ŷ

David's Reviews > Open Throat

Open Throat by Henry Hoke
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
132767190
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fiction-queer

I'm a fan of short, unassuming novels like this one. Open Throat follows a mountain lion who lives along the Brush Canyon trail in Los Angeles. The entire story is told from the lion's perspective, as it eavesdrops on hikers, recounts its own story, and goes on the move after disaster strikes. Although slight, the story covers quite a bit of terrain, from California's acute housing crisis to the treatment of wildlife to climate change. The book is political, both in terms of alignment but also in its call to action. There are two things that elevate this above a clever but forgettable story. The first is the playful syntax - spelling is irregular and punctuation largely absent - which is fitting for a story told by an animal. But the second is I think more interesting: the decision to label the mountain lion as queer. There's little in the text to indicate the lion's sexual orientation or identity, whatever that may be. But I don't think Hoke is using the word queer in that sense. Rather than a commentary on the lion, I read it instead as a commentary on the meaning of queerness. The lion is free and yet confined, allowed to live as long as it doesn't transgress. It's labeled as a threat, even though it is the one being hunted. There's more to unpack with this, and even if Open Throat doesn't do a lot of unpacking, it illustrates these ideas in a fresh way. Many thanks to the US publisher, MCD/FSG, for making a digital ARC available via Netgalley.
392 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Open Throat.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 6, 2023 – Started Reading
June 6, 2023 – Shelved
June 6, 2023 – Shelved as: fiction-queer
June 6, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Marc (new)

Marc Just put in a request for this one from my library, so glad to see you rated it highly.


David I liked it a lot, Marc. It's getting a lot of buzz, which is fun.


Jacob wow, i love this interpretation. makes me want to read it again!


David Thanks Jacob. There are layers to this below the surface. Lots to think about.


blake I was so surprised by this book in the BEST way


David blake wrote: "I was so surprised by this book in the BEST way"

Same here! I think I was lucky to go into it before seeing the buzz.


David Jacob wrote: "wow, i love this interpretation. makes me want to read it again!"

I read your review again Jacob. I think it's a fair question whether the blurb is faithful to the text or overselling it in a way. You're right, it's the publisher, rather than the text, that explicitly highlights the queerness of the lion.

My own reading is that exploring queerness is one of the central themes of the book, which the publisher probably thought might be missed unless it highlighted it in the blurb. But that does have the consequence of making explicit what was otherwise latent in the text in a way that may feel inconsistent with other readings.


Raven Your review put this book on my radar! This month, I've started and vacillated between a ton of different books, but I haven't found anything particularly attention-grabbing. After reading this review, I bought a copy of Open Throat and I'm so excited to read it. Thanks, David! :-)


David Hope you like it Raven.


message 10: by Jax (new) - added it

Jax I have had my eye on this one. Great review David!


Gumble's Yard - Golden Reviewer I found this about as deep as a Disney (sorry diznee) or Hollywood (sorry hollywood) movie.


message 12: by Camelia Rose (new) - added it

Camelia Rose A wonderful review. Will read this one.


Andrea Great interpretation! I really enjoyed this short book and agree there is a lot to think about.


message 14: by Deborah (new) - added it

Deborah Taylor-French Thank you for your thoughtful insightful review. You have put this novel on my radar.

As a Californian and lover of wild animals I am intrigued.


message 15: by Debra (new)

Debra Terrific review, David! Love that the POV is of the Mountain lion


Carly What a great review! Totally thought provoking with the theme of “queerness�. I didn’t even think about it like that and appreciate your insight!


message 17: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray I third your brilliant insight: "The lion is free and yet confined, allowed to live as long as it doesn't transgress. It's labeled as a threat, even though it is the one being hunted."


message 18: by Pat (new) - rated it 4 stars

Pat David wrote: "Jacob wrote: "wow, i love this interpretation. makes me want to read it again!"

I read your review again Jacob. I think it's a fair question whether the blurb is faithful to the text or oversellin..."


David - I am curious how you thought that queerness was a central theme of the book, other than the blurb telling us it was. As an old cis female, i ery well may have missed it. Still loved the book, though.


David I read it as an illustration of the queer experience. The lion is free and yet confined, allowed to live as long as it doesn't transgress. It's labeled as a threat, even though it is the one being hunted.

I don't think it's any more deep than that, but I thought it a nice illustration as far as it went.


message 20: by Pat (new) - rated it 4 stars

Pat Perfect, I can see that. Thanks!


David I wish it wasn’t called out on the blurb. I think it works better as a subtle, understated commentary than as something everyone is looking for when they read


message 22: by Justin (new)

Justin Garay Such a great review. Seen this book in Barnes was thinking about reading it. Maybe I’ll check the library near me.


Kanako Okiron CAT!


Jessie Gray Thank you for this review! Your commentary on why the lion was labeled queer made the experience of reading this book even more enjoyable.


back to top