ŷ

JimZ's Reviews > Pew

Pew by Catherine Lacey
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
99765491
's review

really liked it

I was impressed by this author’s writing in “Nobody is Ever Missing� and gave that novel 4 stars, and will give this novel 4 stars too because again, this woman’s writing, is sometimes just striking. Very clever her use of words, some of those phrases, descriptions of things � I never came across such descriptions, but a number of them resonated with me. Impressive.

I think my rating would have gone down if this book had been any longer than its 204 pages. Because, to me, although I thought the book had a clever structure to it, it would have gotten old and repetitive if it had gone on any longer. The length of the book seemed to be just right.

The structure was that various people in the unnamed town would drop into a chapter and be talking with Pew, a person of indeterminate age and sex and race. I could have said “talk to� because Pew said next to nothing in the book, but s/he did listen and sometimes s/he nodded…I think one time s/he shook somebody’s hand when proffered it to her/him. The rare times s/he talked was typically one word and I think her/his longest utterances were “I can’t remember� and “I was sleeping�.

Total times Pew talked that I counted was 9 times.

You’re not going to get a whole lot from her/him if you want to know the plot from what s/he says. It is her/his memories of things in the past, usually incomplete and difficult for her/him to latch on to, that one gets a disturbing sense that s/he has been violated or abused…almost to the point of catatonia. And w/he makes her/his most utterances to a young man, Nelson, who was orphaned and witnessed his whole family being killed in another country�

This book, near the end, reminded me a lot of ‘The Lottery� by Shirley Jackson. There is an annual Forgiveness Festival that the church members are referring to throughout the book, and from what the reader can gather it does not seem that it’s you ordinary hum-drum run-of-the mill annual church festival. Like something nasty is going to happen. Did I already say that this book reminds me of Shirley Jackson’s The Lottery? Oh, I did? Then it is time for me to end my review. 🙃

Book reviews:


� interview with Lacey about the book:

56 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Pew.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 16, 2020 – Started Reading
November 16, 2020 – Finished Reading
November 17, 2020 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Brandice Great review Jim, this (still) sounds good � Thanks for the rec!


JimZ Brandice wrote: "Great review Jim, this (still) sounds good � Thanks for the rec!"
You are most welcome!


message 3: by Judith (last edited Nov 18, 2020 06:58AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Judith E She was skilled at giving us slight clues and lets the reader make their own conclusions. You’re right-any longer and it would have been repetitive.


message 4: by Cecily (last edited Nov 17, 2020 05:06AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cecily I'm glad you enjoyed this, but I'm afraid I winced at your repeated mention of Pew as "she/her". A significant point of the story, as I interpreted it, was that Pew's gender, race, and even whether they were adult or child was unclear to everyone, as you yourself state (even Pew expresses uncertainty).


message 5: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Terrific review, Jim! Sounds rather intriguing :)


message 6: by Kimber (new)

Kimber I can't help adding this- it sounds mesmerizing!


message 7: by Nat (new) - added it

Nat K Fab review JIm, I can see why you enjoyed this so much. It certainly has an air of intrigue. And just over 200 pages! I love how novellas can have such an impact. Looks like I may have to move this up Mt.TBR after all 🙂


message 8: by Neale (new) - added it

Neale Great review JimZ. You have convinced me to move it up! :-)


JimZ Nat wrote: "Fab review JIm, I can see why you enjoyed this so much. It certainly has an air of intrigue. And just over 200 pages! I love how novellas can have such an impact. Looks like I may have to move this..."
I like the 'Mt. TBR'! I think I will shamelessly use that (pirate it) now and then!


message 10: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Cecily wrote: "I'm glad you enjoyed this, but I'm afraid I winced at your repeated mention of Pew as "she/her". A significant point of the story, as I interpreted it, was that Pew's gender, race, and even whether..."
Point well taken. I changed to s/he.


Rachel Thanks for your review. I added it to my wish list at the library.


message 12: by Usha (new) - added it

Usha Convincing review Jim!


message 13: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Another one on my list that you endorsed by a fine review, Jim - you make the structure sound truly intriguing.


Rachel I started this novel and put it down due to what I perceived as its Christian overtones. As I am not a believer, that bothered me. Does anyone else feel the same? Did I give up too soon?


Cecily Rachel wrote: "I started this novel and put it down due to what I perceived as its Christian overtones. As I am not a believer, that bothered me. Does anyone else feel the same? Did I give up too soon?"

I realise this is Jim's review, but you did ask anyone else: I'm an atheist, and I loved this book, which I don't think was in any way preaching or even showing religion in a positive light.


message 16: by Tania (new)

Tania Looks intriguing; my library has 'Nobody is Ever Missing' so I've put it on my library list.


Teresa Jim, I too thought of Shirley Jackson's The Lottery. The ending was different than I thought it would be, but still themes were similar.


back to top