Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

RandomAnthony's Reviews > Stoner

Stoner by John  Williams
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
721021
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites
Read 2 times. Last read June 22, 2020 to February 14, 2021.

John Williams's Stoner blew me away. I've never read anything like it and some passages left me moved to the point of exhaustion. When I finished I put down the book (well, the Nook), picked it up again, and re-read highlighted pages. Stoner gave me strength; if you believe that the right books find you at the right time, as sometimes I believe, this book found me at the right time.

Stoner outlines the life of a farm kid who, at his dad's recommendation, attends college for agricultural studies but switches to literature and becomes a low-level university faculty member for most of his career. He marries an affluent city girl, starts teaching, and loves his daughter. His marriage begins to crumble and he starts an affair with a student. He runs afoul of university politics and lands an insulting teaching schedule. Williams manages, with breathtaking grace, to create complex, nuanced characters through lean, careful sentences. He'll pass years with a few heartbreaking paragraphs and allow the reader to generate what's between the lines. Stoner is like a Rothko painting put to words; empty blotches, perhaps, at first glance, but sublime, minimalist depth with time and attention. Characters change, but not all the way, then change back again, and, if a happy ending emerges, it's a still, sublime happiness.

I'm a teacher so I was, of course, overlaying my own background on the text while reading. But I think I would have appreciated Stoner anyway. The novel's power rises from its quiet, subtle movement. An excellent introduction (I don't think I've ever said that before...most introductions are stupid) in the NYRB edition includes a rate Williams interview in which the author describes the main character as heroic for, essentially, sticking to his own values and doing the best he can. What might appear as small failures are potentially victories in the context of Stoner's values (which, in other characters' eyes, sometimes appear as stubbornness). And even if you can't control every element of your environment, the politics at your job, how the people you love respond to challenges, and other variables across the multitudes of contexts, you can respond with grace and dignity. And when, nearing death, he experiences this:

A sense of his own identity came upon him with a sudden force, and he felt the power of it. He was himself, and he knew what he had been

I wanted to raise my fists in the air and recognize all of the invisible punk rock people living quietly, without affectation, holding as true as possible to their cores in the face of unrelenting messages that there is something wrong with them and they should feel other than they do and be other than what they are.

Stoner is amazing. You might not like it, I suppose, as some of my GR friends didn't. But even glancing through the text, searching out quotes, makes me feel more alive. For me, Stoner is one of those books. Thank you, Mr. Williams. You made my weekend. And beyond.

P.S. In some of the book's NYRB promotional materials Tom Hanks praises Stoner. I swear, Mr. Hanks, if you turn this novel into a movie, I will beat your ass. At least on the internet. I'm afraid you'll include scenes in which you're standing on a leaf-blown quad, deep in thought, staring into the sky, while treacly strings play in the background and the camera pans high and away. Don't fucking ruin this novel, Mr. Hanks. I'm warning you.
265 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Stoner.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 3, 2012 – Shelved
July 5, 2012 – Started Reading
Finished Reading
July 14, 2013 – Shelved as: favorites
June 22, 2020 – Started Reading
February 14, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

This book, and this writer, are insanely good. His novel AUGUSTUS is the finest novel I've ever read on ancient Rome, and his novel BUTCHER'S CROSSING is as good as it gets for a Western.


RandomAnthony Okay, you've solidified it, sir, I'm getting this one. I read the first few pages on the Nook preview last night and liked them. Your recommendations are high-quality. And I can't seem to find the book in the library system, so a rare purchase is in order. Thanks, sir. David K. hates this book, too, and anything that he hates is usually at least interesting.


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

If I were within two hours' driving distance of South Bend, I would accost David K.


RandomAnthony Imagine if we showed up on his doorstep. I think he'd mistake us for hallucinations.


message 5: by David (last edited Jul 04, 2012 01:22PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

David I'd love to see you guys on my doorstep. Even in the service of fisticuffs.

Actually, RA, if you're not committed to the Nook version, I can send you the NYRB edition. I obviously have no sentimental attachment to it. (I hope you see this before you buy it!)


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Hey, who tipped him off?


David I saw you two Chatty Cathys on my feed. Whenever I see someone talking about this dumb book, I'm there.


RandomAnthony I buy Stoner via the Nook: 2:42PM

David texts me that I can have his copy: 3:38PM

Fuck! Thanks anyway, David. I started the novel this afternoon ensconced in one of only two rooms in the house with air conditioning. And I was going to read it while taking a bath but I'm afraid of dropping the Nook in the water so I read Faulkner instead.


message 9: by David (last edited Jul 04, 2012 04:31PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

David I'm telling you... I can't give Stoner away! Nobody wants that awful book.

While we're on the subject of NYRBs, I also have Rock Crystal by Adalbert Stifter if either of you fine fellows want it.

You don't have central air, RA? That sucks. I'm as cool as a cuke right now even though hell is right outside.


RandomAnthony No, our house is ancient and not well-suited for central air. So we have white-trash wall units scattered throughout the space. Normally I don't care. But today sucks.

David, did you read African in Greenland yet? I remember you mentioning, at the start of your NYRB marathon, you might.


message 11: by Jessica (new)

Jessica RandomAnthony wrote: David, did you read African in Greenland yet?

I've read that RA. It's excellent.


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

Faulkner in the tub? That makes me horny.


RandomAnthony It was a long bath. I'll leave it at that. And yes, Jess, now I remember!


message 14: by David (new) - rated it 1 star

David My vote for this was very, very unethusiastic.


Chris David wrote: "My vote for this was very, very unethusiastic."

Is that a mash-up of unethical and enthusiastic?

My vote for this review, by the way, was very, very enthusiastic. I may just read it next as a result of RA's review.


message 16: by Rod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rod Maybe he meant "euthenasiastic," meaning that he thinks anyone who liked this book should be euthanized.

For my part, I'm right in the middle between RandomAnthony and David. Some of the problems that David had with Stoner also bothered me, but they weren't deal-breakers for me like they were for him. However, they were enough to keep me from being as enthusiastic about it as RandomAnthony was, despite a strong emotional reaction to it.


message 17: by Melki (new)

Melki I enjoyed picturing you standing on a leaf-blown quad, deep in thought, staring into the sky, while treacly strings play in the background, shaking your fist at the sky and yelling "Hanks! Goddamnit, Hanks!"


message 18: by Clackamas (new)

Clackamas RA's review made me want to read it. David can send his copy to me! *grin*


RandomAnthony Thanks, people! And Melks, my fist-shaking would be enthusiastic:)


Eddie Watkins Excellent review! If there are any unwanted copies floating around I'll take one.


RandomAnthony Thanks, Elizabeth! Do I get to punch photographers and play in a horrible band, too?

David's got one, Eddie...thanks...if I hadn't ebooked it, I'd send you mine.


message 22: by knig (new) - rated it 4 stars

knig What a great take on Stoner. I just finished it, and like you, I am blown away. But, whereas you say 'I wanted to raise my fists in the air and recognize all of the invisible punk rock people living quietly, without affectation, holding as true as possible to their cores in the face of unrelenting messages that there is something wrong with them and they should feel other than they do and be other than what they are', and whilst I do accept that, on one level, and it is an excellent precis of what this book may be about, I do have trouble reconciling in my mind whether overall (and regardless of what Williams actually says, as opposed to what comes across in the book), ‘Stoner� is actually an affirmation or an indictment of that very concept: I feel it can easily go either way, and its precisely this ambiguity which makes it so memorable for me.


RandomAnthony That's an excellent point, Knig-o-lass. Your last sentence about the novel's ambiguity is spot-on, I think. Thanks.


Sarah Mcinerney Nice review. Fantastic novel. And a favourite of many legendary writers


Dolors That was maybe the best book I read last year. Was so moved in the end I couldn't keep my tears from running freely. Sad, beautiful and realistically suffocating. I loved it.


Jason A great film can be made from any great novel. Why would a film necessarily ruin the book?


Sophie Vyncke Felt exactly the same way!


Zhanna this book seriously called my name.......it just came to mind on it's own with no connection at all, a whole year after i bought it and it was collecting dust on the bookshelf


message 29: by Sue Ann (new)

Sue Ann Painter Stoner is a marvelous novel with deep roots in Regionalist art and literature. Stoner is a stoic, mythical character, living the life of the heart and mind. His story may be sad but not depressing.


Deborah @RandomAnatomy Your review of 'Stoner' matches my experience of the book. I became exhausted, I cried, I re-read and realized that the book had come to me at exactly the right time in my life. I recommended this book for my Bookclub this month. I KNOW there will be dissenters. Usually, this would leave me feeling a little aggrieved at a perceived insult to my choice and taste. But 'Stoner' has left me in a place where I am at one with myself (as William finally was) and with an acceptance of the differences which make people who they are. An exceptional reward for having taken the time to read this remarkable novel. Thank you for such a succinct review.


Marilyn Peters Deborah - my sentiments entirely!


message 32: by Rod (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rod Deborah: You rated it 1 star?


message 33: by Mark (new)

Mark Thanks, great review.


message 34: by Ned (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ned This review was like a mirror of mine, if only I could write. But I can read, and would never have found this without this silly GR invention.


message 35: by Marcela (new) - added it

Marcela "I've never read anything like it and some passages left me moved to the point of exhaustion." describe exactly my feelings.


Angela thanks, great review!


Julie G Hi Anthony,
I don't think I've run into you on here before. Your reviews have a vitality in them that is fantastic. God, I hope you have this much energy in your daily life!
What a vibrant review for a most beloved book. Thank you.


Matthew Ignoffo This is a perfect review. I agree with you on all of your points.


back to top