ŷ

Alana's Reviews > The Queen of Nothing

The Queen of Nothing by Holly Black
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
12402009
's review

liked it
bookshelves: fantasy

"For what we want most, we will take almost any chance."

Let me preface this by saying I've always been honest in my reviews and I'm not about to start sugar-coating things now. So, if you loved this book and are willing to down fighting tooth and nail over it, do you. You're entitled to your opinions and they're totally valid since we all have different reading experiences. If you loved this book, I'm happy for you but this just wasn't for me. And it's not that it was bad, I mean, I devoured it in one day. But basically on every single level this book did not live up to my expectations which was something I worried was going to happen. To put it simply this was underwhelming AF and instead of writing some nice cohesive review let's just break it down, shall we?

What I Liked

👸🏻ܻ.Jude is basically the one thing in this book that felt the most authentic from start to finish. I think out of everyone in the book her character development was the best. And I will always appreciate how badass she is and the fact that she basically takes what she wants out of life, no questions asked.

🌎The worlds.I really liked that there was more of a clash of Faerie and the mortal world in this book. It added a nice element to the story imagining some of the fae characters doing things like eating pizza or learning what gummy worms were and left a nice lighthearted touch to the story. I also loved being back in Faerie. This fae world is without a doubt my favorite and I'll always love how Holly Black is basically the master of creating all things faerie. The TRUEE Queen of Faerie.

👵🏻Grima Mog. The MVP of the story. Don't even try and change my mind.

What I Didn't Like

🧚🏻‍♂️�䲹岹.Let's start with my first biggest issue with the book, and that's Cardan. Now, I know that obviously a hate to love story is not going to stay on the "hate" side forever. I get that. However, what I was not expecting is to have two books filled with so much hate and then book three Cardan turns around and is just all mushy, gooey, head over in heels "I'll die without Jude by my side". Like what?! Meanwhile homeboy would have killed her with a smile on his face during the last two books. Where is the growth? Don't just expect us to believe it. SHOW US.Show us how much pain Cardan was in while Jude was in exile IN. THE. STORY...not in the Barnes and Noble exclusive edition all the way at the end that most reader's won't get to experience!!!Honestly, I'm low-key heated about this whole thing. When I read the letters in the back of my book I could not believe that they were not included in the story. That was such a bad move since those letters would have given Cardan just an ounce of decent character development.

📈ʲԲ.The beginning of this book didn't necessarily drag, but it also didn't do anything for me either. With the first two books if anyone even looked at me while I was trying to read they would have gotten screamed at, however, with this one once I hit chapter five I was like "alright nothing's happening let me take a break."Things eventually did start to pick up once you hit part two but that's halfway through the story. At that point I was shitting bricks thinking there was no possible way everything was going to be resolved in the next 150 pages. Much to my surprise it was, but it was mediocre as hell.

⚔️Battle Scene. Where was it? Because I'm still waiting. I legitimately cannot believe Jude got strapped for battle and then it just literally lasted like 2.5 pages...maybe less. It was so anticlimactic and predictable that I had to laugh. Where are the twists and turns books one and two delivered?! Why was there nothing that shocked me in this book?Holly Black's plot twists usually take my breath away and it was all just so predictable and underwhelming.

🔚The end.In terms of wrapping up the series it was pretty weak and again super underwhelming. After the whole battle scene I knew that any hope of a truly good wrap up was out the window.

All in all, this was definitely the weakest out of all three books for me, but I don't think three stars is a bad rating. It's average and that's exactly what this book was for me.The Wicked King will always be my favorite and I'm perfectly fine with having the first two books be basically perfection. So, am I sad to see these characters go? After this book not really. But would I read more books written in the Faerie world? Absolutely.


|
418 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Queen of Nothing.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 3, 2018 – Shelved
January 3, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
May 1, 2019 – Shelved as: fantasy
November 18, 2019 – Started Reading
November 18, 2019 –
page 50
15.58% "My expectations for this are so low"
November 19, 2019 –
page 170
52.96% "I like mean Cardan better"
November 19, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth Markelonis I just finished TWK yesterday and I'M still not ready.


Alana No amount of preparing could have ever made us ready 😭


message 3: by Riley (new)

Riley Ashby


Alana Kristina Reads - wrote: ""

HAHAHAHA LITERALLY ME THE ENTIRE TIME I WAS READING THE WICKED KING!!!!


Mary-Faith I haven’t read The Wicked King yet...ugh, I am so not ready for any of this emotional turmoil 😭


Alana Mary-Faith wrote: "I haven’t read The Wicked King yet...ugh, I am so not ready for any of this emotional turmoil 😭"

LOL WELP, you have a few more months to prepare 💀


Aleksandra I regret reading The Wicked King... I'm such a big mess right now. WHAT THE HELL AM I SUPOSE TO DO WITH MY LIFE NOW - when I need to wait over a year for next book 😭😭😭

I should have waited for all 3 books to be out and then start reading them... 😭


Gaby (lookingatbooks) As soon as I finished The Wicked Queen I knew this book was going to kill all of us. The title alone promises death to all my hopes and desires for Jude 🤭


Alana Gaby (lookingatbooks) wrote: "As soon as I finished The Wicked Queen I knew this book was going to kill all of us. The title alone promises death to all my hopes and desires for Jude 🤭"

UGHHHHHHH what are we going to do until 2020?!


message 10: by zara (new) - rated it 4 stars

zara i know something terrible happens at the end of wicked king but i hope jude comes out as a queen at the end of this mess. like, i want her bloody and victorious in the end.


Alana zara wrote: "i know something terrible happens at the end of wicked king but i hope jude comes out as a queen at the end of this mess. like, i want her bloody and victorious in the end."

My lips are sealed but UGHHHHHH it hurts so bad 😭 I am so with you though, she better come out bloody and victorious otherwise I will riot!


message 12: by zara (new) - rated it 4 stars

zara Alana � thebookishchick wrote: "zara wrote: "i know something terrible happens at the end of wicked king but i hope jude comes out as a queen at the end of this mess. like, i want her bloody and victorious in the end."

My lips a..."

also, extra hate for lock and taryn. if they don't get everything terrible then i will riot. Hard to say anything about cardan until i read what atrocity he committed. dammit, i don't want to hate him.


Alana zara wrote: "Alana � thebookishchick wrote: "zara wrote: "i know something terrible happens at the end of wicked king but i hope jude comes out as a queen at the end of this mess. like, i want her bloody and vi..."

We riot at dawn!!!!


Micaela Bonner Taryn is a disloyal evil twin biaaatchhh and her and Locke deserve each other, buried 6ft deep of course! And why why did Cardan do that?!! Does he even love Jude?!! I need answers. I’m going crazy here


Alana Micaela wrote: "Taryn is a disloyal evil twin biaaatchhh and her and Locke deserve each other, buried 6ft deep of course! And why why did Cardan do that?!! Does he even love Jude?!! I need answers. I’m going crazy..."

YAAAAAS to Taryn & Locke! And I think TWK ended the way it did because Cardan really loves Jude and is trying to protect her from maybe something we don't know yet?!


message 16: by [deleted user] (new)

SNEAK PEEK. PROLOGUE PLUS FIRST 2 CHAPTERS OF QUEEN OF NOTHING




Paula (She Sniffs Books) Lordy, by your rating of 3.5, please tell me I'm not the only one disappointed by this book...?


Alana Paula wrote: "Lordy, by your rating of 3.5, please tell me I'm not the only one disappointed by this book...?"

You are most definitely not alone! I had a feeling this wasn't going to live up to the other two books going into it but I wasn't expecting it to be so blah


Paula (She Sniffs Books) I see so many praising it. And I'm happy, truly happy that they loved it. I just wish I could feel the same way. I ended up lower my rating to 2 stars. Definitely kind of low but after my own experience with the book, I felt I should be honest about how I felt.


Alana Paula wrote: "I see so many praising it. And I'm happy, truly happy that they loved it. I just wish I could feel the same way. I ended up lower my rating to 2 stars. Definitely kind of low but after my own exper..."

Totally! Everyone's experiences are different when we read books so never be afraid to let your ratings reflect that regardless of how many 5 star reviews are out there. Honestly, I'm more likely to pick up a book from a negative review anyway haha!


message 21: by TMR (new) - rated it 5 stars

TMR Definitely I will consider what you have said in your review while I’m reading the book. Thanks for your honest opinion.


Sunny Cardan was literally the biggest disappointment. He had no character development what so ever. I hate when authors do a complete 180 with their characters. Like...he went from being a dick to a perfect husband. I was so confused as to how he changed lol.


Alana Sunny ✨wordslikefury� wrote: "Cardan was literally the biggest disappointment. He had no character development what so ever. I hate when authors do a complete 180 with their characters. Like...he went from being a dick to a per..."

Ughhhh yes exactly!!!

The Masked Reader wrote: "Definitely I will consider what you have said in your review while I’m reading the book. Thanks for your honest opinion."

Thanks for reading!


message 24: by Sumit (new)

Sumit RK Great Review, Alana! :)


Kacey YESSSS TO ALL OF THIS. Seriously how were the letters not part of the book? Or like a chapter from cardans point of view during her exile? That was such a pivotal part of the story!!! So many important things happened off page, it’s lazy story telling and I’m still bitter about it


Vanessa (The Wolf & Her Books) I still enjoyed it BUT I'm worried it was rushed in favor of the author's other release, Heart of Moors. I wish it was so much longer. I think The Wicked King was the best out of all of them. I was literally shutting my book closed every few chapters because I could NOT. In this case, it read like a novella or companion novel.


Melanie I agree with everything you said! The ending was super underwhelming and I wanted more. More from the plot, the characters & the conclusion. Also I completely agree we should’ve got to see Cardan’s letter in the actual story. It would’ve been better than just adding them to the back of the book.


MichelleRae I agree with many parts of this review. I'm glad I'm not the only one.


Helen this summed up my thoughts perfectly


message 30: by Jane (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jane Lam Your review summarized exactly everything what I was disappointed with while reading the book. Somehow I'd preferred to have waited for a little longer for the book than to get this as the end of the series... I still need time to recover from it, but I am glad that I came across your review!


message 31: by zara (new) - rated it 4 stars

zara I understand your sentiments and agree, however I still enjoyed this book. But it is definitely weakest of the trilogy, still not a bad book though.


message 32: by Kenz (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kenz The Dragon Queen Spot on review 👍


Alana Vanessa wrote: "I still enjoyed it BUT I'm worried it was rushed in favor of the author's other release, Heart of Moors. I wish it was so much longer. I think The Wicked King was the best out of all of them. I was..."

I'm glad you enjoyed it and I couldn't agree more with you! I would have been more than happy to wait a little longer if it meant that the story would have had more to it!


message 34: by T.M. (new) - rated it 3 stars

T.M. Ghent This review is all the worlds I failed to find in my fury typing of a review. Pacing is such a good way to describe reading this book.


Christine | Chapter Christine Hi I feel EXACTLY the same.


Alana Christine | Chapter Christine wrote: "Hi I feel EXACTLY the same."

Welcome to the club 😏😏😏


Mara YA Mood Reader Definitely very valid points on what was lacking in this MUCH anticipated book.
It made me feel like, the publication date got pushed up to an earlier release and Holly Black has to scramble and just throw out what she had or something.
I would’ve gladly waited for a later release date for better content. It was short and blunt and felt rushed which is disappointing for how much love this series has.


message 38: by Rose (new) - rated it 4 stars

Rose I feel the same way! I felt bad but because I loved wicked king and this just fell short. Very underwhelming


Alana Rose wrote: "I feel the same way! I felt bad but because I loved wicked king and this just fell short. Very underwhelming"

Totally, totally agree!!


message 40: by Dawn (new) - rated it 3 stars

Dawn I completely agree with this review!! No growth, very little character development in any of the characters.


message 41: by chi (new) - rated it 3 stars

chi I'm so glad I found someone who didn't enjoy it all that much. I just feel like I read a completely different series to everyone else. It's not bad, but it's just mediocre to me. Like, I had so many problems with this. Why must books be such a disappointment???


Rabbiya Farrukh Honestly what you said about Cardan and the Pacing of the work, you have stolen the words from my brain. However, personally, I would’ve loved the novel to end on a tragic note. Jude becoming the heartless person she wanted to be, and Cardan out of the way. Because that’s the theme of the novel. Angst and tragedy.


Alana Rabbiya wrote: "Honestly what you said about Cardan and the Pacing of the work, you have stolen the words from my brain. However, personally, I would’ve loved the novel to end on a tragic note. Jude becoming the h..."

At this point I think I would have rathered a tragic ending as well


message 44: by Anna (new) - rated it 4 stars

Anna Makowska Oh gosh, thanks to your review I figured out what are all those "letters" people are gushing about in other reviews, they're not in the e-book. D:


back to top