Jason's Reviews > The Master and Margarita
The Master and Margarita
by
by

The Chicago Tribune : “The book is by turns hilarious, mysterious, contemplative and poignant, and everywhere full of rich descriptive passages.�
Hilarious and contemplative my ass, CT. This book is an interminable slog.
Look, here’s the deal. I get that this book satirizes 1930s Stalinist Russia, and I get that—for some—this earns The Master and Margarita a place on their “works-of-historical-importance� shelves. But for me, it earns nothing. I mean, let’s just call a spade a spade, shall we? There are articles in the Journal of Biological Chemistry that have more successfully held my attention than this Bulgakovian bore. ()
To start, the characterization in this book is near zero. Although there is a point where some barely discernable personality traits become apparent in one or two of the characters, by the time the reader makes it this far the show is nearly over. And if by curtain call the reader discovers Woland and his retinue to be even remotely interesting, it is not because of careful character construction. It’s more like the end of a really stuffy dinner party when you begin making your parting rounds. The thrill is in the palpability of finally being free of these people. Toodle-oo!
And what is the author’s intent here, to single out the literary bureaucrats and the nouveaux riche? If so, the demographic is not effectively targeted. The Faustian demon who comes to wreak havoc across Moscow does so seemingly at random, with little adherence to agenda. Bartenders, ticket sellers, poets, little old ladies—they are all ambushed. It is clear someone needs to take a lesson from Omar Little, who “ain’t never put no gun on no citizen.�
Whatever. I’m tired of even writing about this book. Before we part, though, I’ll leave you with several examples of yet another unworthy aspect of this novel: its ridiculous sentences. Here are some of my favorites.
Hilarious and contemplative my ass, CT. This book is an interminable slog.
Look, here’s the deal. I get that this book satirizes 1930s Stalinist Russia, and I get that—for some—this earns The Master and Margarita a place on their “works-of-historical-importance� shelves. But for me, it earns nothing. I mean, let’s just call a spade a spade, shall we? There are articles in the Journal of Biological Chemistry that have more successfully held my attention than this Bulgakovian bore. ()
To start, the characterization in this book is near zero. Although there is a point where some barely discernable personality traits become apparent in one or two of the characters, by the time the reader makes it this far the show is nearly over. And if by curtain call the reader discovers Woland and his retinue to be even remotely interesting, it is not because of careful character construction. It’s more like the end of a really stuffy dinner party when you begin making your parting rounds. The thrill is in the palpability of finally being free of these people. Toodle-oo!
And what is the author’s intent here, to single out the literary bureaucrats and the nouveaux riche? If so, the demographic is not effectively targeted. The Faustian demon who comes to wreak havoc across Moscow does so seemingly at random, with little adherence to agenda. Bartenders, ticket sellers, poets, little old ladies—they are all ambushed. It is clear someone needs to take a lesson from Omar Little, who “ain’t never put no gun on no citizen.�
Whatever. I’m tired of even writing about this book. Before we part, though, I’ll leave you with several examples of yet another unworthy aspect of this novel: its ridiculous sentences. Here are some of my favorites.
To tell the truth, it took Arkady Apollonovich not a second, not a minute, but a quarter of a minute to get to the phone.I ask this question in complete earnestness: is this supposed to be funny? I have absolutely no idea.
Quite naturally there was speculation that he had escaped abroad, but he never showed up there either.Huh?
The bartender drew his head into his shoulders, so that it would become obvious that he was a poor man.Yeah, I give. I don’t even pretend to understand what this means. Anyhoo, hey—it’s been a pleasure meeting you all; we should do this again soon. Toodle-oo!
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Master and Margarita.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 26, 2012
– Shelved
August 31, 2012
–
6.72%
"Thankful there's no "hour of the hot spring sunset" in my version."
page
25
September 6, 2012
–
20.16%
"I haven't read anything this slowly since that time I was forced to read a Bukowski novel."
page
75
September 10, 2012
–
33.6%
"I want to grab this feline by the neck and smother him in his own kitty litter."
page
125
September 18, 2012
–
60.48%
"My biggest fear is that I will be reading this book for the rest of my life."
page
225
Started Reading
September 24, 2012
–
Finished Reading
December 24, 2012
– Shelved as:
groupthink
December 24, 2012
– Shelved as:
2012
December 24, 2012
– Shelved as:
reviewed
December 24, 2012
– Shelved as:
flames-on-the-side-of-my-face
Comments Showing 1-50 of 586 (586 new)
message 1:
by
Rod
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Jul 26, 2012 10:47AM

reply
|
flag




We're actually letting people read whichever version they would like - we recommended the Ginsburg for people who want to read the censored version, based on all the feedback we heard on how well the version read.


I'm trying to remember - is it your first time through Cloud Atlas? What do you think of it? I loved it, but I know a lot of people are divided on it.







fucking LOVE that scene.

Right. Or just books. More specifically, the ones with words, I guess.

fucking LOVE that scene."
Same here. She ad-libbed the whole thing.

Right. Or just books. More specifically, the ones with words, I guess."
Yeah, maybe you could try learning to read in Braille? Try picture books? Try audiobooks? Nope there's still words associated.



Was that a comment of epic pompous twattery or is there a mitigating nuance that I'm missing here?

This is a great analogy, Bram; I feel the same way. Someone let me in on this joke, please!

I have no idea who he is, David, so if there's a nuance there, I'm not aware of it.

"epic pompous twattery..."
just beautiful.
i have yet to read it myself...now i really want to read it...


Was that a comment of epic pompous twattery or is there a mitigating nuance that I'm missing here?"
"epic pompous twattery" aw dd, you always know just what to say to warm my bitter little heart


already did!

Hahaha! How hilarious and contemplative!
Perhaps you're just , Jason, and covering with your dislike of this book?

Careful, guys. He threatens to use all caps when he types if you make him angry enough. He's like a loaded gun, that one. A CAP GUN.

But maybe he's just a small minded simpleton who can't read no littry fixshion.



"POW! BANG! SMASH!"

Poor boy must have been forced to read Are you there god? It's me, Margaret. at a young age.
