ŷ

Angela M 's Reviews > Long Island

Long Island by Colm Tóibín
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4685500
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: netgalley-reviews, 2024-favorites

I was as drawn to Eilis Lacey Fiorello as I was in Brooklyn when I first met her, even more so, perhaps. I found her more mature and stronger. I found it sad, though, that she’s lonely, 20 years after emigrating from Ireland and still not really feeling a part of her husband’s extended Italian family who live houses away from each other on Long Island. However, she manages to live her life, care for her family and maintain some independence and work as a bookkeeper. That is, until her husband Tony commits a transgression that turns their lives upside down. Sad because she has no one to call. I was impressed with Eilis� strength, though, as the family plots to take care of things going against Eilis� wishes as if what is happening doesn’t affect her and if she should have no say . She takes the reins and decides to return home to Ireland to visit her mother after twenty years.

Anyone who has read Brooklyn knows that Eilis is a complex character and that things were complicated when she returned to Ireland back then. As you might suspect, they will again be complicated upon her return. Told not just from Eilis� point of view, but also from the man she once loved and her best friend, we get an introspective and intimate view of each one filled with uncertainty and emotions that are so realistic . Tóibín also gives us another ending that has me wanting to know what the future holds for Eilis. His alluring writing has me wanting to get to those books of his that I have not yet read . And hopefully a third book about Eilis.

I received a copy of this book from Scribner through NetGalley.
218 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Long Island.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 21, 2023 – Shelved
December 21, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
May 11, 2024 – Started Reading
May 11, 2024 – Shelved as: netgalley-reviews
May 16, 2024 – Shelved as: 2024-favorites
May 16, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 63 (63 new)


message 1: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Lucky you! I still haven't gotten to Brooklyn yet.


Lisa (NY) I'm reading it now and enjoying!


switterbug (Betsey) I'm also reading and enjoying it now!


Angela M Lisa, I’d recommend reading Brooklyn first ,


Angela M Lisa(NY), glad you are enjoying it, too . Have to get my thoughts together on this one !


Angela M Betsey , glad you are enjoying it, too ! Looking forward to your thoughts as well as Lisa’s.


message 7: by � Sandi � (last edited May 16, 2024 12:38PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

♥ Sandi ❣	I just picked this up from the library. But it has been so long since I read Brooklyn that I also picked up that CD. Just started listening to that last night. Wanted to refresh my memory before I started Long Island. Too much time in between them. Will read your review once I read Long Island...lol! 🙈


message 8: by Angela M (last edited May 16, 2024 12:43PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Angela M � Sandi � wrote: "I just picked this up from the library. But it has been so long since I read Brooklyn that I also picked up that CD. Just started listening to that last night. Wanted to refresh my memory before I ..."

Sandi, it’s been a while for me, too, but I remembered quite a bit of it. There is also enough told of what happened in Brooklyn to refresh your memory .


message 9: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Oh my, Angela. I thrilled to know there’s another book on Ellis of ‘Brooklyn�. I’d love to read it one day. Thank you for putting this on my radar. Love your empathic review, Angela.


Angela M Laysee , thanks so much .


message 11: by Rosh (new)

Rosh Interesting review, Angela! This sounds good, but I think I'll read the first book first and get to know the characters better.


Angela M Rosh , I would recommend that to fully appreciate this one . Thanks!


Lisa (NY) Your review captures so many of my feelings about this novel which I just finished. I listen to a short interview by Toibin today. He said he hates sequels, but you never know he did one�


Angela M Thanks, Lisa. Now I hope he makes it a trilogy. Very curious to know what happens when Eilis return to Long Island.


Antoinette I loved Brooklyn and am really looking forward to this one. Excellent review, Angela!


Cathrine ☯️ Great endorsement. I'm looking forward to this one.


message 17: by Jodi (last edited May 16, 2024 03:33PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jodi Beautiful review, Angela! Oh, how wonderful it will be if Toibin publishes yet another book about Eilis' life! Two more days until I start on Long Island and I cannot wait!!!


Karen Wonderful review, Angela!
I just finished the book myself.. flew through it.. loved it!


Angela M Antoinette wrote: "I loved Brooklyn and am really looking forward to this one. Excellent review, Angela!"

Thanks, Antoinette . Looking forward to your thoughts.


Angela M Cathrine ☯️ wrote: "Great endorsement. I'm looking forward to this one."

Hope you enjoy, C. A complex story, but a good one. Thanks.


Angela M Jodi wrote: "Beautiful review, Angela! Oh, how wonderful it will be if Toibin publishes yet another book about Eilis' life! Two more days until I start on Long Island and I cannot wait!!!"

Thanks very much, Jodi. I’ll be watching for your thoughts.


Angela M Karen wrote: "Wonderful review, Angela!
I just finished the book myself.. flew through it.. loved it!"


Thanks so much, Karen. Look forward to your review.


message 23: by Bianca (new)

Bianca Terrific review, Angela. I haven't read Toibin, I did watch the adaptation of Brooklyn, so I know the plot.


message 24: by Carmel (new) - added it

Carmel Hanes Sweet review my friend.


Angela M Bianca, thanks . He’s worth reading .


Angela M Carmel, thanks so much !


message 27: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen I do still need to read Brooklyn but will be adding it to my list. Nice review, Angela!


message 28: by Liz (new)

Liz Excellent review.


Margo Laurie So looking forward to this - glad to hear it's a 5� read, and not a disappointment after Brooklyn. Wonderful review, Angela


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader I’m so excited to be reading Brooklyn and this one back to back very soon, Angela. Your lovely review has me even more ecstatic. I cann’t wait to meet Eilis!


Linda Wonderful review, Angela. Loved this one, too. Sure hope that a third book in this series is in the making. So good.


message 32: by Beth (new) - added it

Beth Angela,m I have to read book #1 in order to follow book 2 of this series, and enjoy it?


Angela M Canadian Jen wrote: "I do still need to read Brooklyn but will be adding it to my list. Nice review, Angela!"

Thanks, Jen. Definitely read Brooklyn first to get a better understanding of Eilis .


Angela M Liz wrote: "Excellent review."

Thanks so much, Liz.


Angela M Margo wrote: "So looking forward to this - glad to hear it's a 5� read, and not a disappointment after Brooklyn. Wonderful review, Angela"

Thanks very much, Margo. Hope you enjoy it.


Angela M Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader wrote: "I’m so excited to be reading Brooklyn and this one back to back very soon, Angela. Your lovely review has me even more ecstatic. I cann’t wait to meet Eilis!"

Jennifer , I read Brooklyn a while ago, but I think it would be a great experience to read them back to back. Thanks so much.


Angela M Linda wrote: "Wonderful review, Angela. Loved this one, too. Sure hope that a third book in this series is in the making. So good."

Thanks, Linda! I’d love a third book , too!


Angela M Beth wrote: "Angela,m I have to read book #1 in order to follow book 2 of this series, and enjoy it?"

Beth, you might enjoy this without having read Brooklyn, but I would definitely recommend reading it first to get a fuller understanding of the complexity of Eilis� character .


Diane Barnes I'm picking this up from my library next week. Pretty sure I'll love it.


Angela M Hope you do , Diane !


message 41: by JanB (new)

JanB I loved Brooklyn, and have this ARC. I’m anxious to dig in. Fabulous review Angela!


Angela M Jan, thanks so much for! Hope you love it. This was a sequel that was meant to be written, unlike the one you recently reviewed!


Angela M Hope you enjoy, Aravind.


message 44: by May (new)

May Looks like I need to track down Brooklyn asap! Loved the review. As is so often the case, you have me truly intrigued!!
Thank you!


Angela M May , thanks so much ! Definitely read Brooklyn first .


Cathy I really liked your review. I wish I had felt the admiration you had for this book. I loved Brooklyn and really was excited to read this but was heartbroken for Eilis after Tony’s indiscretion. I felt uneasy as I read the story and then, the ending, but can we really call it an ending? I thought my Kindle had skipped ahead. It really felt like the author wrote one long book, decided it should become a trilogy so he went back, cut it in half, and now we wait for the other half to get published. Not a fan.


Angela M Cathy, sorry it didn’t work for you . While we don’t agree , I respect your thoughts .


J Vogey It did end abruptly. Looking forward to someone making a commitment and going for it . But sometimes it ends with a manipulation . Secrets and innuendo . True lifeZ


Angela M J Vogey , abrupt ending might leave it open to a third book .


Leslie I found the abrupt ending a bit odd. I was reading it on my Kindle, and my first thought was that it hadn't been completely downloaded.


« previous 1
back to top