ŷ

Mark Porton's Reviews > Loved and Missed

Loved and Missed by Susie Boyt
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18643650
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 5-stars, susie-boyt, literary-fiction, modern-fiction

This book commences with Ruth, our narrator, chatting with three old girlfriends. All middle-aged, maybe a bit younger � the writing was engaging, I settled in. Within four to five pages � one friend said she saw Ruth’s daughter, Eleanor, recently. The circumstances of that sighting � turned me on my head. From then on, I was strapped in for one incredible ride.

If anyone has ever been unfortunate to experience daughter or son-initiated estrangement, this book will resonate like no other. I can think of nothing else that has the capacity to leave one so powerless, so frustrated, so sad � one’s confidence is ripped from your soul.

I never knew what I was allowed to think.



Eleanor floats into and out of Ruth’s life (more out than in). Ruth goes through what can only be described as ‘hell.�

Eleanor has a daughter, Lily. Leaving Lily with her mother is out of the question � Ruth does what any grandparent would do. The relationship between Ruth and Lily, we follow, it is beautiful. Both characters created and developed by this author, Susie Boyt, are unforgettable, they will stay with me.

How can such beautiful people sprout from such misery?

This story broke my heart many times. This story also made me laugh � and laugh hard.

What a writer Boyt is. What a talent.

The world was Eleanor’s widow � you know the estranger, the child, or children who decide to (.......) their parent/s. They hold all the cards.

Please believe me, from experience, they DO hold all the cards. Un-fun fact - son or daughter initiated estrangements are on the rise. Interestingly, parents are reminded, told, ordered to respect our children's boundaries. That's what we call progress, perhaps? The whole estrangement thing causes damage.

The male characters here, are shadows. Mere puff.

I will no longer allow myself to be pilloried by the lack of her. I let go of her hand.

Ruth and Lily, the characters we follow for many years, will break your heart, you’ll cry and laugh. You will be surprised about the reserves of resilience ‘ordinary� people can draw on.

”For Christ’s sake, Ruth, you need to think before you open your fucking mouth!.� For mouth, I half-heard legs.

The sense that we understood each other, without having to say anything, that we know how to be careful, not anxious careful, just full of care, full of caring

Please read this book. It is my favourite of the year.

5 Stars

This was an accidental buddy read with Diane - how's that? Her wonderful review can be found here: /review/show...
114 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Loved and Missed.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 20, 2024 – Started Reading
November 20, 2024 – Shelved
November 22, 2024 –
page 70
0% "This is brilliant. Exquisite writing."
November 23, 2024 –
page 124
0% "I have to sleep, but I don't want to. Brilliant!"
November 25, 2024 – Shelved as: 5-stars
November 25, 2024 – Shelved as: susie-boyt
November 25, 2024 – Shelved as: literary-fiction
November 25, 2024 – Shelved as: modern-fiction
November 25, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 82 (82 new)


message 1: by Lorna (new)

Lorna Oh Mark, what a beautiful review. And with an endorsement as your favorite of the year, I am paying attention.


Antoinette My favourite of the year as well. Love your review!! I have not been able to stop thinking of this book since I read it. A library book but a must buy book.


message 3: by Esta (new)

Esta What an extraordinary heartfelt review Mark. Favourite of the year says a lot, I'll keep it on my radar for when I'm in the mood to be heartbroken 🥺


message 4: by Lori (new) - added it

Lori You made me add another! Heart yanking review


Mark  Porton Lorna wrote: "Oh Mark, what a beautiful review. And with an endorsement as your favorite of the year, I am paying attention."

I'd love to read your thoughts on this one Lorna - it is so good, thanks so much again :))


Mark  Porton Antoinette wrote: "My favourite of the year as well. Love your review!! I have not been able to stop thinking of this book since I read it. A library book but a must buy book."

You're one of the culprits that put me through this emotional meat grinder Antoinette!!!!!!!! I'll have to re-read your review with more open eyes now - it is a 'must buy' isn't it? Thanks so much :))


message 7: by Mark (last edited Nov 25, 2024 08:49PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark  Porton Esta wrote: "What an extraordinary heartfelt review Mark. Favourite of the year says a lot, I'll keep it on my radar for when I'm in the mood to be heartbroken 🥺"

As one not prone to hyperbole (😉) - this is definitely worth being one your radar Esta!!! You'd love it I am sure - it would be nice to read a younger friend's perspective too. Or is this mainly good for us old, gnarly, juandiced, bitter, tired old buggers?? Thank you :))

Oh Esta, I just want to add this is also uplifting (really) and hilarious in parts!!!


Mark  Porton Lori wrote: "You made me add another! Heart yanking review"

I'm so happy to see you've added this one Lori - it's well worth it and thank you!!!


Laysee Mark, wow! I like knowing that this is the book of the year for you. High praise. I also read several positive reviews of this book. Estrangement between parent and child is heartbreaking. It looks like this book captured how hard this can be. Fab review.


Mark  Porton Laysee wrote: "Mark, wow! I like knowing that this is the book of the year for you. High praise. I also read several positive reviews of this book. Estrangement between parent and child is heartbreaking. It looks..."

Thanks for you very kind words Laysee, as usual. I am just about to take my afternoon nap, and will now snooze with a smile on my dial - thank you!! 😴☺️


message 11: by Sara (new) - added it

Sara That settles it. I have got to get my hands on this book.


Mark  Porton Sara wrote: "That settles it. I have got to get my hands on this book."

Dammit, I was looking forward to putting pressure on you Sara!!

Enjoy :)).................it's well worth it.


message 13: by Chris (new) - added it

Chris St Laurent Sweet


message 14: by Dave (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dave Marsland Mark's favourite book this year?
Copy ordered... great review Markus.


message 15: by Jeannie (new) - added it

Jeannie Another great review! I have this on my TBR. I will need to get to it soon. Your favorite of the year? I am really looking forward to this one now.


message 16: by Diane (new) - added it

Diane Barnes Love those quotes Mark. This was so hard to read at times, but the humor always saved it. Estrangement doesn't have to be from drugs, it can be caused by anything and can be of short duration, but it still hurts. I'm with Antoinette, this was a library book but I may have to buy a copy to reread. Do you think it will hurt less on rereading?


message 17: by K (new)

K I trust your recommendations, so it really says something about this novel if it's your favorite of the year.


Holly R W I enjoyed your review. I found the book to be moving and poignant.


Karen I love your review, Mark!
I bope many people ick this one up!


message 20: by Violeta (new)

Violeta Mark, the change of tone in your writing speaks volumes about how much this book affected you. It's touching (your review), and the same must be true of the book. Sometimes unadorned language conveys a lot more than a more stylistic one, and this is one of them. Beautiful review.


message 21: by Ceecee (new) - added it

Ceecee Terrific review Mark - that’s quite an endorsement!


Canadian Jen Well done review, Mark! I had meant to add this when I saw Karen's review and didn't so thanks for this!! I hope I find it as compelling as you did!


Mark  Porton Chris wrote: "Sweet"

Thanks very much Chris, great to see you've added this one!


Mark  Porton Dave wrote: "Mark's favourite book this year?
Copy ordered... great review Markus."


Yep Davey, I still feel that way 24 hours after finishing it. Okay, okay - I could still be suffering from the recency effect. Ask me again in a month!!! I reckon I might still say 'yes'. Great to see you've added this one brother, enjoy and thank you!! 🤗


Mark  Porton Jeannie wrote: "Another great review! I have this on my TBR. I will need to get to it soon. Your favorite of the year? I am really looking forward to this one now."

Oh, I hope you do get to it soon Jeannie - I can't wait to read what you think of this, and of Ruth & Lily, in particular. Yes - my favourite of the year - yeah, I do sprinkle dried hyperbole on my morning muesli every day. But, believe me!!!! Thanks again :))


NILTON TEIXEIRA And that’s how you sell it!
Great review!
I put a hold on it. 5 weeks! Luckily it will be available sooner.


Mark  Porton Diane wrote: "Love those quotes Mark. This was so hard to read at times, but the humor always saved it. Estrangement doesn't have to be from drugs, it can be caused by anything and can be of short duration, but ..."

Thanks so much Diane, I loved your review. You described this book beautifully. You're right about the heartfelt pain experienced when reading this, but oh my - it was also so funny in parts. The part where one of Ruth's friends suggested she 'think before opening her mouth' - and Ruth heard "Legs" instead of "Mouth" - made me howl with laughter. I read and re-read that part and just could imagine the horror on poor Ruth's face - BAHAHAHA. It's only the best of authors who can take us from misery to hilarity in a heartbeat right??? Thanks again :))


Mark  Porton K wrote: "I trust your recommendations, so it really says something about this novel if it's your favorite of the year."

Yep, I've thought about it K - I'll need to review this important decision after my hormones have settles. But I think it'll still be my best for 2025. Sad, funny - what more can one want? Thanks again :))


Mark  Porton Holly R W wrote: "I enjoyed your review. I found the book to be moving and poignant."

I just read and commented on your review and loved it too Holly, particularly your views on Ruth, there's plenty to discuss here isn't there? Thanks so much - did you find it funny too?


Mark  Porton Karen wrote: "I love your review, Mark!
I bope many people ick this one up!"


I loved your review too Kazz, and also the fact you gave this 5-stars (what else?).....what a book hey? Thanks again :))


Candi A splendid review of this devastating yet hopeful novel, Markus! Antoinette started the wave of readers that this book truly deserves, and I'm happy that you and Diane are passing on the word now too! Favorite of the year - it might be in the running for me, too :)


Mark  Porton Violeta wrote: "Mark, the change of tone in your writing speaks volumes about how much this book affected you. It's touching (your review), and the same must be true of the book. Sometimes unadorned language conve..."

I love the way you give thoughts and commentary on my writing, of my reviews Violeta. As someone who doesn't really know these things - I just write as I feel at the time, of course, those feelings usually book induced. But, I ALWAYS appreciate your thoughts - because I respect your opinion. Thank you so much Violeta - I love that comment of yours "unadourned language" :))


message 33: by Renee (new)

Renee Roberts Lovely, sentimental tribute, Mark.


message 34: by Vishakha (new)

Vishakha Mark, what a beautiful review! I was waiting for a wisecrack or a funny remark to sneak in but after reading your thoughts I can understand this book has made a place in your heart.


message 35: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Children have fears, and parents do too. You worded one of a parent's worst fears empathically, Mark. Your review brought a lump to my throat.

And the favourite novel of the year for you as well as Antoinette? A double endorsement I won't forget - added, of course.


Mark  Porton Ceecee wrote: "Terrific review Mark - that’s quite an endorsement!"

Thanks so much Ceecee - I reckon you'll find this one very worthwhile too!!!!


Mark  Porton Canadian Jen wrote: "Well done review, Mark! I had meant to add this when I saw Karen's review and didn't so thanks for this!! I hope I find it as compelling as you did!"

I'm sure you will find this one compelling Jen Jen - it is so good!!!! Great to see you've added this!


Mark  Porton NILTON wrote: "And that’s how you sell it!
Great review!
I put a hold on it. 5 weeks! Luckily it will be available sooner."


Hey Nilton, if it is a 5 week wait, it's well worth it - enjoy!!!!


Mark  Porton Candi wrote: "A splendid review of this devastating yet hopeful novel, Markus! Antoinette started the wave of readers that this book truly deserves, and I'm happy that you and Diane are passing on the word now t..."

Yes, it was you and Antoinette, Canders!!!!! Thanks heaps to you both - loved it, and thanks for your kind comments again :))


Mark  Porton Renee wrote: "Lovely, sentimental tribute, Mark."

Much appreciated, Renee!


Mark  Porton Vishakha wrote: "Mark, what a beautiful review! I was waiting for a wisecrack or a funny remark to sneak in but after reading your thoughts I can understand this book has made a place in your heart."

Hahaha - thanks so much Vishakha. Hey "wise-crack" & "sneak", are you thinking of the right guy 😂😂😂? Thanks again for your kind comments Vishakha :))


Mark  Porton Ilse wrote: "Children have fears, and parents do too. You worded one of a parent's worst fears empathically, Mark. Your review brought a lump to my throat.

And the favourite novel of the year for you as well a..."


Sorry to make you sad Ilse - but it's a horrible experience, but as with most things - over time, and with some practice and good therapy - it gets better. A bit better. Thanks again for you nice comments, and I reckon you'll find this very worthwhile!


message 43: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Compelling review Mark!


Bianca Beautiful review, Mark. I was so depressed while reading and after.


Mark  Porton Maureen wrote: "Compelling review Mark!"

Thanks again Maureen!! 🤗🎈


Mark  Porton Bianca wrote: "Beautiful review, Mark. I was so depressed while reading and after."

Thanks so much Bianca, I thought your review was great, just read it. I do agree with it being a depressing read, mostly. But I thought there was a wee bit of optimism in it too - not much though :))


message 47: by Dianne (last edited Nov 29, 2024 07:53PM) (new)

Dianne Alvine An excellent review, Mark of a very devastating situation. I have known someone who has been estranged from an adult child, and this is an agonizing, depressing thing to happen to any parent who loves their child.


message 48: by Angela (new)

Angela Such a moving review Mark, it's obvious the book resonated with you.


message 49: by Rowan (new)

Rowan Favourite of the year? Damn, what a review, Mark! I'm glad you enjoyed this so much. It sounds great! 😊


message 50: by Debbie Y (new)

Debbie Y Wow, Mark, what a wonderfully touching review� I wasn’t ready for this, and with my morning coffee I almost spilled! I’m so glad this ended up being such an effective reading experience for you. Your favorite book of the year? I must check it out. :)


« previous 1
back to top