anonymous speakers like anonymous writers, we would hear all sorts of things! Soun..."

I do agree with this, Judith. We certainly worry what others will think or say. I do as well, but then next thing I know, I'm oversharing anyway :D I'd love to hear what you think of this one, if you get around to reading it! A book about conversation, which leads to lots of discussion - how apt :)


Bianca Marvellous review, Candi. You ask/ponder some questions that I've been thinking about myself.


Candi Charles wrote: "I've had extraordinary encounters while traveling and struck meaningful conversations when and where I least expected them. I had no idea the book featured these dynamics. Add the Triton's trumpet ..."

See, this is exactly why I need to travel more, Charles ;D Trips to Disney World and the Adirondack Mountains don't necessarily inspire the most thoughtful conversations :D And that cover! Yes, it's very cool, isn't it? And rather symbolic as well. I'd love for you to read this and tell me what you think of it. I'm happy I've enticed you, as I know you like to keep your list nice and trim ;)


Candi Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "Fab review, Candi. This novel sounds great but I wonder how well the narrative flows, meaning, I wonder if my mind would wander without much happening....."

Thank you, Anne! Well, I can see your point there. It is one that requires a bit of concentration, in my opinion. Not because it's difficult to understand, but because of the structure. I wonder if any of her other novels would work better. This is my first, so I can't really say!


Candi Dolors wrote: "Great writing in this review, Candi. You manage to put your finger precisely where it needs to be, the introductory passages have not a wasted word. I often feel the same about conversation with go..."

Thanks a bunch for your kind comment, Dolors. Maybe as readers we expect to get as much out of our personal interactions as we do from our novels. Or perhaps I'm just really nosy and want to find out what makes everyone tick! :D Actually though, I think it's a curiosity and a desire to learn more - about people and the world in general. If read Cusk one day, do let me know!


Candi Sue wrote: "Your excellent review makes this sound intriguing, Candi. It sounds like you need to be in an introspective mood for it though. The novel seems to go back and forth about opening up as we probably ..."

Oh yes, Sue. Quite right. It's all very introspective! I think opening up is a great thing as long as both parties are prepared to understand that everyone is different. We don't all have to have the same motivations, fears, dreams, etc. It's difficult for some people to accept, but I think it's what makes life so interesting :)


Candi Violeta wrote: "I love your review, Candi, even though I didn't exactly love the book.
I had read it almost upon publication, before it became fashionable. I stumbled upon it in an airport bookstore (!) and bought..."


Thanks very much, Violeta! In the airport bookstore?! Not what one would expect to find there :D I do agree with your assessment of the 'coolness' of the narrator. As if one couldn't quite get close to her, even knowing her inner thoughts. But then I wonder if that was one way in which we were to understand how alienated she still felt in her feelings, despite all of these "heart to heart" conversations? I really don't know! I'm still trying to figure it all out.

Now, I would love to feel the heat of that sun while out on a boat in the Aegean sea for real! If I ever make it out to Greece, you will be the first person I tell, friend :)


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "Candi writes: Are you a fan of Cusk, Justin? Other than the next in this trilogy, would you recommend another? I definitely would like to read more of her work!

I've only read two Cusks, Candi, w..."


Well, I'm certainly glad to hear you weren't turned off by Cusk, Justin! It seems there are a few choices to turn to in her writing yet. I'm looking forward to it :)


Candi Maureen wrote: "Fantastic review Candi!"

Many thanks, Maureen! :)


message 32: by Laysee (new)

Laysee A thoughtful review, Candi, that made me reflect on the effect the quality of conversations have on relationships. It's hard to know how much to share of things that matter to even people close to us. Guess it is a risk we all take. But I think that when people do authentically connect with one another, they do end up having a deeper and more meaningful relationship.


Terence M - [Quot libros, quam breve tempus!] Your review was thoughtful and interesting, Candi. Reading your review and others, I understand that I do not understand 'literary fiction', if that's what it is, and I am unlikely to understand it, either, but I really liked the cover!😏


message 34: by Vishakha (new)

Vishakha A lovely, thoughtful write-up, Candi. I enjoyed your thoughts on opening up and getting to know others more deeply. True, most of the times we remain at the surface, dancing our way through casual chit-chats, shared interests, latest news and so on. And it seems like such a privilege to go a bit deeper, to be understood well and most importantly, to misquote Gatsby, "to be understood just as far as you wanted to be understood". But to be misunderstood even after laying bare our innards is an even greater ache, as you've touched upon so beautifully.


Candi Laura Anne wrote: "That first quote about the man who had LEARNT to ask questions also struck me - as I've found that so many men simply don't bother. It seems to create the sense of - not interested. I liked Cusk in..."

Glad you like that quote, Laura Anne. I've found it to be true of a lot of both men and women, actually. Many people aren't all that interested really. Except for a special few. I agree with your assessment of Cusk and her writing - very intelligent. I have Second Place on my shortlist, but I think perhaps I'll grab next in this series first.


Candi Pedro wrote: "Candi, I don't know if it's going to make any sense but I read this whole review as a big question mark. I can't speak for you or anyone else but I think it all comes down to masks. Not the ones we..."

Yes, that's exactly it, Pedro - a big question mark. It left me wondering about people even more, their motivations, etc. When it seems as if honest communication would solve a lot of problems, it seems the most difficult thing in the world to achieve. And you are right about many of those conversations being lopsided. Even when people (especially those close to you) ask questions, they really want the answers to fit into their own agendas. It's hard for people to understand everyone is quite different from one another.

I'd love to hear about these conversations people have tried to strike up on your holidays :D Thanks for your thoughtful comment, friend :)


Candi Bianca wrote: "Marvellous review, Candi. You ask/ponder some questions that I've been thinking about myself."

Thanks so much, Bianca! If we weren't an entire continent and humongous ocean away from one another, we could sit and chat about these questions someday :) For now, I'm glad we have books as a vehicle for these conversations.


message 38: by Steven (new)

Steven Godin Fine review, Candi. I'll have to think about reading her some time.
This sounds like a good place to start.


message 39: by Barbara (new)

Barbara This author has been on my list for a long time, Candi. Your fine review will force me to move Cusk to the top of the list.


Mark  Porton Sooper Dooper Review Candi!! You're right about the different perspectives of say first person to third person, it entirely different for sure. I really like the point you made in that first paragraph - also the 'holding back' bits of information, we all do that - some better than others. I love the idea of exploring chats with strangers - as you say if we do, it's usually superficial. It's such a shame, everyone is staring at their phones (or reading a book) and wearing earphones in public transport nowadays so it's hard to chat. When it does happen I often end up with 'crackpots' as I am often smiling like a village idiot when I'm looking for a seat - DON'T DO THAT!! This one does sound interesting, nice one! :))


message 41: by Antoinette (new) - added it

Antoinette Awesome review, Candi. You have brought up some interesting points. How many people actually bother to have meaningful conversations? How many people truly know our deepest self? It’s amazing what strangers tell me at times. I meet all kinds of people when I walk with my dog, and I come away with more than I ever asked for. Sometimes there is safety in talking to a stranger.
It sounds like this book would make for a very interesting discussion, as long as people are willing to share from deep down.


Candi Laysee wrote: "A thoughtful review, Candi, that made me reflect on the effect the quality of conversations have on relationships. It's hard to know how much to share of things that matter to even people close to ..."

Thanks so much, Laysee. I think the key really is to "authentically connect" as you so perfectly state. And truly listening is a key to the whole process as well. It is a risk to share, but if we don't take the risk now and then, we are left feeling rather shallow, I think.


Candi Terence M (Away with the pixies sometimes) wrote: "Your review was thoughtful and interesting, Candi. Reading your review and others, I understand that I do not understand 'literary fiction', if that's what it is, and I am unlikely to understand it..."

Many thanks, Terence! This isn't the sort of writing everyone will take to, and that's just fine! A lot of what I'm doing here is thinking out loud as well, which makes it seem even more complicated. It's really me that's the complicated one ;D


Candi Vishakha wrote: "A lovely, thoughtful write-up, Candi. I enjoyed your thoughts on opening up and getting to know others more deeply. True, most of the times we remain at the surface, dancing our way through casual ..."

Thank you very much for your keen insights as well, Vishakha. I'm really enjoying all the feedback from my friends here. It is truly a lonely feeling to open up and to feel completely separate even still. I think it's something a lot of people struggle with.


Candi Steven wrote: "Fine review, Candi. I'll have to think about reading her some time.
This sounds like a good place to start."


Thank you, Steven. For me, this was a perfect starting point. I'd love to hear your thoughts on it if you decide to give it a try :)


Candi Barbara wrote: "This author has been on my list for a long time, Candi. Your fine review will force me to move Cusk to the top of the list."

She was on my list for a while too, Barbara. I finally decided to take the plunge and am very glad I did. Thanks for your kind words :)


message 47: by Linda (new)

Linda Wonderful review! Beautifully written!


Candi Mark wrote: "Sooper Dooper Review Candi!! You're right about the different perspectives of say first person to third person, it entirely different for sure. I really like the point you made in that first paragr..."

Thanks a bunch, Mark! You are right. People are often engaged quite personally with their devices, music, etc. I don't necessarily want to strike up a conversation with a complete stranger myself at times. I've had some weird encounters in the past :D But even our conversations with close friends and family are often guarded. We are an odd bunch, us homo sapiens! :D


Candi Antoinette wrote: "Awesome review, Candi. You have brought up some interesting points. How many people actually bother to have meaningful conversations? How many people truly know our deepest self? It’s amazing what ..."

Thank you, Antoinette! Of course, when engaged in conversation with strangers one doesn't have as much on the line, so to speak. So perhaps it is easier to say things you may not share with close relations. I can just imagine you with your dog, getting caught up in some strange chats!! :D


Candi Linda wrote: "Wonderful review! Beautifully written!"

Thanks for your lovely comment, Linda! :)


« previous 1
back to top